#119 The Dodge Brothers
What this covers
Dave Senra walks through the story of John Dodge and Horace Dodge, two machinists who moved to Detroit in 1887 to be near its foundries and shops. Their path ran from a modest bicycle business to a machine shop, then to a February 1903 agreement to supply Henry Ford before Ford Motor Company existed, and finally to their own car in 1914. Senra reads this as Selling Pickaxes in a Gold Rush: while everyone in Detroit wanted to build cars, the Dodges sold the components.
The money details carry much of the episode. The Dodges spent over $60,000 on retooling and materials before Ford paid anything. When Ford struggled to pay, they threatened to seize the machines. They later wrote off $7,000 of overdue payments and extended $3,000 more credit for about 10 percent of Ford's stock, and the original $10,000 stake eventually returned $32 million. The story also covers Ford's gradual effort to cut his Single Point of Dependence on them, and the lawyer who asked why they didn't build their own car. In 18 months they designed one, built a dealer network, and still filled Ford orders.
The contested claims concern structure. Senra credits the Owner-Operator Speed of Decision that came from owning the company outright and avoiding banks and boards. He also argues that one factory kept complexity low, compared with Ford's fourteen assembly plants and GM's hundreds of plants. Further turns include the Dodges raising prices while Ford cut them, and their 1917 output of French Recoil Mechanism units at about five times the French rate. Senra also detours into Detroit as an industrial hotbed, compared with Enzo Ferrari's Modena, and into earned press versus advertising.
The Dodge brothers became fabulously wealthy by staying machinists who owned their business outright, supplying the raw components of the emerging auto industry, and only building their own car after Ford's dependence had made them rich enough to do it.
- Full ownership and a single decision-maker let the Dodges move far faster than rivals like Ford, Durant and Sloan, who had to answer to banks and boards.
- Supplying parts to Ford, rather than building cars, turned a $10,000 stake into a $32 million return before the brothers launched their own car.
- Their success came in steps (bicycles, machine shop, auto supplier, own car), each built on skills and risks taken in the prior stage.
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Ford Motor Company struggled to make its early payments to the Dodges, and the Dodges threatened to seize and sell the machines; a last-minute $10,500 investment kept Ford afloat, and the host argues the early days of companies are fragile.
“Malcomson admitted to the Dodge Brothers that he did not have the money to pay them.”
Unlike Henry Ford, who kept lowering Model T prices, the Dodges raised prices over time as models improved, and John Dodge justified this by saying Ford owners would one day want an automobile.
“Dodge Brothers prices rose over time, reflecting the various improvements incorporated into new models.”
When the US asked for recoil mechanisms for French artillery in 1917, the Dodges produced 24 a day at their peak, about five times the output the French had managed with their skilled machinists.
“They never made more than five of these things a day. The Dodge Brothers at their peak, were able to make 5x of that, 24 a day.”
Everyone in Detroit wanted to build an automobile, so the Dodges did not build cars yet; they sold the components the manufacturers needed, which the host calls selling pickaxes instead of digging for gold and gave them a huge advantage.
“everybody is in a gold rush, you don't dig for gold. You sell pickaxes.”
The Dodges built their enormous new plant so quickly because they owned it and were on the factory floor, so they did not need board, bank, or outside stockholder approval for millions in spending, as the plant manager explained.
“Chiefly because the Dodge brothers themselves own the plant. If we had been obliged to get permission from a board of directors, from banking interest, from outside stockholders”
Because the Dodges owned their company outright, never borrowed from banks, and never answered to a board or outside stockholders, they could make large investments quickly, whereas Ford, Durant, and Sloan had to manage far more complexity.
“Unlike Ford, Durant and Sloan, the Dodges enjoyed full ownership of Dodge Brothers from the beginning. Never borrowed from banks and never had to consider stockholders or a board of directors in making business decisions.”
During World War I the U.S. government compelled Dodge Brothers to produce war supplies, and when Secretary of War Newton Baker sought a manufacturer for French recoil mechanisms, John Dodge said blueprints were all they needed.
“John Dodge replied in angry and earthy language that he in Horace needed only blueprints to begin machine production.”
The Dodges moved from a small Michigan city to Detroit in 1887 because Detroit's foundries and machine shops, filled with people wanting to build horseless carriages, were the place where their machinist skills matched the emerging auto industry.
“Well, Detroit in early 1900s was full of people that wanted to build horseless carriages.”
Lawyer Howard Bloomer asked the Dodges why they did not build their own car and reminded them that total dependence on Ford could prove costly; both brothers conceded the next day that he was right.
“Bloomer reminded the Dodges that their total dependence on Ford could prove costly to their business.”
Ford gradually reduced dependence on the Dodges by sourcing a Model B with outside parts in 1904, announcing in 1905 plans to produce engines and transmissions in-house, and manufacturing a substantial share of components himself in 1906, which the host calls keeping options open while applying leverage.
“Henry Ford was keeping his options open and applying leverage to the Dodge Brothers at the same time.”
The Dodges wrote off $7,000 of overdue Ford payments and extended $3,000 more credit in exchange for about 10 percent of Ford Motor Company stock, a deal that later became worth tens of millions and the host calls a hell of a return on investment.
“the Dodge agreed in June 1903 to write-off overdue payments of $7,000 and extend Ford an additional $3,000 credit.”
The Dodge Brothers manufactured about 60 percent of the total value of Ford cars produced from 1903 to 1914, including the Model T, so the host argues there was no Henry Ford without the Dodges and no Dodge Brothers without Ford.
“The Dodge Brothers manufacture 60% of the total value of the Ford cars produced between 1903 and 1914, including the legendary Model T.”
Over an 18-month span the Dodges designed and produced an entirely new automobile, built a national sales organization and franchise dealer network from scratch, and expanded their factories while still fulfilling Ford contracts until June 1914.
“Over a remarkable 18-month span, John and Horace Dodge designed and produced an entirely new automobile”
The original $10,000 investment in Ford Motor Company in 1903 yielded a total return of $32 million for the Dodges.
“The original investment of $10,000 in the Ford Motor Company in 1903 yielded a total return of $32 million.”
To begin production for Ford, the Dodge Brothers spent more than $60,000 on retooling and raw materials before receiving any revenue from Ford, a huge risk the host considers central to their story.
“To begin production for Ford, the Dodge Brothers spent more than $60,000 for retooling and raw materials before receiving any revenues.”
Certain cities become hotbeds for a single industry because they concentrate passionate, skilled people, as Modena did for racing cars under Enzo Ferrari and Detroit did for horseless carriages in the early 1900s.
“there's just certain cities in certain geographical locations... that are just a hotbed of activity in one particular industry.”
The Dodges got lengthy favorable press in the Detroit Free Press in 1901, and the host argues that earned editorial coverage is more valuable than advertising, citing James Dyson's experience.
“James Dyson would tell you that editorials are more valuable than advertisements.”
The further a company spreads across plants and locations, the more complexity it invites, which the host says the Dodges understood intuitively with one factory after 1910, versus Ford's two major plants and fourteen assembly plants and GM's hundreds of plants.
“The further you get away from one, the more complexity you're inviting in.”
Dividends from Ford Motor Company to the Dodges grew from $98,000 in 1904 to $500,000 in 1908, $3.6 million in 1909 and $2.3 million in 1910, showing how fast a company can grow once it succeeds.
“1904, $98,000; 1905, $200,000; 1906, nothing; 1907, $10,000; 1908, $500,000, huge jump; 1909, $3.6 million; 1910, $2.3 million.”
The Dodges' formula for success was complementary skills, interests, and personalities combined with genuine mutual understanding and liking, along with staying honest and fair to customers and employees.
“Their formula for success was quite simple. They had complementary skills, interest and personalities while they genuinely understood and liked each other.”
The Dodges' careers unfolded in steps: a modestly successful bicycle business, then a very successful machine shop, and finally a hugely successful automobile manufacturer, with over a decade of experience-building between them.
“So think of the careers of John and Horace in steps. One, they have a small, relatively modestly successful bicycle manufacturing business”
Founders are constantly influenced by and borrow ideas from other founders, so the careers of later famous founders can be traced to earlier figures such as Steve Jobs's ties to Edwin Land, Bob Noyce and the Packard/Hewlett pair, and Jeff Bezos's ties to Sam Walton, James Sinegal and Sol Price.
“Founders are constantly influenced and borrow ideas from other founders.”
In February 1903 the Dodges agreed to become the major component supplier for Henry Ford before the Ford Motor Company existed, which was riskier than their factory build-out but ultimately brilliant.
“They agreed in February 1903 to become the major supplier of components for Henry Ford, before the current Ford Motor Company even existed.”
The Dodges' near-total dependence on Ford, who would eventually make all of his own components, pushed them to take their fate into their own hands and build their own car.
“They worried about their near-total dependence on Ford, recognizing that he would eventually manufacture all of his own components.”
The Dodge company survived and prospered after the brothers died, later becoming a core component of the Chrysler Corporation, and the host argues the brothers' formula was complementary skills, shared interests and mutual trust.
“Their formula for success was quite simple. They had complementary skills, interest and personalities while they genuinely understood and liked each other.”
The Dodge brothers thought of themselves primarily as machinists, not as investors or businessmen, even after they became fabulously wealthy, and this made them more comfortable with working-class people than with Detroit's elites.
“But by trade and how they thought about themselves was machinists. They thought of themselves even when they were fabulously wealthy.”
Olds Motor Works served as a training ground for future automotive leaders, employing or contracting with people such as Jonathan Maxwell, Roy Chaplin, and the Wilson Body Company, many of whom later built their own car companies.
“More important, the Olds Motor Works attracted the future automotive pioneers with substantial contracts for automobile components and it was the training ground for other automotive leaders.”
Roughly 2,000 automobile manufacturers in the United States were winnowed to three over about 70 years, so many early pioneers are now forgotten even though they once had their own companies.
“we went from like 2,000 automobile manufacturers down to three in the United States over, let's say, a 70-year period”
John and Horace divided responsibilities and stayed out of each other's way, which avoided duplication of effort and conflict; John handled contracts, finance and sales while Horace handled engineering and production.
“By dividing up the tasks and responsibilities for those tasks, John and Horace Dodge stayed out of each other's way, and thus avoided duplication of efforts and conflict.”
Ransom Olds introduced the first gasoline carriage sold in significant numbers in June 1896 and is described as the single most important early pioneer of the Michigan auto industry, having shifted to gasoline engines after the 1893 Chicago World Fair.
“Ransom Olds was, in many respects, the founder of the Michigan automobile industry and the most important early automotive pioneer in the United States.”
Henry Ford withheld dividends and used company profits to expand his plant, which forced the Dodge brothers to sue him in 1916 to compel distribution of profits to stockholders.
“Dodge Brothers are forced to sue Henry Ford because Henry Ford is not paying out the dividends and he's using it to expand his plant”
The Spanish flu killed an estimated 50 to 100 million people between 1918 and 1920, and the host recommends the book The Pale Rider as a biography of the pandemic for readers interested in using history to anticipate present events.
“Spanish flu killed an estimated 50 million to 100 million people between 1918 and 1920.”
Machining skills transferred from New England to Detroit because the auto industry there valued them more, so talent and knowledge flow to wherever they are best applied.
“those skills are a lot more valuable applied to the automotive industry in Detroit than they are in New England.”
The Dodges sold their stake in the Canadian bicycle company for $70,500 partly because a Canadian bicycle cartel was consolidating independent makers to control prices, a pattern the host links to Vanderbilt and Rockefeller.
“There was a Canadian bicycle cartel. They rolled up a -- we've seen this throughout history.”
When advertising executive Theodore MacManus arrived, John Dodge said the company sweats blood to save a tenth of a cent while ad people throw away 10 percent, and MacManus then chose to promote the new car as honest and practical like the brothers themselves.
“MacManus, impressed with John Dodge's honesty, began thinking about promoting the new car as honest and practical, much like the brothers themselves.”
Horace Dodge treated the shop floor as his domain, constantly designing new machines and processes, and was quiet and shy outside the factory but commanded authority inside it.
“Outside, he was quiet, reticent and could even be termed shy. But within the four walls, he was the master of the domain.”
By early 1901 the Dodges won their first automotive contract, manufacturing engines for Ransom Olds's Olds Motor Works, which the host calls the founder of the Michigan auto industry.
“By early 1901, the Dodges had their first automotive contract. They were to manufacture engines for Olds Motor Works.”
Henry Leland brought high machine-shop accuracy standards from New England to Detroit, and skills like these were more valuable applied to Detroit's auto industry than in New England, which is why Horace gained valuable experience working for him.
“Horace no doubt gained valuable experience working for Henry Leland, who had brought to Detroit the high standards for accuracy already attained in machine shops of Leland's native New England.”
John and Horace Dodge are usually overlooked in histories of the early automotive industry, and some historians understate their importance, despite their critical role in Henry Ford's early success.
“John and Horace Dodge are usually overlooked in histories of the early automotive industry.”
In 1887 Detroit was a city of about 200,000 with scores of foundries and machine shops, which supplied the raw materials and skilled labor needed to build cars.
“In 1887, Detroit was a midsized city of about 200,000 people with an industrial base that included scores of foundries and machine shops.”
Evans & Dodge promoted bicycle riding generally by offering free instruction to owners of its bikes and charging others $2 for five lessons, a move the host sees as a smart way to drive sales.
“They offered bicycle riding instruction. Instruction was free for people that owned Evans & Dodge bicycle”
Billy Durant was primarily a financial tycoon and stock manipulator who combined many automakers into General Motors in 1908 and seemed indifferent to their profitability or efficiency, with his field of dreams on the New York Stock Exchange rather than the assembly floor.
“His field of dreams was not found on the floor of the assembly plant like the Dodge brothers, but on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange.”
In the first two years of the machine shop, John and Horace worked extremely long hours, routinely returning to work until midnight, and John estimated they spent only six weekday evenings at home in that period.
“John Dodge estimated during the first 2 years of the company, they spent a total of only 6 weekday evenings at home.”
Many companies founded by early automotive pioneers still survive more than 120 years later, which the host calls very, very rare.
“How many of these companies that they founded still survived to this day. You're talking about over 120 years later. That's very, very rare.”
The Dodges' contract let them sell all unsold machines and keep the proceeds if Ford missed payments, which gave them leverage and some asset protection.
“If Ford failed to make the required payments, the Dodge Brothers could sell all unsold machines and keep the proceeds.”
Surviving Dodge notebooks document cost and quality estimates from more than 100 potential suppliers for frames, wheels, bearings, and ignition systems, and the book describes them as a primer on launching a new automobile.
“In short, these notebooks are a primer on launching a new automobile.”
Fred Evans, the Dodges' bicycle partner, deliberately went where competitors were not: his company was the only Canadian bicycle maker exhibiting at the February 1897 New York Cycle Show, where he spent 10 days and reportedly sold 50 wheels to dealers in Philadelphia and New York City.
“His company was the only Canadian bicycle manufacturer to exhibit its wares at the New York Cycle Show in February 1897.”
John Dodge specified that his pallbearers at his funeral would be ordinary shop men, a signal of how the brothers preferred factory workers to Detroit's business and social elites long after they became wealthy.
“John's instruction that the pallbearers at his funeral would all be ordinary shop men, is but one indication of this.”
The Dodge Brothers' first ad promised to build marine and stationary engines and to do any class of work done in a first-class modern shop, showing that early on they took any job to keep the lights on and narrowed their focus only later.
“hey, I need to take any job I can, I need to keep the lights on here. I got to take any job. You'll see over time they narrow their focus.”
The Dodge Brothers' machine shop was the first in Detroit able to do very close and accurate work, and they installed machine tools that no one else in Detroit had the courage to consider, which the host sees as a model of doing things better than anyone else.
“They installed machine tools of a size and character that nobody else in Detroit had the courage to consider.”
The Dodges were combative, nearly starting a fistfight with Ford tester Rockelman, but they apologized and corrected faulty flywheel holes when shown they were wrong, showing they would change course when wrong.
“they were gentlemen enough to apologize and said they would correct that.”
As teenagers, John and Horace Dodge could not afford a $200 high-wheel bicycle, so they fabricated their own from scrap, including a baby carriage wheel, and rode it for two years with performance equal to a store-bought model.
“John and Horace fabricated their own high-wheel bicycle from scrap. They fashioned the high wheel by hand and used the wheel from a baby carriage for the small rear wheel.”
The late-1800s bicycle industry was a launchpad: many people who later became pioneers in other fields, including the Wright brothers and the Dodges, got their start in bicycles.
“a lot of people that wound up moving on and becoming pioneers in other fields got their start in the bicycle industry.”
The host recalls a Jeff Bezos anecdote in which a manager needing approval for a large warehouse was told 'you just did,' illustrating how a single decision-maker with full authority moves fast.
“Jeff goes, you just did. Go do it and that was it.”
In 1896 Horace invented an improved bicycle bearing that was dirt-proof and gave a smoother ride, and the brothers shared the patent, which is how they became inventors and bicycle manufacturers before the machine shop.
“Horace is the one that invents and patents an improved bicycle bearing in 1896, and then he has his brother on there to share the patent with him.”
A disastrous fire that destroyed most of Ransom Olds's factory forced him to rely more on outside suppliers, which gave the Dodges more work, showing that businesses can benefit from random tragedies outside their control.
“sometimes you're granted an opportunity from random tragic events. They're outside of your control, but you can still benefit from them.”
Books are the original links, leading readers from one idea to another the way hyperlinks do on the Internet, which is how the host discovered the interconnected early automotive figures in the Dodge book.
“books are the original links, they lead us from one idea to another, just like the modern links on the Internet do.”
John Dodge admitted the Ford contract was foolish and that they would have demanded much more if they had been wiser, which the host reads as a lesson that people grow into who they become without knowing what they don't know.
“We had a rather foolish contract, or we would have compelled them, meaning the Ford Motor Company, to pay over much more.”
The Dodge brothers launched their first car when John was 50 and Horace was 46, and the host argues this shows it is never too late to start something new.
“At the introduction of the first Dodge Brothers car, John Dodge was 50 and Horace was 46.”
Horace, chronically ill and psychologically devastated by John's death, saw no reason to live, and died within a year, with liver complications also contributing to his death.
“Chronically ill with influenza and psychologically devastated by John's death, he saw no reason to live.”
Horace Dodge resembled Henry Royce: a gifted engineer who focused on engineering and craftsmanship and left other areas of the business to his partner.
“He reminds me a lot of Henry Royce, the gifted engineer responsible with -- for the high-quality products that you see from Rolls-Royce, where he let other people run other areas of the business”
John Dodge died of pneumonia from influenza on January 14, 1920, at age 55 with his lungs previously damaged by tuberculosis, and Horace, chronically ill and grieving, died on December 10, 1920, at age 52.
“He died on January 14 at the Ritz-Carlton Hotel in New York City, with Horace at his side. He was 55 years old.”
After the brothers died, the Dodge company remained with their widows until its 1925 sale to New York bankers and then its 1928 purchase by Walter Chrysler.
“with the company remaining in the hands of their widows until its sale in 1925 to New York bankers and then the subsequent purchase in 1928 by Walter Chrysler.”
The brothers' first automotive factory was a two-story brick building of 50 by 138 feet, which the host considers a reminder that all new ideas start small.
“It was 50 feet wide and 138 feet long.”
John and Horace Dodge insisted that business mail be addressed to Dodge Brothers and refused letters addressed to them individually, and when John died in January 1920, Horace died less than a year later, reflecting a bond the host says was like friendship.
“The brothers insisted that mail directed to the business be addressed 'To Dodge Brothers' or they would return it unopened.”