#160 Peter Cundill
What this covers
This episode follows Peter Cundill through his own notebooks, with Dave Senra reading passages and adding commentary. It begins with how Cundill found his method. After years of apprenticeship, a chapter on Benjamin Graham and the margin of safety in George Goodman's Supermoney struck him "like a thunderbolt." He then reworked Graham and Dodd's current asset value into net-net working capital per share and kept a hand-built sheet of hundreds of companies he called the Bible. Charles Ellis's suggestion that a good manager should compound at 35 percent sets the bar. Cundill averaged roughly 17 percent over 25 years.
The middle of the episode covers his working principles. He did the unappealing detail work first and did not hesitate to buy once convinced, since the price only needs to include the margin of safety. He distrusted national economic forecasting. After selling most of his firm he kept research in-house so that at least 80 percent of his time went to finding opportunities, and he held that reputation is all an investment firm has to sell. Roy Thomson's advice to let the brain work as if unattended also comes up.
The second half turns personal and more contested. Cundill drew on Aristotle for the idea that excellence is a habit. He followed Aldous Huxley's picture of routine punctuated by orgies, and he chose high highs and low lows over equilibrium. The notebooks also record an optimistic alter ego named Frank Cundill, a blend of Stoicism and Epicureanism, a brush with suicide after burnout, and the tremor later diagnosed as Fragile X-associated tremor/ataxia syndrome. It closes with how he kept his routines while Joanie was dying.
Cundill's life, as recorded in his daily journals, shows that his investing edge came from a disciplined net-net method built on Graham and Dodd, and that his self-chosen routines and intense pursuit of extremes shaped both his success and his personal costs.
- Cundill found his investment philosophy by reading Graham and Dodd after years of searching, then layered his own net-net working capital screen on top of it
- He built a daily routine of fitness, reading, and research that he treated as the foundation of his character and work
- He deliberately sought high highs and low lows, and his journals show the same pattern in both career and personal life
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Cundill redefined Graham and Dodd's current asset value per share as net-net working capital per share, made it an essential condition of his investment process, and built his company research on a net-net sheet he called the Bible, tracking hundreds of companies by hand.
“He had redefined Graham and Dodd's terminology of current asset value per share as net-net working capital per share and made it an essential condition of his investment process.”
Cundill concluded that reputation and credibility are actually all an investment firm has to sell, and that taking risks beyond the shareholder mandate would starve the trust company of capital and damage its reputation.
“The more I think about this, the more I recognize that reputation and credibility are actually all we have to sell.”
Drawing on Aristotle, Cundill held that excellence is an art won by training and habituation, so that we are what we repeatedly do, and excellence is therefore a habit rather than a single act.
“Excellence is an art won by training and habituation. ... We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence then is not an act but a habit.”
Charles Ellis suggested that any money manager worth his salt should achieve a 35 percent compound annual rate of return, a bar that Cundill found riveting even though no manager he knew achieved it, and Cundill averaged roughly 17 percent compound growth over 25 years.
“Ellis had suggested that any money manager worth his salt ought to be able to achieve a 35% compound annual rate of return.”
For years Cundill had hand tremors, and after repeated tests and numerous opinions that found him in peak health, a later specialist identified a rare genetic disorder, Fragile X-associated tremor/ataxia syndrome, which resembles Parkinson's but is far less treatable.
“Eventually, he gets like a fifth, sixth, seventh opinion, something like that, and they find this rare genetic disorder.”
Roy Thomson's autobiography advised letting the brain work as if unattended, since it uses its bank of experience to reach lateral conclusions and obscure connections intuitively, and intuition, emotion, and intelligence are inextricably linked.
“The brain is like a very sophisticated computer. My advice is to allow it to work as it were unattended.”
George Goodman's book Supermoney, specifically its Chapter 3 on Benjamin Graham and the margin of safety, struck Cundill like a thunderbolt and gave him the theoretical backing for selecting investments based on underlying value, ending his years of apprenticeship.
“Goodman devotes Chapter 3 to Benjamin Graham and the margin of safety. It struck me like a thunderbolt. There before me was the method.”
Cundill concluded that national economic forecasting was scarcely more reliable than corporate forecasting, and that troubled economies provided rich pickings for vultures, though industry analysis could be a useful addendum to company research.
“Peter gradually reached the view that national economic forecasting was scarcely more reliable than corporate.”
Cundill advised thinking positive thoughts even when lying to yourself, reasoning that the brain does not know the difference between true and false positive thoughts.
“Think positive thoughts even when you're lying to yourself, the brain doesn't know the difference.”
After selling most of his firm, Cundill kept the primary research function in-house, aiming to spend at least 80 percent of his time identifying investment opportunities, because a principal officer who becomes known for sound decisions risks becoming an administrator and losing his primary role.
“I'm trying to ensure that my main focus, no less than 80% of my time is based on identifying investment opportunities for the fund and our other clients.”
Cundill wrote that one can lose the fear of death by acknowledging that one is already dying from the moment of birth, since the body is a form that has no permanence.
“I think that you can lose your fear of death by acknowledging that you're already dying from the moment you emerge from your mother's womb. Your body is a form that has no permanence.”
Cundill created an optimistic alter ego named Frank Cundill, after his father, to counter his negative thoughts, and he suspected superimposing a healthy persona over a flawed one might be a known psychiatric technique.
“As an anecdote to the negative thoughts, which still occasionally obtrude from that old peak Cundill, I have created an optimistic character in the form of Frank Cundill.”
Once an investor has done homework and is convinced an investment is right, Cundill wrote that he should not hesitate or wait for others, and that the initial purchase price will almost always be imperfect but should not discourage buying, since the price only needs to incorporate the margin of safety.
“Once you've done your homework properly and are absolutely convinced that an investment is right, you should not hesitate or wait for others to share the adventure.”
Drawing on Huxley's idea that human life is routine punctuated by orgies, Cundill combined rigid daily routine with periodic intense experiences, and the host argues this pairing explains the apparent contradiction in his life.
“Routine supports man's weaknesses, makes the fatigue of thought unnecessary and relieves them of the intolerable burden of responsibility. Orgies ... provide that periodical excitement, which all of us crave.”
Cundill's notebooks gradually formed a quirky personal philosophy that was a unique blend of Stoicism and Epicureanism, built on contradictions such as being a warrior and a monk, reason and passion, daydreaming and acute awareness, and seeking balance through harmonizing contradictory aspects of life.
“which is a unique amalgam of the stoic and the epicurean.”
Cundill said the thing that drove him to the verge of suicide was not the ebb and flow of investment markets but feeling burned out and losing the confidence and support of the people at the top of his organization.
“What drove me into the verge of suicide was not really the ebb and flow of the investment business with its daily measurement. That I can cope with, but I had begun to see myself as burned out and I felt the waning of support and confidence right at the top of my organization.”
When his wife Joanie was dying and during his own decline, Cundill kept to his routines as far as possible, reasoning that routine was how he could cope with the prospect of her passing.
“I find that it can only deal with the prospect of Jay's passing by sticking to all my routines as far as possible, reprehensible as some would feel this is.”
Cundill advised studying systems and financial statements while remembering that the beauty of numbers can dilute, and that understanding relationships is as important as financial analysis in investment matters.
“Study systems and financial statements. Remember, though, that the beauty of numbers can dilute. Be intuitive, warm, and fuzzy in your analysis. Understanding relationships is as important in investment matters as financial analysis.”
At age 25 Cundill wrote that real greatness requires passion combined with immense discipline, concentration, patience, and an unshakable determination to become a master of one's craft, and the host argues he lived by this standard until his death.
“I'm convinced that to achieve real greatness, a person needs above all to have passion but at the same time, immense discipline, concentration, patience and an unshakable determination to become a master of his craft.”
Cundill's journal emphasized doing the unappealing work first, never shirking detail, and not hesitating once homework was done, because detail gives the grounding for strategy and keeps the mind clear, while intuition built on experience makes investing an art.
“do the unappealing things first, never shirk the detail. ... Detail gives the grounding for strategy and keeps the mind clear. Intuition based on experience and instinct is what makes investment an art form.”
The host argues that people interviewed near death commonly regret not living a unique or authentic life, and that Cundill's near-death sense of having had a wonderful life is rare and valuable, which motivates the host's own reading and reflection.
“one of the main regrets that people have in life is that they didn't live a life that was unique or authentic to them.”
The host's takeaway from Cundill's business structure is that you should identify the most important activity in your work and then spend all your time doing it, which is what Cundill did.
“identify the most important activity in your work and then spend all your time doing that.”
Aldous Huxley argued that routine supports human weaknesses and relieves people of the burden of responsibility while orgies, whether sexual, religious, sporting or political, provide periodic excitement everyone craves, and the host reads this as a fair description of Cundill.
“Routine supports man's weaknesses, makes the fatigue of thought unnecessary and relieves them of the intolerable burden of responsibility. Orgies, whether sexual, religious, sporting or political, provide that periodical excitement, which all of us crave.”
Cundill took losses decisively and without self-flagellation, performing a sober assessment of what went wrong and why, and according to the host he had only two down years in roughly 25 years of managing money.
“You will inevitably have to take losses from time to time and then you must do it decisively. ... I think he only had two down years in 25 years, if I remember correctly.”
Cundill wrote that one can seek equilibrium or enjoy the heights and suffer the depths, and he deliberately chose the second path, accepting high highs and very low lows.
“There's a choice of courses in life either to seek equilibrium or to enjoy the heights and suffer the depths. He chose that second path.”
Cundill identified procrastination and fragmented attention as weaknesses to fix, but warned that procrastination should not be confused with allowing sufficient time for a good decision to emerge.
“However, it is essential to be aware that procrastination and indecision are not the same things as measuring one's response and allowing sufficient time to elapse for a good decision to emerge.”
Senra argues that Cundill's core drive was independence, that he disliked constraints on his time and being told what to do, and that abundant money relieves a person of many limits that others must endure.
“he wanted money and power, but I think a lot of that had to do because he strove for independence. He didn't like any constraints on his time.”
Cundill said he had a real terror of doing a bad job, and he saw this fear as a positive side effect that spurred his performance, while also recognizing that ambition could corrupt good intentions.
“I have a real terror of doing a bad job. But this has a positive side effect as a spur to performance. ... I think ambition is healthy, but it can also be a corrupting influence which can obscure good intentions.”
Cundill argued that in a consumer society where obsolescence is vital to progress, only stasis is frightening, and the host suggests this summarizes his guiding philosophy.
“in a consumer society where obsolescence is vital to progress, only stasis is frightening.”
Cundill arrived at his investment method by first eliminating approaches he saw as wrong, such as relying on national economic forecasts, and only then finding Benjamin Graham's writing, which he recognized as the approach he wanted.
“he's realizing what is not right before discovering what is. So he sees things being done the wrong way, he's like okay, I can eliminate that from contention and then he starts reading.”
Cundill wrote that value in an investment is like character in an individual, standing up better in adversity and overcoming it more readily.
“Value in an investment is like character and an individual. It stands up better in adversity and overcomes it more readily.”
Senra argues that the books Cundill read were original links, meaning one book leads to a more foundational source, and that constant reading and searching for new ideas is what produces valuable insight.
“This is an example of what this idea that you and I always talk about, the books are original links.”
The host argues Cundill's edge came from constantly reading and searching for new ideas, then layering his own thinking on top, which combined the inputs into something unique.
“he did something that is extremely intelligent, which is constantly reading, constantly searching for new ideas. He takes in those ideas and then he adds, he layers on his own thinking. And by doing so, this combination creates something unique.”
Cundill drew strength in the early 1990s, during a depressive period, from Terry Waite's survival of five years of captivity, reasoning that if someone endured that, he could endure his own troubles, and that everyone must pass through the fire to progress.
“We all have to pass through the fire if we were able to progress. And for some, it is worse than others.”
Cundill believed retirement is simply a death warrant and that one should keep contributing strategically, looking forward rather than back, which is why he kept working on investments while ill.
“Retirement is simply a death warrant. Hang on, you're still contributing strategically. Do not look back, look forward.”
Cundill's notes quoted Seneca's maxims that happiness is balance, to teach is also to learn, knowing is better than remembering, we are born unequal and die equal, and to govern is to serve, not to rule.
“Happiness is balance. To teach is also to learn. Knowing is better than remembering. We are born unequal. We die equal. To govern is to serve not to rule.”
Frank Trebell took money from another fund to cover losses on real estate speculations that were failing during the early 1970s recession, and although investors were eventually made whole, he went to jail for stealing money that was not his.
“He winds up actually stealing money from another fund to cover the losses in real estate.”
In his last interview Cundill told regular investors that the mantra is patience, patience, and more patience, and that they should think long term because big rewards accrue through compound annual rates of return.
“the mantra is patience, patience, and more patience. Think long term and remember that the big rewards accrue with compound annual rates of return.”
Cundill's wife Joanie was diagnosed with cancer and given 9 to 12 months to live, and Cundill continued traveling for work and seeing other lovers during this period.
“The oncologist says she has 9 to 12 months to live.”
Cundill was worried about Trebell's exposure in the early 1970s recession and real estate losses, and the uncertainty around the crisis left him feeling insecure about his entire professional life, which he later called a mini mental breakdown.
“This unquantifiable uncertainty left Peter feeling insecure about his entire professional life, and he suffered what he called a mini mental breakdown.”
Cundill's early mentor, Frank Trebell, whom he had almost idolized as a teacher of the business, later went to jail for fraud after stealing from another fund to cover real estate losses, and Cundill grew wary of Trebell's risk-taking before this happened.
“his mentor this guy, he almost engaged in like a form of hero worship, the one that was showing him the business, winds up going to jail for fraud.”
After eight years with his boss Frank Trebell, Cundill questioned whether Trebell had reached the limit of his capabilities, judged him emotional rather than rational, and left because he would not take the real estate risks Trebell favored.
“After 8 years, I'm forced to question whether Trebell has reached the limit of his capabilities.”
During a late Bermuda business trip, Cundill needed full-time care, nearly drowned in a pool, and suffered repeated near-fatal incidents, yet he still joked and stayed in motion, as recounted by ex-girlfriend Phyllis Ellis.
“He just burst into laughter and then so did I, crisis averted for the moment.”
Cundill used proceeds from selling shares in Yorkshire Financial to fund the acquisition of Peter Cundill and Associates for a total consideration of $160,000, which he later called the best investment he ever made.
“The total consideration was $160,000 and it turned into the best investment he was ever to make.”
The book's title Routines and Orgies comes from Aldous Huxley's travel book Beyond the Mexique Bay, which Cundill read at a young age and which provided the idea for the title.
“And it's actually a quote from a writer and philosopher that Cundill loved, and that's Aldous Huxley”
Cundill owned all six editions of Graham and Dodd's Security Analysis, heavily underlined and annotated, and continually re-read it to evaluate basic principles against contemporary circumstances.
“His library contained all 6 editions as originally published in 1934 and frequently updated. Every copy is heavily underlined and annotated”
The host speculates that Cundill's rare genetic tremor and ataxia disorder, which may be present from birth, overlaps with people who become extremely high achievers with singular focus, and that this may explain his compulsive note-taking and unusual philosophy.
“there's a large overlap with people that have it. They wind up being extremely high achievers. They have almost like a singular focus”
Among Cundill's notebook tips was the claim that the stock market is almost always wrong, though once in a while it is right, a contrarian stance consistent with his value approach.
“The stock market is almost always wrong. Once in a while, it is right.”
Cundill believed in seeking balance by harmonizing the physical, spiritual, emotional, and sexual aspects of life, and he saw the physical world as an illusion that should still be dealt with as if it were real.
“Seek balance through harmonizing the different aspects of life, physical, spiritual, emotional, sexual. The physical world is an illusion, but deal with it as if it were real.”
Cundill held that reason and passion go together but that reason should never come before passion, which he paired with rotating between daydreaming and acute awareness.
“Reason and passion go together, but not reason before passion. Rotate between daydreaming and acute awareness.”
Cundill came to see physical fitness as inseparable from mental agility, endurance, and the elevated curiosity and awareness he considered vital in life, and he argued that mind and spirit are bolstered or hampered by the condition of the body.
“the health of the mind and the spirit are either bolstered or hampered by the condition of the body.”
Cundill decided to remain a bachelor for a time because his primary ambition was to be a great professional, and he doubted he wanted children or could live with one woman, reasoning that domestic life would interfere with his work.
“I'm probably better off as of bachelor because my primary ambition is to be a great professional. I'm not sure if I really want children”
Cundill's notes said one should be responsible but remember that ultimate freedom is the absence of obligation, and the host suggests this was what Cundill was seeking throughout his life.
“Be responsible, but remember that the ultimate freedom is the other absence of obligation.”
Cundill became obsessed with physical fitness after being called pudgy or chubby as a child, set a goal of below 10 percent body fat, and carried that drive throughout his life, aiming to be in the top fitness percentile for his age.
“he has a goal in his life to have a below 10% body fat.”
Cundill's father attempted suicide after the 1987 crash and his grandfather may have jumped from a window, which suggests a possible multi-generational pattern of suicidal tendency in the family.
“His dad attempted suicide after the crash of '87 tried to jump out the window.”
Cundill sold his fund to Mackenzie in the 1990s, retaining about 5 to 15 percent, then sold the rest roughly 8 to 9 years later, because he only liked finding investments and wanted to outsource all other business aspects.
“He keeps a small percentage, maybe like 5%, 10%, 15% of business like that. Another 8, 9 years later or something like that, he sells the rest of it.”
Cundill rebelled against parental authority after his father returned from the war, grew closer to his mother, and pulled away from the family when his younger brother was born, a pattern he later regretted, especially after his mother died.
“I essentially rebelled against parental authority from the time dad got back from the war.”
Cundill initially questioned whether his job should become his obsession, but he eventually concluded yes, making work the most important thing in his life and placing it above marriage and children.
“Do I want my job to become my obsession? I'm not sure.”
The host argues that books are original links, meaning one book can lead directly to a key idea, as Goodman's Supermoney led Cundill to Graham and Dodd, and that this is a recurring theme in the podcast's approach to learning.
“This is an example of what this idea that you and I always talk about, the books are original links.”
Cundill believed Warren Buffett's line that intensity is the price of excellence, and the host argues this was the core operating principle Cundill applied throughout his career.
“Warren Buffett has got this great quote that says, Intensity is the price of excellence. And I think that's something that Peter definitely believed in.”
Cundill deliberately put himself into dangerous or painful situations, such as climbing Everest, rappelling waterfalls, flying experimental planes, and zero-gravity flights, because he wanted to feel alive and rejected ordinary monotony.
“Peter wants to feel really alive. And so he goes out and purposely puts himself into dangerous or painful situations”
The host argues Cundill's marriage contradicted his own maxim against lying, since he was constantly traveling and reportedly seeing other lovers worldwide while his wife, Joanie, possibly did not know.
“he was cheating on her constantly. I just don't know if she knew that or not.”
Cundill freely confessed he was far from naturally gifted at everything, and mastery came at real personal cost, so that the learning process itself and continual learning were the recurring themes of his life.
“Mastery often came at a real personal cost because as he freely confessed, he was far from being naturally gifted at everything. What counted always was the learning process”
Cundill understood that a private diary can serve as an uncritical confidant for frustration and pent-up emotion and a sounding board for the pros and cons of life decisions, though the habit can become addictive.
“He had learned that a private diary could potentially be one's best friend, an uncritical confidant for one frustrations and pent-up emotion and a sounding board for the pros and cons of life's decisions.”
Cundill's notebook advised being highly principled but flexible and above all fair, optimistic or pessimistic but above all realistic, and to be humble while believing in oneself.
“Be highly principled, but be flexible and above all fair. Be optimistic or be pessimistic, but above all be realistic.”
Cundill's maxims for a happy marriage were don't lie, don't make promises you can't keep, and above all don't quit, and he believed happy couples keep self-reliance on occasion to defuse conflict.
“Don't lie, don't make promises you can't keep and above all, don't quit.”
During the joint book process Cundill reviewed transcribed passages each day, and he said it enabled him to relive his wonderful life, while his memory was intact despite his physical decline.
“As Peter put it in an extraordinary way, it enabled him to relive his wonderful life.”
At 27 Cundill identified poverty of the family despite its connections, rebellion against parental authority after his father returned from the war, and arrogance as major influences, and recognized unresolved hang-ups in his relationship with his father.
“I essentially rebelled against parental authority from the time dad got back from the war. And it got worse when Grier was born.”
Cundill's optimistic persona reminded him to balance taking with giving, to become rich and famous while remaining exceedingly generous.
“Just remember to balance all this taking with some giving. You have what it takes to be exceedingly generous.”
The company Cundill sold his firm to was strong at marketing and sales, so it brought billions of additional dollars into the funds he managed, after which he wrote cautionary notes to himself about the pressures of wealth and fame.
“the company he sells to is really good at marketing, really good at sales, so they wind up getting a ton more money, like billions and billions and billions of dollars more”
Cundill and a small team followed hundreds of companies internationally by hand, without computers, and he carried the Bible research sheets with him wherever he traveled, even putting net-net on his BMW license plate.
“Using the relatively simple methodology, Peter and a small team were able to follow hundreds of companies on an international basis. ... He's not working with computers. He's doing this by hand.”
The host argues the book is unique not only because it draws on 40 years of daily journal entries but also because it documents the collaborative writing process, offering a rare primary-source view of a founder's thinking.
“not only is the book unique because you have 40 years of daily journal entries.”
The book is unusual because it is built largely on Cundill's own handwritten daily journal, kept for over 40 years starting August 16, 1963, so much of the material is his unfiltered first-person thinking rather than retrospective memoir.
“And when I look back on the parts I highlighted, almost all of it is his own actual words taken directly from his journal.”
The book's author, who worked with Cundill daily, came to believe that Cundill's finest hour was his brave struggle with his deteriorating disability, marked by no self-pity, good humor, and determination never to surrender to hopelessness.
“I came to realize that his finest hour was, in fact, in his brave struggle with his deteriorating disability.”
Cundill believed the spirit can always triumph over depression if one quashes negativity and fatalism with absolute determination and clings to the positive, though he suspected he might be feeling better for some of the wrong reasons.
“the spirit can always triumph. Although you have to quash the negativity and fatalism with absolute determination and just cling to the positive.”
Cundill's journal reflects that the trip around the world toughened the softer edges of his character, preparing him for the troubled waters ahead.
“The trip has started to toughen up some of the softer edges of his character.”