#305 Robert Caro on the relationship with your father, power, poverty, ruthlessness, obsession and running.
What this covers
David Senra works through the life and method of Robert Caro, drawing on Caro's accounts of reporting and writing about Robert Moses and Lyndon Baines Johnson. The starting point is Caro's frustration as a reporter: he saw what Moses did but not where the power came from. He concluded that highways go where they do because Moses wanted them there, not for the reasons textbooks give, which is the Textbook vs Raw Power gap his books aim to fill.
The middle ground is the mechanics of power. Johnson's accuracy at vote counting is traced to his father's overpayment for the family ranch and the ruin that followed, and to his rages at staffers who reported only that a senator would "probably" vote a certain way. Scoop Jackson's contrast between Kennedy's charm and Johnson's willingness to threaten or bribe also appears. Moses gets his own examples: investigators he called bloodhounds, dossiers leaked to the press, the pressure applied to a holdout named Epstein, and officials who flipped on a Long Island bridge within a day of his visit to Albany. Sam Houston Johnson admits that the happy childhood stories never happened.
The last stretch turns to Caro's craft. It covers Alan Hathway's maxim "turn every page," Professor Blackmur's warning about thinking with your fingers, and Caro's slow longhand drafts. It also covers his harsh self-talk, five years of isolation that bred doubt, and his years of living in the Hill Country. Senra adds his own view that ruthlessness and the capacity to endure pain run through all three men.
Senra argues that Robert Caro's craft, and the power Caro studied in Robert Moses and Lyndon Johnson, grew from formative struggles with difficult fathers and poverty, and that the 'turn every page' work ethic of exhaustive research and self-criticism is what produces great biography.
- Johnson's vote-counting and ruthlessness trace to his father's financial failure and the insecurity that followed
- Caro's refusal to stop researching ('turn every page') is an innate compulsion he accepts rather than resists
- Peer isolation nearly ended Caro's project, and community with other serious writers restored his persistence
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Caro argued that highways get built where they do not because of population density, traffic patterns, or grade elevation as textbook analysis claims, but because Robert Moses wanted them there.
“They get built there because Robert Moses wants them there.”
Lyndon Johnson's exceptional ability to count votes accurately grew out of his youth, when his father's optimism and overpayment for the Johnson Ranch led to financial ruin, teaching Lyndon the cost of wishful thinking and false optimism.
“Lyndon had seen firsthand when his father failed, the cost of optimism, of wishful thinking, of hearing what one wants to hear”
Senra argues that the source of both Johnson's and Caro's greatest talents lay in dysfunctional relationships with their fathers, with Sam Houston Johnson's account of dinnertime shouting matching the screaming home that Caro fled.
“the source of both Johnson's and Caro's greatest talents came from the dysfunctional relationship that they both had with their fathers.”
Caro argues that as a reporter he saw events but did not understand where Moses got power, and that a book explaining the real, unlisted sources of power would add knowledge that textbooks lack.
“If I could explain it, I would be adding something to the knowledge people ought to have.”
According to Scoop Jackson, Kennedy won votes through charm and explanation, while Lyndon Johnson would refuse to understand a senator's constituency problems and instead threaten, cajole, bribe, or charm to get the vote, because winning mattered more than friendship.
“Lyndon Johnson wouldn't understand. He would refuse to understand.”
By reading filed folders that appeared useless from their descriptions, Caro repeatedly found valuable material at the LBJ Presidential Library, showing that spending more time mining yields unexpected diamonds that less thorough researchers miss.
“scores and scores of times this happened”
Lyndon Johnson tried to train his staffers to find out how senators would vote, and flew into rages at reports that said 'I think he's going to vote this way,' demanding certainty because, as he snarled, 'What good is thinking to me? I need to know.'
“What good is thinking to me? I need to know”
Caro felt his book had taken on an air of unreality because for five years he lived in a world where no one else was doing what he did, with no writer to discuss a writing problem, and this isolation caused his doubt more than any other factor.
“I had for five years been living in a world utterly unpopulated by anyone else who was doing what I was doing.”
Robert Moses described flipping a legislator, Epstein, by first finding where the holdout was weak, then pushing on that weakness, with the implied threat that a holdout who went against him would have his farm foreclosed, showing how he did business.
“I looked for where he was weak. I found where he was weak, then I found somebody that could push on that weakness until he changed his vote”
Robert Moses used a team of investigators called his bloodhounds, who compiled dossiers on city officials and leaked them to newspapers when an official opposed him, a tactic he used against Epstein.
“This was a team of investigators who had compiled dossiers on other city officials, which Moses leaked to newspapers if an official opposed him.”
Caro moved his family to the Hill Country for about three years because he felt he could not understand the people of Johnson's background from New York, and living there let him gain fundamental insight into Johnson's relationship with his father.
“I'm not understanding these people, and therefore, I'm not understanding Lyndon Johnson. We're going to have to move to the Hill Country and live there.”
Lyndon Johnson was unusually accurate at counting votes because he refused to inflate support the way true believers and optimists typically do, and he demanded hard knowledge of how senators would vote rather than their impressions.
“True believers were always inclined to attribute more votes to their side than actually existed. But Lyndon Johnson never had that problem.”
Ambitious people are rare, so when they are randomly mixed with others early in life they lack ambitious peers; putting them together with other ambitious people helps them bloom, like dying plants given water, because most ambitious people are starved for encouragement from peers.
“Ambitious people are rare. So if everyone is mixed together randomly, as they tend to be early in people's lives, then the ambitious ones won't have many ambitious peers.”
Senra argues that Caro shares with Johnson and Robert Moses a ruthlessness that is used to get what they want, and this trait was not obvious to him until he read Caro's book.
“one trait I actually think Robert Caro shares with Lyndon Johnson and Robert Moses is the ruthlessness that all three of them have”
One can understand a son by the story of his father, because the father's story is embedded in the son and shapes the son's drive, which is why Caro's understanding of Johnson hinged on Johnson's relationship with his father.
“you can always understand the son by the story of his father. The story of the father is embedded in the son.”
Those who become the very best at their profession are the ones who spend more time thinking about and practicing their work, which is the core of the 'how bad do you want it' pattern visible throughout Caro's career.
“those that get to the top of their profession, those that are the very best at what they do, just spend more time thinking about their work, practicing their work.”
Caro's professor Blackmur warned that he would never achieve what he wanted if he did not stop 'thinking with your fingers,' and Caro responded by writing first drafts in longhand, the slowest method, so he would think things through before committing them to paper.
“I determined to do something to slow myself down, to not write until I had thought things through.”
When Caro asked Sam Houston Johnson to repeat wonderful childhood stories about Lyndon, the brother said he could not because they never happened, and the admission gave Caro a truer picture of Johnson's hard childhood.
“'Because they never happened'.”
Caro's harsh negative self-talk, such as calling himself a schmuck for wanting more details after he already had enough, reflects the same hypercritical drive that Johnson showed, and this drive is part of why no one worked as hard on biographies.
“'You schmuck. This is what you always do. You don't need any more details.”
Caro's officials who had firmly opposed a Moses bridge across Long Island reversed and became firmly supportive within a day after Moses visited Albany, revealing to Caro that one unelected person could flip an entire state government.
“When I went back to the same officials who had assured me that they were firmly against the bridge, they were now firmly for it.”
Caro experienced his obsessive, slow research as a compulsion beyond his control that overrode deadlines and financial pressure, and he accepted it rather than fighting it, which explains why his books took much longer than other biographies.
“neither of these constraints could stand before the force of this other thing”
Caro does not experience his exhaustive research as a choice; he describes an internal force that compels him to keep finding new questions and avenues, so that he has no choice at all, and he accepts this rather than fighting it.
“It wasn't something about which I had a choice. In reality, I had no choice at all.”
Senra argues that excellence is the capacity to take pain, illustrated by Caro's struggle through years of broke living and a failing book, since quitting would have prevented the books that became classics.
“Excellence is the capacity to take pain.”
Alan Hathway's maxim 'turn every page, never assume anything, turn every god damn page' became Caro's life motto, and the discipline of exhaustive research it encodes is what drives the length of his books.
“Alan looked at me. 'Just remember', he said, 'Turn every page, never assume anything. Turn every God d*** page'”
Caro, as a young newspaper reporter, learned from his interactions with Robert Moses that he 'knew nothing' about how the world actually works, including a level of political power and ruthlessness he had never conceived, which reshaped his life's purpose.
“I knew nothing, nothing at all. That there was a whole level of political power”
Senra argues that entrepreneurs often say that if they had known how hard it would be, they would never have started, and that Caro shows the same pattern in underestimating how long The Power Broker would take.
“they talk about like they knew how hard -- at the very beginning or even before they started their company if they knew how hard it was going to be they would have never done it.”
Senra argues that a Newsday reporter who hops from deadline to deadline cannot digest the implications of what he sees, and that Caro needed the Nieman fellowship's time to finally think about how one person could flip a state government.
“you need time in your life to slow down and actually think”
Caro found relief from doubt when he was assigned a desk at the Frederick Lewis Allen Room in the New York Public Library, where meeting writers like Joe Lash with long projects instantly dissolved five years of doubt because they treated his timeline as normal.
“In a couple of sentences, these two men, idols of mine, had wiped away five years of doubt”
When Lyndon Johnson was 14 his father went broke and lost the ranch, and the resulting insecurity, fear of losing the house, constant illness, lack of food, and public ridicule of his father became a defining feature of Lyndon's youth.
“When Lyndon was 14, his father went broke and lost the ranch.”
Caro was hired at Newsday as a joke on managing editor Alan Hathway, who disliked Princeton graduates, but when Caro was sent to the FAA files on a Sunday and wrote a memo, Hathway assigned him investigative work after realizing a Princeton graduate could dig.
“'I didn't know someone from Princeton could do digging like this', he said. 'From now on, you do investigative work'.”
Biography should not just be a collection of facts; it must enable the reader to see in his mind the places where the book's facts are located, so that the reader can understand things without the writer explaining them, because seeing something for yourself makes you understand it better.
“Biography should not just be a collection of facts. It's of real importance to enable the reader to see in his mind the places in which the book's facts are located.”
Senra argues that Caro's deliberately slow workflow shows he values spending more time with his work than finishing it efficiently or outsourcing it, and that this is why his method resonates.
“he sees great value in slowing down and actually spending more time with your work than trying to get it done as efficiently and as fast and like outsource everything.”
At 18 and 19 Lyndon Johnson worked almost two years on a highway gang driving a Fresno, a heavy sharpened iron slab pulled by mules, hauling the reins behind his back, a physical hardship that Senra presents as the embodiment of living with his father's mistake.
“When Lyndon Johnson was 18 and 19 years old, he worked for almost two years on a highway gang driving a Fresno.”
The Power Broker, published in 1974, went through around 47 printings, was on top 100 nonfiction lists repeatedly, and won a Pulitzer, which disproved the editor's prediction of a very small printing.
“The Power Broker was published in 1974. It is on -- it's almost like 47th printing.”
Caro received a very small contract with a $2,500 advance to begin The Power Broker, and a Carnegie Fellowship paid a working journalist's salary for a year, but Caro had estimated nine months and money ran out after the year, leaving him broke for four more years.
“He goes and he gets a small -- very tiny contract, and he gets a $2,500 advance.”
Caro's editor told him that few people would read a book on Robert Moses and that he should prepare for a very small printing, refusing to provide the remaining half of his advance, which left Caro in a worst-night moment of despair.
“We like the book, but not many people are going to read a book on Robert Moses, and you have to be prepared for a very small printing”
Caro's contract had an out clause allowing him to leave when his editor departed, which let him switch to a new agent, Lynn Nesbit, who connected him to editor Robert Gottlieb and resolved his funding problem.
“there was an out clause in my contract saying that I could leave if he left”
Johnson's chauffeur reported that during campaign travel Johnson often talked to himself, berating himself for losses and rehearsing aloud what he would say to voters next time, showing relentless self-criticism.
“Boy, wasn't that dumb. You know you just lost that ballot box.”
Senra argues that the reward for great work is more work, citing Kevin Kelly, and applies this to Caro, whose The Power Broker success gave him the means and motivation to pursue deeper research.
“The reward for great work is more work”
Caro's mother died of breast cancer when he was 11, after a long illness beginning when he was 5, and his father's yelling made him unwilling to come home, so that he found refuge in libraries and reading in Central Park.
“His favorite place was the library. He would go to a library, check out a book, take it, and read it in Central Park so he didn't have to go home.”
Caro's explanation for Johnson's ruthlessness, which hundreds of writers agree on, is that it came from the place he grew up, with Caro's position being that the origin of the trait is his childhood environment.
“I tried to explain why he was ruthless. And a large part of that explanation is the place he came from.”
Caro's first night reading government files at the FAA offices felt like coming home, and he discovered he loved making files yield their secrets, which led Hathway to assign him investigative work.
“I loved going through those files, making them yield up their secrets to me”
Lyndon Johnson arrived in Washington in 1931 with a cardboard suitcase and one thin coat, and he ran up Capitol Hill each morning out of urgency, which Caro presents as desperation to escape poverty and get ahead.
“From the land of poverty to this, everything he had ever wanted, everything he had ever hoped for was there.”
Caro's work seeks to explain how power actually operates, and Senra suggests that the mismatch between what Caro learned in college and what he saw as a reporter is the thread that connects his books.
“He wants to understand how power works. He wants to understand and to be able to explain to others how the world actually works.”
Sam Houston Johnson recreated dinner-table screaming matches in which their father called Lyndon a failure and Lyndon shouted back, and Caro felt these exchanges brought him closer to the heart of Johnson's boyhood.
“You're just a failure Lyndon, and you're always going to be a failure”
Senra argues that Steve Jobs's statement 'I'm a reflection of what I do' applies equally to Caro, whose books and life are one and the same, and to Johnson, whose work is an innate part of his being.
“'I'm a reflection of what I do'. And I think that's exactly what Caro is telling us right here.”
Caro's residence in the Hill Country helped him gain the trust needed to get information from Lyndon Johnson's brother, Sam Houston Johnson, which gave him a clearer picture of Johnson's youth.
“first unsuccessfully and then eventually successfully got information out of Lyndon's brother”
Caro's decision to examine the stolen Texas election in detail in Means of Ascent was driven by an internal nature he could not fully explain, not by professional reasoning, and Senra connects that compulsion to Johnson's own drive.
“It had to do with something in me. That's something in my nature”
Caro describes his persistent research drive as something innate and beyond his choice, and Senra argues this same innate drive explains Johnson's and Jobs's work ethic as well.
“The way I work is an innate part of my being”
After the Albany reversal, Caro drove home 163 miles telling himself that everything he had been doing was worthless, a hypercritical self-talk pattern Senra says Caro shares with Lyndon Johnson.
“I kept thinking everything you've been doing is b*******”
Caro describes Robert Moses as a ruthless genius with a rare imaginative vision and a savage energy, shown by pacing, smashing his hand on tables, hurling inkwells, and pounding walls until his skin scraped off in rage.
“how he would pound his clenched fists into the walls hard enough to scrape the skin off them in a rage beyond the perception of pain”
Caro's book Working explains why his books take so long, and he insists he is actually a very fast writer, the delay being in research rather than writing.
“And when I say that I'm actually a very fast writer, people can barely conceal their disbelief”
Senra argues that a creator's trajectory is changed less by talent alone than by finding the right partners, such as agents and editors who will fund the work and not undermine it.
“what changes in his life is that he finds the right partners and that changes everything.”
Among four editor lunches Caro attended, Bob Gottlieb offered to talk over a sandwich at his desk rather than going out, and Caro chose him, a choice Senra presents as part of how Caro selected the right partner.
“Bob Gottlieb says, 'Well, I don't go out for lunch, but we can have a sandwich at my desk and talk about your book'. So of course, I picked him.”
Caro treated his slow, exhaustive research as an unquestioned requirement for telling a story completely, and was willing to take two more years on a book rather than skip material.
“Of course, I'm going to turn every page. Of course, I'm going to tell the complete story to the best of my ability.”
Caro typically takes about 8 to 10 years between books, and by the time of the episode he had gone more than 10 years since his last published volume on Johnson, with the final volume still in progress around age 86 or 87.
“Usually, it's about an 8- to 10-year gap between each book.”
Senra argues that the point of reading is not to run eyes across words but to stop and think about what is going on, which is what he did when he reached the sentence about Johnson's brother.
“It's to stop. It's to think about what the hell is going on.”
Senra argues Caro's book is aimed at people who truly want to be great at what they do and at no one else, because its lessons only matter to those willing to pay the cost of thoroughness.
“This is a book for those that truly want to be great at what they do and for no one else.”
Caro says he is publishing short recollections now because he may never write the full memoir, given his age and his books' multi-year timelines, so he preserves his anecdotes in case he does not live to finish.
“I'm quite aware that I may never get to write the memoir”
Senra says the Turn Every Page documentary, about Caro's 50-year relationship with his editor Robert Gottlieb, showed Caro's approach to work and led Senra to pick this book from his shelf of roughly 100 unread books.
“in that documentary, you see Caro's approach to his work.”