#275 Paul Graham
What this covers
This episode of Founders is a host-led reading of the essays of Paul Graham, with the host quoting passages and commenting rather than interviewing anyone. It starts with choosing work. Michael Jordan is the example: colleagues called him the hardest worker they had met, while he said everything felt like play. That becomes the case for Work That Does Not Seem Like Work. Lottery winners and heirs show what happens when constraints are removed.
Most of the episode is about how startups live and die. The tactical advice includes Doing Things That Don't Scale, such as recruiting users by hand or starting with a deliberately narrow market, as Facebook did at Harvard. It also covers measuring weekly growth, where 100 users growing 10 percent a week reach about 14,000 in a year and about 2 million in two (Compounding Growth). On survival, Graham advises running as cheaply as possible, "a cockroach of the corporate world", and the host links this to de Gaulle, Buffett, and Ed Thorp on avoiding ruin (Survival First). Ideas are treated as hypotheses, since determination without flexibility is a Greedy Algorithm that can stall at a mediocre peak.
Several positions are contested. Graham argues that determination beats intelligence and that the economy is a "rounding error" next to the founders. Yet he also grants that luck mattered in Bill Gates's IBM deal, and he models outcomes as skill times determination times luck. Other threads include the weight of sales and distribution, the effect of feigned certitude on investors, and the claim that fear of looking bad motivates founders more than money does. The episode also gives Graham's advice for starting a company at 22: raise about $500,000 and stay small.
Graham's essays argue that finding and doing work you genuinely like is the core of success, and that founders succeed through determination, resourcefulness, and survival rather than intelligence, luck, or timing, so the host recommends internalizing these ideas through repeated reading.
- Liking the work is the foundation: people who love their work persist without forcing themselves, and prestige and money are the main forces that lead people astray.
- For startups, determination predicts success better than intelligence, and the founder matters more than the economy or timing.
- Founders succeed by doing unscalable, laborious work early (recruiting users manually, staying frugal, delighting few customers) rather than by launching big.
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
If a startup with 100 users grows 10 percent a week, it reaches about 14,000 users after a year and about 2 million after two years, so founders should measure progress by weekly growth rate because humans do not understand compounding intuitively.
“If you have 100 users, you need to get 10 next week... you'll have 14,000 users. And after 2 years, you'll have 2 million.”
Early startups often struggle to get users, and it is hard to tell whether the problem is lack of exposure or a bad product, so founders must focus on the cost of customer acquisition as well as making something people want.
“When you can't get users and another way to think about this when you can't get customers, it's hard to say whether the problem is lack of exposure or whether the product is simply bad.”
The way to make a startup recession-proof is to run it as cheaply as possible, because running out of money is the immediate cause of death, so being a cockroach of the corporate world makes the company hard to kill.
“So the cheaper your company is to operate, the harder it is to kill.”
Investors become reluctant in bad times, even though they should buy when times are bad, because in equity markets good times are defined as everyone thinking it is time to buy, so investing successfully requires being contrarian, and only a minority of investors can be.
“in equity markets, good times are defined as everyone thinking it's the time to buy. You have to be contrarian to be correct.”
A sometimes-right unscalable tactic is to focus on a deliberately narrow market, as Facebook did with Harvard students, because when a critical mass of a narrow group feels the site is for them, they sign up and the product feels like their natural home.
“Sometimes the right unscalable trick is to focus on a deliberately narrow market. That's what Facebook did. At first, it was just for Harvard students.”
Luck is a big factor in startup success, as shown by the IBM DOS licensing decision, and the outcome of a company is best modeled as the product of skill, determination, and luck, so Gates would still have been rich without that luck but would have ranked lower.
“the best model would be to say that the outcome is the product of skill, determination, and luck.”
Preparation puts you in a position to get lucky, so once you have done the preparation, you can get rich by simply not letting your company die, which most people never manage.
“You've now done the preparation. The work you've done so far has, in effect, put you in a position to get lucky.”
It is normal in a startup to feel that what you are doing is not working, because most early attempts fail: you launch something and no one cares, which does not mean you have failed, but you should iterate rather than do nothing.
“Startups almost never get it right the first time. Much more commonly, you launch something, and no one cares.”
Graham tells founders that the Y Combinator expects about one-third of funded companies to succeed and hopes for as many as half, which means half of the founders will die, since success is defined as founders getting rich and failure means getting nothing.
“Another way of saying that is half of you are going to die.”
If your work is not your favorite thing to do, you will procrastinate and have to force yourself to work, and forced work produces distinctly inferior results.
“If your work is not your favorite thing to do, you'll have terrible problems with procrastination.”
Superior sales and distribution by itself can create a monopoly even with no product differentiation, but the converse is not true, so a founder must spend much time on sales and marketing.
“Superior sales and distribution by itself can create a monopoly, even with no product differentiation, the converse is not true.”
The economy is a rounding error compared to the founders, because startups succeed or fail based on the qualities of the founders, so you should think more about who you recruit as a co-founder than the state of the economy.
“The economy is a rounding error compared to the founders.”
The most important predictor of startup success is determination rather than intelligence, because there are plenty of people as smart as Bill Gates who achieve nothing, and in most domains talent is overrated compared to determination.
“We learned quickly that the most important predictor of success is determination. At first, we thought it might be intelligence.”
If Graham were starting a company at 22, he would apply to Y Combinator but raise only about $500,000, keep the company small for the first year, work closely with users, aim for profitability on that initial money, and stay off Silicon Valley's radar so that later funding is on his own terms.
“I would raise maybe $500,000. I'd keep the company small for the first year.”
Several legendary figures, including Charles de Gaulle, Warren Buffett, and Ed Thorp, all teach the same core idea that you must survive or avoid ruin first, because in a startup, if you survive, you can get rich.
“You got Buffett, Thorp, De Gaulle, all saying the same thing.”
Startups do not simply take off or fail on their own merits; founders make them take off, and the most common unscalable thing founders must do early is recruit users manually, because you cannot wait for users to come to you.
“Actually, startups take off because the founders make them take off.”
Michael Jordan's colleagues described him as the hardest working person they had met, but Jordan said he did not like working at all and that everything felt like play, illustrating that the same effort can look like work to others while feeling like play to the person doing it.
“if you ask Jordan, he says, 'He doesn't like working at all and that everything he did, it felt like play.'”
Constraints give your life shape, and removing them leaves most people with no idea what to do, as shown by lottery winners and heirs, because the happiest people are not those with financial security but those who like what they do.
“Look at what happens to those who win lotteries or inherit money.”
Founders are impressed by the degree to which feigned certitude impresses investors, and Nolan Bushnell advised Steve Jobs to pretend to be completely in control because people will assume you are if you act like you can do something.
“I told him, pretend to be completely in control and people will assume that you are.”
The dangers of indiscipline increase with temptation, and if you are sufficiently determined to achieve great things, this will probably increase the number of temptations around you, which may explain why high achievement is hard to maintain over time.
“The dangers of indiscipline increase with temptation. If you're sufficiently determined to achieve great things, this will probably increase the number of temptations around you.”
Startup ideas should be treated as hypotheses rather than blueprints, because determination without flexibility is a greedy algorithm that can end at a mediocre local maximum and deliver nothing more.
“We've always encouraged founders to see start-up idea as a hypothesis rather than a blueprint. Mere determination without flexibility is a greedy algorithm that may get you nothing more than a mediocre local maximum.”
Founders are more motivated by the fear of looking bad than by the hope of getting millions of dollars, so to motivate yourself to persist you can put yourself in a position where failure will be public and humiliating, as with the Octopart founder on the Newsweek cover.
“founders are more motivated by the fear of looking bad than by the hope of getting millions of dollars.”
Always Produce also finds work you love by automatically pushing you away from things you think you are supposed to work on toward things you actually like, like water finding a hole in a roof, provided you consciously keep your wants uncontaminated by what seems possible.
“It will automatically push away from things you think you're supposed to work on toward things that you actually like.”
A heuristic for finding your fit is that if something seems like work to other people but does not seem like work to you, you are well suited for it; the stranger your taste seems to others, the stronger evidence it is for what you should do, since programmers often like debugging even though most people find it unpleasant.
“If something that seems like work to other people doesn't seem like work to you, that's something you're well suited for.”
Startups officially die from running out of money or a critical founder leaving, but the underlying cause is usually that the founders become demoralized, and startups rarely die from practical failures like unpaid bills while they are still working hard.
“But I think the underlying cause is usually that they become demoralized.”
A sentence that ends with but we are going to keep working on the startup signals you are giving up while refusing to admit it, because a startup is so hard that working on it cannot be preceded by but, and distraction from other projects is fatal.
“If you find yourself saying a sentence that ends with, 'But we're going to keep working on a startup,' you are in big trouble.”
The best short description of what makes a good startup founder is relentlessly resourceful, meaning not merely determined but able to keep trying new things when the difficulties are novel, because startup obstacles are external and cannot simply be plowed through.
“Relentlessly Resourceful is the recipe for success. I think that is the best short description we'll find of what makes a good startup founder.”
Founders should assume deals and outside investment will fall through and operate as if they will never get additional outside capital, since optimism about things you cannot control is the mistake.
“My advice is generally pessimistic, assume you won't get money. And if someone does offer you any, I assume you'll never get any more of it.”
The super pattern behind startup surprises is that the things founders were surprised by are the same things Graham tells people in advance, and people just do not understand how different startups are until they do it.
“People just don't seem to get how different it is until they do it.”
The least successful startups were hard to talk to because they lacked resourcefulness: the founders could not chase down implications from a single word, and their conservatism came from weakness, traversing idea space as gingerly as a very old person traverses the physical world.
“They traversed idea space as gingerly as a very old person traverses the physical world.”
People unconsciously judge larval startups by the standards of established companies, like someone looking at a newborn and concluding it can never accomplish anything, when the right question is how big the company could get if the founders did the right things, which often look laborious and inconsequential at the time.
“The question to ask about early-stage start-ups is not is this company going to take over the world, but how big could this company get if the founders did the right things.”
The big launch usually does not work, because startups are powered aircraft rather than projectiles, and you only need an initial core set of users from a launch; most users are busy, and getting users is always gradual.
“I occasionally meet founders who seem to believe start-ups are projectiles rather than powered aircraft.”
The Always Produce heuristic keeps you honest: if you have a day job while planning to be a novelist, you should be writing pages of fiction, however bad, because producing prevents the vision of a grand future work from becoming an opiate.
“As long as you're producing, you'll know you're not merely using the hazy vision of the grand novel you plan to write one day as an opiate.”
Because people must decide what to do on ridiculously incomplete information, you get better results by choosing flexible work, such as a type of work that could become either an academic career or a high-earning career, and by seeking early jobs that let you do many different things.
“In the design of lives, as in the design of most other things, you get better results if you use flexible media.”
Founders overreact to competitors because they overvalue ideas, but ideas are not the key since a competitor with the same idea is not a real threat; execution matters more, and the space of possible startups is large enough that competition rarely kills a company.
“One reason people overact to competitors is that they overvalue ideas. If ideas really were the key, a competitor with the same idea would be a real threat, but it's usually execution that matters.”
The lower bound for doing what you love is that you must like your work more than any unproductive pleasure, enough that the concept of spare time seems mistaken, because unproductive pleasures pall and eventually you need to do something to stay happy.
“As a lower bound, you have to like your work more than any unproductive pleasure.”
Determination consists of willfulness balanced with discipline and aimed by ambition, and two of these three qualities can be cultivated, since willfulness is partly inborn but self-discipline can be learned and ambition is malleable.
“So here in sum is how determination seems to work, it consists of willfulness balanced with discipline, aimed by ambition.”
Understanding all the implications of a brief instruction is a subset of resourcefulness, so a resourceful founder given a one-line introduction to a VC will chase down the money.
“Understanding all the implications is a subset of resourcefulness.”
Rather than thinking of startup ideas as scalable, think of each as a pair of what you will build plus the unscalable things you will do initially to get the company going, so founders need to work hard in two dimensions.
“Instead, we should try thinking of them as pairs of what you're going to build plus the unscalable things that you're going to do initially to get your company going.”
As a founder you are buying stock with your work, so like any investor you should buy when times are bad; Larry and Sergey became rich not so much from work worth tens of billions but from being the first investors in Google.
“As a founder, you're buying stock with work.”
Based on historical examples such as Carnegie and Frick, Ford, Jobs, Rockefeller, and the Wright Brothers, founders who work together after one acquires the other almost always end up with one clear main founder in a subordinate role, and the host could not find an acquisition of this kind that went well.
“I can't even think of many acquisitions that go well.”
Hardware startups can benefit from pulling a Meraki, meaning assembling products themselves because factory minimum runs cost several hundred thousand dollars, and this doing-things-that-don't-scale is a form of education that lets you iterate design faster and learn what you would never have known otherwise.
“Doing Things That Don't Scale is actually a form of education... You can treat the design faster when you are the factory and you learn things you would never have known otherwise.”
Ambitious people are rare, so when they are scattered among ordinary peers they lack encouragement; when they are brought together with other ambitious people they bloom, and building events and institutions to bring them together is one of the best ways to help a society.
“When you take people like this and put them together with other ambitious people, they bloom like dying plants given water.”
You should not worry about prestige, since prestige is the opinion of the rest of the world, and if you do anything well enough you will make it prestigious, as jazz became prestigious despite not being so at first.
“Prestige is the opinion of the rest of the world.”
The test of whether people love what they do is whether they would do it even if they weren't paid for it, even if they had to work another job to make a living.
“The test of whether people love what they do is whether they'd do it even if they weren't paid for it.”
Running a startup is demoralizing and painful, and knowing this in advance helps, because when it feels terrible you won't conclude that you should quit; excellence is the capacity to take pain.
“excellence is the capacity to take pain.”
The relationship between startup co-founders goes from friendship to something like marriage, is far more intense than typical coworker relationships, and therefore has to be built from top-quality materials and carefully maintained, since it is the basis of everything.
“Several people use the word married. It is far more intense relationship than you usually see between coworkers.”
Estée Lauder recruited customers one at a time, such as giving makeovers on buses and trains, and decades later those early customers were still sending letters, showing that doing things that don't scale compounds into a large customer base over time.
“she would say decades later, she would still be getting cards and letters in the mail from people that she took the time on an individual basis to provide a service for.”
Worrying about prestige is worrying about the opinion of people beyond your friends and respected peers, and you should ignore it because prestige is the opinion of the rest of the world.
“Prestige is the opinion of the rest of the world.”
It is better to get a few people to really love you than a bunch of people to kind of like you, so founders should take extraordinary measures to acquire and delight early users, as Wufoo did by sending each new user a handwritten thank-you note.
“Wufoo sent every new user a handwritten thank you note.”
Stripe's founders invented Collison installation, where instead of sending a beta link to someone who agreed to try their product, they set the user up on the spot, which is an example of aggressive early user acquisition.
“When anyone agreed to try Stripe, they'd say right, they would say, right then, give me your laptop, and they would set them up on the spot.”
Viaweb built online stores for merchants who would not buy the software outright, and although it felt lame at the time, doing this taught the founders how it would feel for merchants to use their software and provided instant feedback loops for new features.
“it was exactly the right thing to do because it taught us how it would feel for merchants to use our software.”
A third factor in achievement is how much you like the work, and if you really love working on something you do not need determination to drive you, because it is what you would do anyway.
“There's a third factor in achievement. How much you like the work? If you really love working on something, you don't need determination to drive you.”
Startups win through lots of little things rather than a single magic idea, so founders often find themselves tracking down bugs rather than having brilliant strategic flashes, and should never bet everything on one feature or deal.
“It is much more of a grind than glamorous.”
Founders are overconfident and expect instant success like YouTube or Facebook, but only about one in 100 successful startups follows that trajectory, so most should expect things to take much longer than they expect.
“You tell them only 1 out of 100 successful startups has a trajectory like that, and they think, yes, we're going to be that one.”
Founders underweight customer acquisition cost because Y Combinator emphasizes making something people want, and a company must become a great marketing company, since a product that improves customers lives creates a moral obligation to get good at marketing.
“YC preaches make something people want. There is very little focus on the cost of customer acquisition.”
Most people are doomed in childhood by accepting the axiom that work equals pain, and those who escape this are nearly all lured onto the rocks by prestige or money, so doing what you love requires first unlearning the idea that work is by definition unpleasant.
“Most people are doomed in childhood by accepting the axiom that work equals pain.”
The most common surprise founders reported was that they should have paid more attention to character and commitment rather than ability when choosing co-founders, especially in failed startups, where founders who flaked were the problem.
“Number one, be careful with co-founders. This was the surprise mentioned by the most founders.”
Founders consistently underestimate how important persistence is, and persistence alone dissolves obstacles that seem outside your control, making it more important than raw intelligence.
“the determination required was still understated. And also by the degree to which persistence alone was able to dissolve obstacles.”
Whether a recession is a good time to start a startup is hard to say and matters little; for a given set of people working on a given technology, the time to act is always now.
“It's the people that matter. And for a given set of people working on a given technology, the time to act is always now.”
Most people underestimate how much they should like their work, so they stop searching too early and end up doing something chosen by parents, money, prestige, or inertia.
“if, like most people, you underestimate it, you tend to stop searching too early.”
Graham warns that bad things always come in a startup and that the odds of getting from launch to liquidity without some kind of disaster are about 1 in 1,000, so founders should not get demoralized when disaster strikes.
“The odds of getting from launch to liquidity without some kind of disaster happening are 1 in 1,000”
Peer communities of founders facing similar obstacles at similar times are very valuable, and creating wealth is not zero-sum, so as founders grow successful they can restock the stream they fished from by mentoring others, as Bob Noyce did.
“Creating wealth is not a zero-sum game. So you don't have to stab people in the back to win.”
Recessions and difficult economic times are normal and recur throughout history; in the 1800s and early 1900s they were called financial panics.
“they called them financial panics”
Start with something minimal: release fast and iterate, building the absolute smallest thing that can be considered a complete application and shipping it, which is practically a mantra at Y Combinator.
“build the absolute smallest thing that can be considered a complete application and ship it.”
Bad economic times mean there is less competition, because when everyone else is cowering in a corner, you may have the whole car to yourself, so downturns can favor startups that act.
“Another advantage of bad times is that there's less competition.”
Achievements tend to increase your ambition, so success creates a feedback loop that deepens determination over time.
“Achievements also tend to increase your ambition.”
Running a startup never stops and consumes almost every waking moment, but in the best case total immersion can be exciting, so that you think about the startup day and night yet never once feel it is work.
“It's surprising how much you become consumed by your startup, in that you think about it day and night, but never once does it feel like work.”
Founders need core beliefs repeated for decades, as Bezos, Ogilvy, Buffett, and Jobs did, and Graham repeats his ideas across essays because repetition is persuasive.
“you have a core set of beliefs and ideas, you're going to have to repeat them for decade after decade.”
Early startups can delight customers one by one in a way that large companies cannot, such as Tim Cook not sending a handwritten note after a laptop purchase, so being small is an advantage in customer service.
“Tim Cook of Apple doesn't send you a handwritten note after you buy a laptop. He can't. But you can.”
Steve Jobs meant insanely literally, that founders should focus on quality of execution to a degree that in everyday life would be considered pathological.
“He meant it more literally, that one should focus on quality of execution to a degree that in everyday life would be considered pathological.”
Great work takes less discipline than people think, because the best approach is to find something you like so much you do not need to force yourself, though finding such work usually still requires discipline.
“great work takes less discipline than people think because the way to do great work is to find something you like so much that you don't have to force yourself to do it.”
Doing what you love does not mean doing what you would most like to do this second, since even someone who loves their work, like Einstein, sometimes wants coffee and must choose the work instead.
“Do what you love doesn't mean, do what you would like to do most this second.”
Only a few hundred thousand people out of billions ever discover something they love to work on, which shows that finding such work is hard and should not be underestimated.
“A few hundred thousand perhaps out of billions.”
Many founders were surprised by how clueless investors were, with one saying 95 percent of the investors they dealt with were unprofessional and lacked business skill or creative vision, while angel investors were generally better to talk to.
“95% of the investors we dealt with were unprofessional.”
If you admit to yourself that you are discontented with your work, you are a step ahead of most people who are still in denial.
“if you admit to yourself that you're discontented, you're a step ahead of most people who are still in denial.”
Any strategy that minimizes the visible effort required to get users is suspect, because a startup needs an extraordinary effort initially and the right way is the hard way, as Jerry Seinfeld also argued about his show.
“You have to make an extraordinary effort, and he italicized effort initially. Any strategy that emits the effort is suspect.”
Even if you succeed in finding work you love, it is rare to be free to work on what you want until your 30s or 40s.
“Even if you succeed, it's rare to be free to work on what you want until your 30s or 40s.”
The host says Graham's essay on doing what you love pushed him in July 2018 to focus 100% on the Founders podcast and risk his last dollar of savings on it, a decision he says he would not have made without the essay.
“I was willing to spend my last dollar in savings to try to make this work.”