#42 One From Many: VISA and the Rise of Chaordic Organization
What this covers
David Senra works through Dee Hock's account of building Visa, mixing biography with Hock's organizational philosophy. Hock was 36 and thought himself a failure, having been fired repeatedly for unorthodox methods despite good results. Visa's founders had no money, power, or influence, and they could not buy the system from Bank of America or hire consultants. Hock calls the resulting reliance on cooperation necessity, not genius. He later resigned in 1984 at Visa's peak and spent about a decade in isolation, wary of ego, envy, avarice, and ambition.
The range is wider than a corporate history. Hock's three motivating questions concern failing institutions, alienated individuals, and a disordered biosphere. He claims no new organizing idea has appeared since the corporation, nation-state, and university. Dick Simmons, a cynical coworker, demonstrated that procedure outranks purpose by stirring months of petty bickering over signs and office space without telling a lie. Hock proposes a balance sheet of wasted time spent obeying, dodging, and enforcing senseless rules. He also offers Four Ways of Looking at events and his mother's attitude of Nothing Finer. He coined "chaordic" after reading Complexity, whose edge of chaos matched what he had built.
The most contested material is duality: whether banks could own both card networks. Hock feared eventual monopoly, and he predicted banks would take two years to go dual if the ban lifted. They took six months. He argues such futures rest on judgment, not proof, and he regarded the Justice Department's rejection, which forced Visa to drop its ban, as a failure of courage. He rates Visa a success by orthodox metrics but a failure against what it ought to be.
Hock's book argues that industrial-age command-and-control organizations are failing, and that organizations should be designed around purpose, principles, and people, as they ought to be, using a self-organizing 'chaordic' model that Visa was built on.
- Mechanistic, command-and-control organizations waste talent on procedure and politics rather than results
- Visa emerged from necessity, without money or power, by educing cooperation rather than compelling it
- Hock judged Visa a success by orthodox metrics but a failure by what it ought to be, so it is an archetype to study, not to copy
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Dee Hock was 36 years old and considered himself a failure before he started Visa, having been fired repeatedly for unorthodox methods even when his results were good, which undermines the myth that founders have it figured out early.
“Dee Hock was 36 years old, and he considered himself a failure before he started Visa.”
Hock predicted banks would take two years to become dual owner/members of both systems if the prohibition was dropped, but they did so in six months, and today there is no third, fourth, or fifth bank card system, with Visa and Mastercard dominating debit.
“The banks didn't take two years to go dual. They did it in six months. Today, there is no third, fourth or fifth bank card system.”
Despite accelerating change, there has been no new, commonly accepted idea of organization since the corporation, nation-state, and university emerged, the newest of which is several centuries old, so institutional forms have only been tinkered with in size, form, and labels.
“there has been no new, commonly accepted idea of organization since the concepts of corporation, nation-state and university emerged”
Hock's mother taught him that 'nothing finer' is the attitude to take toward unpleasant conditions, which means doing the best you can in the present and not making future desires the condition for present happiness, because limiting desire is the key to happiness.
“Nothing finer, according to my mother, teaches one to attend to business and not dawdle.”
Dee Hock resigned from Visa in 1984 at the height of its success and spent roughly a decade in isolation, believing he was trading money for time, position for liberty, and ego for contentment, because the four beasts of ego, envy, avarice, and ambition would otherwise devour him.
“In 1984, I severed all connections with business for a life of isolation and anonymity, convinced I was making a great bargain by trading money for time, position for liberty, and ego for contentment”
Hock was reading the book Complexity when he formed the chaordic idea, and the book's claim that complex adaptive systems sit at the edge of chaos, with enough self-organization to produce order, matched how he had designed Visa decades earlier.
“all complex, adaptive systems exist on the edge of chaos with just enough self-organization to create the cognitive patterns we refer to as order.”
If banks became owner/members of both Master Charge and BankAmericard, the two networks would eventually merge into one monopoly, because shared owners would reduce competitive vigor and produce dominance by one network.
“interlocking ownership of Master Charge and BankAmericard would inevitably result in diminishment of competitive vigor between the two, eventual dominance of one or the other and merger of the two in substance, if not form.”
Hock argued that a prospective situation can never be proven with evidence and is a matter of judgment informed by experience, and that banks would go dual within two years, a prediction that proved right, coming true within six months.
“Look, I argued, there is never a way to prove a prospective situation. It's not a matter of evidence. It's a matter of judgment.”
The early bank card industry was out of control by 1968, and once the problem was examined, losses were not in the tens of millions as thought but in the hundreds of millions and accelerating.
“Losses were not in the tens of millions as everyone had thought, but in the hundreds of millions and accelerating.”
Department of Justice investigators told Hock that banks assured them they would not go dual, and the agency's denial of his letter forced Visa to withdraw its prohibition on duality, which Hock later regarded as a failure of courage.
“The senior investigator informed us that the vast preponderance of banks had assured them that they would never go dual.”
Visa came about because its four vice presidents had no money, power, or influence, and that forced them to rely on purpose, principles, and people, which Hock says was plain-old necessity rather than genius.
“the need to rely entirely on the power of purpose, principles, and people was what brought Visa into being. It was no stroke of genius. It was plain-old necessity.”
Businesses, nations, races, and tribes die not when defeated or suppressed but when they become despairing and lose excitement and hope about the future.
“Businesses as well as nations, races and tribes, die out not when defeated or suppressed, but when they become despairing and lose excitement and hope about the future.”
Dick Simmons, a brilliant and cynical coworker, showed Hock that in companies like this procedure is more important than purpose and method more important than results, and he used this by stirring months of trivial bickering over signs, office layouts, and space without telling a single lie.
“What you don't understand is that in companies like this, procedure is more important than purpose and method more important than results.”
Understanding events and influencing the future requires mastering four ways of looking at things: as they were, as they are, as they might become, and as they ought to be.
“Understanding events and influencing the future requires mastering of 4 ways of looking at things: as they were, as they are, as they might become and as they ought to be.”
A prospective situation cannot be proven with evidence; it is a matter of judgment informed by deep experience with how banks act and react, so arguing for a future outcome depends on judgment rather than proof.
“there is never a way to prove a prospective situation. It's not a matter of evidence. It's a matter of judgment.”
Visa was a phenomenal success by objective measures like growth, profit, and market share, but by the standard of what it ought to be, Hock believed it was a failure, and it should be studied as an archetype to learn from and improve upon, not copied.
“I do not believe that Visa is a model to emulate. It is no more than an archetype to study, learn from and improve upon.”
After 16 years of unorthodox management and strong results, Hock was judged a failure by the standards of industrial-age command-and-control organizations, with labels like stubborn, opinionated, unorthodox, and rebellious, and the host notes these were not without justification.
“After 16 years of unorthodox management and unblemished results, the sheep, by the standards of industrial age command-and-control organizations, was a failure.”
Visa's founders had no money to buy the system from Bank of America, no money for consultants, research, or staff, and no influence over regulators, yet they were accepted by banks partly because no one thought such an organization was likely to be created.
“We had no money with which to purchase the system from Bank of America; no money to hire consultants, advisers or other experts”
Hock coined 'chaordic' by combining chaos and order to describe the behavior of any self-organizing, self-governing system that harmoniously blends characteristics of chaos and order, which he holds is the fundamental organizing principle of nature.
“One, the behavior of any self-organizing and self-governing organism, organization or system that harmoniously blends characteristics of chaos and order”
Healthy organizations are relationships people join by hope, vision, values, meaning, and liberty, and they educe behavior that is inherently constructive, whereas unhealthy organizations are relationships people are compelled into by birth, necessity, or force, and they compel behavior that is inherently destructive.
“Healthy organizations educe behavior. Educed behavior is inherently constructive.”
Hock argued that if his group had power, capital, position, or influence, they would have used them in the command-and-control style they had been indoctrinated in, and that the lack of those resources forced them to change their consciousness toward larger ideas.
“Had we power, capital, position or influence, we would undoubtedly have used them in the command-and-control style in which we had been so admirably indoctrinated.”
Hock's lifelong project was driven by three questions: why institutions everywhere are increasingly unable to manage their affairs, why individuals are increasingly in conflict with and alienated from those institutions, and why society and the biosphere are increasingly in disarray.
“why are institutions everywhere, whether political, commercial or social, increasingly unable to manage their affairs?”
Hock asked whether the industrial machine age was an extension of human muscle and the computer age an extension of human mind, and the host sees this as shaping how technology now lets individuals and small groups have much larger impact.
“Is there some analogy between the industrial machine age as an extension of muscle and the computer age as an extension of mind?”
Organization members should make a simple balance sheet showing how much time, energy, and ingenuity they spend obeying senseless rules, how much they spend circumventing them to get productive work done, how much is wasted enforcing rules on others, and how much talent they withhold out of frustration.
“How much time, energy and ingenuity did they spend obeying senseless rules and procedures that had little to do with the results they were expected to achieve?”
Hock built Visa by focusing on what it ought to be, not on the barriers, and he thought an impossible list of obstacles, including Bank of America giving up ownership and banks worldwide cooperating, did not matter if the ideal was right.
“But did I believe it was what ought to be? Ah, that was another question indeed, powerful enough to draw me on.”
Hock argues that the eclectic mix of bankers, outsiders, pragmatists, dreamers, renegades, and incompetents in early card departments contained the innovative, adventurous spirits the resulting disaster required, and many later rose to major bank management.
“Strangely, however, the eclectic mix of people contain more than enough of the innovative, adventurous spirits that the resulting disaster required.”
Human-made institutions are a poor imitation of how creatures and organisms have worked together for thousands or millions of years, and they should be designed like nature's self-organizing systems rather than rigid hierarchies.
“Nothing in nature feels like church or school. There's no blackbird principal pecking away at the rest of the flock.”
Studying how founders got to their results, including their setbacks, is more valuable than studying the results themselves, because the process reveals the human experience and ideas that can be applied elsewhere.
“we should study not the results of what these founders have done but how they got there”
Hock argued against letting banks be owner-members of both Master Charge and BankAmericard because he believed more competing card systems would benefit consumers, even though this position damaged the profit the system would have earned.
“I was deeply convinced that there could and should be many card systems within the consumer banking industry”
Hock argued that ordinary people's economic power comes from freedom of choice and sufficient resources, so consumers are best served by many competing card systems and many competing card issuers within each system.
“the economic power of ordinary people arises from freedom of choice and sufficient resources to pursue them.”
Hock asks whether people will copy the past command-and-control organizations or innovate, and argues that anyone unwilling to examine their internal model of reality makes a grave mistake, because no one is without influence or power to choose wisely.
“If you are unwilling to examine your present consciousness, your internal model of reality, your perception of how you were, how you are, how you might become, and how you ought to be, you're making a grave mistake.”
In industrial-age organizations, purpose slowly erodes into process, and procedure takes precedence over product, so people end up doing the doing with virtually nothing getting done.
“In industrial-age organizations, purpose slowly erodes into process. Procedure takes precedence over product.”
Hock observed that nature has no blackbird principal, super frog, or teacher tree directing others, and concluded that the coercive hierarchy of school and church contradicts how natural systems actually coordinate.
“Nothing in nature feels like church or school. There's no blackbird principal pecking away at the rest of the flock.”
Hock's early career at a consumer finance company showed that when a small team was left alone and succeeded, the company's top management responded by enforcing conformity and punishing the unorthodox success.
“Anonymity was gone and the blind fist of corporate power and orthodoxy began pounding for conformity.”
The host argues that Hock's career shows people are very bad at predicting what will make them happy, since even when Hock got the success he wanted, it did not bring the contentment he expected.
“we're very bad at predicting what's going to make us happy.”
Hock argued that the hubris of science is astonishing, because complexity, diversity, interconnectedness, and self-organization have been understood by poets, philosophers, theologians, humanists, and mystics for thousands of years and are not a new scientific discovery.
“The hubris of science is astonishing. It will come as quite a surprise to countless poets, philosophers, theologians, humanists, and mystics”
Bank of America was willing to surrender ownership of its trademark and licensing system, which would have assured licensees 25 percent or more of every participant's revenues in perpetuity, because the system was losing money to fraud and disorganization.
“Bank of America would surrender ownership of a trademark and licensing system that assured them 25% or more of the revenues of every participant in perpetuity.”
Most bankers looked down on the card business, ranking it below auto dealer financing, and card operations were located in the least desirable part of bank premises and staffed with people who did not fit elsewhere.
“Card operations were located in the least desirable part of the bank premises and staffed with employees who did not fit elsewhere.”
After severe financial vulnerability, Hock and his wife swore that, aside from a home mortgage, they would never again carry more debt than cash in the bank.
“we would never again have more debt than cash in the bank”
Visa, now valued at about $328 billion and bigger than virtually every other bank on earth, began as a nonprofit owned by banks, and its nonprofit ownership structure was meant to keep the central platform from taking too much economic rent.
“it started out as a nonprofit owned by banks”
The host argues that the founder mythology hides the reality that founding a company brings joy, sorrow, depression, and anxiety together, and that people are poor at predicting what will make them happy even after they get what they want.
“we're very bad at predicting what's going to make us happy.”
Hock began working at age 10 harvesting produce for pennies per pound and held many manual jobs through his teens, and he came to see such work as dignified rather than demeaning.
“None of it seemed demeaning. It was life. It was making a living.”
Before centralized electronic clearing, card transactions were recorded as paper imprints sent to separate banks or processors without a central clearinghouse, and some hundreds of thousands of dollars of these imprints were never processed at all.
“There wasn't like one central clearinghouse place.”
Hock sat frozen in his car across from an unemployment office line, unable to get out, which he later described as a deep depression that recurred several times, showing that founders do not simply overcome despair and then have it all figured out.
“Something deep inside said, 'No, take me there and I will die.'”
Products and companies should be designed around what they ought to be rather than around how others did it in the past or do it now, as Steve Jobs did with the iPhone by asking what a mobile device should be rather than starting from existing keyboards.
“What should a mobile device be? What should it ought to be?”
The theology of chaordic organizations holds that heaven is purpose, principle, and people, purgatory is paper and procedure, and hell is rules and regulations.
“heaven is purpose, principal and people. Purgatory is paper and procedure. Hell is rule and regulations.”
Hock said he regretted withdrawing the duality prohibition rather than fighting on, and that he would never know whether that choice was a prudent act or a failure of courage and judgment, possibly due to death threats.
“To this day, I wonder if the implied death threats affected my courage and judgment.”
Hock experienced crushing confinement and boredom in school and church as a child, sensing that institutions shed wholeness and humanity, and this lifelong distaste for institutions shaped the Visa choices he later made.
“It was as though everyone began to shed wholeness and humanity at the doors of institutions.”
Starting a company is very hard, long work that exposes founders to the full range of human experience, including depression and anxiety, so the myth that entrepreneurship is always great should be rejected because positives cannot be had without negatives.
“I don't like this false myth of entrepreneurship that everything is always great.”
Hock grew up poor with no indoor plumbing in a farming community at the edge of the Rocky Mountains, born just before the Depression to parents with eighth-grade educations, and his mother taught him to attend to business and not dawdle.
“Nothing finer, according to my mother, Teaches one to attend to business and not dawdle.”
After five years of successful turnaround work for a small investment firm, its owner claimed the promised profit share must absorb years of prior losses, leaving nothing to share, and Hock walked away, concluding the owner's greed had consumed him.
“Keep the money. You apparently need it more than I do.”
Hock received death threats while fighting against duality, and the host notes the stress of this campaign pushed him to long walks through restricted watershed land.
“And he actually gets death threats from this.”
Hock's main theme is that people should rethink how they organize work, because applying centuries-old organizational structures to a fast-changing environment makes no sense.
“we need to rethink the way we organize people. You're using things that are centuries old that don't make any sense.”
At 25, Hock was too naive, too indoctrinated, and too eager to rise in the company to see that the company was damaging a capable man, and within a year he was fired, much wiser about hierarchy.
“The lamb stepped eagerly into the jaws of the beast. He wanted to believe in the company.”
Hock's interest in self-organization was rooted in his childhood spent largely in nature, which later shaped how he designed Visa.
“the amount of time when you've seen him as a child, he spent most of his time just out in nature.”
Valve, which the host describes as the most profitable US company per employee, is rethinking the answer to how organizations should be structured, and its handbook shows a deliberate design that delivers high profit with fewer people than competitors.
“Valve is the most profitable company in the United States per employee.”
Until someone has repeatedly said no and adamantly refuses further discussion, they are in the process of saying yes and do not know it, so persistence in persuasion is justified.
“until someone has repeatedly said no and adamantly refuses another word on the subject, they are in the process of saying yes and don't know it.”
Hock held that until someone has repeatedly and adamantly said no, they are in the process of saying yes without knowing it, and he applied this persistence to recruiting hundreds and then thousands of banks into the system.
“until someone has repeatedly said no and adamantly refuses another word on the subject, they are in the process of saying yes and don't know it.”
Collecting ideas is valuable even when they are not immediately applicable, because an idea can click and add value years later when circumstances change.
“it's just better to spend your time collecting ideas because the idea might not be applicable to your life now, but something clicks later on”
During dark times, Hock coped with stress by long walks in the woods, including trespassing onto the San Francisco watershed, where the sense that his troubles were of little consequence in the grand picture helped him face the next week.
“A sense that, in the great picture of things, my trials and tribulations were of no consequence”
At college, a dean introduced Hock to the classics and to the powers and limits of the human mind, while his conflicts with the college inflamed a growing preoccupation with the paradoxes inherent in institutions and the people who hold power in them.
“increasing conflict with the college and other organizations inflamed a growing preoccupation with the paradoxes inherent in institutions and the people who hold power within them.”
Hock described himself at 20, newly married and unemployed, as an absurdly naive, idealistic young man who was eager to learn but averse to being taught, comparing himself to an innocent lamb hunting the lion of life.
“Thus at 20, newly married, unemployed, eager to learn, but averse to being taught, emerged an absurdly naive, idealistic young man.”
Elon Musk said he would rather be optimistic and wrong than pessimistic and right, and the host argues excitement about the future, which is another word for optimism, is what makes life and companies worth sustaining.
“I'd rather be optimistic and wrong than pessimistic and right.”
The host notes that Hock's memoir repeatedly argues that whining is useless, a theme he returned to in his later aphorisms.
“something that he talks about constantly in The Autobiography of a Restless Mind is the uselessness of whining.”
Dee Hock walked away from Visa in 1984 at the height of its success, and the host presents this as evidence that Hock's motivations were not money, power, or ego.
“turning my back on Visa in 1984 and walking away at the pinnacle of success was the hardest thing I have ever done.”
The host's mother was diagnosed with metastatic breast cancer that was already Stage 4 when found and died young, and he coped by realizing the loss of a parent is part of the human condition outside his control.
“My mom was diagnosed with metastatic breast cancer. By the time she got it checked out, it was already too late.”
The host suspects that much of what people in large companies do is 'fake work,' such as the internal political wrangling Simmons exploited, and that a simple task could often be completed in 30 minutes.
“I suspect the vast majority of what they're doing is what I call fake work”
Hock's book contains interludes called the old monkey mind, which interrupt the chronology with extended reflections on one idea, and the host argues these were the result of his deep thinking.
“he has this thing called the old monkey mind”
The host argues the book's ideas are too deep to capture in a podcast and that a reader would need to read and reread the book to understand it fully.
“if you want the full story, you're going to have to read it and probably reread it over and over again.”