#291 David Packard (Founder of HP)
What this covers
David Senra works through David Packard's account of building HP, reading from Packard's own writing and adding parallels from other companies. The story runs roughly in order. It starts at GE, where Packard's work on failing mercury vapor rectifier tubes led him to the practice later called Management by Walking Around, and where a manager told him electronics had no future. It then moves through Fred Terman's influence at Stanford and the partnership with Bill Hewlett. HP's first major sale was an audio oscillator priced under $100 that beat a rival product costing about $400.
The range is wider than product history. Packard's financial caution gets detailed treatment: a bank refusal, a series of local lenders, and his father's work as a bankruptcy referee, which shaped his refusal of long-term debt. The Honors Cooperative Program is covered as a recruiting tool that put engineers through Stanford degrees. So is a Japanese joint venture whose board-failure rate fell roughly 400-fold. Product strategy covers building complementary instruments, and HP's growth from $125 million in instrument sales in 1964 to $20 billion in computer products by 1994.
Some of the sharper turns come in the disputes. Packard criticizes Wall Street's focus on quarterly earnings, since cutting R&D flatters the numbers. The episode also covers Chuck House defying orders to keep building a display monitor, with Packard placing the line between insubordination and entrepreneurship at intent. Senra connects all this to Steve Jobs wanting a company that outlives its founders, and to Apple skipping the netbook.
Packard's HP principles (customer contribution over profit, growth from earnings rather than debt, differentiated products, and meticulous quality) show that durable companies are built on disciplined, self-funded, customer-driven execution, not on maximizing short-term profit.
- Profit is a result of contributing something unique, not the reason a company exists
- Growing from reinvested profits and avoiding long-term debt let firms survive depressions and downturns
- Differentiated products and attention to quality beat me-too copying and short-term cost cutting
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
While fixing high failure rates in GE's mercury vapor rectifier tubes, Packard found the engineering department's written instructions were inadequate, and he concluded that personal communication with factory workers was often necessary to back up written instructions, which became the origin of management by walking around.
“That personal communication was often necessary to back up written instructions.”
HP had $125 million in sales in 1964, all from instruments, and by 1994 computer products generated $20 billion, showing that doing the best with present opportunities can unlock large future opportunities that cannot be predicted.
“In 1964, 30 years before, our sales total were just $125 million, and they were entirely in instruments, not a penny was from computer sales.”
Wall Street's fixation on quarterly earnings is easy to manipulate, since cutting R&D can quickly raise profits and win praise, but this is short-term thinking, and technology companies must keep creating new products to survive.
“It is always possible to improve profits for a time by reducing the level of your investment in new product design and engineering.”
HP's early instruments looked different but were all designed to measure and test electronic equipment, reflecting a deliberate strategy to build complementary products rather than unrelated ones and to take on no more than the company could reasonably handle.
“They reflected our strategy to concentrate on building a group of complementary products rather than becoming involved in a lot of unrelated things.”
Companies combine people, materials, facilities, money and time into products, and profit is the value they add by selling for more than cost, making profit the ultimate source of funds to prosper, grow, and provide employment security.
“This difference, our profit represents the value that we add to the resources that we utilize.”
GE's Mr. Boring told Packard there was no future for electronics at General Electric and steered him toward heavy utility components; Packard later noted that HP grew larger than all of GE was at that time.
“our electronics firm, HP, has become larger than the entire General Electric Company was at that time that he gave me this advice.”
Professor Fred Terman sparked Packard's interest in electronics, and his course, which included visits to radio firms run by industry pioneers, made the young students friends and produced the nucleus of HP's future management team.
“It was Fred who sparked my interest in electronics and who later encouraged and helped Bill and me go into business for ourselves.”
Steve Jobs, near the end of his life, said his most important goal was to do what Hewlett and Packard had done: build a company so imbued with innovative creativity that it would outlive its founders.
“his more important goal, he said, was to do what Bill Hewlett and David Packard had done, which was to create a company that was so imbued with innovative creativity that the company would outlive them.”
After Bank of America rejected HP's credit request, Packard found a local bank, Palo Alto National, whose president became a long relationship, and when HP outgrew that bank's legal lending limits it moved to the associate bank Wells Fargo.
“So that's a no from Bank of America. So then David walks over to his little local bank, which is called Palo Alto National.”
When HP asked the Naval Research Laboratory what else it needed, the answer expanded HP's product line and gave it knowledge to manufacture instruments it had not previously been able to build.
“They're building products for the Naval Research Laboratory for the U.S. government, and they just ask them. Like what else do you need us to make?”
HP's Honors Cooperative Program let qualified engineers pursue advanced degrees at Stanford on a full salary with tuition paid, which let HP recruit top graduates nationwide and was, in Packard's view, an important factor in HP's success; more than 400 engineers earned master's or doctorate degrees through it.
“More than 400 HP engineers have obtained master's or doctorate degrees through this program.”
Packard's father was a bankruptcy referee who showed him that banks foreclosed on firms that had mortgaged their assets, leaving them with nothing, while firms that borrowed little survived the depression with assets intact, so Packard decided HP should incur no long-term debt.
“I noted that the banks simply foreclosed on firms that had mortgaged their assets and these firms were left with nothing.”
Apple, according to the Jony Ive biography, declined to make a netbook even though netbooks held about 20 percent of the laptop market, and redirected its resources to development that eventually became the iPad.
“Steve directs the energy instead of using Apple's time and resources to make a netbook, they actually start doing development and experimentation on a product that eventually turns into the iPad.”
HP won its first major sale when Disney's sound engineer Bud Hawkins chose HP's audio oscillator, under $100, over General Radios' product, which cost about $400, because HP offered a good product at a considerably lower price.
“He was planning to buy audio oscillators from another company for $400 each. Our model would cost less than $100.”
Packard and Hewlett decided to reinvest profits rather than take long-term borrowing, finding they could finance 100 percent annual growth from reinvested earnings alone, a principle they kept for more than half a century.
“We found we were clearly able to finance 100% growth per year by reinvesting our profits.”
HP's Japanese joint venture, led after manager Kenzo Sasaoka took over, grew faster and then achieved a printed circuit board failure rate of 10 per million versus HP's best of about 4 per thousand, a roughly 400 times improvement that shifted quality targets across the company.
“Our Japanese unit, on the other hand, came in with a failure rate of only 10 per million.”
Most entrepreneurs pursue the question 'How can I succeed?', whereas Packard pursued 'What can we contribute?' from day one, and that orientation produced HP's extraordinary success.
“Most entrepreneurs pursue the question, 'How can I succeed?' From day 1, Packard pursued a different question. 'What can we contribute?'”
A retired Wells Fargo engineer advised Packard that more businesses die from indigestion, meaning growing too fast and overextending, than from starvation, and Packard said he observed that truth many times afterward.
“He said that more businesses die from indigestion than starvation. I have observed the truth of that advice many times since then.”
Chuck House kept developing a display monitor after management told him to abandon it, showed prototypes to customers, and then persuaded his manager to rush it into production, leading to over 17,000 units and $35 million in sales; Packard distinguished this defiance from insubordination by intent.
“HP sold more than 17,000 display monitors, representing sales of $35 million for the company.”
Packard judged that the line between insubordination and entrepreneurship lies in intent; Chuck House said he was not trying to be defiant but wanted HP to succeed.
“To this young engineer's mind, the difference lay in the intent.”
Packard demanded performance from HP's people: customer satisfaction, second to none, was the only acceptable goal, and leaders who could not achieve it would be replaced.
“Customer satisfaction, second to none, is the only acceptable goal, admonished David Packard.”
Packard rejected the idea that a company exists simply to make money; profit is an important result, but the real test is whether a company's products offer something unique and improve people's lives, and if not, the company is a failure even if it is profitable.
“I think many people assume wrongly that a company exists simply to make money”
HP would not be a me-too company that merely copied products already on the market, and Packard insisted every new business should be differentiated, even if it is not big on the day it is born.
“Bill and I knew we did not want to be a me-too company, merely copying products already on the market.”
Quality gains come from meticulous attention to detail, with every manufacturing step done as carefully as possible rather than as quickly as possible, and this requires the whole organization to be dedicated to quality.
“Gains in quality come from meticulous attention to detail, and every step in the manufacturing process must be done as carefully as possible, not as quickly as possible.”
Success enabled HP to invest more in contributing, which produced greater success, which led to increased contribution, creating a self-reinforcing cycle that eventually let Packard and Hewlett give far more to society than they had imagined as young men.
“This success, in turn, enabled them to invest more in making a contribution, which produced even greater success”
At the start of an industry you cannot predict how large it will become, so you should follow your own intense interest rather than the advice of incumbents who see no future in it.
“at the beginning of industries or markets, you can't possibly predict how large they're going to be.”
According to Packard, HP was profitable from its first year and remained profitable every year for 50 years afterward.
“HP was profitable from the very first year, and it was profitable every year for 50 years after that.”
Packard's grade-school decision to become an engineer, narrowed to electrical engineering through interest in radio, led him to Stanford, where his pursuit of radio led to the founding of HP.
“I had decided as far back as grade school that I wanted to be an engineer.”
Packard argued that good new products are the lifeblood of technical companies, so innovation cannot be deferred to protect short-term profits.
“Good new products are the lifeblood of technical companies.”
Michael Malone described David Packard as setting the ultimate Silicon Valley career standard: founding a garage company, growing it into an industry leader, taking it public, reaching the Fortune 50, becoming an industry spokesman, going to Washington, and becoming a global figure.
“Only Packard had accomplished all of this. He set the bar, and the Valley had honored his achievement by making him the unofficial mayor of Silicon Valley.”
In 1995 Packard was told at a Stanford dinner that he and Hewlett had donated, on a present value basis, as much to Stanford as Jane and Leland Stanford had given to fund the university.
“The Dean of Engineering mentioned to Packard that he and Hewlett had donated, on a present value basis, as much to Stanford as Jane and Leland Stanford had given to fund the university.”
Packard and Hewlett flipped a coin to decide whether the company would be called Packard-Hewlett or Hewlett-Packard, and Hewlett won.
“We flipped the coin to see whose name would come first in the company, needless to say, Bill won.”
HP's first product, the Model 200A audio oscillator, was named with a 200 designation to make the company look established, though its founders had never finished a product; it was the first practical low-cost method of generating high-quality audio frequencies.
“We designated this first product to Model 200A because we thought that the name would make it look like we had been around for a while.”
Terman observed that most successful early radio firms were built by people without much education, and concluded that business opportunities would be greater for someone with a sound theoretical background in the field.
“Adding that business opportunities would likely be greater for someone with sound theoretical background in the field.”
Even while selling to the government during WWII, HP kept costs controlled to the point that the government could not get better products from anyone else at a lower price, and it asked the Naval Research Laboratory what else it needed.
“We've controlled our costs to the extent that the government could not get better products from anyone else at a lower price.”
Looking back, events that seemed unimportant at the time, such as admission to Stanford and meeting key people there, had profound effects on shaping business and professional careers.
“seemingly unimportant at that time, had a profound effect in shaping our business and our professional careers.”
Packard developed his interest in electronics early by reading the family World Book encyclopedia and building small-scale models of railroads, bridges, motors, and generators in the backyard, a pattern the host notes also appears in Bill Gates's childhood.
“Even as a young child, I spent hours curled up with the family World Book encyclopedia.”
Charlie Litton, though a competitor, let HP use his shop for production and invited Packard to seminars, treating them as compatriots and believing that competitors should share ideas.
“He never saw us as competitors, but always as compatriots.”
Packard found that moving cattle through a gate worked best with steady, gentle pressure from behind, since pressing too hard causes panic and easing off lets them drift back, and he said this insight stayed useful throughout his management career.
“applying steady, gentle pressure from the rear worked best”
Packard predicted that the 21st century will see greater growth than the 20th because growth is proportional to the effort expended, and that future growth will come from new products that make real technological contributions rather than copies of others' work.
“Exponential growth is based on the principle that the state of change is proportional to the level of effort expended.”
The host observed that American founders around World War II did not believe they had limits on what they could do or learn, and often did things themselves, as shown by Charlie Litton excavating his plant site with a bulldozer that Packard later learned to operate.
“Charlie was able to do everything better than anyone else. When he wanted to build a new plant, he didn't hire a contractor to do the excavating.”
Coach Porter told Packard that when two teams have equally good players, teamwork and the team with the strongest will to win prevail, and Packard applied this to hiring the best people, stressing teamwork, and getting them fired up at HP.
“Given equally good players and good teamwork, the team with the strongest will to win will prevail.”
At age 11, Packard's father bought him a bucking horse and refused to let him quit, teaching persistence; the host reads this as Packard's preferred teaching method of telling anecdotes from which lessons are inferred.
“My father wouldn't let me quit, however. So I finally learned how to handle the horse.”
HP named its first product the Model 200A because the number made the young company look like it had been around for a while, since they feared buyers would be scared off if they knew they had never built a finished product.
“We designated this first product to Model 200A because we thought that the name would make it look like we had been around for a while.”
Ken Olsen, founder of Digital Equipment Corporation, described the older scientists he met in the late 1940s as blowing their own glass, machining their own parts, and building radar and the atomic bomb, a self-reliance that shaped the founder generation.
“These older generation scientists blew their own glass. They did their own machining. They made their own parts.”
Packard recalled feeling as a Stanford sophomore that he was born 100 years too late because all frontiers had been conquered, but he later saw the 20th century bring breathtaking advances, a lesson he applied to his own generation.
“I remember lamenting that I had been born 100 years too late that all the frontiers had been conquered”
Packard's wife Lucile recalled that mailing his GE resignation letter cut the family's financial ties, and they felt hopeful and excited despite the risk.
“Mailing that letter cut our financial ties, but we were hopeful and excited about what the future had in store.”
The founding group held its first official business meeting, with tentative organization plans, before deciding what products to make, and they set up in Hewlett's garage without a defined product.
“we started a company before we knew what product we wanted to make.”
Packard conveys business lessons through small personal anecdotes, such as horse riding, ranching, and sports, and the reader must infer the principle from each story.
“He's going to tell you these old stories, those little anecdotes. And from there, you'll infer the lessons that he's trying to impart to you.”
Founder autobiographies like Packard's are written to pass lessons from decades of experience to future entrepreneurs, and the host sees this documentation impulse repeated across at least 20 episodes of the Founders archive.
“There's at least 20 episodes in the Founders' archive where you'll find the exact same thing.”
Edwin Land did not want to waste his powers on me-too products, a stance the host sees as the same thinking Packard and Hewlett held when building HP.
“Edwin Land clearly did not wish to waste his powers on me-too products.”
The host argues that Packard's introduction, centered on obsessing over customers and asking what products offer something unique, is essentially the same message Jeff Bezos repeats in his shareholder letters.
“That's the exact same message that David Packard is writing in that introduction.”
Packard kept his own salary lower than it should have been because he thought it unfair for it to exceed Bill Hewlett's army salary during the war.
“I kept my salary at a lower level than it should have been because I did not think it was fair for my salary to be higher than Bill's army salary.”
The host argues that founder biographies form one continuing conversation about entrepreneurship, with figures like Ken Olsen, Edwin Land, Packard, and Jobs quoting, influencing, and referencing one another.
“This is why I think about founders just as one giant conversation you and I are having on the history of entrepreneurship”
The host observes that many company founders built bombs or experimented with explosives as youths, citing Packard and Hewlett and Peter Thiel's claim that four of PayPal's six founders built bombs in high school.
“He says, of the 6 people who started PayPal, 4 had built bombs in high school.”