#277 Paul Graham’s Essays Part 3
What this covers
This is Senra's third pass through Paul Graham's essays, and it runs along two tracks: how wealth gets made, and how good work gets made. It starts by separating wealth from money. Wealth is the food, clothes, houses and travel people want, and money is only a way of moving it. From there it builds toward the claim that the pie is not fixed, so Steve Jobs and Steve Wozniak did not have to make anyone poor to get rich.
The economic half is the more contentious. Technology is treated as leverage: a tractor widens the gap between farmers who master it and those who don't, and Sam Walton's new kind of store counts as technology too. Senra relays Graham's argument that large companies cannot pay someone for working ten times harder, that one great programmer can create a million dollars of value in weeks while a mediocre one creates none, and that a society must let founders keep a share of what they create. The Henry Ford tractor example makes that case. Graham's view that "underpaid" really means people want the wrong things is also here. Smaller points include gross margin and cash flow, and Jobs on recruiting.
The craft half covers gradual refinement across a painter's career, learning by copying masters (Franklin's essay reproductions), and the claim that good design is simple. It also argues that taste is learnable and can be better or worse, not just different. The gap between Leonardo da Vinci and his peers, and the pull of talent hotspots like 15th-century Florence, round it out.
Senra argues that Paul Graham's essays reduce getting rich to creating wealth by making things people want, and that small teams, technological leverage, relentless refinement, and learnable taste are the practical means of doing so.
- Wealth is what people want, and money is only a way of moving it, so wealth can grow without zero-sum theft
- Small groups of extraordinary people with technological leverage capture far more value than large bureaucracies
- Great work comes from gradual refinement, relentless attention to unseen details, and taste that can be developed through practice and imitation
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Technology will increase the gap between the productive and the unproductive, which is the whole point of technology, because a tractor could plow six times as much land per day as a team of horses but only for a farmer who mastered a new kind of farming.
“It will certainly increase the gap between the productive and the unproductive. That is the whole point of technology.”
Wealth is the stuff people actually want, such as food, clothes, houses, and travel, while money is only a way of moving wealth; the two are usually interchangeable in practice but are not the same thing, and you can have wealth without money.
“Money is not wealth. This paragraph is key to understanding this entire essay.”
Sam Walton got rich not by being a retailer but by designing a new kind of store, a technology in Graham's broad sense, and he found it by targeting small rural towns big retailers ignored with the lowest prices.
“Sam Walton got rich not by being a retailer, but by designing a new kind of store.”
Hackers and painters both learn mostly by doing, and each work builds on what was learned in previous ones, so a painter's chronological body of work shows gradual refinement that also applies to companies and writers.
“You learn to paint mostly by doing it. Ditto for hacking, you learn to hack mostly by hacking.”
Copying the works of great masters forces you to look closely at how a painting is made, Benjamin Franklin learned to write by summarizing and reproducing essays, and hackers can likewise learn to program by reading good source code.
“copying forces you to look closely at the way a painting is made”
For Graham, technology equals leverage: technology is technique, the way people do things, and when someone discovers a new way of doing things its value is multiplied by everyone who uses it, which favors small companies that can adopt unorthodox methods.
“For him, technology equals leverage. This is another very important line. What is technology? It's technique.”
Good design is simple across math, painting, programming, and writing, and people tend to overcomplicate when they try to be creative; being forced to be simple forces you to face the real problem.
“When you're forced to be simple, you're forced to face the real problem. When you can't deliver ornament, you have to deliver substance.”
Societies grow richer only if they let founders with founder mentality keep a percentage of the wealth they create, and historically the ability to accumulate wealth by creating it has been switched on and off across places and eras, with prosperity appearing and disappearing accordingly.
“At various times and places in history, whether you could accumulate a fortune by creating wealth had been turned on and off.”
Taste is not merely subjective preference; as you design things you get better and your old taste was not merely different but worse, so the axiom that taste cannot be wrong is false.
“If so, your old taste were not merely different, but worse. Poof, goes the axiom that taste can't be wrong.”
When people care enough to do something well, the best are far better than everyone else; making money is a specialized skill, and those who make more are often simply better at doing what people want.
“Like chess or painting or writing novels, making money is a very specialized skill.”
When people care enough to do something well, the best practitioners are far better than everyone else, with a huge gap between Leonardo and second-rate contemporaries, and a top chess player could win 10,000 games against an ordinary club player without losing once.
“A top-ranked professional chess player could play 10,000 games against an ordinary club player without losing once.”
There are two things in business that matter, high gross margins and cash flow, and all companies that go out of business do so for the same reason: they run out of money.
“All companies that go out of business do so for the same reason. They run out of money.”
In most fields the appearance of ease comes with practice, because practice trains the unconscious mind to handle tasks that once required conscious thought, and great founders, athletes, and artists produce their best work only after years of repetition.
“Perhaps what practice does is train your unconscious mind to handle tasks that used to require a conscious thought.”
Wealth is whatever people want, and making something people want is the most direct route to creating wealth and getting paid for it; nearly all companies exist to do this.
“Wealth is whatever people want. That is a concise description of this essay.”
Founders with founder mentality will not make a society richer unless they are allowed to keep a percentage of the wealth they create; if a society decreases variance by penalizing outsized wealth, it ends up making everybody poor.
“But the only way they'll make our society is richer if you let them keep a percentage of the wealth that they create.”
There are economies of scale in how much of one's life is devoted to work; in the right kind of business someone who devotes themselves fully to work could generate 10 or even 100 times as much wealth as an average employee.
“In the right kind of business, someone who really devoted himself to work could generate 10 or even 100x as much wealth as an average employee.”
Companies are not set up to reward people who want to work 10x harder, and wealth is hard to generate inside large companies because the decisions people make there rarely have a big effect; if a job feels safe, there is almost certainly no leverage and therefore no route to getting rich.
“If you're in a job that feels safe, you're not going to get rich because if there's no danger there's almost certainly no leverage.”
In a free market prices are determined by what buyers want, so to say a kind of work is underpaid is identical to saying that people want the wrong things, which means people who make more money are often just better at doing what people want.
“To say that a certain kind of work is underpaid is thus identical with saying that people want the wrong things.”
Many people treat the world's wealth as a fixed pie, but wealth is not finite: people can create wealth by making things others want, so Jobs and Wozniak did not have to make others poor to become rich.
“Steve Jobs and Steve Wozniak didn't have to make us poor to make themselves rich. Quite the opposite.”
If you let Henry Ford get rich, he will make you a tractor to replace your horse, meaning that rewarding founders produces the innovations that benefit everyone.
“If you let Henry Ford get rich, he'll make you a tractor to replace your horse.”
Something was happening in 15th-century Florence that cannot have been genetic since it is not happening now, and nothing is more powerful than a community of talented people working on related problems, since great work still comes disproportionately from a few hotspots.
“Nothing is more powerful than a community of talented people working on related problems. Great work still comes disproportionately from a few hotspots.”
Steve Jobs repeatedly insisted that you must find extraordinary people, and Jobs considered recruiting the founder's most important job because a start-up's output is averaged with the quality of the people it hires.
“The people you work with had better be good because it's their work that yours is going to get averaged with”
Programmers are unusually aware of huge variation in the rate at which wealth is created; at Viaweb one exceptional programmer added several hundred thousand dollars to company value in a day, and a great programmer can create a million dollars of wealth in a couple of weeks while a mediocre one creates zero or negative wealth.
“A great programmer can create a million dollars' worth of wealth in a couple of weeks. A mediocre programmer over the same period will generate zero or even negative wealth.”
Large companies are not set up to reward people who want to work 10 or 100 times harder, because an employee cannot tell a boss I want to work 10x as hard so pay me 10x as much; startups are the closest substitute because they let individuals make that bargain directly with customers in a small group.
“Companies are not set up to reward people who want to do this”
We should expect ever-increasing variation in individual productivity over time, because the lever of technology keeps growing, and a single person from a bedroom can now build something enormously impactful with open source and cloud services like AWS.
“So we should expect to see ever-increasing variation in individual productivity as time goes on.”
Programmers should figure out programs while writing them, sketching as painters, writers, and architects do, rather than planning the complete program on paper before going near a computer.
“You should figure out programs as you're writing them just as writers and painters and architects do.”
Software is a very competitive business prone to natural monopolies, so a company that gets software written faster and better will, all else equal, put its competitors out of business.
“Software is a very competitive business prone to natural monopolies.”
There is a large random multiplier in the success of any company, and most startups fail, often because a good product takes slightly too long to build and the company runs out of money before it ships.
“There is a large random multiplier in the success of any company. Most start-ups tank.”
There are only two things you have to know about business: build something users love and make more than you spend, and the less you spend the easier it is to make more than you spend.
“There are only two things you have to know about business, build something users love and make more than you spend”
The right way for several people to collaborate on software is to divide the project into sharply defined modules, each with a definitive owner and interfaces as carefully designed as programming languages, mirroring how painters never worked on the same part of a painting.
“The right way to collaborate, I think, is to divide projects into sharply defined modules, each with a definitive owner”
Big companies want to decrease the standard deviation of design outcomes to avoid disasters, which damps oscillations and loses the high points as well as the low, so big companies win by sucking less than other big companies while startups win with great products.
“Big companies want to decrease the standard deviation of design outcomes because you want to avoid disasters.”
Use difficulty as a guide: the harder something is to do, the less competition you will face, so add decision points that favor the harder option, as in the run upstairs rule where a nimble person escapes a bully by running up rather than down.
“the harder something is to do the less competition you're going to have.”
Great work has to be better than it needs to be, because in the aggregate unseen details become visible; Leonardo painted every leaf of a juniper bush that no one would scrutinize, and that accumulated care produces something stunning.
“Relentlessness wins because in the aggregate, unseen details become visible.”
The growth of taste moves from unconscious imitation, to a conscious attempt at originality, to a stage where masters just want the right answer and will take from anyone, because being right matters more than being original.
“Finally, he decides it's more important to be right than original.”
At every stage a company should be kept as small as possible in employees, so people are surprised by how few employees it has, because fewer employees mean lower costs and less need to turn into a manager; smallness refers to headcount, not revenue.
“When I say small, I mean small in employees, not revenue.”
At Viaweb the main thing interviewers cared about was what software programmers wrote in their spare time, because you cannot do anything really well unless you love it and people who love to hack inevitably work on their own projects.
“At Viaweb, when we interviewed programmers, the main thing we cared about was what kind of software they wrote in their spare time.”
As a predictor of startup success, the economy is a rounding error compared with the founders, so what matters is who you are rather than when you start, and the right sort of person wins even in a bad economy.
“as a predictor of success, it's a rounding error compared to the founders”
In business there is nothing more valuable than a technical advantage your competitors do not understand, and a startup should give competitors as little information as possible, which is why Graham said nothing publicly about Viaweb's use of Lisp.
“In business, there is nothing more valuable than a technical advantage your competitors don't understand.”
The less you spend, the easier it is to make more than you spend; the cheaper your company is to run, the harder it is to kill, so founders should be cockroaches of the corporate world.
“So the cheaper your company is to operate, the harder it is to kill.”
The immediate cause of death for a startup is running out of money, so the cheaper your company is to operate, the harder it is to kill, which makes running it as cheaply as possible a recession-proof strategy.
“So the cheaper your company is to operate, the harder it is to kill.”
If something appeals to people today and would also have appealed to people in 1500, there is a good chance it will appeal to people in 2500, and aiming at timelessness forces you to find the best answer, since an ugly solution cannot be the best.
“If you can make something that appeals to people today and would also have appealed to people in the year 1500, there's a good chance that it will appeal to people in the year 2500.”
In practice it is easier to see ugliness than to imagine beauty, and most people who made beautiful things did so by fixing something they thought ugly, which requires understanding a field well enough to develop a nose for what needs fixing.
“In practice, I think it's easier to see ugliness than to imagine beauty.”
You can measure the value of work done by small groups, and this measurability is the opposite of why personal wealth is hard to generate inside large companies.
“And then he goes into smallness equals measurement. That's the second part of this.”
Once you examine the question, the ideas of beauty across different fields have much in common, and the same principles of good design crop up again and again, such as simplicity, timelessness, suggestiveness, difficulty, nature-resemblance, and redesign.
“Once you start to examine the question, it's surprising how much different field ideas of beauty have in common.”
The recipe for great work is very exacting taste plus the ability to gratify it.
“The recipe for great work is: very exacting taste plus the ability to gratify it.”
Wealth is whatever people want, and that concise principle summarizes Graham's essay and underlies Y Combinator's motto of making something people want.
“Wealth is whatever people want. That is a concise description of this essay.”
To get rich you need leverage in the sense that your decisions have a big effect, and a job that feels safe almost certainly lacks leverage because danger and leverage go together.
“If you're in a job that feels safe, you're not going to get rich because if there's no danger there's almost certainly no leverage”
The people most likely to grasp that wealth can be created are craftsmen, whose handmade objects become more valuable, but industrialization has reduced their numbers, leaving computer programmers as one of the largest remaining groups who create wealth directly.
“The people most likely to grasp that wealth can be created are the ones who are good at making things, the craftsmen.”
Only a small percentage of hackers can actually design software, and it is hard for company leaders to pick them out, so companies entrust design to committees and let hackers merely implement it.
“Only a small percentage of hackers can actually design software.”
In a big company you can do what all the other big companies are doing, but a startup cannot do what all other startups do, and startups succeed by being good at one thing rather than having business experience.
“In a big company, you can do what all the other big companies are doing. But a start-up can't do what all other start-ups do.”
Viaweb's development cycle was fast enough that it could sometimes duplicate a competitor's new feature within a day or two of the competitor announcing it in a press release.
“Our development cycle was so fast that we could sometimes duplicate a new feature within a day or two of a competitor announcing it in a press release.”
It is rare to get things right the first time, experts expect to throw work away and plan for plans to change, and mistakes should be made easy to acknowledge and easy to fix rather than treated as disasters.
“It's rare to get things right the first time. Experts expect to throw away some early work.”
Good design is hard and looks easy, like great athletes, but this ease is an illusion created by years of practice, since the conversational tone of good writing comes only on the eighth rewrite and the appearance of ease seems to come with practice.
“Mostly, this is an illusion. The easy, conversational tone of good writing comes only on the eighth rewrite.”
Most software is intended for a human audience, so you have to see things from the user's and customer's point of view, which Graham calls practically the secret of success.
“It turns out that looking at things from other people's point of view is practically the secret of success.”
Graham cites England in 1800 as a period when creators could keep their wealth, versus England in 1974, when a 98 percent tax on investment income switched wealth creation off.
“England in 1800, on. England in 1974, off.”
Venture capitalists have a name for the difficulty-as-moat idea, barriers to entry, and their first question about a new idea is how hard it would be for someone else to develop.
“Venture capitalists know about this and have a phrase for it, barriers to entry.”
Steve Jobs said design is how a thing works, not how it looks, which means a product or industry can be improved by noticing what is not quite right.
“Design is how it works. People think it's how it looks.”
Good design resembles nature because nature has had a long time to work on the problem, so when your answer resembles nature's it is a good sign, a principle Dee Hock also drew on when building Visa.
“nature has had a long time to work on the problem. So it's a good sign when your answer resembles nature's.”
Improved technology in 1985 let Graham buy a computer and earn money as a freelance programmer within months, a job that did not exist a few years earlier, illustrating that new technology creates new wealth without making others poorer.
“Within months, I was using it to make money as a freelance programmer. A few years before, there was no such thing as a freelance programmer.”
By keeping a group small and selected, you can get the best people, each in the top 1 percent; a startup is not merely 10 people but 10 people like you who also want to work harder and be paid more.
“By selecting that small of a group, you can get the best rowers, each one will be in the top 1%.”
Good design suggests rather than tells: giving users a few basic elements they can combine, like LEGO, is more engaging than specifying everything, as Jane Austen's sparse description lets readers envision the scene.
“In software, it means that you should give users a few basic elements that they can combine as they wish, like LEGO.”
Enzo Ferrari believed innate gifts are a peculiarity of certain regions, and transferred into industry these propensities can become exceptionally important, as with racing-car psychosis in Modena.
“It is my opinion that there are innate gifts that are a peculiarity of certain regions.”
To build something users love, start by making something clean and simple that you would want to use yourself, compare it to what it could be rather than what competitors currently offer, and use your own product all the time.
“Start by making something clean and simple that you would want to use yourself.”
If a painter were offered a brush that would make him a better painter, he would use it in all his paintings, and by analogy a company should adopt any idea that makes it better, since ideas function as tools.
“If a painter were offered a brush that would make him a better painter, it seems to me that he would want to use it in all his paintings, wouldn't he?”
Hackers and painters are among the most alike types of people, because both are makers whose shared goal is to make good things.
“What hackers and painters have in common is that they're both makers”
Parts of good software that no one is ever supposed to see should also be beautiful, in the same way a carpenter does not put crappy wood on the back of a dresser even though no one sees it.
“If you look inside good software, you'll find that parts no one is ever supposed to see are beautiful, too.”
As a general life plan, when you have two choices pick the harder one, because when one option is harder the only reason you consider the easier one is laziness, and choosing the harder option forces you to acknowledge what you already know is right.
“If you have 2 choices, choose the harder.”
Successful company builders do not have dozens of lessons to remember; they have a handful of core principles that they repeat decade over decade.
“they have a handful of core principles that they repeat decade over decade.”
Reading biographies of entrepreneurs works like a painter studying a museum, because each idea an entrepreneur develops builds on lessons from earlier ideas, which makes their history a reference library of techniques.
“This is the same exact idea that you see when you read a biography of an entrepreneur.”
Nearly all companies exist to do something people want; a company is simply a group of people working together on that, which is why opportunities are limitless because people always want new things.
“All a company is, is a group of people working together to do something people want”
Reading a great book is like a movie for the mind, because strong words on the page put images in the reader's mind.
“Just I would say like reading a great book is like a movie for the mind.”
Senra's readout of podcast sponsorship and listener promotion such as Readwise and the book link is promotional and not analytical content about the essays.
“you go to readwise.io/founders, and you can try it for 60 days for free”