#176 Linus Torvalds
What this covers
This Founders episode works through Linus Torvalds's memoir, with the host summarizing and commenting rather than interviewing. It begins with the person: a kid who gravitated to computers because they gave him a sense of control that people never did, a world of logic instead of illogical human relations. The host links this to the idea that control, over one's own work rather than over others, is the main drive behind entrepreneurs. The host also notes that the book opens with Torvalds's flaws, a trust-building move the host compares to David Ogilvy's sales technique, and that Torvalds credits laziness for Linux's growth. His inner scorecard gets a nod to Warren Buffett.
The middle of the episode covers the technology and its economics. It explains why AT&T, as a regulated monopoly, gave Unix source licenses to universities, and sets Unix's composable primitives against Windows's special-case interfaces. It then looks at how open source runs: Torvalds waits for volunteers to take over subsystems, and the key point is that anyone can ignore the leader and do the work themselves. Contributors are paid in esteem and in job offers from employers scanning code, which the episode calls a reputation economy.
It turns more contentious on business strategy. The music industry's reaction to Napster serves as an example of resource control fragility. Torvalds also says he wanted to be paid well for good work and preferred the American pay model to the Finnish one. The episode closes on forecasts: nobody predicts the future well, operating systems should fade from view, and following fun is the best defense.
Torvalds argues that fun is the ultimate motivator, and that Linux succeeded because he gave up control, let contributors work on what interested them, and built a useful product instead of controlling a resource.
- Survival, social order, and entertainment are the ordered motivators of life, and entertainment is the end goal
- Open source worked through volunteer self-selection and peer esteem rather than top-down management
- Controlling a scarce resource is fragile, while a better product outlasts incumbents
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
A clean operating system provides a small set of general building blocks that combine into infinite complexity, whereas an ugly system provides special interfaces for every task; Unix followed the first philosophy and Windows the second.
“An ugly system is one in which there are special interfaces for everything you want to do. Unix is the opposite.”
Open source contributors are motivated by reputational rewards: prolific contributors attract employers who scan code for talent, and peer esteem for solid contributions provides a strong motivation even without direct payment.
“The most prolific contributors attract the attention of employers who troll the code hoping to spot and hire top programmers.”
Open-source contributions function as a public demonstration of skill that lets programmers attract employers, because top contributors get noticed by employers scanning code, which turns the job search from outbound applying into inbound hiring.
“The most prolific contributors attract the attention of employers who troll the code hoping to spot and hire top programmers.”
Many problems are solved not by grinding through brute force but by finding the right approach; when you look at the problem differently, the problem can disappear, because it was only a problem given the wrong framing.
“You can do something in the brute force way. ... or you can find the right approach, and suddenly the problem just goes away.”
Trying to make a living by controlling a scarce resource or channel is fragile, because rising prices invite a better technology or route, such as piping water from a distance, that renders the controller obsolete; the better strategy is to build a better product.
“If you make money by controlling people or a resource, you'll eventually find yourself out of business.”
AT&T's Unix was freely distributed with source licenses, especially to universities, because AT&T was a regulated monopoly that could not sell computers and did not treat the operating system as a serious commercial venture.
“In fact, AT&T was a regulated monopoly. And one of the things they couldn't do was to sell computers anyway.”
Predicting the future is nearly impossible, as Torvalds did not predict Linux's success, and companies such as AT&T and Microsoft decline eventually, so no business will live forever.
“No business will live forever.”
The best way to lead is to let people do things because they want to, not because you want them to; leaders should also admit when they are wrong and let others make decisions for them.
“the best and most effective way to lead is by letting people do the things -- do things because they want to do them, not because you want them to.”
When incumbent industries move to protect their fiefdoms, such as the music industry against Napster-style file sharing, the defensive move backfires because it prevents the market from expanding and invites disruption.
“What the incumbent typically does during this, the industry moves to protect its fiefdom and it backfires. It prevents the market from expanding.”
The point of open source is not that its leader is more accessible or open to suggestions, but that anyone can ignore the leader and do the work themselves, so even a difficult leader cannot block progress.
“It's not about me being open. It's about them having the power to ignore me.”
Making software free does not mean money is irrelevant to the creator; Torvalds wanted financial rewards for good work and believed the American system of paying top performers far more is superior to the Finnish model of paying them just a little more.
“In Finland, if a worker is much better than his colleagues, you give him just a little more money and keep him very quiet. In America, you give him a lot more money, and it works.”
Torvalds argues that history does not repeat, but human nature does, so predictable patterns of incumbent control and disruption recur, and the obvious outcome of controlling a resource should have been foreseen by the entertainment industry.
“Could the entertainment industry not have predicted the obvious that the price of water would get so high that somebody would devise a new method of piping it from somewhere else.”
Torvalds manages the hundreds of thousands of Linux developers by not delegating proactively; instead he waits for people to volunteer to take over subsystems, approves or disapproves their work, and lets things happen naturally.
“I don't proactively delegate as much as I wait for people to come forward and volunteer to take over things.”
Opening with one's flaws builds trust, as antique dealers and David Ogilvy used it in sales, and Torvalds's book leads with his ugliness, nerdiness, and poor social skills to make the story refreshing and believable.
“telling somebody the flaws upfront causes them to trust you.”
Torvalds argues Linux's success is attributable to his personal flaws, laziness and wanting credit for others' work, because these traits pushed him to let others contribute and build a development model with hundreds of thousands of participants rather than a half-dozen geeks.
“Much of Linux's success can be attributed to my own personality flaws. One, I'm lazy. And two, I like to get the credit for work of others.”
Users do not want operating systems or even computers; they want the outcomes these tools provide, like browsing and writing papers, so the infrastructure should eventually become invisible and operating systems should not be a major topic in the future.
“the fact is nobody wants an operating system.”
Torvalds followed an inner scorecard, making decisions based on his own judgment of what was interesting and skillful rather than on the expectations of others, as Warren Buffett's inner-scorecard idea describes.
“It sounds like he's got an inner scorecard.”
Torvalds's theory of the meaning of life holds that the three motivational factors for all living things are survival, social order, and entertainment, which progress in that order, so the ultimate goal of life is to reach entertainment and have fun.
“The first is survival. The second is social order. The third is entertainment.”
Torvalds became obsessed with computers early because they gave him a sense of control that he lacked with people, letting him feel like he could play God in a world governed by logic rather than by the illogic of human relations.
“he didn't have a sense of control with other humans in the real world, so he would kind of escape into this -- almost like this world within the world because he could play God in a sense.”
Creativity has a high price because most people mimic others, so truly original work is rare and therefore extremely lucrative; survival and flourishing come from making the best product possible, and businesses that cannot do so deserve to fail.
“Human creativity got a price tag, and it turned out to be quite expensive. Creativity is rare.”
Games are often at the cutting edge of technology and are the first programs programmers build, because some of the smartest programmers are teenagers playing in their rooms, so today's toys become tomorrow's industries.
“Partly, it has to do with the fact that some of the smartest programmers out there are 15-year-old kids playing around in their rooms.”
Torvalds kept working on Linux by divesting himself of responsibilities that held little interest for him, which he argues sustained his motivation and kept him from quitting.
“I divested myself of things that didn't hold much interest for me.”
The number one trait driving entrepreneurs is control over what they get to do, more than fame or wealth, and Torvalds fits this pattern while wanting control only over his own work rather than other people.
“I would say the #1 trait, and I even see this playoff in some like opinion polls, it's control, control over what you get to do”
Torvalds argues that no one is good at predicting the future, and he never predicted Linux would spread widely; the best defense is to pursue fun work and see what opportunities open up.
“I've not been a very good predictor of much of anything in my life. Did I predict that this little operating system I started writing for my own use would someday be all over the place? Nope.”
Torvalds says being a good programmer pays well and being acknowledged as world-class pays even better, and he did not need a commercial company because he hates paperwork and could not manage employees.
“being a good programmer actually pays pretty well, being acknowledged as being world-class pays even better. I simply didn't need to start a commercial company.”
Simplicity should not be confused with ease; being simple takes design and good taste, and it is a deliberate achievement rather than a shortcut.
“You should absolutely not dismiss simplicity for something easy. It takes design and good taste to be simple.”
Torvalds's computer was paid off through a collection started by other Linux users who loved his work, demonstrating how the community gave back to him without his asking for money.
“People just started saying, let's start a collection to pay off Linus' computer.”
Shareware, in which software is distributed freely and users pay if they find it useful, shaped early business ideas, and id Software's Doom made roughly 1 to 5 percent of players pay for extra levels while earning around 100,000 dollars a day at its peak.
“only like 1% to like 5%, something like that”
Andrew Tanenbaum's book on operating systems, which described the Unix philosophy and included the MINIX teaching system, was the book that launched Torvalds into serious operating system work and led to his building his own Unix-like kernel.
“The book that launched me to new heights was Operating Systems: Design and Implementation by Andrew S. Tanenbaum.”
Early Linux users were asked for postcards rather than payment, which tracked the geographic spread of usage and helped shape the project's non-commercial norms, and Torvalds planned to monetize value-added services on top of a free base.
“I asked for postcards instead of money from people who use Linux.”
Companies built on Linux that went public in the late 1990s and early 2000s gave Torvalds stock options, reportedly worth around 20 million dollars, which the host notes contradicts the view that he avoided money.
“He winds up -- there's a couple of companies that go public in the late '90s, early 2000s that are built on Linux. They gave him stock options. He winds up -- in the book, it says something like $20 million.”
Major ventures start small, like an acorn growing into an oak, and a new idea needs to be willing to grow slowly from a sapling into a business over time.
“We know from our past experiences that big things start small. The biggest oak starts from an acorn.”
Torvalds describes himself as an unattractive, socially awkward nerd whose good grades came easily and who had an accepted place in the social order, a self-portrait the host reads as a deliberate trust-building choice.
“I was a nerd, a geek. ... I'm good at math, good at physics and no social graces, whatsoever.”
People do their best work when they are driven by passion and having fun, and this applies to artists, entrepreneurs, and software engineers alike, so a job you love makes persistence far easier.
“It has been well established that folks do their best work when they're driven by a passion, when they're having fun.”
Torvalds tracked Linux's popularity in early internet newsgroups, where it became one of the most discussed topics, showing that the project's community formed through online discussion.
“one of the most popular in the Internet at the time -- I think this is early '90s, was Linux.”
Computer science resembles physics but differs in that physics discovers how the world is made while computer science lets you create the world, giving the programmer near-total control within the machine.
“in physics you're supposed to figure out how the world is made up, in computer science you create the world.”
Linux spread because it solved a real need, and Torvalds's decision to not seek commercial control while others found it useful became a model for projects that grow through use rather than through sales.
“It's fascinating that he winds up building a successful commercial project not trying to make it commercial.”
Torvalds argues that invincible-seeming companies like AT&T eventually go limp, and by the same logic the weeds will overrun the buildings in Redmond, meaning Microsoft will eventually decline; no business lasts forever.
“we can predict that if we stick around long enough, the weeds will overrun those tidy little green buildings in Redmond someday too”
Sleeping about 10 hours a day, or at least 8 hours a night, makes waking hours sharper so that the brain functions on all cylinders, and skipping sleep for longer shifts is counterproductive.
“I'm a firm believer in sleep. Some people think it's being lazy.”
Torvalds released the first crude Linux version privately to only 5 to 10 people rather than publicly, a low-stakes release that still gave him feedback and momentum.
“I just informed a handful of people by private e-mail, probably between 5 and 10 people in all.”
Torvalds says he lacked a commercial company because he hated paperwork and could not handle employees, and that a company he started would never have succeeded because it was not what he was interested in.
“I absolutely hate paperwork. I couldn't take care of employees if I tried.”
Torvalds rejects the label benevolent dictator for his role because it conjures an authoritarian image, and he says he is merely lazy, not controlling.
“Benevolent dictator, no, I'm just lazy.”
Torvalds defines Linux's success as the number of people who use it, rather than financial return or personal fame, so he measures his project by adoption.
“for me, I want Linux the success, and the definition of that success is a lot of people would use it.”
Torvalds describes himself as an awkward nerd with poor social skills, and he argues that his personal flaws do not matter to Linux because the project is organized so that his unavailability is not critical.
“Listen, I'm deficient in social skills. I'm not good with people.”
Finns are stoic and silent, which Torvalds attributes to surviving domination by Russia and to harsh weather, and this contrasts sharply with the chatty culture he encountered in America.
“Finns are stoic to a fault. Silent suffering and fierce determination might be what helped us survive”
Repetition is persuasive, and Torvalds repeats key ideas throughout the book, such as the ordering of survival, social order, and entertainment, which makes the book's philosophy stick.
“repetition is persuasive.”
If you optimize for fun and do not chase social status or money once your needs are met, you will enjoy most of your life, as Torvalds does when he says he wakes up feeling like the luckiest person alive.
“if you're always optimizing for fun, if you don't get too caught up in your social status or what other people think of you or just chasing money if you already have all your needs met, you're going to enjoy most”
Torvalds chose to make several major life changes at once, including moving countries, changing jobs, becoming a father, and marrying, which he later called madness but considered a reasonable decision.
“In retrospect, I guess getting all those changes over at once was a good idea, but it was madness.”
Co-author David Diamond described Torvalds as lacking ego compared with Silicon Valley peers, but the host argues this applies only in relative terms, since Torvalds displayed ego in his interactions with other top technologists.
“I think what he's talking about there is in the context of other people.”
Linux has changed substantially over the years and so has Torvalds, and this continual change with new challenges is what keeps the work fun, because a project that never changed would be boring.
“It's interesting, it's challenging. And if I didn't have those interests and challenge, it would be boring. In other words, it wouldn't be fun.”
The host argues very few people live their lives the way Torvalds does, treating fun as the organizing principle, which makes his philosophy appealing and difficult to adopt in practice.
“very few people actually live their lives that way. It's extremely, extremely hard to do so”
Torvalds chose a job in California partly to avoid Finnish snow and to live somewhere warmer, showing that quality-of-life considerations can override career opportunities.
“I don't want to deal with the snow, and I want to be in California”