#20 Setting the Table: The Transforming Power of Hospitality in Business
What this covers
This is David Senra's episode of the Founders podcast on Danny Meyer's book about running restaurants. Senra works through the book as a sequence of lessons, most of them rooted in Meyer's family history. His father, Morty Meyer, expanded too fast: Open Road Tours spread from Chicago to Paris and across Europe before it went bankrupt in the late 1960s, and further failures followed in Italian hotel leases and St. Louis real estate. Senra reads Meyer's restraint as a response to that. Meyer treats Infrastructure Before Growth as a rule, with people as the infrastructure, and he partners with those who are smarter than he is in specific areas. He is not risk-averse, but he refuses to behave like a gambler.
The middle of the episode is about practical bets. Meyer rejects the Location Maxim in favor of an emerging neighborhood with a cheap, long-term, Assignable Lease, so a failure could be handed off to someone else. He asks Who Wrote the Rule of conventions such as hot dogs without high standards or wine at a burger shack. Shake Shack's path from a 2001 cart to a kiosk to a company with over 100 locations illustrates Jeff Bezos's point that big things start small. Meyer also fired himself as chef, becoming a Restaurant Generalist.
The most instructive cases are failures. Eleven Madison Park's box lunch program left 3,000 unused boxes, a case of Inappropriate Brand Extension before the core experience was defined. Doubling lunch business in six months came from basics: a maître d' who recognized guests, lighter menus, and speed. Meyer also calls opening Gramercy Tavern while Union Square Cafe struggled possibly his worst mistake. Advice from Stanley Marcus that success is paved with mistakes well handled, and Irving Harris's claim that business is problems, frame these failures as normal costs rather than reasons for shame.
Meyer's book argues that hospitality, meaning how a business makes people feel, is the core of business. Success comes from disciplined, deliberately paced growth, from keeping options open so failure is survivable, and from treating mistakes as the normal cost of problem-solving.
- Danny Meyer's father's serial overexpansion and bankruptcies taught him to grow slowly, hire people smarter than himself, and keep his leases assignable
- Meyer applies first-principles questioning ('whoever wrote the rule?') to restaurant conventions like location, wine with burgers, and hot dog carts
- Stanley Marcus's advice that the road to success is paved with mistakes well handled reframed Meyer's view of perfectionism and risk
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
A restaurant must answer basic questions about its identity, such as whether it is a bistro or grand restaurant, expensive or for special occasions, French or not, before it can avoid confusing potential customers.
“Until we had answered all those questions for ourselves, we couldn't avoid confusing our potential customers”
Meyer insisted on an assignable lease so that if his restaurant failed he could transfer the lease to someone else, and he now tells every new restaurateur that getting an assignable lease is the first piece of advice to follow.
“I wanted to have the right to assign my lease to someone else if my restaurant should go out of business. ... To this day, getting an assignable lease is the first piece of advice I give any new restauranteur”
Pursuing perfection as company policy is dangerous because it stunts a team's willingness to take intelligent risks, and a team that plays it safe to avoid mistakes cannot create legendary hospitality.
“As a company policy, the notion of perfection can be dangerous, and the folly of pursuing it can stunt your team's willingness to take intelligent risks.”
Before a business grows, it must build infrastructure, and for Meyer the people are that infrastructure, so growth without capable people is dangerous.
“But before you grow, you have to have the infrastructure and the people. He considers the people the infrastructure to help you grow.”
Stanley Marcus told Meyer that the road to success is paved with mistakes well handled, so a mistake is not a reason for shame but an expected part of progress when it is managed well.
“So you made a mistake. ... The road to success is paved with mistakes well handled”
Eleven Madison Park's box lunch program failed because the restaurant tried to extend its brand to office lunches before establishing what the core dining experience represented, and it produced 3,000 unused boxes.
“We had made a fundamental mistake of trying to extend an original brand without first having established the core brand”
Meyer rejected the maxim 'location, location, location' and instead chose an emerging neighborhood with a long-term low-rent lease, reasoning that it allowed excellence at good value, attracted loyal customers, and transformed the neighborhood, while the lease could be reassigned if the restaurant failed.
“if I had handicapped the location correctly and could successfully play a role in transforming the neighborhood, my restaurant, with its long-term lease locked in at a low rent, could offer excellence and value”
Meyer repeatedly asks 'Whoever wrote the rule?' to challenge industry conventions, such as the assumption that good hot dogs cannot be served with high standards or that wine cannot be served at a burger shack, insisting that a business can do whatever makes sense.
“Whoever wrote the rule that you can't push the envelopes of excellence and hospitality for something as ordinary as a hot dog cart?”
Meyer decided not to be a chef because he was better suited to be a restaurant generalist, and he considers firing himself as chef one of the smartest business decisions he ever made, since his culinary education let him communicate with chefs in their own language.
“it increasingly dawned on me that as much as I loved to cook I was much more suited to become a restaurant generalist. My culinary education in Europe had provided the necessary foundation with which to communicate clearly about food with chefs in their own language. Firing myself as chef turned out to be one of the smartest business decisions I have ever made”
Business, like life, is fundamentally about how you make people feel, and creating positive, uplifting outcomes in human experiences and relationships matters more than the product itself.
“Business, like life, is all about how you make people feel. It's that simple and that hard”
Selling excellent coffee or food is secondary to creating a sense of community, because people select restaurants to be part of a community experience, and a business that does not understand it is fostering community will inevitably underperform.
“A business that doesn't understand its reason for existing is fostering a community will inevitably underperform.”
Shake Shack's trajectory from a 2001 hot dog cart to a 2004 kiosk and then a company with over 100 locations and over $1 billion in value illustrates Bezos's idea that big things start small and grow over time.
“The biggest Oak starts from an acorn. If you want to do anything new, you've got to be willing to let that acorn grow into a little sapling”
Danny Meyer's father Morty repeatedly failed through overly rapid expansion (Open Road Tours bankruptcy, Italian hotel leases, St. Louis real estate), and this deep fear of repeating those mistakes made Meyer hesitant to expand his own business too quickly.
“Because each of his doomed experiences was marked by overly rapid expansion, I have always been afraid to expand my business too quickly.”
Eleven Madison Park's team explained slow lunch sales by claiming people lacked time to leave their desks, rather than facing that the restaurant itself had not yet defined its identity or focused on improving the core product.
“rather than explaining the sluggishness as a natural challenge of building a business from scratch, we convinced ourselves that people didn't have the time to leave their desks for lunch”
Meyer sees gambling as a metaphor for his father's business approach, and his fear of repeating those mistakes shapes his management: he is not risk-averse but has tight self-control and refuses to behave like a gambler.
“I'm not risk-averse, but I have tight self-control, and I'm not a gambler”
Big things start small, so a new venture should be allowed to grow from an acorn into a sapling and then a small tree before it becomes a large business, as Jeff Bezos suggests and as Shake Shack's history illustrates.
“We know from our past experiences that big things start small. The biggest Oak starts from an acorn.”
Meyer deliberately hires and partners with people who are smarter than he is in specific areas, the opposite of his father's failure to surround himself with competent, loyal, trustworthy colleagues.
“he failed to surround himself with enough competent, loyal, trustworthy colleagues whose skills and strengths would have compensated for his own weaknesses”
Meyer considers the people who work in a restaurant far more important than the food concept, and this belief is why he wrote the book about hospitality and how customers feel.
“he considers the people that work in the restaurant way more important than the concept of the food”
A restaurant with a long-term low-rent lease in an emerging neighborhood can attract loyal, adventurous customers, which encourages other businesses to move in until a critical mass changes the neighborhood for the better.
“This combination would attract smart, adventurous, loyal customers, in turn giving other restaurants and businesses the confidence to move into the neighborhood until a critical mass had been reached”
Meyer felt guilty and worried after opening Gramercy Tavern in July 1994 while Union Square Cafe was struggling without him, and he said this might be the worst mistake he ever made, because he had violated his own commitment to expand only when quality would not suffer.
“I had betrayed my own commitment to expand only if I was certain I could do so without compromising quality there.”
Irving Harris's piercing analytical business mind was radically different from Morty Meyer's intuitive entrepreneurialism, which generated many imaginative ideas that he tried to run himself.
“Grandpa Irving's piercing analytical business mind was radically different from my father's intuitive entrepreneurialism.”
Meyer's father's Open Road Tours expanded to offices in Chicago, Los Angeles, New York, Paris, and across Europe before going bankrupt in the late 1960s, leaving the family with shame and strained relationships.
“Open Road Tours had offices and staff in Chicago, Los Angeles, New York, and Paris. Later, it opened offices all over Europe.”
Irving Harris's view that 'the definition of business is problems' implies success comes not from eliminating problems but from creative, profitable problem solving, so the best companies distinguish themselves by solving problems most effectively.
“The definition of business is problems. ... Success lies not in the elimination of problems, but in the art of creative, profitable problem solving.”
After abandoning the box lunch program, Eleven Madison Park doubled its lunch business within six months by focusing on basics: a maître d' skilled at recognizing guests, lighter menu options for frequent dining, and speed at lunchtime.
“by working on the basics, our lunch business doubled within 6 months”
Operating a hotel business across two continents was impossible for Meyer's father because he spent half of each month away from his family to address labor strikes and operational problems.
“it inevitably proved impossible for him to operate a hotel business across two continents”
Eleven Madison Park's team realized that the box lunch program had diverted attention from improving the restaurant itself and from building lunch business one guest at a time.
“creating the box lunches had kept our chef, Kerry Heffernan, and the management team from focusing on what we should have been doing all along”
Meyer was soberly aware that failure was a real possibility because of his father's bankruptcies and the high rate at which new restaurants went belly-up.
“Having experienced my father's bankruptcies and knowing something about how many new restaurants went belly-up, I was soberly aware that failure was a real possibility.”
The first permanent Shake Shack opened in Madison Square Park in July 2004 and was an immediate success, leading to long lines and wide press praise, with New York magazine calling it burger heaven.
“Shake Shack was an instant success when it opened in July 2004.”
Back when Meyer was opening restaurants, an excellent restaurant was too often confused with an expensive one, and high overhead from prestige locations forced restaurants to charge too much for lunch and dinner.
“Back then, an excellent restaurant was too often confused with an expensive restaurant.”
Meyer's father failed because he used leverage on his entire company and lacked the emotional skills, discipline, and competent loyal colleagues to offset his personal weaknesses, which made the business fragile when the economy turned.
“Although dad may have been an inventive entrepreneur, he did not have the necessary emotional skills or discipline, and he failed to surround himself with enough competent, loyal, trustworthy colleagues”
Shake Shack began in December 2001 as a hot dog cart operated as part of an art installation in Madison Square Park, which Meyer's team used as a test of enlightened hospitality.
“We volunteered to give life to the project by actually operating the sculpture's hot dog cart.”
Starbucks learned to replicate its blueprint across thousands of locations while conveying that each store belongs to its own community, a model Meyer admired and followed for Shake Shack.
“The company also learned to superimpose its blueprint onto thousands of locations, north, south, east, and west, while also conveying the sense that each Starbucks belonged to its particular community”
Baseball's top hitters make seven outs out of every ten at-bats and still reach a .300 lifetime average and the Hall of Fame, showing that high-level success coexists with frequent failure.
“Baseball's top-hitters can make seven mistakes out of every ten at-bats and still ride a 300-lifetime batting average into the Hall of Fame”
Irving Harris, Meyer's maternal grandfather, who co-founded Toni Home Permanent and sold it to Gillette for $20 million, was a towering influence on Meyer, who admired his competitive zeal and analytical business mind.
“He graduated from Yale, and he made his first fortune before he was 40 years old, having cofounded the Toni Home Permanent Company with his brother Nieson”
In September 1994 on a book tour in Dallas, Meyer sat next to Stanley Marcus, the Neiman Marcus leader, and confessed he feared that opening Gramercy Tavern might be the worst mistake he ever made, while Union Square Cafe was struggling in his absence.
“'Opening this new restaurant,' I said, 'might be the worst mistake I ever made.'”
Meyer's first restaurant concept was intuitively shaped by a confluence of interest, passion, pleasure, and family dynamics, after a family friend's suggestion that he open a restaurant instead of becoming a lawyer.
“It would reflect the confluence of interest, passion, pleasure, and family dynamics that had shaped my life.”
Meyer's father went bankrupt again and died of lung cancer in 1990 at age 59, having repeatedly exposed his family to business failure.
“By 1990, shortly before he died of lung cancer at the age of 59, he was once again bankrupt.”
Meyer's hot dog cart lost nearly $5,000 in its first season because it hired too many people and ran an inefficient system, even though demand and lines were high.
“we'd addressed my requirement for excellence and hospitality by hiring too many people and working in a very inefficient system”
Eleven Madison Park targeted the Credit Suisse First Boston office upstairs with a box lunch program of three sandwiches, house chips, water, and a cookie, but the company already had a subsidized cafeteria and few people bought the boxes.
“Credit Suisse First Boston already had a first-rate, company-subsidized cafeteria for its employees”
Shake Shack chose to serve beer and wine alongside burgers and hot dogs, extending the 'who wrote the rule' idea by challenging the assumption that fast-casual burger places cannot serve alcohol.
“there was no way we were going to pass up the opportunity to add something to the possibilities of what one might drink with a double burger, hot dog, or bratwurst”
Shake Shack remained a single restaurant for its first five years, reflecting Meyer's deliberate caution about growth even after the concept proved successful.
“for the first five years, they just had one restaurant. So he's very, very hesitant.”
Meyer spent about 100 days in Italy and France before opening his first restaurant, using the trip to learn the real work of restaurants, meet industry people, and envision the restaurant he wanted to open.
“In my many solitary moments during those 100 days, I'd had an ample opportunity to contemplate, feel, and envision the kind of restaurant I now knew I had to open”
Meyer's maternal grandfather Irving Harris, an analytical investor, bet on the quality of senior leadership rather than operating companies himself, considering evaluation of human potential as important as any business idea.
“His passion wasn't to operate the companies, but rather to bet on the quality of their senior leadership. Evaluating human potential was every bit as important to him as any other business idea.”
Meyer treated a temporary hot dog cart seriously as a test of enlightened hospitality, asking whether an ordinary product could be pushed to excellence, rather than accepting that a hot dog cart can only be a hot dog cart.
“Could a hot dog cart be anything more than just a hot dog cart?”
Meyer's father's 1972 Caesar Associates succeeded for years by packaging discounted group tours for airline employees (interliners) who could fly standby through IATA travel benefits, aggregating every available discount into packages with hotels, transport, and dining.
“Dad's business model was simple but original. He aggregated all the discounts to which members of IATA were entitled and packaged trips lasting up to two weeks.”
Shake Shack's unexpected success in its first summer created operational strain, as the team struggled to assemble and serve more than 500 items per hour during a nine-hour day at the pickup window.
“our team struggling to assemble and serve more than 500 different items per hour at the pickup window in a nine-hour day”
Eleven Madison Park's early launch was overshadowed by the anticipated Tabla opening four weeks later, so many saw Eleven Madison Park as the warm-up act, and it had to succeed on architecture, hospitality, and a solid kitchen rather than novel concept.
“many people saw the more classic Eleven Madison Park as the warm-up act for the main event”
Meyer's childhood weekends at Steak 'n Shake, a drive-in hamburger place in St. Louis, inspired the concept he later built as Shake Shack in Madison Square Park, adapted from drive-in to a walk-up kiosk.
“he spent almost all his weekends at Steak 'n Shake”
Many entrepreneurs feel they had no choice in their career path because the work tapped them on the shoulder, and Meyer's book suggests business is built on the intersection of interest, passion, pleasure, and family dynamics.
“It would reflect the confluence of interest, passion, pleasure, and family dynamics that had shaped my life.”
Meyer's father left St. Louis in 1970 to run hotel leases in Rome and Milan from abroad, and despite a $1 million loan from Irving Harris, he had to sell the leases at great financial and emotional cost after the business failed.
“By 1970, when I was 12, my father leaped into the hotel business in Italy. Despite the pleas of my mother and with Irving's begrudging help in the form of a $1 million loan”
Meyer's father leveraged his entire company to buy two St. Louis hotels and a Clayton medical building for redevelopment, and when the economy collapsed and funders withdrew, he lost the bet and was sued.
“My father had leveraged his entire company to purchase these hotels, and also purchase a medical building in Clayton, Missouri”
Meyer's father and grandfather had profoundly different business philosophies, with Irving seeing Morty as an irresponsible gambler and Morty seeing Irving as an overbearing tyrant, which strained family relations.
“Irving would have described Morty ... as an unpredictable, irresponsible riverboat gambler.”
Meyer's uncle Richard Polsky told him to open a restaurant, reframing Meyer's aimless plan to become a lawyer as a return to his lifelong passion for food and restaurants, which Meyer found both foreign and like a bullseye.
“Why don't you just do what you've been thinking about doing your whole life? ... Why don't you just open a restaurant?”
Danny Meyer's maternal grandfather Irving Harris was the most important business role model in his life because he combined social consciousness with business acumen, shaping Meyer both as a human being and as a restaurateur.
“Irving Harris was a singular man whose combining of social consciousness with business acumen was an enormous influence on me as a human being and ultimately as a restauranteur.”
Meyer did not want to simply replicate a favorite Roman trattoria in New York; replication can succeed, as Balthazar did with brasserie style, but his own business and design sense aimed at original creation rather than copying existing things.
“replicating something already in existence isn't where my own business or design sense has ever guided me”
Before designing Shake Shack, Meyer toured burger and shake stands across the country, from Steak 'n Shake and Ted Drewes in St. Louis to In-N-Out in Los Angeles, searching for the best of each style to inform his own concept.
“I was eager to ... study burger and shake stands all across the country”
Shake Shack's burger was developed in Eleven Madison Park's private dining room kitchen through many variations, landing on a blend of sirloin and brisket that gave a juicy, intensely beefy result.
“the perfect ratio of ground sirloin steak to brisket”
Meyer, after succeeding as a salesperson at Checkpoint, realized he would never work for someone else, having run his own business within a business, and he left to pursue a restaurant career after a dinner conversation urged him to open one.
“I would never go to work for someone else. Even at Checkpoint... I worked for myself”
For the hot dog cart, Meyer's team chose Chicago-style hot dogs from Vienna Beef, boiled in garlic, coriander, and bay leaves water, served on imported poppyseed buns with full traditional toppings, to deliver a higher standard than the typical New York street cart.
“we boiled it in water spiked with garlic, coriander, and bay leaves”
Books function as the original hyperlinks because they connect readers to other ideas and people, and Senra used this framing to justify sampling Neiman Marcus founder Stanley Marcus's book.
“books are the original hyperlinks”
Meyer admits he did no research, gathered no evidence, and interviewed no one for the book, so it reads as personal reflection rather than a systematic study.
“In the process of writing this book, I've done no research, gathered no evidence, and interviewed no one else.”
Meyer describes his book as a set of life experiences rather than a how-to manual, avoiding advice because he dislikes being told what to do and is uncomfortable giving unrequested advice.
“This is not a typical business book, and it's certainly not a how-to book.”
Balthazar in SoHo became so faithful a reproduction of a Parisian-style brasserie that Meyer said he would almost rather eat there than at half a dozen authentic brasseries in Paris, which he called an awesome accomplishment.
“Balthazar, in Manhattan's SoHo district, became such a perfect reproduction of a brasserie”
Meyer tested many variations of freshly ground beef, settling on a blend of sirloin and brisket with a specific fat-to-meat ratio, and chose each ingredient with an eye toward authenticity.
“until we landed upon what we thought was the perfect ratio of ground sirloin steak to brisket”
During Meyer's time at Checkpoint, his commission-earned stock rose from around $2 to nearly $12 per share, and he earned about $125,000 a year in his early 20s with no obligations except to himself.
“I was in my early 20s, making $125,000 a year, with no obligations except to myself.”
Shake Shack's IPO increased Danny Meyer's net worth by about $350 million, making it his greatest business success, and by the time of the episode the company was public with over 100 locations.
“After the IPO Shake Shack had a few years ago, it increased his net worth -- Danny Meyer's net worth by about $350 million.”
The Shake Shack app lets customers skip lines and includes a live camera feed of the original Madison Square Park location.
“they have a camera sitting out there in first location in Madison Square Park, and so they embedded that in the app”