#251 Ben Franklin and George Washington: The Founding Partnership
What this covers
David Senra tells the story of Benjamin Franklin and George Washington as one joint narrative, starting on the colonial frontier. Washington's journal from a mission at 21 was published on the orders of Governor Dinwiddie and made him a hero, and it reached Franklin in Philadelphia. Washington's early battles, including the defeat at Fort Necessity, were disasters, and he thought his military career was over. General Braddock's rout in the forest taught a wider lesson about fighting on terrain where the enemy has the advantage. Franklin took the frontier reports as proof of danger and began pressing for an intercolonial defensive confederation, publishing the "Join or Die" cartoon. He carried that plan to the Constitutional Convention.
The range is wide. On Franklin's side it covers his vertical integration of printing, with about two dozen print shops and almost as many paper mills. It also covers his electricity experiments, his late-life guesses about volcanoes and winter, daylight saving, bifocals, and his diplomacy in France, which Gordon Wood judged unmatched. On Washington's side it covers teenage surveying for land speculation and the Fabian strategy of attrition after the winter of 1776-77. Franklin's arithmetic propaganda aimed at British readers and his remark that Philadelphia had taken Howe also get space.
The contested material is mostly about temperament and politics. Franklin's reasoned appeals, such as rum after chapel, are set against Washington's reliance on discipline. Franklin's opposition to the Stamp Act is framed as practical rather than rights-based, and he warned that the executive would drift toward monarchy. Senra also turns Braddock's fate into a business lesson, never underestimate your opponent, alongside Charlie Munger's point about playing games where others have the aptitudes.
Senra argues that Franklin and Washington's three-decade partnership, built on shared hardship, frontier lessons, and coordinated division of labor, was decisive in founding the United States, and that their practical habits (industry, reasoned persuasion, willingness to learn from defeat) are worth studying.
- Franklin handled logistics, diplomacy, and finance while Washington commanded in the field, and their success depended on coordination
- Early defeats in the French and Indian War taught both men lessons (e.g., never underestimate opponents, fight on the enemy's terms) that resurfaced in the Revolution
- Both men shared a pragmatic faith in reason and reform and acted on belief shifts among colonists
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Franklin proposed an intercolonial defensive confederation and printed the first original editorial cartoon in an American newspaper, the 'Join or Die' rattlesnake, to press the colonies to unite against the frontier threat, an early outline of the later federal union.
“Beneath this appeal, he printed the first original editorial cartoon in any American newspaper”
Franklin warned that the executive would keep growing until it ended in monarchy, and he twice defended the power to impeach corrupt presidents against those, like Governor Morris, who would place them above the law during their terms.
“The executive will always be increasing from here as elsewhere till it ends in a monarchy.”
Franklin and Washington were friends first, never rivals, and their three-decade partnership, spanning the French and Indian War, the Revolution, and the founding of the federal government, did more than any other pairing to forge the American nation because Franklin's diplomacy and Washington's command required coordination to succeed.
“Victory required both of these efforts to succeed and their success required coordination and cooperation.”
Franklin integrated forward and backward from printing, owning or holding interests in about two dozen print shops and almost as many paper mills, and he positioned himself through public printing contracts, the postmastership, and the assembly clerkship to get the news first.
“He owned or had an interest in some two dozen other print shops and almost as many paper mills.”
General Howe failed to recognize that armies, not cities, were critical in this war, and his capture of Philadelphia was strategically shortsighted, which led Franklin to say that Philadelphia had taken Howe rather than the reverse.
“Instead of Howe taking Philadelphia, Philadelphia has taken Howe.”
Franklin wrote a piece aimed at British readers arguing that Britain had spent $3 million to kill 150 Yankees while gaining a mile of ground, and invited readers to calculate the time and expense needed to conquer the colonies, using arithmetic as a propaganda tool.
“Britain at the expense of $3 million has killed 150 Yankees this campaign”
Franklin reasoned that anger over unfair economic conditions is predictable and, if left unresolved, leads to violence, which is what happened when Boston mobs forced officials such as Andrew Oliver to resign and the local militia and sheriff failed to restore order.
“when you have anger over unfair economic conditions is one completely predictable. And two, if it's unresolved, it's going to lead to violence”
Braddock's British troops, disciplined for European formal battle, were exposed and routed in the forest by French and native fighters who were at home in the terrain, illustrating Munger's point that playing games where others have the aptitudes and you do not is nearly certain to lose.
“If you play games where other people have the aptitudes and don't, you're going to lose.”
General Braddock dismissed warnings about native ambush, arrogantly assuming disciplined regulars would withstand them, and this underestimation of the opponent led directly to his defeat and death, making it a lesson that applies to business competition as well.
“These savages may indeed be a formidable enemy to your raw American militia, but upon the King's regular and disciplined troops, sir, it is impossible that they should make an impression.”
After the winter of 1776-77 Washington favored a Fabian strategy, named after Roman general Quintus Fabius, of avoiding open battle, disrupting supply lines, and wearing down a stronger army through attrition, which he justified as needed because desperate diseases require desperate remedies.
“Washington now favored adopting a so-called Fabian military strategy which was named after the Roman General Quintus Fabius who wore down a superior Carthaginian army through a war of attrition.”
In his late seventies Franklin attributed the unusually cold European winter of 1783 to emissions from an Icelandic volcano, proposed daylight saving time, invented bifocals, and contributed to early hydrogen-balloon flight while serving as ambassador in France.
“In a remarkably original deduction, he attributed the unusually cold winter of 1783 in Europe to the atmospheric impact of emissions from an Icelandic volcano.”
Governor Dinwiddie recognized the propaganda value of Washington's journal from the frontier mission and ordered it published, turning the 21-year-old militia officer into a frontier hero almost overnight, and the published journal reached Franklin in Philadelphia.
“Recognizing the propaganda value of Washington's account Dinwiddie immediately ordered it published for wide distribution.”
The frontier defeats in the French and Indian War, including Braddock's, gave Americans the first suspicion that British soldiers were not invincible, and Virginia soldiers in frontier fighting outperformed British troops, a lesson that resurfaced in the Revolution.
“This gave us Americans the first suspicion that the exalted ideas of the prowess of British soldiers was not well founded.”
Franklin, despite his age and gout, kidney stones, and gall problems, arranged arms, uniforms, naval support, foreign loans, prisoner releases, and back-channel peace talks, and the historian Gordon Wood concluded that no one else could have represented America abroad as well and that Franklin was the greatest diplomat America has had.
“He was the greatest diplomat that America has ever had.”
Franklin, seeing Washington's frontier reports as proof of danger, began promoting an intercolonial defensive confederation, which was the first step toward the union he later helped craft.
“Franklin saw Washington's on-the-ground reports from the frontier as proof that the 13 colonies needed to join in common.”
Franklin, with no prior military experience, oversaw construction of stockades and a line of forts garrisoned by some 500 men across Pennsylvania's northern frontier, and his strategy worked against an unprecedented military crisis, illustrating his rare universal competence.
“Resulting in a line of forts that were garrisoned by some 500 men securing Pennsylvania's Northern frontier.”
Senra argues that underestimating an opponent is all downside and no upside, and that in head-to-head competition one should assume the opponent is smarter and better equipped, a lesson repeatedly ignored in entrepreneurship and shown by Braddock's arrogant dismissal of native warriors.
“It is all downside and no upside.”
Franklin gained cooperation through reasoned appeals and pragmatic solutions, such as authorizing rum after chapel services to boost attendance, whereas Washington relied on discipline and punishment, and Franklin's regiment was oversubscribed while Washington's was undermanned.
“Franklin in contrast gained cooperation by reasoned appeals and pragmatic solutions”
Franklin's early federal concept, which Walter Isaacson described as orderly, balanced, and enlightened, was carried forward by Franklin all the way to the Constitutional Convention, roughly 30 years later.
“Franklin had helped to devise a federal concept. One that was orderly, balanced, and enlightened, that would eventually form the basis of a unified American nation.”
Washington's early battles were disasters, including a defeat at Fort Necessity after brash, ill-advised aggression at age 22, and he later called these mistakes and believed his military career was over.
“With ill-advised bravado, Washington led his small band relentlessly forward, even into a battle where you clearly can't win.”
Unencumbered by preconceived notions about electricity, Franklin conducted simple, clearly designed experiments that laid the first groundwork for the modern physics of energy conservation and for electrical circuits, moving electricity from curiosity to science.
“He found electricity a curiosity and left it as science.”
Franklin opposed the Stamp Act because its predictable damage to commerce and imperial relations made it wrong, and he cared more about doing what was right than defending abstract rights, arguing the policy's economic harm would inevitably produce anger and violence.
“Franklin cared more about doing what was right than defending abstract rights.”
Franklin carried his early plan for orderly, balanced union all the way to the Constitutional Convention, and he later argued the plan would have sufficed to defend the colonies against the French, whereas Britain's costly intervention led to the taxes that touched off revolution.
“Franklin remained convinced that the plan would've sufficed to defend the colonies against the French”
As a teenager, Washington became a surveyor to build a fortune through land speculation on the frontier, using the inside information that surveyors had to acquire the best parcels early.
“Through their inside information, they could get in on the ground floor by acquiring some of the best parcels of land.”
The postwar economic depression and European bank panic, combined with the Stamp Act's taxes, led Washington to shift his plantation from tobacco export to domestic wheat and led Franklin to see the British tax as predictably harmful to commerce and imperial relations.
“Washington began the process of turning his plantation from raising tobacco for export to growing wheat for domestic sale.”
Franklin built a line of stockades and forts garrisoned by about 500 men on Pennsylvania's northern frontier, and he led by sleeping with his men and sharing food, while Washington led with discipline, punishment, and distance.
“Franklin spent his time on the frontier sleeping with his men on cabin floors and sharing food.”
Franklin and Washington observed that colonists increasingly saw themselves as citizens of their colonies rather than subjects of Parliament, and Senra generalizes that understanding what people believe is pivotal to understanding why they do what they do.
“if you could understand that, understanding what people believe is pivotal to understanding why they do what they do.”
In his farewell letter Washington described America as an empire of states that could take its place among the great nations, using 'empire' rather than 'league of states,' a usage Senra says was unusual under the singular Confederation-period framing, and then Washington retired rather than seize power like many revolutionary generals.
“Unlike countless revolutionary generals before and after him, Washington retired.”
Franklin wrote to Washington that European observers, including old generals studying American maps, spoke with great applause of his operations, which Senra presents as the kind of encouragement that matters during a dark stretch of the war, and he compares it to Edison encouraging Henry Ford.
“I frequently hear the old generals of this country who study the maps of America and mark upon them all of your operations speak with great applause at your conduct.”
Franklin was convinced that acts mattered more than beliefs, and he built his early reputation on demonstrated industriousness rather than stated intentions.
“He was convinced that acts mattered more than beliefs.”
Franklin and Washington were both hardworking entrepreneurs who listened more than they talked, compromised on means, relied on others, sacrificed for the common good, never wavered on principle, and shared a faith in human reason and divine providence over traditional dogma, which Senra argues is what they had in common beneath their different public images.
“Franklin and Washington shared a faith that relied on human reason and divine providence rather than traditional ways and established dogmas.”
Washington was the obvious pick to lead the Continental Army because he had more military experience than any other member of Congress, and Senra suggests that building products or services requires making yourself the obvious choice to customers.
“So how do we make it obvious that we are the ones that they should choose?”
Senra argues that scalping, evidenced archaeologically in North America back to 600 AD and in Europe about 5,000 years ago, reflects something in human nature that recurs throughout history rather than a unique feature of the French and Indian War.
“there is substantial archeological evidence of scalping in North America that goes back as early as 600 AD”
Franklin founded a self-improvement club for tradesmen (the Junto), a subscription library, a volunteer firefighting brigade, an academy that became the University of Pennsylvania, and a 10,000-man volunteer militia when Pennsylvania's Quaker leaders would not defend the colony.
“A 10,000 man volunteer militia to defend Pennsylvania when it's Quaker leaders would not.”
Franklin's Poor Richard's Almanac, which sold roughly 10,000 copies a year, advised that the way to wealth depends chiefly on industry and frugality, and Franklin gave this same advice to fellow tradesmen, which Senra says is still relevant 275 years later.
“The way to wealth if you desire it, Poor Richard would say, depends chiefly on two words, industry and frugality.”
Franklin, who turned 70 during the Revolution and doubted he would survive it, took on a staggering number of tasks for Congress and his colony, saying he was so immersed in business that he had scarce time to eat or sleep.
“I am immersed in so much business that I have scarce time to eat or sleep.”
The Revolution disrupted domestic life for both families, and after leaving his estate in 1775 Washington did not see Mount Vernon again until 1781, and then only briefly.
“After leaving his estate in 1775, Washington did not see it again until 1781.”
On Christmas night 1776 Washington took his army across the icy Delaware River to capture the Hessian garrison at Trenton, paid each man who would reenlist a $10 bounty for six more weeks, and then held off a British counterattack and routed a British force at Princeton, restoring morale and initiative.
“On Christmas night 1776, in a desperate effort to restore morale and regain the initiative, Washington took his army back across the ice choke Delaware River”
The 1780-81 winter nearly broke the Continental Army through hunger, desertion, and mutiny, and Benedict Arnold's offer to sell out the American defensive line around New York for $20,000 and a Royal army commission came during this crisis.
“Then one of Washington's most trusted officers Benedict Arnold offered to sell out the American defensive line around New York for $20,000”
The Stamp Act crisis of 1765, which imposed taxes directly on colonists, pulled Franklin and Washington back into alignment after their wartime separation and set them on parallel political courses, though neither anticipated it.
“The Stamp Act crisis, which erupted in 1765 after parliament imposed taxes directly on the colonist.”
At age 21, Washington was sent by Governor Dinwiddie on a six-week journey to deliver an ultimatum to the French, and on the return trip he survived an ambush by a French-allied native guide who fired at him from about 15 feet away.
“If the French did not leave, we do hereby strictly charge and command you to drive them off by force of arms.”
Franklin, born the 15th of 17 children to a working-class family and largely self-taught, built a dominant regional printing business by judging the two existing Philadelphia printers unqualified and outworking them, becoming one of the richest American columnists north of the Mason-Dixon line.
“He became one of the richest American columnists living north of the Mason-Dixon line.”
After his second term Washington threw himself into farming and whiskey distilling at Mount Vernon, and whiskey netted him a larger return than any other product, making his distillery the largest in the United States.
“No product ever netted him a larger return on his investment than whiskey.”
Because of differences in background, age, manner, and public image, the Franklin-Washington relationship was not widely commented on in their time and remains little discussed today, though it shaped American history.
“their relationship was not widely commented on then, and it remains little discussed today, but it existed and helped to shape the course of American history”
In his autobiography Franklin proposed an ideal prayer asking for wisdom that discovers one's true interest, which Senra regards as a smart statement of what Franklin wished for himself.
“It was for wisdom that discovers my true interest.”
Washington gained Mount Vernon and a military command through his older brother Lawrence's death from tuberculosis, which created a vacancy in the Virginia military that gave a young man with little experience the colony's top military post.
“Lawrence's death created a vacancy in the Virginia military.”
The shared frontier crisis, including a massacre of a British settler family reported in Washington's diary, drew Pennsylvania and Virginia into a widening war and threw Franklin and Washington together for the first time.
“And this is also the historical event that's going to throw Franklin and Washington together for the first time.”
When the partnership began Franklin was about 48 and Washington about 22, far from the elderly figures on the currency that most people picture, and Franklin still had roughly 40 years to live.
“That is not what they look like when they start.”
Washington's early overconfidence, shown by pressing on in a battle he could not win, contrasted with the composed commander he later became, and his first defeat left his men exhausted, drunk, and out of horses and cattle before he capitulated.
“A third of his defenders were dead or wounded. Many of the survivors were drunk and all of their horses and cattle had been slaughtered by enemy fire.”
Franklin observed that history is full of the errors of states and princes, arguing that Britain's abuse of the colonies through taxation without representation forced a revolution that could have been avoided.
“History is full of the errors of states and princes.”
Washington remained remarkably calm under fire during Braddock's defeat, later writing that he was protected beyond all probability despite four bullets through his coat and two horses shot under him, and the British lost 976 men to about 40 on the other side.
“The British lost 976 people and the other side lost 40.”
Washington wrote that Americans could forge a more perfect union, an empire of states capable of taking its place among the great nations, a vision Senra says describes America not as it was but as it could be.
“Americas could forge, this is Washington writing. Americans could forge a more perfect union”
Franklin, nearly bedridden, received Washington at his home on the way to the presidency, and neither left a record of what was said, though both knew it would be their last meeting.
“No record remains of what was said, even though both knew that it would be their last meeting.”
In the ambush at the Monongahela, the British lost 976 men against roughly 40 on the other side, because the attackers used cover and flanking tactics while the British, trained to fight in ordered lines, were exposed with no visible targets to fire back at.
“The British lost 976 people and the other side lost 40.”
Franklin, on arriving in Philadelphia as a printer, judged the city's two printers unqualified and set out to dominate the regional printing trade, which he did by being industrious and frugal while avoiding any appearance to the contrary.
“I took care not only to be in reality industrious and frugal, but to avoid all appearances to the contrary.”
The geographic and frontier knowledge Washington accumulated while surveying and trading in the wilderness became valuable later in the French and Indian War and the Revolution, though at the time he used it simply to make money.
“this knowledge that he's building up is going to be really useful later on”
Senra argues that because Washington's destitute army kept going for one more year, the world turned upside down, and Franklin's outside work supplied much of what kept the army alive.
“By soldiering on for one more year, Washington's army destitute and half naked turned the world upside down.”
Franklin died at home with grandchildren holding his hands, about 20,000 mourners attended his Philadelphia funeral procession, and the French national assembly decreed three days of mourning.
“In Philadelphia, nearly 20,000 mourners turned out for Franklin's funeral procession, more than had ever gathered in the city.”
Franklin wrote that he would rather have it said that he lived usefully than that he died rich, and Senra links this to Steve Jobs's remark that being the richest man in the cemetery does not matter.
“When it does, I would rather have it said that he lived usefully then he died rich.”
Franklin had an adept understanding of human nature and what motivated people, and he persuaded by identifying what each person was motivated by, which Senra presents as a pattern visible throughout his life.
“he had a very adept understanding of human nature and what motivated people and how to convince you”
Senra argues that both Franklin and Washington were reformers who identified problems and tried to fix them, and that this disposition, rather than fear, is what individuals can bring to times of faction and failure.
“And both were reformers. They solve problems and they tried to fix them.”
Washington's army, destitute and half naked, endured one more year and turned the world upside down, and the host argues the world would have looked different if they had quit at that point.
“By soldiering on for one more year, Washington's army destitute and half naked turned the world upside down.”
Franklin and Washington shared a faith that relied on human reason and divine providence rather than traditional ways and established dogmas, sought truth and accepted facts, and believed life could get better, which they demonstrated by building a new order to replace the collapsing old one.
“Franklin and Washington shared a faith that relied on human reason and divine providence rather than traditional ways and established dogmas.”
Marc Andreessen's observation that running a startup involves only euphoria and terror is applied by Senra to Washington's last year of the war, which was all terror and no euphoria.
“When you're running a startup, you only experience two emotions, euphoria and terror”
Franklin expanded his Philadelphia house with a three-story wing and a large second-floor scientific library, acknowledging that building was an amusement at his age, and Senra treats this as evidence of his perspective on how much can change in a lifetime.
“we are apt to forget that we have grown old and building is an amusement”
Franklin, nearly 50 and already a successful entrepreneur, scientist, and writer, focused his talent on the project of colonial union, and Senra frames this as the most important project of his life.
“now he focuses his talent on the most important project of his life”
Franklin was a universal genius who could be put in charge of unfamiliar tasks and succeed, like a Swiss army knife, serving on committees for saltpeter manufacture and postal reestablishment and later becoming postmaster general.
“Franklin's like a Swiss army knife.”
Senra argues that reading every day is valuable even without knowing when the information will be used, because knowledge gathered from shared experiences, like the lessons Franklin and Washington drew from the French and Indian War, comes in handy decades later.
“I read every day, I have no idea when I'll use this information. I just know that it's likely to come in handy at some point in the future.”
Senra argues that books are original links that lead readers from one idea, person, and book to another, which is why he keeps reading widely and reads a biography of Robert Morris after reading about Franklin.
“books are the original links. They lead us from one idea to another, one person to another, one book to another.”
Benjamin Franklin is the single most influential American entrepreneur who ever lived, because the inspiration from his life story has been passed down through generations of people whose own remarkable lives were written about.
“I think he's the single most influential American entrepreneur to ever live.”
Senra compares Franklin's early dominance of the Philadelphia printing trade to Larry Bird's account of doubters who underestimated him coming from a small school.
“It took me three days of rookie camp and I found out that this league is nothing.”