#132 Edwin Land (Steve Jobs’s Hero)
What this covers
This episode of the Founders podcast has David Senra working through the life and thinking of Edwin Land, mostly in Land's own words. The story starts with instant photography, which Land conceived on vacation when his three-year-old daughter asked why she couldn't see the picture. A small group then worked out most of the system in secret within about six months. Senra calls Land "the original Steve Jobs," citing shared traits: no college degrees, perfectionism, showmanship, superlatives and secrecy. He also relays Jobs's own tribute to Land as a national treasure.
The range is practical as well as philosophical. Senra covers the 1948 launch: one Boston department store the day after Thanksgiving, then a 30-day city exclusivity to seed demand. He covers Land's rule of Don't Do What Others Can Do, which led Polaroid to scrap a photocopier project once Xerox got to market first. He covers the pairing of scientific daring with financial conservatism (no debt, a large municipal bond portfolio) and the dense patent wall Land built. Land's strong support for the patent system is one of the contested positions. Senra sets George Eastman and Jeff Bezos beside Land on building around what doesn't change, and sets Land's paid critic Ansel Adams beside Akio Morita's at Sony.
The more contentious material concerns how creativity works. Land held that originality is individual and that group creativity isn't real. He blamed formal education for beating the desire for greatness out of students. He said inventors need long, uninterrupted immersion when solutions start to surface, because a break could cost a year. He also thought the public's role is to resist, so a new invention needs a teaching program that quietly replaces the old gestalt.
Senra argues Edwin Land's success came from creating markets that did not yet exist, controlling the entire product system instead of depending on suppliers, and concentrated individual creativity, and that these traits make Land the template for founders like Steve Jobs.
- Land treated 'problems' as 'opportunities' and judged inventions by markets they would create, not by existing markets
- Land refused to be a supplier and built products sold directly to consumers so he could control the whole system
- Land's creativity was individual and concentrated, and he argued group creativity is not real originality
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Each of Polaroid's big bets, the headlight system and 3D glasses, required transforming an industry controlled by an existing power structure, and that resistance is why Land decided to bypass third parties and sell directly to consumers.
“each invention involved a certain degree of transformation of an existing industry controlled by an existing power structure.”
Land launched the camera by selling it first at one Boston department store the day after Thanksgiving 1948, where it sold out, then used a 30-day city exclusive with a store paying for local advertising to build exclusivity and seed demand nationwide.
“they put the first camera, it was first offered to sale to the public at the Jordan Marsh department store in Boston, this is 1948, the day after Thanksgiving.”
Land found it essential to work intensively for long hours when solutions began to appear, because atavistic competencies surface only at a barely conscious level of handling many variables, and an interruption could cost a year to recover what 60 hours could otherwise cover.
“If you are, it may take a year to cover the same ground you could otherwise cover in 60 hours.”
Land conceived instant photography on vacation after his three-year-old daughter asked why she could not see the picture, and within about six months he had worked out most essential details of the system with a small group in secret.
“within 6 months of his original inspiration, Land had worked out most of the essential details of the Instant Photography system.”
Steve Jobs described Edwin Land as a shrine-like figure, hailed him as a national treasure, and said near his death that Land's idea about people at the intersection of humanities and sciences led him to his own path.
“I read something that one of my heroes, Edwin Land of Polaroid, said about the importance of people who could stand at the intersection of humanities and sciences.”
Land believed creativity is an individual phenomenon not generally applicable to groups, and that there is no such thing as group originality or group creativity in science or outside it.
“there is no such thing as group originality or group creativity.”
Land's sudden breakthroughs, which Senra calls Instant Images, were the visible end of extensive prior preparation: he had familiarized himself with all the elements of each challenge, consciously or not, before the insight arrived.
“The inspiration, Land would be quick to point out, was neither blind luck nor a fortunate gift of the gods. He had prepared himself through countless hours of familiarization with all the elements of the challenge”
Land was a major supporter of the patent system because it protects individual innovators, while large uncreative companies see patents as a threat and benefit from weak national patent systems that let them acquire others' innovations cheaply.
“to a large and fundamentally uncreative company, patents are a threat and a nuisance.”
Land argued that after a short time in college, most young people give up any hope of individual greatness, a catastrophic problem for society that needed fixing right away, and he blamed formal education for beating out students' desire for greatness.
“our young people, for the most part, unless they are geniuses, after a very short time in college, give up any hope of being individually great.”
Land argued that scientific leaps come from individuals who free themselves from the group mind, even when their peers are more educated, and that industrial science must disseminate knowledge quickly as pure and applied science blur together.
“every significant step in each single field is taken by some individual who has freed himself from a way of thinking that is held by his friends and associates”
Land held that the public's role is to resist, because most ideas are inconsequential, so the inventor must build a new gestalt that quietly replaces the old one and fund an extensive teaching program to prepare society for the invention.
“It is the public's role to resist. ... It is the duty of the inventor to build a new gestalt to quietly substitute the gestalt, the old one had place in the framework of society.”
Experts repeatedly predicted Land's products would fail because they evaluated each new product only by how it fit the existing market, and conventional wisdom has little capacity to evaluate a market that did not exist before the product defined it.
“Conventional wisdom has little capacity with which to evaluate a market that did not exist prior to the product that defines it.”
Land argued that every significant invention must be startling and unexpected, must arrive in a world not prepared for it, and that if the world were prepared it would not be much of an invention.
“By definition, it must be startling, unexpected and must come to a world that is not prepared for it. If the world were prepared for it, it would not be much of an invention.”
Land and Eastman built their companies around enduring human delight in photography, which stays constant, while novelty of individual photographs wears off within a few years, a logic parallel to Bezos's advice to invest in things that do not change.
“the newness of photographs had worn off within a few years of Eastman's first Kodak. The delight of capturing each other on film never did.”
Land's guiding motto was 'Don't do anything that someone else can do,' and he applied it strictly by refusing to make products already on the market, which led Polaroid to scrap a photocopier project after Xerox reached market first.
“Polaroid winds up doing about a decade's worth of research and development on a photocopier before Xerox exists.”
Land's operating philosophy was to be scientifically daring and financially conservative, which Polaroid expressed by never taking on debt to finance expansion and by holding a large municipal bond portfolio that produced tax-free income approximating a university endowment.
“Land's view is that the company should be scientifically daring and financially conservative.”
Land described the SX-70 as enabling a new kind of relationship between people, with families and groups photographing and sharing, and the host notes that Land framed his company as heading up an experience rather than a business.
“Other corporate leaders might head up businesses. Land sees himself as heading up an experience.”
Land learned that a company making products for other companies has no control over the system or customer relationship, so he later pursued a model in which Polaroid controlled the entire chain, including direct sales to consumers.
“if he's making products for other companies, he has no control. He needs to control the entire system and the relationship with the customers”
Land set up Polaroid around his natural instincts so that practical economic pursuits aligned with his intellectual interests, and Senra applies Munger's advice to follow your natural drift instead of copying others.
“you need to follow your natural drift. Like you can't just try to copy what me and Warren Buffett did because that may not suit your personality.”
Land believed that if he pursued science and built the best products possible, money would take care of itself, and this motivation persisted throughout his life.
“He wants to do science and he wants to make the best products possible. And he feels if he does those 2 things, that money will take care of itself.”
Land hired the photographer Ansel Adams as a paid consultant whose long memos critiqued Polaroid products, paralleling Akio Morita's hiring of a paid critic at Sony, and Senra argues companies should welcome such criticism from people who love their work.
“Sony did something that's fricking genius. He hired a paid critic”
Senra argues Edwin Land was the original Steve Jobs, because both lacked college degrees, were perfectionists and showmen, used superlatives, and were secretive about product development.
“In many ways, Edwin Land was the original Steve Jobs.”
Land believed that making a new commodity of beauty for everyone required an extensive teaching program to prepare society for the magnitude of the invention, rather than relying on the product to sell itself.
“then we must be prepared for the extensive teaching program needed to prepare society for the magnitude of our invention.”
Land built a dense wall of patents with specialist patent attorneys so that once a technology was revealed, it remained exclusively Polaroid's.
“the ever more impressive wall of patents he erected between his discoveries and the outside world enforced by a dedicated cadre of specialist patent attorneys”
Financial analysts argued Land should sell out to a large established firm for financial security, but Land kept control, and Polaroid later grew enough that Fortune ranked him among the wealthiest Americans.
“from a narrow dollar-and-cents point of view, Land and his colleagues might easily benefit financially by selling out to a large established firm.”
Land, as a 17-year-old Harvard freshman in New York, was struck by headlight and Times Square glare and invented the polarizer, which founded the company that became Polaroid.
“he sees the glare from -- there's 2 different stories, the glare from Times Square and then a glare from an oncoming headlight.”
Investors who bought control of the company treated Land's mind as the company's main asset, and they required the previous owner to stay on, because what was acquired was a single person's thinking rather than technology or assets.
“Unlike most new business capital ventures, what they had bought into was not a new technology, a new product or concrete assets, but one man's mind.”
Polaroid won its largest patent infringement case against Kodak roughly four decades later, with Kodak ordered to pay almost $1 billion for copying the instant photography system.
“Polaroid winds up winning the largest patent infringement case against Kodak. ... Kodak winds up having to pay them almost $1 billion.”
George Eastman, whose influence outlived him, died by suicide in his 70s after suffering severe spinal pain that was never diagnosed.
“He himself lived into his 70s at which point he decided he had enough and put a bullet through his heart.”
Bill Gurley's advice to become the most knowledgeable person in your craft, study the pioneers, and hold yourself accountable for continual learning parallels Land's reading of every volume on light in the New York Public Library, and the internet now makes such knowledge easier to obtain.
“strive to know more than anyone else about your particular craft, you should be the most knowledgeable person.”
Polaroid's growth was slow and marked by false starts, and when the automotive headlight market failed to materialize, the company pivoted to 3D movie glasses, selling over 5 million pairs a year before the craze collapsed and left warehouses full of lenses.
“Polaroid did sell over 5 million pairs of cardboard frame glasses a year.”
Land's polarizing sheet-plastic headlight glare idea, framed as saving lives with about 50 deaths a night and more than 20 million US cars on the road, served as a company-wide mission and a dream of financial security.
“in the early days of the company, they put on the board, I think, that 50 people a night die.”
As a teenager Land read everything in the New York Public Library on light polarization and then ran experiments at night in an unlocked Columbia University physics lab, showing that free resources plus relentless effort can substitute for money and access.
“During the day, he availed himself of the voluminous resources of the New York Public Library, reading everything he could get his hands on relative to the subject of light polarization.”
Land held roughly 535 patents, placing him third among people covered on the podcast behind Thomas Edison and Adi Dassler.
“Land had, I think, over 535 patents in his life”
Land was comfortable saying 'I don't know,' and when a student asked a Polaroid researcher a question, Land's direct answer was 'We have no idea,' which Senra treats as a trait leaders often lack.
“Land's strong inclination towards control apparently did not carry over to the actual realm of scientific knowledge. He is able to express doubt”
Land believed discoveries are not arbitrarily transferable between people, and the same individual might not reproduce results under different circumstances, so he carefully protected his associates' chances by stressing the fragility of scientific discovery.
“He also believes that discoveries are not arbitrarily transferable from one person to the next nor might the same individual under different circumstances, be able to achieve the same scientific results.”
Land described himself first as an artistic person interested in love, affection, and making beauty part of everyday life, and said that earning a living by contributing to a warmer and richer world, using his scientific abilities, makes for a great life.
“I suppose that I am, first of all, an artistic person. I'm interested in love and affection and sharing and making beauty part of everyday life.”
Land was driven from an early age by a determination to outdo his businessman father, which explains his drive but not his imagination and insight.
“It helps to explain, however, only the drive and not the imagination and insights.”
Land argued the Soviets taught youth to enjoy science and basic research, while the United States focused on mass-producing existing achievements, and he urged American focus on inventing new things that only Americans could make.
“Edwin Land argued eloquently that the Russians were teaching their youth to enjoy science and focus on basic research”
Land described himself as heading up an experience rather than a business, and his shareholder writing used poetic, superlative language that Senra contrasts with the plainer letters of Buffett and Bezos.
“Other corporate leaders might head up businesses. Land sees himself as heading up an experience.”
Land wrote that the SX-70 would create a new relationship between people and groups, because people, including children aged 2 to 5, have a latent interest in each other and a primordial competence for shared delight in photographing and sharing photos.
“We could not have known and have only just learned perhaps mostly from children from 2 to 5, that a new kind of relationship between people and groups is brought into being by the SX-70.”
Land began his science and business careers with the study of light, and the host says his personal scientific interest became the basis for an entire industry, which in turn kept him lifelong focused on light.
“Land had begun both his scientific and business careers with the study of the behavioral and properties of light. This study created an industry.”
A licensing contract with Kodak to use Polaroid's polarizing material in photographic filters provided enough revenue to give Land and Wheelwright breathing room to continue research.
“the revenue from the Kodak contract furnished Land and Wheelwright with a little breathing space, allowing them to continue their research.”
Land founded his own company because he wanted to avoid university formality and work as a scientist while having his inventions used, creating an environment of his own making for his inventive work.
“I planned a company in which I could work scientifically and still have my inventions used.”
Jobs described Land as a hero and said his own thinking about a product in finished form and reverse-engineering it through experiments was similar to Land's, indicating a deep bond and a model of career built on Land's example.
“that's how I feel.”
Land used superlatives heavily, calling his camera the best ever made and dismissing Kodak's imitation as slow, a showmanship pattern Senra compares to Jobs's product demos and his dismissal of Windows and Android.
“He loved using superlatives. If you ever watch Jobs' product demonstrations. Land would talk about how wonderful his inventions were.”
Senra recounts that in Amazon's early years Bezos gave a talk at Harvard Business School, where a student told him to sell to Barnes & Noble before being flattened, an example of how outside experts underestimate founders.
“You got this like arrogant snotty-nosed Harvard Business School student, saying, hey, you seem like a nice guy. But really, I think you should sell it to Barnes & Noble's before they flatten you.”
Land repeatedly compared his camera to the telephone, saying at the 1972 annual meeting that he fantasized the camera would be as widely used as a telephone and would have the same impact on how people live.
“my fantasy is that this camera will be as widely used as a telephone.”
Edwin Land's vocabulary replaced the word 'problem' with 'opportunity' even during the high-stakes SX-70 crisis in 1971, when the camera had cost millions without returning a dime.
“the word 'problem' had completely departed from Edwin Land's vocabulary to be replaced by the word 'opportunity.'”
Land was not bound by what had come before, so he could build on past knowledge without being put off by what was previously considered impossible, which Senra contrasts with cooks who follow recipes.
“in a world full of cooks, Edwin Land was a chef”
A 1969 Polaroid vice president concluded that selling as directly to the consumer as possible let the company control as many marketplace factors as possible, especially compared with the chaotic movie business.
“We learned that the best way is to sell as directly to the consumer as possible where we could control as many factors as possible in the marketplace.”
Land developed the Polaroid camera in secret within a small group of associates, the same way Steve Jobs developed the iPhone and Henry Ford developed the Model T, with most employees unaware of the work.
“The work was done by him and a small group of associates in secrets, not too different from Henry Ford”
When asked as an older man what he wanted as a child, Land said his two goals were to be the world's greatest scientist and the world's greatest novelist.
“I had 2 goals, to be the world's greatest scientist and to be the world's greatest novelist.”
Senra speculates, without evidence, that Land may have modeled Polaroid's large municipal bond holdings on the endowment approach of Harvard and MIT, where he spent most of his life.
“I wonder if he was inspired by what MIT and Harvard and other institutions like it do with their money”