#306 David Ogilvy (Confessions of an Advertising Man)
What this covers
In this episode Senra works through David Ogilvy's Confessions of an Advertising Man, which Ogilvy wrote in the summer of 1962 to attract clients, prepare the market for a public offering of agency shares, and raise his profile. He expected to sell 4,000 copies and sold over a million. Senra reads it as much as a management book as an advertising one, and spends time on how a company's maxims, repeated until they are woven into Corporate Culture, shape behavior.
The craft material is concrete and often contested. Ogilvy treats an audience as a moving parade, not a standing army, so a good ad can be reused for years. His Hathaway campaign ran 21 years and his Dove campaign 31. He argues that the headline carries most of the work, that he writes at least 16 for each ad, and that long, benefit-led headlines outsell short ones. He also holds that the more you tell, the more you sell, as in his fact-only Rolls-Royce ads. Editorial technique, backed by a line from James Dyson, is offered as a model.
The remaining ground is people and process. Ogilvy wants nonconformists and difficult talent, the idea behind Tolerate Genius, and he admits he relies on incubation rather than logic. Senra highlights the excess homework behind the Rolls-Royce clock headline and the pursuit of Shell's president. Other threads include Jerry Lambert's monthly profit reviews at Listerine, the claim that only five agencies are truly excellent, blunt feedback from founders, and Ogilvy's advice to become the best-informed person on your account.
Senra argues that Ogilvy's Confessions of an Advertising Man is best read as a playbook for building a formidable, excellence-driven business: hire talented nonconformists, do more homework than competitors, sell with facts and repeatable headlines, and let a strong founder's standards shape the culture.
- Ogilvy's maxims (we sell or else, tolerate genius, the moving parade) are compressed, memorable rules that spread through the organization
- Ogilvy's success came from outworking rivals, such as the Shell pursuit and the Listerine research, not from luck or credentials
- Great companies are the lengthened shadow of a single formidable individual, so founder standards determine culture
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Advertisers should treat their audience as a moving parade, not a standing army: three million people marry each year, so an ad that sold a refrigerator to newlyweds last year still works on the next year's newlyweds.
“You are not advertising to a standing army. You are advertising to a moving parade. Three million customers get married every year.”
The key to success is to promise the consumer a benefit, such as better flavor, wider wash, more miles per gallon, or a better complexion.
“The key to success is to promise the consumer a benefit, like better flavor, wider wash, more miles per gallon.”
Companies that deliberately cultivate their identity by shaping values, creating heroes, spelling out rites and rituals, and acknowledging their cultural network have an edge, and Ogilvy & Mather's maxims became woven into its culture through repetition.
“Companies that have cultivated their individual identities by shaping values, making heroes, spelling out rights and rituals, and acknowledging the cultural network have an edge.”
Talent is most likely to be found among nonconformists, dissenters, and rebels, and organizations run by committees and smooth caretakers cannot create potent campaigns.
“Talent, I believe, is most likely to be found among nonconformists, dissenters, and rebels.”
Jerry Lambert sped up Listerine marketing by reviewing advertising and profits monthly rather than locking into annual plans, and made $25 million in eight years; most big corporations fail to treat profit as a function of time.
“Instead of locking himself into annual plans, Lambert reviewed his advertising and his profits every month. The result was that he made $25 million in 8 years.”
Ogilvy wrote Confessions of an Advertising Man in summer 1962 with three goals: attract new clients, condition the market for a public offering of agency shares, and raise his profile in business. He expected 4,000 copies and it sold over 1 million.
“First, to attract new clients to my advertising agency. Second, to condition the market for a public offering of our shares. Third, to make myself better known in the business world. It achieved all 3 of these purposes.”
Ogilvy's rule that the more facts you give the more you sell: very few advertisements contain enough factual information, and his Rolls-Royce ads that gave only facts, with no adjectives or gracious living, sold well because consumers want information.
“The more you tell, the more you sell. Give facts. Very few advertisements contain enough factual information to sell the product.”
Ogilvy says he is almost incapable of logical thought and instead keeps a line open to his unconscious through rest, baths, gardening, music, and vacations, so his brain can lie fallow and send him raw material for advertisements.
“I have developed techniques for keeping open the telephone line to my unconscious in case that disorderly repository has anything to tell me.”
The difference between one advertisement and another, measured in sales, can be as much as 19 to 1, which is why advertising craft matters so much.
“The difference between one advertisement and another when measured in terms of sales can be as much as 19:1.”
A change of headline can make a difference of 10:1 in sales, which is why Ogilvy never writes fewer than 16 headlines for a single advertisement.
“A change of headline can make a difference of 10:1 in sales. I never write fewer than 16 headlines for a single advertisement.”
If you write a good advertisement, repeat it until it stops pulling, because many good advertisements were discarded before they lost their potency.
“If you're lucky enough to write a good advertisement, repeat it until it stops pulling. Scores of good advertisements have been discarded before they lost their potency.”
Every headline should appeal to the customer's self-interest and promise a benefit, and headlines of around 10 words or more consistently sold more merchandise than short headlines, so selling promises require long headlines.
“Include your selling promise in your headline. This requires long headlines. Research has found that headlines of 10 words are longer consistently sold more merchandise than short headlines.”
The headline is the most important element in an advertisement, since five times as many people read the headline as read the body copy, so spending on the headline is spending about 80 cents of every advertising dollar.
“The headline is the most important element in advertisements. 5 times as many people read the headline as read the body copy.”
Editors of magazines are better communicators than advertising people, so advertisers should copy editorial techniques; James Dyson likewise said one great editorial is worth 1,000 advertisements.
“Editors of magazines are better communicators than advertising people. Copy their techniques.”
The most talented people are usually highly disagreeable mavericks and nonconformists, so organizations must tolerate their difficult personalities rather than destroy them, since 'they lay golden eggs.'
“My observation has been that mediocre men recognize genius, resent it and feel compelled to destroy it. There are very few men of genius, but we need all we can find. Almost without exception, they are disagreeable. Do not destroy them. They lay golden eggs.”
Ogilvy's best headline, 'At 60 miles an hour, the loudest noise in the new Rolls-Royce comes from the electric clock,' came from reading an internal Rolls-Royce engineering document that few others would bother to read, showing that extra research creates advertising advantage.
“At 60 miles an hour, the loudest noise in the new Rolls-Royce comes from the electric clock.”
Clients who haggle over agency compensation are looking through the wrong end of the telescope; shaving cents off the agency's 15 percent fee ignores the 85 percent spent on media, where the leverage lies, so pay peanuts and you get monkeys.
“Instead of trying to shave a few measly cents off the agency's 15%, they should concentrate on getting more sales results from their 85% that they spend on time and space. That is where the leverage is.”
Good campaigns can run for many years without losing selling power; Ogilvy's eye patch campaign for Hathaway shirts ran 21 years and his Dove soap campaign ran 31 years and was still a bestseller.
“Good campaigns can run for many years without losing their selling power. My eye patch campaign for Hathaway shirts ran for 21 years.”
Ogilvy's success or failure as agency head depends above all on finding people who can create great campaigns, people with fire in their bellies, and he stresses tolerating genius because the most talented people are often disagreeable.
“My success or failure at the head of this agency depends more than anything else on my ability to find people who can create great campaigns, people with fire in their bellies.”
Ogilvy flew to London to chase Shell's president, Max Burns, after the questionnaire was sent to him, and after 10 days of silence he sent a signal that he was lunching with the Secretary of State for Scotland, which got a lunch invitation; in-person candor on the way to lunch helped win the account.
“So I flew to London and left a message at this hotel saying that I wanted to see him.”
Ogilvy claims there are perhaps 1,000 good agencies, 15 great agencies, and 5 truly excellent agencies, so setting high standards and doing work others won't do reduces competition and lets a firm stand out.
“There might be 1,000 good agencies in the world. There might be 15 great agencies in the world. There might be 5 truly excellent agencies in the world.”
Steve Jobs argued that as teams grow it is too easy to tolerate a few B players, who attract more B players until C players appear, and that A players will only work with other A players, so B players cannot be indulged.
“It's too easy, as your team grows, to put up with a few B players. And then they attract a few more B players. And soon, you will even have some C players.”
The business community wants remarkable advertising but turns a cold shoulder to the nonconformist people who produce it, which is why most advertisements are so dull: they are made by dull people.
“The business community wants remarkable advertising but turns a cold shoulder to the kind of people who can produce it.”
No creative organization, whether a research laboratory, magazine, kitchen, or advertising agency, will produce a great body of work unless it is led by a formidable individual, and great creators are rarely bland.
“I have observed that no creative organization, whether it is a research laboratory, a magazine, a parish kitchen, an advertising agency, will produce a great body of work unless it is led by a formidable individual.”
Founders should say plainly when work falls short, explaining exactly what is inadequate and asking for another attempt, rather than pussyfooting, because vague feedback leaves teams guessing.
“Disastrous consequences can arise when a founder pussyfoots in his day-to-day dealings with his business. It is better to say, what you've just shown me is not up to your usual high standard.”
Ogilvy claims that next to luck, midnight oil is the best weapon in hunting new business, and that a less self-promotional approach would have taken him 20 years to arrive, which he could not afford.
“Next to luck, midnight oil is the best weapon to use in hunting new business.”
Ogilvy declines to preside over a vast bureaucracy and kept his agency to 19 clients, reasoning that the pursuit of excellence is less profitable than bigness but can be more satisfying.
“I have no ambition to preside over a vast bureaucracy. That is why we only have 19 clients. The pursuit of excellence is less profitable than the pursuit of bigness, but it can be more satisfying.”
Ogilvy concludes that the top person in an organization has one principal responsibility: provide an atmosphere in which creative mavericks can do useful work.
“I've come to the conclusion that the top man has one principal responsibility, to provide an atmosphere in which creative mavericks can do useful work.”
In a great kitchen, one must always honor what one has promised on the menu, and Ogilvy applied this by refusing to accept an agency failing to deliver an advertisement on the promised date, saying promises are kept whatever it costs in agony and overtime.
“In the best establishments, promises are always kept, whatever it may cost in agony and overtime.”
Ogilvy claims that the most rewarding brains to pick are those of predecessors and competitors, and that studying successful campaigns is how he learned, while advertising agencies that repeat known mistakes are ignorant amateurs.
“I am an inveterate brain picker, and the most rewarding brains I've picked are the brains of my predecessors and of my competitors.”
Advertising agencies keep wasting clients' money by repeating mistakes that were discovered in years gone by, so copywriters and art directors who ignore prior principles are ignorant amateurs, and Ogilvy asks whether they fear knowledge would impose discipline or expose their incompetence.
“Most of them violated elementary principles, which were discovered in years gone by. The copywriters and art directors who created them are ignorant amateurs.”
Mediocre men recognize genius, resent it, and feel compelled to destroy it; there are very few men of genius, almost all are disagreeable, and organizations should not destroy them because they lay golden eggs.
“My observation has been that mediocre men recognize genius, resent it and feel compelled to destroy it.”
Ogilvy's careermanship formula: become the best-informed person on your assigned account by reading textbooks, trade journals, research, and spending time with customers, so that by year two you know more than your boss and are ready to succeed him.
“Set yourself to becoming the best-informed man in your agency on the account to which you are assigned.”
Unless a campaign contains a big idea it will pass like a ship in the night, and Ogilvy doubted more than one campaign in 100 contains one; in his own long career he had not had more than 20.
“Number six, unless your campaign contains a big idea, it will pass like a ship in the night. I doubt if more than one campaign in 100 contains a big idea.”
Ogilvy won the Seagram account by sending useful progress reports and a 16-page speech to Sam Bronfman, who replayed the last two paragraphs back to him, showing that giving valuable information to prospects beats self-promotion.
“Sam Bronfman played back to me the last two paragraphs of a 16-page speech that I had sent him shortly before, and he hired us.”
With no money and no reputation, Ogilvy's client acquisition had to be outbound: he solicited companies without agencies, sent progress reports to 600 people, and made a list of five blue-chip clients, all of which eventually became clients.
“I sent frequent progress reports to 600 people in every walk of life.”
Most campaigns are too complicated because they try to reconcile too many executives' views and objectives, and by covering too many things they achieve nothing, so their ads look like committee minutes.
“Most campaigns are too complicated. They reflect a long list of objectives and try to reconcile the diversion views of too many executives. By attempting to cover too many things, they achieve nothing.”
Ogilvy hires 'gentlemen with brains' and insists that brains must be paired with intellectual honesty, because brilliance without integrity breeds politics and damage.
“I admire people with first-class brains, because you cannot run a great advertising agency or a great company without brainy people. But brains are not enough unless they are combined with intellectual honesty.”
Ogilvy argues that hard work has an economic logic: the harder people work, the fewer employees are needed and the more profit results, which then makes more money available to everyone.
“There is an economic factor built into hard work. The harder you work, the fewer employees we need and the more profit we make.”
Good leaders hire subordinates good enough to succeed them, and build up subordinates so the firm can promote internally rather than hiring outside, while insecure leaders who hire inferiors deserve pity.
“I admire people who build up their subordinates because that is the only way we can promote from within the ranks. I detest having to go outside to fill important jobs”
Ogilvy stayed up overnight drafting Shell's questionnaire with answers more candid than customary, believing that candor would differentiate him from the agencies that filled in conventional answers.
“I stayed up all-night drafting answers to the Shell questionnaire. My answers were more candid than is customary.”
Ogilvy modeled his management on head chef Pitard at the Hotel Majestic, who ruled with an iron rod, praised very seldom so praise was exalting, and did not tolerate incompetence because it demoralizes professionals.
“I have always believed that if I could understand how Pitard, the head chef, inspired such white-hot morale, I could apply the same kind of leadership to the management of my advertising agency.”
Agencies should pursue knowledge the way a pig pursues truffles: a blind pig can sometimes find truffles, but it helps to know they grow in oak forests, meaning curiosity should be guided by knowing where valuable knowledge lives.
“We pursue knowledge the way a pig pursues truffles. A blind pig can sometimes find truffles, but it helps to know that they grow in oak forests.”
When selling something new you cannot mix messages, because a consumer can barely handle one great new idea, let alone two or several.
“You simply cannot mix your messages when selling something new. A consumer can barely handle one great new idea, let alone two or even several.”
The most important job in advertising is deciding what you are going to say about your product and what benefit you are going to promise, and Ogilvy considers this the most important sentence in Ogilvy on Advertising.
“Your most important job is to decide what you are going to say about your product, what benefit you are going to promise.”
Managing an advertising agency is like managing any creative organization such as a research laboratory, magazine, architect's office or great kitchen, so lessons from a master chef apply broadly to leadership.
“Managing an advertising agency is like managing any other creative organization, a research laboratory, a magazine, an architect's office or a great kitchen.”
Ogilvy's first maxim is 'We sell or else,' and he insists advertising is judged by sales results, not by awards or entertainment value.
“We're not here to win awards, we're here to sell products for our customers”
Great creators are cantankerous egotists, and Winston Churchill, who drank heavily, sulked, and was inconsiderate to staff, was nonetheless described by his Chief of Staff Lord Alanbrooke as one of the supermen who occasionally exist on earth.
“Few of the great creators have bland personalities. They are cantankerous egotists... Consider Winston Churchill. He drank like a fish.”
You cannot bore people into buying your product; you can only interest them in buying it, so advertising must earn attention before it can persuade.
“you cannot bore people into buying your product. You can only interest them in buying it.”
Ogilvy's 1962 book did not discuss corporate culture because the concept was not yet known; it was popularized later by business researchers Terrence Deal and Allan Kennedy.
“In 1962, I had never heard of corporate culture nor had anybody else.”
Teamwork in advertising is bunk and a conspiracy of the mediocre majority; no ad, commercial, or image can be created by committee, though most top managers secretly know this.
“This emphasis on teamwork is bunk, a conspiracy of the mediocre majority. No ad, no commercial and no image can be created by committee.”
Ogilvy's maxim: never run an advertisement you would not want your own family to see, a personal ethics test for advertising.
“Number eight, never run an advertisement you would not want your own family to see.”
Creating successful advertising is a craft, part inspiration but mostly know-how and hard work; with modest talent and knowledge of which techniques work at the cash register, one can go a long way.
“Creating successful advertising is a craft. It's part inspiration, but mostly know-how and hard work.”
The temptation to entertain instead of selling is contagious, and advertisers should resist it because the purpose of advertising is to sell products.
“The temptation to entertain instead of selling is contagious.”
Established agencies tried to buy Ogilvy's agency because excellent founders recognize each other, and Ogilvy refused because he wanted to be a great man rather than work for one.
“Word got around that I was one of these rare birds, and it occurred to several of the big agencies that they should hire me even if they had to take my whole agency.”
It takes uncommon guts to stick to one style despite pressure to come up with something new every six months, because humans are obsessed with novelty and it is tragically easy to be stampeded into change.
“It takes uncommon guts to stick to one style in the face of all the pressures to 'come up with something new every 6 months.' It is tragically easy to be stampeded into change.”
When the agency grew to around 500 employees, Ogilvy gathered staff once a year to teach them the behaviors he admired and expected, and then stated what he expected of himself, which the speaker identifies as a form of company culture before the term was in use.
“So once a year, what he would do is he would gather everybody together, and he's just going to teach, teach, teach.”
Albert Lasker made around $50 million in advertising partly because he could stomach the atrocious manners of his great copywriters, who included Claude Hopkins.
“Albert Lasker made $50 million, partly because he could stomach the atrocious manners of his great copywriters”
What works in one country almost always works in other countries, so advertising principles are transferable across markets.
“What works in one country almost always works in other countries.”
Most modern copywriters write short, lazy advertisements because collecting facts is hard work, even though Claude Hopkins showed the value of facts about 50 years earlier.
“Claude Hopkins made the same discovery about advertising 50 years ago, but most modern copywriters find it easier to write short, lazy advertisements because collecting facts is hard work.”
Only a handful of people can preside over an agency's creative output, and these rare trumpeter swans must inspire talented people, judge campaigns across products, present and sell well, and have a colossal appetite for midnight oil.
“These rare trumpeter swans must be capable of inspiring a motley crew of talented people”
Ogilvy enforces an inviolable rule against employing nepotism or spouses, because family ties breed politics, and when two employees marry one must leave.
“I have an inviable rule against employing nepots and spouses because they breed politics. Whenever two of our people get married, one of them must depart.”
Steve Jobs said the most important business lesson was that the dynamic range of people dramatically exceeds other encounters in life, so you should find really great people who love what they do; Ogilvy expresses the same idea about needing people with fire in their bellies.
“That's been the most important lesson I've learned in business, that the dynamic range of people dramatically exceeds things you encounter in the rest of our normal lives”
Ogilvy's maxim 'You can't save souls in an empty church' argues that advertisements must be designed for people who want to read them, not as passive placements.
“We make advertisements that people want to read. You can't save souls in an empty church.”
The consumer is not a moron; she is your wife, and insulting her intelligence by offering vapid slogans and adjectives instead of information is a mistake, so advertisers should give consumers all the information they can.
“The consumer is not a moron. She is your wife. Don't insult her intelligence.”
Unconscious ideas are not enough on their own; creative output also requires hard work, an open mind, and an ungovernable curiosity.
“But more is required, hard work, an open mind, and an ungovernable curiosity.”
Because consumers are exposed to over 10,000 advertisements a year, ads must make sure people know the product name, repeating it ad nauseam throughout the commercial.
“The average consumer is subjected to over 10,000 advertisements a year. Make sure that she knows the name of the product being advertised in your commercial. Repeat it, ad nauseum throughout.”
A young staffer who assembled 177 pages of analysis on television, while the other agencies submitted 5 or 6 pages, was ridiculed by lazy colleagues but was elected to the Board of Directors a year later, showing how successful careers are built on isolated acts of diligence.
“a young man on my staff took the trouble to assemble every conceivable statistic... came up with an analysis, which covered 177 pages.”
Ogilvy holds that the best way to keep the peace inside an organization is candor, and he abhors quarrelsome people and paper warfare.
“I abhor quarrelsome people. I abhor people who engage in paper warfare. The best way to keep the peace is to be candid.”
Ogilvy's self-expectations include being fair and firm, planning policies far into the future, recruiting the highest-quality people at all levels, and landing new accounts, which together describe a founder's obligations.
“Number six, I plan our policies far into the future.”
Ogilvy says that if you do not enjoy your work you should find another job, since life is short, and he admires people who work with gusto.
“I admire people who work with gusto. If you don't enjoy what you're doing, I beg you to find another job.”
Ogilvy claims a single formidable individual is responsible for successful campaigns and that the fashion for teamwork is 'bunk, a conspiracy of the mediocre majority,' though he credits top managers for spotting individuals who lay golden eggs.
“This emphasis on teamwork is bunk, a conspiracy of the mediocre majority. No ad, no commercial and no image can be created by committee.”
Ads should include testimonials because readers believe fellow consumers more than anonymous copywriters, opening paragraphs should be at most 11 words, and all paragraphs should be as short as possible because long paragraphs fatigue readers.
“You should always include testimonials in your ad. Keep your opening paragraph down to a maximum of 11 words.”
Through repetition, Ogilvy's maxims such as 'we sell or else' were woven into Ogilvy & Mather's culture, and the head of a major agency told Ogilvy it was the only agency with a real corporate culture, which may differentiate it more than anything else.
“Through maddening repetition, some of my maxims have been woven into our culture.”
Ogilvy claims his self-regard is selective: he admits to being a miserable duffer at everything except advertising, where he considers himself the creative king.
“my conceit is selective. I am a miserable duffer in everything except advertising.”
Ogilvy's advice was to aim out of the park rather than bunt, setting high standards and praising home runs, since aiming for the company of immortals is the path to great work.
“Ogilvy was an Englishman interested in baseball. He would say, don't bunt. Aim out of the park. Aim for the company of immortals.”
The phrase 'pay peanuts, and you get monkeys' is one of Ogilvy's most repeated aphorisms, and the host argues that Ogilvy's skill at condensing ideas into memorable maxims is why his ideas stick.
“You can read that entire paragraph, or you can just read the last sentence, 'Pay peanuts and you get monkeys,' and you'll understand what he's saying.”
Senra discovered Ogilvy through Warren Buffett's shareholder letters, where Buffett repeatedly called David Ogilvy a genius, and Senra argues this should make listeners pay attention to Ogilvy.
“I was reading Warren Buffett's shareholder letters, and he kept referring to David Ogilvy as a genius.”
Ogilvy started an advertising agency in New York in 1948 despite Americans thinking he was crazy for a Scotsman to presume to know advertising, and it became an immediate and meteoric success.
“14 years before writing these confessions, I had gone to New York and started an advertising agency. Americans thought I was crazy. What could a Scotsman know about advertising?”
Ogilvy's Sam Bronfman and Shell anecdotes show that personal prospecting worked, but Ogilvy's claim that a less professional approach would have taken 20 years to arrive is a speculative, self-flattering counterfactual.
“Gentle reader, if you are shocked by these confessions of self-advertisement, I can only plead that if I had behaved in a more professional way, it would have taken me 20 years to arrive.”
Ogilvy & Mather grew to be 60 times its size when the book was written, because colleagues largely followed Ogilvy's ideas and sold products effectively for manufacturers.
“My colleagues at Ogilvy & Mather have largely followed my ideas, and they have sold a lot of products for a lot of manufacturers, with the result that our agency is now 60 times as big as it was when I wrote this book.”