What this covers
This episode of Founders has Senra working through Tim Urban's Wait But Why writing on Elon Musk and Tesla, with commentary on top. It begins with the history of electric cars. The 1990s California boom faded after a zero emissions vehicle mandate was passed and then repealed. AC Propulsion's tzero reached 60 mph in 4.9 seconds and ran 250 miles by wiring thousands of small lithium-ion battery cells together instead of using heavy lead-acid batteries. The story then moves to the Roadster, built on a Lotus body, and to the troubled early years. Martin Eberhard was fired, Tesla nearly failed in late 2008, and Musk put in roughly $180 million across his companies.
The middle of the episode covers specific design and business choices. Tesla built an all-aluminum body using SpaceX technology and a 17-inch touchscreen it had to make itself. It replaced model years with continuous software updates, built a supercharger network and a battery factory, and opened its patents. The discussion also takes up Vertical Integration as the source of Tesla's cost advantage.
The more contested material is the argument that dealership laws amount to Regulatory Capture, and that large industries grow risk-averse enough for an outsider to rethink the whole product. The episode also forecasts that the Model 3 could push incumbents to invest in EVs, citing GM's Bob Lutz and the Chevy Volt. It closes on a more philosophical note: Henry Ford defining what a car is, and a present dominated by a canopy of past ideas that a few people must will beyond.
Senra uses Tim Urban's Wait But Why post to argue that Tesla succeeded by reasoning from first principles and by treating the car as a clean-sheet product, and that its real aim is to spread EV adoption across the whole industry rather than to dominate luxury cars.
- Tesla's three-step plan used early high-price cars to fund cheaper mass-market cars
- Tesla designed from a clean sheet and reasoned from first principles, unlike incumbents that reason by analogy
- Tesla's influence is indirect: it pressures incumbents to electrify, so its own market share matters less
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Tesla dropped model years and instead adds features continuously through automatic Wi-Fi software updates, so cars of the same model can differ and owners may wake up to new capabilities.
“They did away with the model years... So instead of holding all the year's new features until the new release, they just put features in as they go.”
AC Propulsion realized that the laptop and mobile phone industries had driven small lithium-ion cells to high efficiency, and by wiring a few thousand of these AA-sized cells together they created far better car batteries than the heavy lead-acid batteries used in earlier EVs.
“AC Propulsion realized that the laptop and mobile phone industry had been pouring development into making small lithium-ion batteries increasingly efficient”
Because the Tesla battery is heavy, Tesla made the body very light and used SpaceX's rocket technology to produce the only all-aluminum body of any North American car.
“So they turned to SpaceX and used its advanced rocket technology to make Tesla the only North American car with an all-aluminum body.”
Because Tesla's goal is to transform the whole industry rather than to hold a competitive edge, it made all of its patents available to anyone who wanted them.
“Tesla made all of their patents available to whomever wanted them.”
Starting an EV company in 2003 faced high barriers to entry, unpriced carbon emission costs, opposition from the oil industry, and a century-long pause in EV development, making it like starting a basketball team where everyone else can foul freely.
“There were high barriers to entry that had prevented any startup car company from succeeding in almost a century.”
Tesla and SpaceX can drop costs far below rivals because they are much more vertically integrated than competitors in their industries, which is why adding a dealer middleman makes less sense for them.
“Tesla and SpaceX are able to drop costs so low because they're way more vertically integrated than other companies in their respective industries”
Tesla's real impact is indirect: by proving that an appealing electric car can be built, it pushes incumbents to copy it, so its own sales volume, which is a tiny share of the market, matters less than the competitive pressure it creates.
“The whole idea is to infect other car companies with -- once they see that somebody else can build an electric car”
Over time big industries become flabby, uncreative, and risk-averse, so an outsider with resources and a fresh perspective that rethinks the whole product can create a large opportunity, as the iPhone did for phones and the Model S did for cars.
“Over time, big industries tend to get flabby and uncreative and risk-averse.”
To remove EV barriers Tesla built a supercharger network for long trips and a battery factory aimed at doubling world lithium-ion supply to lower battery prices.
“If there aren't enough charging stations for long trips, build an energy network of superchargers.”
New technology products start expensive because early R&D costs are high, which is why the first cell phones and computers were costly, and a premium first EV can still sell because affordable gas cars already exist.
“the R&D costs early on for a new technology drive up the price of the product.”
Laws requiring car sales to go through dealerships are a form of regulatory capture that adds an unnecessary profit layer for the benefit of dealers rather than consumers, and Tesla's direct-to-consumer model is far more efficient.
“why the f*** would a politician pass a law like that? It's clearly not for the benefit of the consumer.”
The 1990s electric car boom in California faded after the state passed a zero emissions vehicle mandate and then was pressured into repealing it, leaving EV development to scattered garages and tech labs.
“After the brief bubble of new electric cars in California in the 1990s between the year that the state passed the zero emissions vehicle mandate and the year they were bullied into repealing it”
In late 2008, Tesla was close to failing, and Musk took over as CEO and went into full crisis mode to keep the company alive, while SpaceX faced a similar near-death situation at the same time.
“Musk, who wasn't enjoying the drama of the scene, finally was like, 'Pause the movie quick.' And took over as CEO, going into full adrenaline mode to keep the company alive.”
The Roadster was built on an existing Lotus Elise body to generate revenue and demonstrate EV capability, not to be Tesla's long-term product, and Musk insisted the company's mission was not to make toys for rich people.
“So they didn't start from scratch on the body design. Instead, they based it on the Lotus Elise.”
After selling PayPal, Musk put about $100 million into SpaceX, $70 million into Tesla, and $10 million into SolarCity, a total of roughly $180 million after taxes, which kept his companies alive during the crisis.
“he put $100 million at SpaceX, $70 million in Tesla, $10 million at SolarCity.”
AC Propulsion's tzero was fast, going 0 to 60 mph in 4.9 seconds, on par with fast gas cars, and could travel 250 miles on a single charge, far beyond the 60 to 120 mile range of prior EVs.
“It went 0 to 60 in 4.9 seconds, which was crazy fast for an electric car and put it on par with the fast gas cars.”
Tesla eliminated physical buttons and put all controls on a 17-inch touchscreen, and because no suitable car-grade screen existed when the first car was designed, Tesla built one itself.
“But when their first car came out, there was no iPad yet, and a 17-inch touchscreen suitable for a car didn't exist. So they built their own.”
The present is dominated by a canopy of past ideas, norms, and technologies, so what looks like progress is mostly incremental polishing of the past, and a truly advanced future has to be willed into existence by a few brave people.
“The present isn't welcoming of an advanced future because the present is run by a thick canopy made up of the ideas, norms and technologies of the past.”
Change cannot happen on a familiar landscape, so it has to construct the landscape itself: Henry Ford did not just build a car but defined what a car was, and car companies have worked within his landscape ever since.
“Change doesn't happen on a familiar landscape. Change has to construct the landscape itself.”
By 2017 Tesla had 400,000 to 500,000 preorders for the low-priced, high-volume car, showing that Step 3 of the plan was already underway when the 2015 post was written.
“We saw that they have 400,000 to 500,000 preorders of the low-priced, high-volume car”
The Roadster's unveiling signaled to the industry that Tesla was for real, and GM chairman Bob Lutz credited it with prompting GM to build the Chevy Volt, asking why GM could not do what a small California company had done.
“after the Roadster unveiling, he went to the GM Board and asked, 'If a little company in California can do this, why can't we?'”
If large numbers of people buy the Model 3 and see its range, acceleration, and handling beat gas cars at an affordable price, car companies will have no excuse left and will invest real money in their own EV programs, so Tesla can catalyze a multi-order-of-magnitude shift in the industry.
“then that's what will prompt car companies to invest real money into electric vehicle programs of their own.”
Early Roadster problems included delayed completion, costs above plan, and defective shipments, which led Musk and the board to fire CEO Martin Eberhard just before the 2008 recession hit.
“This made Musk sad, so he and the Board fired Eberhard as CEO”
Musk's core advantage is that he approaches problems from first principles, breaking them down to their most fundamental truths and building up from there, rather than reasoning by analogy, which is how most car companies compete and leaves them trapped in their own history.
“a huge advantage that Elon has over most people is that he tries to approach problems from first principles, breaking it down to its most fundamental truth and then building up from there instead of what he calls reasoning by analogy.”
At Tesla design and engineering are assigned equal value, and Musk deliberately keeps them in tension, whereas at other car companies engineering comes first and the designer is handed a prescribed package to make beautiful.
“At Tesla, design and engineering are assigned equal value, and Elon keeps them opposed to each other.”
Tesla's business plan was a staircase: Step 1 was a high-price, low-volume car for the superrich (over $100,000), Step 2 a mid-priced car near $75,000, and Step 3 a roughly $35,000 mass-market car, with profits from each step funding the next.
“Step 1: High-price, low-volume car for the superrich.”
When existing investors refused to fund another round, Musk offered to put in the money himself, a bluff that prompted other investors to match, splitting the investment and saving Tesla.
“he bluffed because I don't even think he had all that money. When they realize, 'Oh, s*.'”
New disruptive technologies meet hostility from incumbents who try to squash them early, but once a disruptor gains a foothold and spreads its ideas the balance tips and everyone scrambles to emulate it.
“a new and disruptive technology is often met with hostility as it emerges as the existing canopy does whatever it can to squash the potential disruptor out of existence”
Franz von Holzhausen contrasted GM, a finance-driven company that must live up to financial expectations, with Tesla, where the product comes first and the company becomes great as a result.
“'A company like GM is a finance-driven company who always has to live up to financial expectations. Here, we look at it the other way around.”
Franz said that when Tesla started the Model S it was a clean sheet of paper, a method similar to Steve Jobs at Apple, who ignored competitors and asked what a phone should be rather than building a better BlackBerry.
“When Apple decided to make a phone, they didn't try to make a better BlackBerry. They asked, 'What should a mobile phone be?'”
Musk argues that the moment a company's leader treats numbers as valuable in themselves, or a CFO becomes CEO, the company is finished, because the product should drive financial results.
“The moment the person leading a company thinks numbers have value in themselves, the company's done. The moment the CFO becomes CEO, it's done, Game over.”
Tesla's mission was not to build the biggest car company but to accelerate the advent of sustainable transport by making compelling mass-market EVs as soon as possible, which would reduce carbon emissions earlier and limit their long-term damage.
“to accelerate the advent of sustainable transport by bringing compelling mass-market electric cars to market as soon as possible.”
The Model S reached 0 to 60 in 3.2 seconds at the time of writing, had a 0.24 drag coefficient, the lowest in the industry, which saves battery power, and earned a 5.4-star NHTSA safety rating, the highest ever tested by the U.S. government.
“It saves battery power by being insanely aerodynamic with the industry's lowest drag coefficient.”
Tesla's victory condition is that half of new cars sold are electric, and its target is to ramp production to 500,000 cars, around 0.5 percent of total cars made each year, which requires other companies to participate.
“a victory condition as far-reaching as half of the new cars being electric”
The Roadster did not change the world, since no $110,000 car could, but it signaled to the industry that Tesla was for real, and it was based on a Lotus Elise chassis to save design time.
“The Roadster didn't change the world. No $110,000 car ever could but it sent a message to the industry that Tesla was for real.”
Tesla did not design the Roadster's body from scratch; it used a Lotus Elise base so it could focus effort on electrifying the car rather than on new body engineering.
“So they didn't start from scratch on the body design. Instead, they based it on the Lotus Elise.”
Earlier EVs had range of only 60 to 120 miles because they relied on heavy, limited lead-acid batteries, which is the main reason the category stalled.
“Previous EVs had used lead-acid batteries, which were heavy and limited.”
JB Straubel brought Musk to see the tzero, and seeing it convinced Musk that EVs were the future, leading him to fund a new car company even though he was already running SpaceX.
“Musk was blown away. Musk had suspected for a while that EVs were the way of the future, and now he saw the possibilities with his own eyes.”
Franz von Holzhausen, a star designer who had been design director at GM and Mazda, left those established companies to bet his career on the barely standing Tesla and became its chief designer.
“had decided to bet his career on the barely standing Tesla and became their Chief Designer.”
Tesla designed its door handles to lie flush with the door so as not to disrupt the car design that Musk and Franz had already perfected.
“So they figured out how to make the handles lay flush with the door.”
After the Space Shuttle program ended in 2011, the U.S. lost its ability to fly its own astronauts to space, and it now contracts with the Russian space program for that capability.
“2011 was the end of the Space Shuttle program. So from there, we lost the ability to even fly our own astronauts in space”
Through software updates and larger batteries, the Model S became faster after purchase, with Ludicrous Mode reducing 0-60 times to around 2.6 seconds or less, versus the 3.2 seconds in the original post.
“through software updates, they make the car faster. So I think with Ludicrous Mode, it goes 0-60 now down to like 2.6 seconds”
Tesla could not sell a $25,000 quality car for $100,000, so it started with a superrich-target premium product and did not treat early high prices as a failure.
“it wouldn't work to come out with the equivalent quality of a $25,000 gas car for $100,000.”
The 2008 recession hit Tesla at its weakest point, since it had no brand recognition, was not profitable, and had heavy upfront investment, nearly killing the company.
“the most inconvenient thing ever happened, the 2008 recession”
Real technological change is recognized by a sudden feeling that the previous tools seem ancient, as when the iPhone made BlackBerrys look obsolete and an iPod made a CD booklet feel clunky, and the Model S gave the same feeling of a magical space car.
“You don't realize your BlackBerry s**** until the iPhone exists.”
Tesla sold only a couple of thousand Roadsters, perhaps 2,500 to 5,000, a very small number, so the car was symbolic rather than a volume product.
“I think I read somewhere that they only sold, I think, a couple of thousand Roadsters, maybe 2,500, maybe 5,000”
Big technology breakthroughs often start in small groups of cutting-edge labs, such as Apple, Microsoft, and Google, so the electric car could emerge from small garages and tech labs as well.
“Big things have emerged out of small groups of cutting edge geek labs. Apple, Microsoft, Google. So why not the modern electric car industry?”
The host believes car accidents are the leading cause of death for children under about 20, so the Model S's top safety rating makes it a good choice for families.
“the #1 cause of death for kids under the age of, like, 20 is car accidents.”
Musk could only give Tesla part of his time, so he funded the company and became chairman while installing Eberhard as CEO, which let him keep his main focus on SpaceX while retaining strong influence.
“Musk, who could only dedicate part-time to the project, could fund the effort, become Chairman, and maintain a strong influence.”
Real technological leaps produce a distinct, exhilarating feeling, and the modern world advances through a collection of such moments in which a person or company makes everyone's jaw drop, rather than through an inevitable river of progress.
“That's how a new, revolutionary technology always feels.”
Musk spends two days a week on Tesla and the rest of his time on making humanity a multi-planetary species, a goal that makes Tesla look like a grapefruit stand by comparison.
“a goal that makes his Tesla mission seem like starting a grapefruit stand.”
Tesla is run by a collective super-brain of about 11,000 employees who all think a lot about electric cars, which is how Musk's personal idea was scaled into an industry-changing company.
“run by a collective super-brain made up of 11,000 Tesla employees who also happen to think a lot about electric cars.”
Consumer Reports gave the Model S an unheard-of 99 to 100 rating, calling it the best car ever made, and owners across the board were obsessed with it.
“consumer reports anointed it the best car that had ever been made with an unheard-of 99 to 100 rating”
The planned $35,000 car would be affordable to the middle class only after the government's $7,500 EV tax credit and fuel savings are applied.
“after the government's $7,500 EV tax credit and the savings on gas would be affordable to the middle class.”
Volvo announced it would switch to EVs, and the host argues that some of this shift is already happening.
“Volvo just came out and said that they're going to be switching to EVs”
Musk described Henry Ford as someone who, when something was in his way, found a way around it, and who focused on what the customer needed even when the customer did not know it.
“He was really focused on what the customer needed even when the customer didn't know what they needed.”
Tesla is challenging state bans on direct car sales one state at a time, and the host expects Tesla to win most of these lawsuits.
“they're fighting the states that won't and slowly overturning direct car sale bans.”
Christie Nicholson recalls meeting Musk in 1989 when he said he thought a lot about electric cars and asked her if she did.
“I believe the second sentence out of his mouth was, 'I think a lot about electric cars.'”
Buying a Tesla online with delivery takes no time, whereas buying a car through a traditional dealership, even used, is a long and painful process that takes hours.
“When you do it with Tesla, you do it online. It takes no time, and they deliver it to you.”