#260 One from Many: VISA and the Rise of Chaordic Organization
What this covers
In this episode David Senra works through the life and writing of Dee Hock, the founder of Visa. The story starts in the late 1960s, when the BankAmericard system was in chaos. Paper-based clearing and fraud produced losses in the hundreds of millions rather than tens of millions. Hock did not want to run the new organization, but the member banks would commit only if he did. He agreed to three years, and it became fourteen. Within two years the losses were under control and the business was growing 50% compounded. Within five, the worldwide system was unified as Visa.
The ideas span several areas. On money, Hock treats it as guaranteed alphanumeric data moving at the speed of light, so a bank is whatever custodies and moves that data, and the plastic card is an accident of its time. On organization, Senra relays the claim, which is contested, that command and control belongs to a dying 400-year-old paradigm. He pairs it with Hock's estimate that 80% wasted time is not uncommon in large institutions. A chaordic structure, a kind of financial United Nations of cooperating competitors, is Hock's answer. There is also a sharp anecdote about Dick Simmons avoiding decisions without ever lying.
The later turns are more personal. Hock urges leading yourself first and holding four perspectives on any situation, with what ought to be as the North Star. He admits that managers hired from mechanistic firms pushed him into using command-and-control to stop command-and-control. He also notes that interest on less affluent debt still subsidizes free service for the affluent. He calls Visa an archetype to study, not a model to copy.
Senra argues that Dee Hock's Visa story shows organizations should be built from purpose and function rather than inherited procedure and form, using a 'chaordic' blend of order and chaos, and that Hock himself repeatedly failed to live up to that standard.
- Industrial-age institutions let procedure override purpose, wasting large shares of people's time
- Visa was reconceived from the function of money exchange rather than the form of the credit card
- Hock's own failures, including reverting to command-and-control, show how hard the ideal is to sustain
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Hock recognized in the late 1960s that computers and telecommunications would make possible a global electronic value exchange system that enables consumers to pay for goods and services anywhere.
“computers and telecommunications would soon make it possible to build a global electronic value exchange system”
By the late 1960s the BankAmericard system was in chaos, with paper-based clearing and fraud producing losses that turned out to be in the hundreds of millions of dollars rather than tens of millions, which created the opening for a new organization.
“Losses were not in the tens of millions as everyone had thought, but in the hundreds of millions and accelerating.”
Money has become guaranteed alphanumeric data recorded and transported on valueless metal and paper, so the value lies in the guarantee and the data rather than the physical coin or currency, which opens the possibility of electronic global value exchange.
“Money had become guaranteed alphanumeric data recorded and transported on valueless metal and paper”
Hock hoped card issuers would shift from making the card an instrument of debt to an instrument for exchanging value, earning revenue from transaction pricing rather than cardholder interest, but 28 years later interest on less affluent debt still subsidizes free service for affluent customers.
“Twenty-eight years later, that has not happened, and interest on debt of those who need to pay monthly supports free service to the more affluent.”
You cannot escape yourself by changing jobs, places, or possessions; the self, with its inferiority and negative self-talk, travels with you, so one must confront and get along with that self.
“Everywhere you go, you take your giant with you.”
A chaordic organization is a self-organizing, self-governing system that harmoniously blends characteristics of chaos and order, and Hock took the concept from nature's fundamental organizing principle.
“The behavior of any self-organizing and self-governing organism, organization or system that harmoniously blends characteristics of chaos and order.”
Within two years of the reorganization the operating problems and losses were under control and the business was growing 50% compounded annually, and within five years the worldwide system was unified as Visa and was by a wide margin the largest system for exchanging value.
“Within two years, operating problems and losses were under control and the business was highly profitable, growing at the rate of 50% compounded annually.”
Bureaucracy builds up in layers without anyone deciding to add it, so leaders must constantly look to eliminate it rather than accept it as the way things are.
“You never set out to add bureaucracy, you just get it period without even knowing it, so you always have to be looking to eliminate it.”
Command-and-control organizations such as government, schools, and most companies belong to a dying 400-year-old paradigm and will not work in the information age; new ways of organizing people are needed.
“the future of something trying to happen of a 400-year-old age rattling in its deathbed as another struggles to be born.”
Hock admitted he failed to live his own ideals at Visa: hiring managers from mechanistic companies brought their habits, and he used command-and-control techniques to stop command-and-control behavior, underestimating the cultural change a chaordic organization required.
“I used command and control techniques to prevent command and control, plain stupid.”
The essential function of a bank is the custody, exchange, and loan of guaranteed alphanumeric data, so any institution that can move and guarantee such data in the way people use as a medium of exchange is effectively a bank.
“Any institution that could move, manipulate and guarantee alphanumeric data in a manner that individuals customarily use and relied upon as a medium of exchange was a bank.”
Hock realized that Visa was not really in the credit card business but in the business of exchanging monetary value, and that this purpose required coordinating thousands of banks and millions of customers, which mechanistic command-and-control organizations like IBM or General Motors could not do.
“We were really in the business of the exchange of monetary value”
A truly global payment system required something akin to a financial United Nations, a structure in which multiple competing institutions cooperate just enough to build something far bigger than any one could build alone.
“A truly global payment system required something akin to a financial United Nations, a social structure in which multiple competing institutions could cooperate just enough to build something far bigger than any one of them could build alone.”
Hock realized the company was not in the credit card business; the card was merely a device for exchanging monetary value whose plastic form was an accident of time and circumstance, so the business ought to be defined as exchange of monetary value.
“We were not in the credit card business. The card was no more than a device bearing symbols for the exchange of monetary value.”
Influencing the future requires mastering four perspectives on any situation: as it is, as it was, as it might become, and as it ought to be, with the last serving as the North Star.
“Influencing the future requires mastering four ways of looking at things as they are, as they were, as they might become, and as they ought to be.”
Because Visa grew so fast it hired outside managers who brought the techniques and habits of industrial-age command-and-control organizations, so Hock ended up using command-and-control methods to stop command-and-control behavior.
“I used command and control techniques to prevent command and control, plain stupid.”
Dick Simmons deliberately gathered conflicting opinions and sketches from officers to avoid decision, leaving murky minds unqualified and petty minds free to fuss, without ever telling a lie.
“He simply left murky minds unqualified and petty minds free to fuss.”
Although Visa has been a phenomenal success by orthodox measures, Hock believed it fell short of what it ought to be and is not a model to emulate, only an archetype to study, learn from, and improve upon.
“I do not believe that Visa is a model to emulate. It is no more than an archetype to study, learn from and improve upon.”
Effective leadership starts with leading yourself, then your superiors and peers, then employing good people and freeing them to do the same; everything else is trivia.
“if you're going to lead others, first you lead yourself, then you lead your superiors, then you lead your peers.”
In companies like the consumer finance firm Hock joined, procedure is more important than purpose, so the question of what the business is actually for gets reversed and the doing of the doing replaces results.
“What you don't understand is that in companies like this, procedure is more important than purpose.”
A founder should focus on how the product or company ought to be and nothing else, rather than on copying existing forms or competitors.
“Focus on how your product or company ought to be and nothing else.”
Hock had no intention of accepting leadership of the new organization and wanted his life back, but the member banks would commit only if he took the role, so he agreed to a three-year commitment that became fourteen years.
“Had I any intention of accepting if asked? None. I was exhausted.”
Asking people to total the time, energy, and ingenuity they spent obeying senseless rules reveals that a rare person in a large institution is productive less than 50% of the time, and 80% wasted time is not uncommon.
“It is a rare person who works in a large institution who arrives at a sum of less than 50% of their time and 80% of their time is not uncommon.”
Hock's framing held that money as alphanumeric data would travel at the speed of light at minuscule cost, implying the emergence of a new form of global currency.
“It would move around the world at the speed of light at minuscule cost by infinitely diverse paths. Inherent in all this might be the genesis of a new form of global currency.”
Coordinating thousands of banks and millions of customers worldwide cannot be done with mechanistic command-and-control organizations like IBM or General Motors, so a new organizational form was necessary.
“For us to do that, we have to be able to coordinate with thousands of banks all over the world and millions of customers. We cannot do that with the mechanistic command and control organizations of the present day.”
People with power to write and enforce rules rarely spend much time following them, so rules fall on subordinates while the powerful exempt themselves, which Hock considered inherently unfair.
“What he realizes is like people with power to write and enforce rules rarely spend much time following them, and that's something Dee observes over and over again.”
Anger, blame, and condemnation are fueled by response and are least able to be sustained when met with calm indifference.
“anger, blame and condemnation, and other negative emotions are fueled by response. They are least able to be sustained when met with calm indifference.”
Hock copied conventional corporate status signals, such as private offices and executive headquarters, even though he disliked them, because he believed banks and regulators would not take a modest organization seriously.
“I lacked ability and courage to lead in the direction of my natural inclination rather than copying acquired behavior.”
Hock argued that the sudden clear failure of the existing system made a new concept of organization both necessary and possible, since it provided a foothold to attempt it.
“Suddenly, like a diamond in the dirt there it lay, the need for a new concept of organization and a precarious toe-hold from which to make the attempt.”
Yvon Chouinard's method for finding meaningful work is to describe the worst version of a job and then design the opposite when building a company, which Senra finds smart.
“What if you were to describe the worst version of the job that you have and in building your company, you design the opposite of that?”
After repeated firings and failures, Hock decided to coast in a job he could do in his sleep to fund his family and leave time for reading and nature, a plan he called retirement on the job.
“he calls it retirement on the job, where he keeps the job.”
Before designing a structure, ask what the purpose of the business is and what it is actually doing, rather than starting from existing procedures.
“In our case, what is the purpose of the business? What is it actually doing?”
The possibility of something that has never occurred cannot be determined by opinion, only by attempt; attempting the impossible is beyond reason and rests on hope, faith, and determination.
“The possibility of that which has never occurred cannot be determined by opinion, only by attempt.”
Until someone has repeatedly said no and adamantly refused to discuss a subject further, they are in the process of saying yes without knowing it, so persistent persuasion can succeed.
“until someone had repeatedly said no and adamantly refuses another word on the subject, they are in the process of saying yes and don't know it.”
In the early 1960s, using a card to buy goods abroad regardless of language, currency, or time zone was unthinkable, showing that today's magic was yesterday's dream and that Hock foresaw the future decades early.
“In the early 1960s, this was simply unthinkable. Today's magic was yesterday's dream.”
Hock's shock at school and church, where discipline followed failure to conform, combined with his observation that nature lacks principals and teachers, produced a lifelong rebellion against institutional command and control.
“Nothing in nature feels like church or school. There's no principal pecking away at the rest of the flock.”
Money is not defined by coin, currency, or credit card but by anything customarily used as a measure of equivalent value and medium of exchange.
“Money was anything customarily used as a measure of equivalent value and medium of exchange”
Failure is not to be feared because most growth comes from failure, provided one can recognize it, admit it, learn from it, rise above it, and try again.
“failure is not to be feared. It is from failure that most growth comes, provided that one can recognize it, admit it, learn from it, rise above and try again”
Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger advise working only with people you like, admire, and trust, because chasing an extra dollar with a bad person is a poor trade, as Hock learned when a partner denied him promised profits.
“Only work with people that you like, admire, and trust.”
In the early credit card industry, banks sent unsolicited cards to every customer through the mail, a practice Senra believes would now be illegal.
“They would just send every single one of their customers a credit card through the mail.”
Hock's decentralized, non-hierarchical organizing principles resemble the structure of open-source collaboration and crypto organizations, and if Visa were founded today it might be built on crypto-style structures.
“there's some kind of weird echo, I guess is what I'm trying to say between how Dee thinks about organizational structures, what people are trying to do in cryptocurrency.”
Forming a new organization requires sound material, a good tool, a capable hand, and a vision of things to come, along with patience and persistence and willingness to change the vision as the nature of the material is revealed.
“It requires sound material, a good tool, a capable hand, and most important, a vision of things to come.”
Hock, who disliked confinement, nevertheless gave in to conventional corporate status markers, moving to private offices and later allowing the open floor plan to be divided into cubicles, which he cited as a failure to lead in his own direction.
“What is now clear is that I lacked ability and courage to lead in the direction of my natural inclination rather than copying acquired behavior.”
Hock as a child concluded that the natural world, with no principal or teacher directing other organisms, was the better blueprint for organizing life than school and church.
“There's no principal pecking away at the rest of the flock. There's no super frog telling the others how to croak.”
Hock's life story is a bargain in which he gave up ego, envy, greed, and ambition, which devour their keeper, for humility, equanimity, time, and liberty.
“It is a story of a great bargain, trading ego for humility, envy for equanimity, greed for time, and ambition for liberty.”
Senra argues that Hock's distributed organizational ideas parallel how nature and open-source software collaboration are organized, and that such ideas now echo in crypto network design.
“There's just this weird overlap between what Dee was doing, how nature's organized, how open sources are organized.”
Large mature companies see bureaucracy as just the way things are, while founders see it as something that must be constantly eliminated, checked, and eliminated again.
“Founders see it as a thing that needs to be constantly eliminated, checked, and then eliminated.”
Hock's early manual labor jobs from age 10 onward, including harvesting, thinning sugar beets, and slaughterhouse work, instilled a view that such work was simply making a living and not demeaning.
“None of it seemed demeaning. It was life. It was making a living.”
Hock's life was organized around three questions: why institutions everywhere are increasingly unable to manage their affairs, why individuals are increasingly in conflict with and alienated from institutions, and why society and the biosphere are increasingly in disarray.
“why are institutions everywhere increasingly unable to manage their affairs?”
Senra uses time as a filter to judge whether ideas are good, which is why he studies historical founders rather than present-day ones.
“I use time as a filter. It's the only way I can tell if the ideas are good or not.”
Hock made major decisions and recovered from adversity through long walks in nature, using the process to think through the trade-offs and to restore equanimity.
“As is customary, anytime he has to make a large decision in his life, he goes to nature.”
Hock advised his grandchildren to use their brain but follow their heart, and he took that path himself when he joined the National Bank of Commerce despite the job being beneath his experience.
“This is the advice I give my grandchildren to use your brain but follow your heart”
The National Bank of Commerce interviews felt like conversations about reading and philosophy rather than employment screening, signaling that its people were like Hock and worth joining even without a clear job.
“These aren't job interviews. These are conversations about what we're reading and philosophy.”
Hock's first corporate job ended with him being pushed out because his naive, idealistic belief that the company could change was overpowered by the company's determination to corral him, showing that rebels are typically crushed by hierarchy.
“The lamb was determined to change the company. The company was determined to corral the lamb. It was no contest.”
In the pre-Visa environment, every meeting ended with forming another committee, which produced more committees, so no one with authority could decide anything.
“Meeting after meeting, hundreds of groups all want all with different ideas on how to do things, no one with authority to do anything without approval.”
Hock's early insistence on asking what the company is for, rather than following the manual, led to a branch tripling its business in two years and leading the company in growth and profit, but also to frequent confrontation with superiors.
“Within two years, business tripled and the office was leading the company in growth, profit, and quality of business”
Excellence is the capacity to take pain, and Hock's career illustrates how much pain building a major institution requires.
“excellence is the capacity to take pain”
Hock's investment-company owner refused to share a sale profit by claiming years of prior losses, which Hock took as naked greed, and Hock responded by walking away, a decision he later saw as naive.
“Keep the money. You apparently needed more than I do.”
Senra believes the emotional power of great writing is among the most powerful media for evoking feeling, which is why he values autobiographies such as Dylan's and Hock's.
“I don't think there is a more powerful medium to evoke emotion than really great writing.”
Senra argues every founder he studies is a misfit, rebel, or outsider, and Hock's background of rural poverty and lack of elite credentials fits this pattern.
“considering that every single person that we study is a misfit, a rebel, some kind of outsider”
Patrick Collison of Stripe publicly described Dee Hock as a very underrated innovator who inspired him and his brother, prompting Senra to read the Hock book.
“Dee Hock, the creator of Visa died this week at 93. He was a very underrated innovator”
The episode recounts the book's chapter-by-chapter narrative, including details like the Visa-era walking routine and the family's rural background.
“That is 260 books down, 1000 to go”