#134 Edwin Land (Polaroid vs Kodak)
What this covers
This Founders episode is a host-narrated biography of Edwin Land, tracing Polaroid from its wartime pivot to its fifteen-year patent fight with Kodak. Senra alternates between Land's working rules and the lawsuit. Those rules include picking problems that are important and nearly impossible, working backward from a perfect imagined product, and running a company as an experiment that tolerates repeated failure. The hiring test is whether a candidate is ahead of Land in conversation. Fragile ideas are kept away from critics.
The range is wider than cameras. Land moved Polaroid to war technology before the US entered the war, and he pitched the U-2 reconnaissance overflight to President Eisenhower and Allen Dulles. The business story covers the cheap Swinger camera, the 60 to 80 percent margins on film, and Kodak, long Polaroid's film supplier, entering instant photography. That market was about 5 percent of Kodak's sales but 90 percent of Polaroid's, and an internal Kodak report admitted its product would be a me-too product.
The trial is the center. It ran 74 days and began and ended with Land's own testimony. Kodak relied on outside experts rather than its own engineers. Judge Zobel upheld eight of ten patents and found seven infringed. Kodak lost about $650 million before the $925 million settlement in 1991. The more contested material is Land's belief that breakthroughs come from special individuals and that patents must protect them, and the claim, shared with Steve Jobs, that consumers cannot say what they want.
Senra argues that Edwin Land's success came from total immersion in hard problems, creative freedom for researchers, and a dominant single leader who communicates expertly, and that these traits, more than corporate planning, explain Polaroid's rise and its win over Kodak.
- Land's creative method was pursuing important, nearly impossible problems with long uninterrupted work rather than systematic planning
- Polaroid's courtroom win came from Land's ability to teach the judge while Kodak underestimated him
- Businesses should be run as experiments in which failure is tolerated, and the leader must hold the integrated vision
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
After a research problem is solved the solution seems obvious, even to those who worked on it for years, so researchers wonder why a simple process took them ten years to develop, which Land framed as why it takes so long to learn so little.
“It is a curious property of research activity that after a problem has been solved, the solution usually seems obvious.”
Neither the United States nor the Soviet Union publicly acknowledged U-2 flights over Soviet territory during peacetime: the CIA would not disclose operations, and the Soviets could not admit they were unable to stop American aerial photography.
“neither America or Russia said anything for different reasons. One, CIA is not exactly going to be a forthcoming institution... Two, Russia couldn't admit that they couldn't stop America”
An internal Kodak report concluded its best possible product would be a me-too system no more than equal to Polaroid's, and its marketing executives admitted there was no unique consumer benefit in the proposed Kodak program.
“We see no unique consumer benefit in the proposed Kodak program at this time.”
The trial began and ended with Land's testimony, and his final rebuttal on the 74th and last day, given about four months after his first testimony, was a deliberate refutation of Kodak's experts, which the host argues made Polaroid's victory inevitable.
“this is the 74th and last day of the trial was devoted completely to a return to the stand of Polaroid's first and star witness Edwin Land.”
Kodak had supplied Polaroid's film negatives for more than 15 years and was Polaroid's third-largest customer, but after the SX-70 launched, Kodak's leadership, now without its founder, grew determined to compete directly, shifting the relationship from paternal support to rivalry.
“Kodak had made tidy profits from supplying material to Polaroid for more than 15 years... Privately, a different mindset, however, had begun evolving.”
Polaroid's low-cost Swinger camera sold 7 million units in its first three years, and because camera makers earn little on hardware but 60 to 80 percent margins on film, Polaroid's cheap cameras expanded a film market Kodak had ignored and drew Kodak into direct competition.
“7 million Swingers were sold in the first three years, driving Polaroid sales and profits to new heights and continuing to change Kodak executives' perception of Polaroid and its market segment growth potential.”
Before the damages judgment, Kodak had lost about $494 million from removing cameras and film from shelves and shuttering manufacturing, plus an additional $150 million settling class action lawsuits with unhappy customers, totaling roughly $650 million.
“its defeat had already caused Kodak, the staggering amount of $494 million. It had also cost Kodak an additional $150 million to settle class action lawsuits”
Land and Steve Jobs both held that it is not the consumer's job to know what they want, so entrepreneurial invention means making products the consumer cannot yet imagine, and Jobs answered a question about market research for the iPad with 'Pure Land' meaning none.
“Jobs reply was, 'Pure Land,' almost a verbatim reprise of comments Land had made many times throughout his career. None. It isn't the consumer's job to know what they want.”
After Polaroid threatened to appeal, the parties settled for $925 million on July 16, 1991, 15 years, three months and 20 days after the suit began, and as of 2014 this remained the largest satisfied judgment awarded by a court in a US patent infringement case.
“the two parties at long last settled the case for $925 million. ... it still remains the largest satisfied judgment awarded by a court in a patent infringement case in U.S. history.”
Kodak did not use the engineers who developed its own instant system as witnesses and instead hired outside experts who had never made an instant photography system, while Polaroid relied on Land and Rogers, who did the work.
“They hired outside witnesses. People that had never made an instant photography system”
Land was certain American involvement in the European war was inevitable and predicted the US would be in the war within a year, so he shifted Polaroid from consumer products to war technology before the United States declared war, motivated by combating a spreading disease rather than profit.
“Land predicted that the United States would be in the war within the next year. As a result, he decided to make a big change in Polaroid's focus.”
Land pushed the U-2 reconnaissance project to Eisenhower and CIA director Allen Dulles, arguing that a single clear-weather mission could photograph a 200-mile-wide, 2,500-mile-long strip of Russia in 4,000 sharp pictures, which he said was the right modern and scientific technique for the CIA.
“A single mission in clear weather can photograph in revealing detail a strip of Russia 200 miles wide and 2,500 miles long and produce 4,000 sharp pictures.”
Kodak's entry into instant photography was a curious decision because the instant business became only about 5 percent of Kodak's overall sales, while it represented about 90 percent of Polaroid's sales.
“It winds up being like 5%. Kodak is a giant company... And for Polaroid, it's like 90% of their sales.”
Land argued that important breakthroughs come from special minds and do not occur spontaneously in multiples, and that with about 1,000 new fields available but only a handful explored by large corporations, the patent system must protect young individual entrepreneurs who will develop the rest.
“There are 1,000 new fields ready to be opened, only a handful of these will be explored by large corporations, leaving many areas untouched. Without the protection of the patent system, young scientific entrepreneurs cannot be counted on to develop the rest.”
Land's view of patents rested on a fundamental belief in individual greatness, so the lawsuit was a manifest duty to shareholders to assert patents that protected the whole field he created.
“Our manifest duty to our shareholders is vigorously to assert our patents.”
Judge Zobel upheld the validity of eight of the ten Polaroid patents involved in the case and ruled that seven had been infringed by Eastman Kodak, with the victory considered total for Land and Polaroid.
“Judge Zobel upheld the validity of eight of the 10 Polaroid patents involved, ruling that seven had been infringed by Eastman Kodak.”
Land argued that diversifying Polaroid away from instant photography would be madness, since the company was already on the 90-yard line and the basic amateur field was in its infancy, not its maturity, and he threatened to derail the plan if managers strayed from his vision.
“It would be madness, he said, now that we're in the 90-yard line with the other guy, 30 years behind to run around nothing. And I honestly believe that the basic amateur field is in its infancy, not its maturity.”
Land's rule for choosing work was to pick problems that are important and nearly impossible to solve, rooted in deep and possibly unarticulated human needs, drawing on the diversity of human knowledge and filling gaps with basic scientific exploration.
“Pick problems that are important and nearly impossible to solve. Pick problems that are the result of sensing deep and possibly unarticulated human needs.”
Start by visualizing the perfect version of what you want to build and then work backward toward reality, hacking away at components. Land took about 30 years to reach the SX-70, and Jobs used the same approach for his computers.
“You always start with a fantasy. Part of the fantasy technique is to visualize something as perfect. Then with the experiments you work back from that fantasy to reality, hacking away at the components.”
Businesses should be set up like scientific experiments, because trial and error is unavoidable in a complex and unpredictable world, and many people accept trial but resist error, which is inseparable from it, so leaders should allow repeated failure until results emerge.
“But many people don't like the error part. As if you could separate the trial from the error, you just can't do it.”
Polaroid's lawyers doubted Land would take part in a lawsuit given his privacy, and Kodak may have built its strategy on the assumption he would not testify, underestimating how personally Land would take an attack on the value of his life's work.
“Kodak made the fatal flaw of severely underestimating the personality of Edwin Land. They thought he was so recluse.”
Land's hiring test was whether a candidate was ahead of him in conversation, meaning they anticipated what he would say and delighted in the construction, because dull scientists who have been stultified by routine add nothing to a research team.
“In talking to this person, how much is he ahead of you? When you draw a breadth to say the next thing, does he know what you're going to say before you say it?”
Land recruited eclectic and unorthodox thinkers, gave them basic equipment without fretting over short-term payoff, and left them alone for long periods, creating a competitive advantage because rival companies could not afford this, as when the instant color film lead sat thinking for two years before starting.
“Land had a pension for bringing a variety of eclectic and unorthodox thinkers to Polaroid, giving them the basic equipment they needed for their research without much fretting about the short-term payoff.”
During testimony, Land's role evolved into that of the court's personal tutor on his favorite subject, as Judge Zobel asked him for greater detail and he explained the process slowly and quietly until she was satisfied, which gave Polaroid a decisive advantage in a judge-only trial.
“Quickly becoming more comfortable on the witness stand as his role evolved into, in effect, the court's personal tutor on his favorite subject.”
Land hired by looking for people who were willing to work hard and found it a pleasure to come to work, and he judged potential scientists by whether they anticipated his thoughts, enjoyed the construction of an idea, and actively steered conversation.
“Does he delight in the construction that you're making? Does he turn the conversation quite subtly because he perceives where it is going and wishes it to go somewhere else?”
Land won the Polaroid v. Kodak case largely because of his ability to communicate complex technical ideas, and the judge herself called him an amazing witness after she issued her decision.
“The judge even said after she delivered her decision that she called Land an amazing witness. And he treated his testimony as a way to educate the judge.”
Fragile new ideas are easily killed early, so Land staffed teams with creative minds, sequestered them from critics, and inspired them with a can-do attitude; McCune said Land insulated himself from anyone critical when doing something wild and risky because a dream can explode in the early stages.
“One thing about Land, when he's doing something wild and risky, he is careful to insulate himself from anyone who is critical. It's very easy in the early stages to have a dream explode.”
Land's personal motto was to pursue only what no one else can do, something you are uniquely suited to, and Kodak's decision to imitate Polaroid's instant system was the direct opposite of that philosophy.
“one of the things that Land is known for us is his own personal motto that you only do what no one else can do, something that you're uniquely suited to do.”
In his Inventors Hall of Fame acceptance speech, Land compared invention to American exploration, arguing that the new frontiers are gold mines of the intellect, and that scientific adventures yield insights no one could have guessed without experiment.
“Now those regions today are not geographic. They are not the gold mines of the West. They are the gold mines of the intellect.”
Akio Morita of Sony hired a paid critic to improve products, and that critic later became Sony's president, while Land used the same tactic by hiring Ansel Adams as a consultant whose exacting feedback would improve Polaroid's imaging.
“He hired a paid critic to make some of these products better. Edwin Land did the same thing. He hires one of the most famous photographers Ansel Adams.”
Kodak's counsel Carr eventually stopped extensive cross-examination of Land because each answer strengthened Polaroid's case and annoyed the judge, since the more Land spoke the more he advanced Polaroid rather than Kodak.
“Carr simply and accurately read Zobel -- judge Zobel's body language, deciding that an extensive cross-examination was becoming counterproductive”
People are attracted when others speak passionately about a subject they care deeply about, so Land's passion for light, color, and perception gave him an advantage in persuading the judge, who listened to his introductory lecture for several minutes.
“they are attracted when other humans speak passionately about a subject they care deeply about.”
When a new product is described as a toy or gimmick, that can signal it may be worth investing in; professional photographers dismissed early Polaroid cameras as gimmicks, and Ansel Adams was considered eccentric for championing them.
“a sign that a new product or an app or a service, anything may be worth investing in is when people describe it as a toy or a gimmick.”
Land believed that good, careful, systematic planning can kill a creative company, so he committed Polaroid to pursuing the same ambitious challenges he had set for himself as a teenager instead of conventional planning.
“Land is creative, and he has the well-grounded suspicion that good, careful, systematic planning can kill a creative company.”
Land described a transient but violent need during scientific preoccupation to be alone and undisturbed for days or weeks, and he saw the cycle of withdrawal, embodiment, and return to others as the source of science and of everything worthwhile in life.
“You want to be free to think, not for an hour at a time or three hours at a time, but for two days or two weeks without interruption.”
Land believed that intense concentration for hour after hour can bring out resources in people that they did not know they had, and he had learned early that total engrossment was the best way for him to work.
“My whole life has been spent trying to teach people that intense concentration for hour after hour can bring about, in people, resources they didn't know they had.”
After more than two decades of developing technology that other companies commercialized, Land concluded he would never enter a commercial field that put a barrier between Polaroid and the customer, and he chose to market his innovations directly to the public.
“I knew then I would never go into a commercial field that put a barrier between us and the customer. Rather than deal with other companies as intermediaries, he would market his innovative products directly to the public.”
When Land committed to the trial, he prepared in the most comprehensive way possible, dedicating nearly every waking hour to it, which the host argues reflects an all-in approach that defined his life.
“he was going to prepare himself for the endeavor in a most comprehensive way.”
Land viewed Kodak's defense that Polaroid's inventions were previously discovered or obvious as a personal denigration of his life's work, which made him angrier the more Kodak attacked the inventions, rather than a business dispute.
“That's not business to Land, that's personal. That's them saying to one of the most -- one of history's greatest geniuses that what you did for 50 years was not valuable.”
Land said that even if instant photography were only one component of Polaroid's business, suing Kodak would be obligatory, because vigorously asserting patents is a manifest duty to shareholders, and he declared that his brilliance and patents were the company's soul.
“The only thing that is keeping us alive is our brilliance. The only way to protect our brilliance is our patents. This is our very soul we're involved in.”
Polaroid built its business around the instant photography field it pioneered, and Land refused to make a me-too version of competitors' products, so Polaroid never licensed its core technology to a rival seeking to enter its market.
“Once somebody else is making a product, I'm not making another me-too version of it.”
The attributes of pioneers, as described at the award ceremony, include a curiosity and idealism dissatisfied with present restrictions and imperfections, plus an inward urge for discovery and the ability to turn that dissatisfaction into constructive achievement.
“A state of mind then includes curiosity, an idealism which is dissatisfied with the restrictions and imperfections of the present.”
The host argues Kodak's strategy changed because its founder George Eastman, who led the company for decades, was replaced by a succession of CEOs, showing that leadership directly shapes company direction.
“the change of Kodak over time was directly influenced by the people running the company.”
Land compared running his company to being a physics professor leading students on a grand adventure, and the host argues founders often see themselves as teachers, which gives them a massive advantage in communicating their ideas.
“Land definitely, he compared running his company to being a physics professor and leading his students on a grand adventure”
James Killian judged that Land's eloquent and lucid exposition in meetings with presidents incited their imagination and prompted decisions, and that Land's work on intelligence gathering technology saved the nation billions of dollars.
“In meetings with presidents, his eloquent and lucid exposition incited their latent imagination and prompted them to make decisions and to undertake leadership roles that had been until then beyond their reach.”
Some insights can only be learned through experience, so reading biographies is valuable because it lets you benefit from the decades of trial and error that others have already run.
“that's probably a good reason why you should read so many biographies too, right? Because Edwin Land is telling us, there are certain things that you're just not going to learn unless you experience them.”
Creating a new technology requires a single dominant individual who holds the objective, with a master plan supported by many others, and that leader must constantly ensure individual efforts complement one another to create an integrated system, a pattern the host sees in every book covered where one person is clearly the main figure.
“Creation of a new technology, such as one-step photography requires that a single individual have in mind the objective to be reached... the single dominant individual must constantly assure himself that the individual efforts complement one another”
Kodak had initially viewed Polaroid as a limited niche and a photographic curiosity that was not a threat to its near-monopoly in consumer photography.
“It had not previously considered Polaroid, or its new technology, a threat to its near monopoly in the consumer market. It was, at most, a limited niche, a photographic curiosity.”
Land became the first inductee into the National Inventors Hall of Fame admitted during his lifetime, joining inventors such as Alexander Graham Bell, Eli Whitney, the Wright brothers, Marconi, Morse, McCormick, Goodyear, and Rudolf Diesel.
“He was the first inductee ever admitted during his lifetime.”
Benjamin Franklin devoted his nights to reading because it improved his conversation, and the better conversation opened doors to money and contracts for his business, a pattern Land echoed when he argued that a brilliant scientist who cannot communicate cannot work with others.
“He talks about why it was so important for him to dedicate all of his nights to reading because he felt that the reading he was doing improved his conversation.”
Land objected that Kodak's charts were highly idealized and did not accurately depict the prior art film units, saying that agreeing with simple questions would imply the charts described the product when they did not.
“Those aren't the film units in the process, Land explained. They are highly idealized statements.”
In rebuttal, Land argued that Kodak's expert T misunderstood how the eye sees color versus how color film must be designed to reproduce it, calling the common misunderstanding a creationist view of color that does not reflect how it actually works.
“Land noted finally that the common misunderstanding that T espoused was a creations view of color, but it's not the way it works.”
Despite his genius, Land had an enormous ego and unrelenting stubbornness, his work consumed the balance with his personal life, and some employees found him difficult, overly demanding, and miserly in praise.
“notably his enormous ego and his unrelenting stubbornness. Land's vision of himself does not take into account the possible imbalance between his all-consuming work and his personal life.”
As a pre-teen, Land read Robert Wood's Physical Optics nightly, with the book under his pillow, and this intellectual awakening shaped the direction of his life and became the host's pick for the single most important idea from Land's career.
“Land slept with Wood's book under his pillow and read it nightly in the way that our forefathers read the Bible. It was an intellectual awakening that would shape his life.”
Land was about 30 years old when the National Association of Manufacturers honored him as a modern pioneer of industrial frontiers, sharing the award with Wilbur Wright, Henry Ford, and Charles Kettering.
“So Land is just 30 years old when he wins an award for being one of the modern pioneers of the frontiers of industry by the National Association of Manufacturers.”
Edwin Land died in 1991 with 535 patents to his credit, third in U.S. history.
“He died in 1991 with 535 patents to his credit, third in U.S. history.”
Ansel Adams described Edwin Land as combining extraordinary curiosity about everything with the discipline to satisfy it, and Adams said he responded warmly to Land's intellect because they intuitively understood each other.
“Land had an extraordinary curiosity about everything and the discipline to satisfy it.”
Land was livid that expert A declared him wrong despite having admittedly zero practical experience designing and constructing integral instant film units, and he insisted on the chance to refute A completely and dramatically.
“A had felt free to declare Land wrong despite having admittedly zero actual experience in the field about which he was testifying.”
Land had lived and breathed instant photography for about 50 years, while Kodak's attorneys studied it for maybe five to ten years, so Land had a massive advantage in understanding the technology underlying the patents.
“This is something he lived and breathed every day for 50 years, where even if you -- the attorneys at Kodak hired, they studied this for maybe five years, 10 years.”
Judge Zobel said that contrary to colleagues' predictions she did not find the patent case dull, attributing her engagement to the cooperation and professionalism of the witnesses and counsel on both sides.
“I confess that contrary to the predictions of my colleagues, I did not find this case dull at all.”
Land's basic tenet was that if you can state a problem clearly, you can solve it, and from then on it is just hard work.
“If you can state a problem, then you can solve it. From then on, it's just hard work.”
Kodak's CEO Fallon had come to dislike Polaroid's founder and minimized his achievements, and this attitude, together with the company's changed leadership after George Eastman's death, reduced Kodak's respect for Land.
“Fallon, who frankly had come to dislike Polaroid's founder and had taken to minimizing his achievements.”
The author does not intend to canonize Land and acknowledges that Land's vision of himself as determined, iron-willed, and hard-driving leaves out costs to his personal life and to employees who find him difficult.
“it is not meant to canonize him in total disregard of his shortcomings”
Land described a period of embodiment during concentrated work as a feeling of almost divine guidance, followed by a return to friends and the world feeling refreshed and fully human.
“And during that period of embodiment, you have a feeling of almost divine guidance.”
Polaroid's four trial lawyers had neither seen nor heard from Land in more than two years, leaving them uncertain whether he would resist or participate in the litigation.
“the four lawyers charged with conducting the lawsuit for Polaroid had neither seen nor heard from Land in more than two years”
The host argues books lay the foundation of all religions, economic systems, and political movements, and also of many people's dreams, including Land's, whose discovery of one book shaped his life.
“books lay at the foundation of all religions, economic systems, political movements, but they also lay the foundation for many peoples' dreams”
The formula for accomplishment Land practiced was creative wonderment and intellectual curiosity followed by inexhaustible effort, which the host considers a model for anyone in any field.
“The formula for accomplishment that he practiced throughout his life, creative wonderment and intellectual curiosity followed by inexhaustible effort”
The host invokes David Ogilvy's quote about the good ones, implying that a founder who knows more than anyone else gains a major advantage that is amplified by masterful communication.
“Go back to the old David Ogilvy quote that is so important. "The good ones no more."”
Land openly championed patents for years before the Kodak suit, and the host notes it is ironic that Polaroid became involved in the largest patent infringement case in US history.
“It is somewhat rather interesting that Land found himself involved in what was the largest patent infringement case in U.S. history”