#29 The HP Way: How Bill Hewlett and I Built Our Company
What this covers
This Founders episode has Senra working through David Packard's memoir of building Hewlett-Packard with Bill Hewlett, alternating long passages from the book with his own commentary. It begins with Humble Beginnings: an audio oscillator named Model 200A so the company would look established, a two-page brochure sent to about 25 prospects, and a first full year in 1939 with $5,369 in sales and $1,563 in profit. Packard's 1934 stint at GE, where a manager named Mr. Boring told him electronics had no future, appears as an irony.
The middle of the episode covers several distinct areas. On finance, Packard traces his aversion to long-term debt to reviewing bankrupt firms with his father, and a banker's warning about Indigestion vs Starvation. The 1970 shared-pay-cut schedule that avoided layoffs shows what that caution bought. On strategy, HP turned down large wartime contracts outside its competence. On management, there is the cattle-herd lesson about steady, gentle pressure, and the story of Chuck House, who defied orders to keep building a display monitor and later received a medal for defiance.
The darkest turn is the 1990 bureaucracy. HP's move into computers brought IBM-style centralization and layers of committees, which slowed decisions even in units with no computer link. Senra also leaves the book. He ties Packard's views on debt to the late-2000s real estate collapse, a claim marked as contested. He also argues, through Steve Eisman's verdict on Ken Lewis, that credentials say little about who understands a subject.
Packard's account of HP argues that durable company success came from treating profit as the measure of customer value, self-financing without debt, staying focused on complementary products, and decentralizing decisions, and that these management principles, not luck, are the transferable lessons of The HP Way.
- Profit is the measure of value added to customers and resources, so a company that cannot earn it cannot meet its other objectives.
- Avoiding long-term debt let HP survive downturns that destroyed leveraged firms, and the 1970 work-sharing plan avoided layoffs.
- The 1990 crisis came from committee bureaucracy, and recovery came from removing management layers and giving units autonomy.
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The computer business is a systems business that requires software, mainframes, peripherals, operating systems, and strong service combined into a salable product, so good coordination is essential, unlike instruments.
“the computer business is a systems business. It requires many elements: software, mainframes, peripherals, operating systems, to be combined in a salable product supported by strong service and maintenance.”
Packard reports that while helping his father, a bankruptcy referee, review bankrupt companies in the 1930s, he saw that banks foreclosed on firms that had mortgaged assets, while firms that borrowed nothing kept their assets and survived, so he decided HP should incur no long-term debt.
“I noted that the banks simply foreclose on firms that mortgage their assets, and these firms were left with nothing. Those firms that did not borrow money had a difficult time, but they ended up with their assets intact and survived during the depression years that followed.”
Packard argues that in a technical business, where progress is rapid, an organization must maintain a continuing education program and select the most capable people for each assignment, because techniques relevant today will be outdated in the future.
“A continuing program of education must be undertaken and maintained. Techniques that are relevant today will be outdated in the future.”
As HP moved into computers in the 1970s, many managers modeled the company on IBM's highly centralized structure, while the computer business's new software demands and need for integrated systems led HP to layer divisions, task forces and committees, which over time created a complicated bureaucracy.
“Over time, these efforts began to create a complicated bureaucracy.”
Professor Frederick Terman encouraged Packard to take a 1934 General Electric job during the Depression, arguing he would learn things useful to their own venture, and at GE a manager named Boring advised that electronics had no future and that Packard should focus on heavy components, advice Packard later found ironic because HP grew larger than GE had been at the time.
“I have often thought of the irony of Mr. Boring's advice because our electric firm, Hewlett-Packard Company, has become larger than the entire General Electric Company was at the time he gave me the advice.”
HP's first full year in business, 1939, produced sales of $5,369 and profit of $1,563, and the company showed a profit every year afterward.
“At the end of 1939, our first full year in business, our sales totaled $5,369, and we had made $1,563 in profits. We would show a profit every year thereafter.”
HP's first product was Hewlett's audio oscillator, which the founders presented at an IRE conference in Portland and then promoted with a two-page brochure sent to about 25 potential customers, yielding several orders accompanied by checks in January.
“We weren't expecting much from our first mailing, but amazingly enough, in the first couple of weeks of January came back several orders and some were accompanied by checks.”
A banker advised Packard that more businesses die from indigestion than starvation, which Packard interpreted as a warning against taking on more debt than a company can digest, and he observed the truth of this many times afterward.
“He said that more businesses die from indigestion than starvation. I have observed that truth -- the truth of that advice many times since then.”
Steve Eisman found that Bank of America CEO Ken Lewis did not understand his bank's balance sheet or risks, and Eisman's group shorted Bank of America along with UBS, Citigroup, and Lehman Brothers.
“Once, he got himself invited to a meeting with the CEO of Bank of America, Ken Lewis. I was sitting there listening to him. I had an epiphany.”
The host argues that during the late-2000s real estate downturn, highly leveraged real estate speculators lost nearly everything, while non-speculators who did not panic largely recovered their wealth, mirroring Packard's observation about debt.
“I think you could say the same thing about people that were highly leveraged in real estate, and you saw the detriment that, that did. That most of them blew up and lost everything”
Profit is the difference between what customers pay and the cost of producing and distributing a product, and it represents the value the company adds to the people, materials, facilities, money and time it uses.
“This difference, our profit, represents the value we add to the resources we utilize.”
Packard argues that employees who leave to start their own companies should be celebrated rather than resented, noting that at least a dozen former HP people built firms employing more than 40,000 people and adopted HP management principles.
“Are we upset that they left us? On the contrary, Bill and I understand and respect the entrepreneurial spirit”
Packard named the audio oscillator Model 200A because the name would make HP look like it had been around for a while, since they feared buyers would be put off if they knew the company had never built a finished product.
“We were afraid that if people knew we'd never actually developed, designed, and built a finished product, they'd be scared off.”
The host argues that people rely on credentials such as schools, CEO titles and law partnerships as heuristics for knowing who understands a subject, but in practice almost nobody knows what they are talking about, as shown by Steve Eisman's finding that Ken Lewis of Bank of America did not understand his own balance sheet before a multibillion-dollar loss.
“And then you realize that almost nobody knows what they're talking about.”
Packard learned from cattle ranching that applying steady, gentle pressure from behind works best for moving a herd through a gate, because pressing too hard causes panic and scattering while easing off lets the herd drift back, and this insight proved useful throughout his management career.
“I found after much trial and error that applying steady, gentle pressure from the rear worked best. Press them too hard, and they panic, scattering in all directions. Slack off entirely and they just head back to their old grazing spots.”
During a 1970 downturn, HP avoided a planned 10 percent layoff by moving everyone to a nine-days-in-two-weeks schedule with a 10 percent cut in pay, applying to factories, executives and staff, and when orders recovered within six months everyone returned to full schedules, so the burden was shared and qualified workers stayed in place.
“We went to a schedule of working 9 days out of every 2 weeks, a 10% cut in the work schedule with a corresponding 10% cut and pay.”
Packard argued in a 1960 managers' speech that profit is the measure of a company's contribution to customers, because it is the amount customers are willing to pay above the actual cost of an instrument, and if customers will not pay, the company's work is futile.
“Profit is the measure of our contribution to our customers. It is a measure of what our customers are willing to pay us over and above the actual cost of an instrument.”
Bill Hewlett and David Packard systematically visited several HP facilities and met employees at all levels to learn what was really happening before deciding what to change.
“Bill and I began systematically visiting several HP facilities and meeting with employees at all levels of the organization to find out what really was going on.”
During World War II HP declined large production contracts that lay outside its capabilities and would not be sustainable, preferring to build a solid base by doing what it did best, and Packard believed the decision to focus on complementary products was extremely important throughout the company's history.
“I believe this decision to focus our efforts was extremely important, not only in the early days of the company, but later on as well.”
Packard defines company culture as the combination of an organization's values, corporate objectives, plans and practices, which together form The HP Way, with the values built into the objectives that guide daily decisions.
“It is the combination of these elements, our values, corporate objectives, plans and practices that forms The HP Way.”
Packard observes that most business executives praise decentralization but resist giving up authority in their own organizations, and that even decentralized companies must watch for creeping centralization.
“It has been my experience that most business executives are quick to praise the concept of decentralization. But when it comes to their own organization, many are reluctant to adopt.”
Packard argues that in early stages the founders had to handle every function, from invention and pricing to shipping, bookkeeping, ad writing and sweeping floors, and that the lessons learned this way were invaluable and not found in business books.
“Many of the things I learned in this process were invaluable and not available in business books.”
Engineer Chuck House continued developing a display monitor after management asked for it to be discontinued, by showing a prototype to potential customers who responded positively, and the resulting monitor sold more than 17,000 units for $35 million in revenue; Packard later awarded him a medal for defiance.
“as it turned out, HP sold more than 17,000 display monitors, representing sales revenue of $35 million to the company.”
By 1990 committees had taken over HP's decision-making, decision cycle times had ballooned, and the Computer Business Executive Committee slowed vital decisions just as the company entered the fast computer market, while paralysis spread to units with no computer connection.
“By 1990, we faced a crisis. Committees had taken over the decision-making process at HP and decision cycle times had ballooned.”
Profit is the final measure of how well people work together, because if the company cannot do the work that customers will pay for, the collective effort is futile.
“So profit is the measure of how well we work together. It is really the final measure because, if we cannot do these things so the customer will pay us, our work is futile.”
After visiting facilities and talking to employees at all levels, Packard and Hewlett removed layers of management, disbanded the Computer Business Executive Committee and much of the bureaucracy, and gave computer operating units freedom to make their own plans, after which HP stock rose from $25 to $70 a share by 1993.
“Too many layers of management had been built into the organization. We reduced them.”
Packard argues that exponential growth depends on effort, so the 21st century will require far more effort than the 20th, and HP's trajectory illustrates this: it took about 40 years from 1939 to reach $1 billion in annual sales, a large part of which reflected inflation.
“Exponential growth is based on the principle that the state of change is proportional to the level of effort expended.”
Packard argues that HP's growth must come from new products that make real contributions to technology rather than copies of what others have done, and that this standard has applied in the past and must apply in the future.
“By new products, I mean products that make real contributions to technology, not products that copy what someone else has done.”
The host argues that in a mass speculative frenzy, roughly 100 or fewer contrarian thinkers who reason from first principles can profit enormously because they see the error and put their money behind it, as the characters in The Big Short did.
“there was about 100 people or less that profited handsomely off of the mass solution that everybody was engaging.”
Packard reports that he and Bill Hewlett discovered their abilities were complementary, with Hewlett stronger in circuit technology and Packard stronger in manufacturing and machine process, and this combination was especially useful for designing and manufacturing electronic products.
“Bill was better trained in circuit technology, and I was better trained and more experienced in manufacturing machine process.”
Packard and Hewlett chose to finance growth from earnings rather than borrowing, reasoning that General Radio, which they admired, had grown successfully for years without outside financing, so HP could do the same.
“We knew self-financing was possible because General Radio, a company we admired had been in business several years had been successful, and had never sought outside financing.”
In fiscal 1994 HP began the year with $20 billion in worldwide sales, added $5 billion by year end with essentially no inflation, and spent $2 billion on new product development, and since 1939 it generated at least $6 of profit over five or six years for every dollar spent on new product development.
“Beginning by 1939, we generated at least $6 of profit spread over 5 or 6 years for every dollar spent on new product development.”
Packard argues that a business cannot operate for long without generating profit, so any other corporate objective requires profit first.
“It is impossible to operate a business for long unless it generates a profit. And so if a company is to meet any of its other objectives, it must make a profit.”
The host argues that large companies like HP look inevitable in hindsight, but they started with one product mailed to about 25 people, so beginnings are always humble and everything starts small, as Jeff Bezos's acorn-to-oak comparison expresses.
“the beginnings are always humble. Everything starts small.”
HP grew rapidly during World War II because military services and defense contractors bought its test equipment, reaching annual sales of about $1 million and employing over 200 people by the war's end.
“Our annual sales volume moved up to $1 million very quickly. And by the end of the war, we employed over 200 people.”
The host argues that books are the original hyperlinks because they lead readers from one idea to another, or from one person to another, allowing deeper exploration of a subject.
“books are the original hyperlinks. That they can lead you from one idea to another idea or from one person to another person”
Packard and Hewlett flipped a coin to determine whose name would come first in the company name, and Hewlett won.
“We flip coin to see whose name would come first in the company. Needless to say, Bill won.”
The host argues that in the biographies of founders he reads, the founders are repeatedly told by others that what they are doing is a waste of time before they succeed, so critics should be discounted, and he calls this pattern critics don't know.
“There's multiple examples of before they were successful, what they were trying to do. Other people trying to tell them that what they were doing is a waste of time.”
The host argues that podcasts are valuable because they let listeners sit in on conversations they could not otherwise access, and he compares this to the 1938 Charlie Litton seminars that only attendees could hear.
“it allows you to be like a fly on the wall in some conversations that you may not otherwise be able to access in your day-to-day life.”
Packard reports that Charlie Litton held seminars in his shop during 1938 on physics and business philosophy, and that Litton's conservative view on supporting the company and paying bills taught Packard a great deal about running a business.
“As eccentric as he was, he knew you had to support your company and pay your bills. I learned a lot about running a business from those conversations.”
Packard emphasizes that relationships are central to business, and that he and Hewlett undertook activities to understand each other and become a more cohesive unit despite different personalities.
“he talks a lot about managing different personalities stuff. But this part, he talks about the benefits of being different”
Packard predicts that the 21st century will be much more than an information age, becoming an age in which many kinds of new products improve life for people around the world.
“The 21st century, however, will be much more than an information age. It will be an age in which many kinds of new products contribute to a better life for all the people in the world.”
Senra suggests the coordination challenges Packard described in HP's shift to computers are exactly what made Apple so successful.
“I think what he's describing in that paragraph is exactly what made Apple so successful.”
The host observes that HP has struggled over the 10 to 15 years since its founders died and no longer ran the company, despite the scale it reached under them.
“even though they've really struggled the last like 10, 15 years since the founders died and they're no longer in charge”
Blinkist offers 15-minute summaries of nonfiction books and is available at blinkist.com/founders for a discount.
“you can get 20% off and start learning faster today.”
The host asks listeners to leave a five-star rating and review on Apple Podcasts so the show reaches more people.
“please go to Apple Podcast or iTunes and leave a 5-star rating.”