#120 Billy Durant (Creator of General Motors)
What this covers
A solo episode that follows Billy Durant from Flint's lumber-funded carriage trade to the founding of General Motors, and finally to a bowling alley at about age 78. The host narrates chronologically and stops to draw lessons, with one point attributed to Senra about Durant's habit of staking his fortune on risky bets. The early chapters cover his theory of salesmanship, his sale of roughly 600 road carts before he had a factory, and Durant-Dort's turn to vertical integration after a builder cut him out. They also cover a colleague's 1901 warning about the automobile, which nobody heeded, and his 1907 decision to stockpile Buicks through a panic.
The middle of the episode is about scale and its costs. Durant took stakes in about 30 companies in GM's first two years by swapping stock, a roll-up strategy that needed little cash. He also bet on the low-price market because Henry Ford could not meet demand. The host then shows the damage: no central staff, no uniform bookkeeping, and cash needs that outran earnings when the 1910 panic arrived. The bankers' loan terms and his removal follow.
The later sections turn contentious. Durant's 10 percent margin positions left him exposed in 1917, and his 1920 defense of GM's share price ended in a loss of roughly $90 million. The host sets him against Hetty Green, who held cash, and the Dodge Brothers, who avoided outside financing. The host also draws on Don Valentine's focus on cash flow and the line between investor and speculator. The claim that simply holding GM stock beats trading it is flagged as contested.
William Durant built General Motors through salesmanship, rapid deal-making, and roll-up acquisitions, but his habit of protecting investors with his own money, speculating on margin, and ignoring cash flow and downturns destroyed the fortune that his talent created.
- Durant's sales and deal-making skill produced the early carriage, Buick, and GM empires
- He personally guaranteed loans and protected investors at his own expense, leading to repeated losses and the 1910 loss of control
- He speculated on GM stock on margin, and the 1920 downturn left him with roughly $90 million in losses and no recovery
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Durant had little faith in a central staff and so had none, leaving GM with no uniform bookkeeping, no clear inventory control, and subsidiaries still operating independently, so he did not know what was happening in businesses he owned while still adding more.
“Durant had little faith in his central staff, so he didn't have one.”
Lumber money financed the transition from harvesting raw materials to manufacturing in Flint after pine forests were depleted, illustrating that the decline of one industry can give rise to another and that old wealth often funds new industries.
“lumber money financed transition from harvesting raw materials to engaging in manufacturing.”
GM grew too fast: sales rose from $29 million in 1909 to $50 million in 1910 and profits were about $10 million a year, but expansion and supplier purchases required more cash than earnings provided, forcing heavy borrowing just as the 1910 panic hit.
“But there's not enough money to finance expansions and then purchase supplies.”
Hetty Green built a fortune by holding cash and not buying on margin, so when others were forced to sell during market declines she was on the other side of the transaction, the opposite of Durant's leveraged approach.
“Hetty Green builds an entire fortune taking advantage of people”
Durant chose to target the low-price car market rather than luxury, reasoning that Ford could not build enough cars to meet demand for an affordable automobile, which the host argues is a method to look for places where demand exceeds supply.
“Ford couldn't build enough cars to satisfy the entire demand for a low-price automobile.”
When a bicycle company that Durant-Dort had encouraged local investors to back failed, Durant decided the investors should be repaid from the Durant-Dort company's coffers, reasoning that the company's officials had urged them to invest.
“But Durant decided that the investors should be repaid out of the Durant-Dort coffers.”
In GM's first two years Durant acquired partial or complete ownership in about 30 companies by exchanging GM stock for their stock, which required little cash because early automakers could buy supplies on credit and finance growth from profits.
“in the first 2 years of GM's existence, Durant purchased -- he was able to purchase partial or complete ownership in about 30 companies. And he did that because they would take stock for it.”
During the 1907 panic Durant ordered factories to produce at full tilt and stored Buicks in barns, warehouses, and fields, so Buick production tripled and when demand returned he had the only automaker with cars on hand, though he then came to ignore business cycles.
“Buick production tripled despite the fact that a financial panic created oppression across the country.”
Durant's strategy was to gain control of some of the biggest automobile companies by exchanging small amounts of stock to acquire them early, because a wide range of products was the only sure road to power in a fickle, infant industry.
“The only sure road to power and success was to have a wide range of products.”
After paying the same prices as competitors and realizing they made no progress, Durant-Dort bought plants to make wheels, axles, paint, varnish, buggy tops, and lumber, becoming vertically integrated and the largest carriage company in the United States, which generated large profits.
“We realized that we were making no progress and we would not until we manufacture practically every important part that we used.”
Durant's salesmanship theory held that a salesperson should assume the buyer knows as much as they do, talk less, give the customer time to think so the customer sells himself, look for a self-seller, and if none exists, make one, which works best with a truly good product.
“Assume that the person you're talking to knows as much or more than you do, do not talk too much. Give the customer time to think. In other words, let the customer sell himself.”
When Paterson, the builder Durant relied on, cut Durant out by selling the orders directly to the buyer, Durant and Dort concluded they must build all their own vehicles, showing that anything important to the business must be controlled in-house.
“If something is important to your business, you need to control it.”
Don Valentine of Sequoia argued there are two things in business that matter, high gross margins and cash flow, and that companies fail for the same reason, they run out of money, a principle the host extends to families and individuals.
“There are two things in business that matter, and you can learn this in 2 minutes.”
Durant held large GM stock blocks bought on only 10 percent margin, so when GM's stock fell from $200 in early summer to $75 in fall 1917 after the US entered the war, he found himself in personal financial trouble.
“Durant, as a major GM stockholder, was holding large blocks of stock by paying only 10% margin required in those days.”
Financial panics and collapses are not unexpected; the unusual happens usually, so businesses must be prepared for them, and Durant repeatedly failed to prepare despite experiencing many panics.
“The unusual happens usually. You have to be prepared.”
Durant repeatedly staked his fortune on risky bets, including stock purchases on margin and speculative ventures, which made his wealth vulnerable to any market downturn.
“Billy bet everything constantly.”
Many people who had far less GM stock than Durant became wealthy because they held it, whereas Durant traded his stock with unnecessary gains at margin and died impoverished, so holding quality equity beats trading it.
“The difference between them and Durant was they sat on it and they became wealthy.”
An investor buys businesses to hold and profit from them over time, while a speculator bets on price moves and uses leverage; Durant's habit of trading on margin and chasing stock gains made him a speculator, which bankers treated as an insult.
“Later in life, people in JPMorgan, they're like, you're not an investor, you're a speculator. They meant it as a great insult.”
In 1920, after the postwar recession cut GM car sales from 47,000 to 12,000 a month, Durant bought heavily to support GM's share price and, after Stettinius's short selling, lost roughly $90 million in 1920 money and was forced to resign as GM president.
“Durant figured he lost $90 million.”
The Dodge Brothers made their fortune selling pickaxes in the gold rush of the automobile industry before starting their own car company, so they avoided outside financing and could make decisions quickly.
“they were already fabulously wealthy before they started making their car.”
After the 1910 panic called GM's bank loans, Durant was forced to accept a $50 million loan on outrageous terms, receiving $12 million in cash for $21.6 million of securities, and the bankers demanded control of the company, so he was removed after only two years.
“Under those terms, I received $12 million in cash, not $15 million, for which I gave $21.6 million of the best securities ever created.”
Hardy, an associate who studied French automobiles in Europe, returned in 1901 warning the Durant-Dort directors to get out of the carriage business before the automobile ruined them, but nobody listened and Durant was unimpressed.
“Get out of the carriage business before the automobile ruins you.”
William Durant founded or saved General Motors, Chevrolet, Buick, Frigidaire and Chrysler-related ventures, yet he died without money, operating a bowling alley at about age 78 and borrowing from his daughter.
“By 1940, Durant was back where he had started, working hard in Flint Michigan, and planning great business expansions. Except by then, he was 78 years old and no longer wealthy. And his business was bowling, not automobiles.”
Durant returned from an auto show where he sold 1,108 machines, although Buick could build fewer than 40 cars at the time, so his optimism again ran far ahead of his delivery capacity.
“Billy just returns from the auto show where he had sold 1,108 machines. At the time, Buick can build fewer than 40 cars.”
Durant sold about 600 road carts before he had a factory or even knew how to make one, bought the design blueprint instead of a factory, and then needed a builder for the orders.
“He sells 600 of these carts before he even knows how to make one. He didn't buy a factory.”
Durant was convinced to buy Buick after a test drive showed the car could climb terrain that stopped others, and because automobiles attracted crowds the way his road cart had, he judged the car would sell itself.
“The automobile attracted public attention. It gathered crowds just as the little road cart had done.”
Durant predicted that half a million automobiles would be built and sold in a single year, when bankers thought he was mad, and he turned out to be right.
“Durant have predicted that someday, half a million automobiles will be built and sold in a single year, the bankers thought he was mad.”
Early automobile founders often got their money from people who had made fortunes in copper, railroads, construction, and steel, and those backers then lent or invested in founders on equity or debt bases, a recurring source of funding in automotive history.
“Ransom Olds secured financial backing from a copper magnate.”
Paul Graham argues that determination, not intelligence, is what makes people successful, and the host agrees, citing Ford's persistence against the Selden patent holders as evidence that most people quit when faced with obstacles.
“And I think he's right, it's determination.”
Durant-Dort's best year in 1906 came just before the horse-drawn carriage market collapsed, so peak performance can be the moment right before irreversible decline.
“The best years can come right before a complete and irreversible decline.”
After the 1907 success, Durant assumed he could always ride out recessions, and the host argues this faith in weathering downturns was a mistake that later hurt him.
“After that, Durant seemed never to worry about business cycles, bad idea, figuring he would ride out any temporary recession.”
Once Durant-Dort was running smoothly and making great profits, Durant lost interest, because to a man of his temperament a well-run company felt dull, and he moved on to new challenges rather than staying focused on the core business.
“Durant liked to create organizations. When they were going well, he would just as soon let someone else take over for the details and look for a new challenge.”
Durant's deal style was to decide quickly, make the pitch, nail down details, and worry about the money later, which the host identifies as the spirit that guided his life and that eventually led to his financial undoing.
“Decide quickly, make your pitch, nail down the details, and don't worry about the money.”
Durant personally guaranteed GM's obligations to friends and associates with limited capital, which exposed his own fortune, and the host considers this an unbusiness-like and senseless procedure made from over-generosity.
“So General Motors for many years was called a one-man institution with respect to these endorsements and guarantees”
Durant tried to protect the people who invested with him even when this protection would break him, and he repeatedly made good on losses out of his own pocket, which eventually left him unable to save his supporters' dollars.
“He tried to protect the people who invested with him, even if this protection would break him.”
The same overriding optimism and drive that let Billy Durant build great organizations also led him into catastrophes that an average man could have seen coming, so the traits that made him strong ultimately destroyed him.
“The same thing that made Billy Durant strong ultimately destroyed him.”
Henry Ford built his life around one idea, mass-producing inexpensive cars so everybody could buy one, and he opposed consolidation because he believed it would raise prices, which the host considers dead right.
“Henry Ford had one single idea, one. You just need one idea to build a life on.”
Durant bought a mix of good businesses and many weak ones, and the host argues that combining raisins with turds leaves you with turds, so his inability to focus made the growing organization fragile, especially when financial panics hit.
“Durant buys good businesses and a bunch of c****y other businesses.”
Durant repeatedly failed to prepare for financial panics that recurred in his career, including 1907, 1910, 1915, and 1920, so the host argues he could only succeed in good times.
“Billy Durant could only succeed in good times. And he never learned because it has happened a bunch of times.”
Durant's syndicate-based buying of GM stock to support its price in 1920 was an attempt to save friends and to protect Morgan-linked capital, but it left him heavily exposed, and he later believed his partners set him up.
“Durant later said he was trying to support the price temporarily so that the British, Canadian money ... would come in.”
Durant's move from running his carriage company into stock speculation, which appealed to his gambling instincts, is what bankrupted him twice in his life, and he never recovered from the second time.
“This is what winds up bankrupting him twice in his life and which -- from which he never recovers.”
Durant's empire-building was daring, impulsive, and erratic rather than prudent, yet on balance he created what became the largest industrial corporation in history, so both his brilliance and his failures are central to his legacy.
“He won big and he lost big. But on balance, he created what became the largest industrial corporation in history.”
Durant almost bought the early Ford Motor Company for $8 million, but the financing he relied on fell through, and he later said the Ford business would never have been what it was without Henry Ford.
“Durant almost successfully bought Ford for $8 million. They had an agreement and then the financing that Durant was relying on fell through.”
Hardy built 52 cars by late 1903 and was then hit with patent-holder demands for a $50 royalty per car, which he chose to pay or give up on, while Henry Ford fought the Selden patent and won in 1911.
“They demand a $50 royalty for each of the 52 cars Hardy had sold.”
After being ousted from GM, Durant founded Chevrolet with Louis Chevrolet, choosing to run it without bankers as a one-man institution and using it as a vehicle to regain control of GM later.
“If I ever expected to regain control of General Motors, which I certainly intended to do, I should have a company of my own, run in my own way.”
Durant decided to buy the road cart maker's entire business within five days after a brief conversation, borrowed $2,000 to do it, and built the Durant-Dort Carriage Company into a top carriage producer.
“Decide quickly, make your pitch, nail down the details, and don't worry about the money.”
Durant founded General Motors in 1908 as a holding company after he already owned Buick and carriage businesses, and he was then approached by J.P. Morgan and Company and a financial backer about a large automobile merger.
“Before 1908 was out, Durant had founded a new company, General Motors.”
People find it very hard to give up on what is working before it is too late, which the host says the whole book is built around, citing Durant's associates' resistance to his shift toward automobiles.
“It's very, very hard for us as people to give up on what is working before it's too late.”
Walter Chrysler left Durant's organization after tiring of his style, and Durant bought Chrysler's stock for $10 million, yet the men stayed friends, and Chrysler later said the auto industry owed Durant more than it acknowledged.
“Chrysler in his autobiography described Durant as a genius and wrote that the automobile industry owes more to Durant than it has yet acknowledged.”
Durant, hired as a cigar seller, ignored his employer's orders and went directly to Port Huron to persuade local sellers to buy directly from the manufacturer, returning with orders for 22,000 cigars in two days, showing that cutting out intermediaries can be powerful.
“In the 2 days that he was gone, he had gotten orders for 22,000 cigars”
Wherever a valuable aspect of the manufacturing process exists, an entrepreneur will inevitably try to build a monopoly or trust over it, regardless of what the arrangement is called.
“any time there's a valuable aspect in the manufacturing process, inevitably, there'll be an entrepreneur building monopoly.”
Durant agreed to buy Cadillac from Henry Leland for $3.5 million, but when he finally got financing the price had risen to $4.7 million, and he avoided visiting the plant while negotiating other deals.
“The price was $3.5 million a few months earlier, but Durant couldn't get the money. Once he gets some money lined up, the price is now $4.7 million.”
Sam Bronfman bought up aged whiskey stock in anticipation of Prohibition ending, so when it was lifted he alone had large supplies of high-quality aged whiskey, a move that secured the American market and generational wealth, similar to Durant's 1907 inventory strategy.
“So this is a very similar strategy that Sam Bronfman did when he started buying up all the stocks of aged whiskey”
Billy Durant was not a back-shop tinkerer like other pioneers; he built organizations, and he had a hand in the beginnings of three of the four major American automakers that survive today.
“Unlike most of the pioneer automotive giants, Durant was not a back-shop tinkerer. While other men put automobiles together, he put organizations together”
A gold rush can enrich suppliers more reliably than miners, and the Dodge Brothers succeeded by selling pickaxes first, which the host uses as a metaphor for early profit from an emerging industry.
“in a gold rush, and this is a gold rush in the automobile industry, they sold pickaxes.”
Walter Chrysler, Charles Nash, and Alfred Sloan all wrote kindly about Durant despite disagreeing with him, with Chrysler calling him a genius and saying the auto industry owes more to Durant than it has acknowledged, which reflects the charm that led investors and staff to adore him.
“Chrysler in his autobiography described Durant as a genius and wrote that the automobile industry owes more to Durant than it has yet acknowledged.”
The host says Durant founded Chrysler, but Walter Chrysler built the Chrysler Corporation after leaving GM, so this statement is inaccurate.
“the guy founded General Motors, Chrysler, and Frigidaire.”
Around 1915 Durant, with Kaufman and Pierre du Pont, formed a syndicate and bought large amounts of GM stock, driving the price up so he could wrest control from the bankers when their five-year board control expired.
“Durant, Kaufman formed a syndicate to buy GM shares.”
Durant worked on very little sleep, sometimes calling meetings at 1:30 in the morning, and acted immediately on ideas, such as buying the cart company the day after riding its cart, illustrating how he did deals.
“he would sleep only 4 to 5 hours at night.”
Durant, a self-made millionaire at 42 who had spent most of his life in other industries, entered the automobile business late and still worked in it for about 40 years, suggesting that a late start in a new industry is not a barrier to success.
“Billy Durant was 42 before he got involved with cars at all, 42. And he worked in that industry for 40 years of his life.”
Durant sourced a spark plug from Albert Champion that was of real merit and cost $0.25 versus $0.35 from the only other maker, saving $0.10 per plug on roughly 1,000 plugs a day, and Champion earned a fortune from GM stock Durant gave him.
“the price we paid him was $0.25, saving $0.10 each spark plug.”
When du Pont and Raskob tried to measure Durant's personal indebtedness, they found it was in the millions but he had no records, and it would take days for brokers to produce reports, a sign of disorganization in his finances.
“The indebtedness was in the millions of dollars, but he was not certain of the figure since he had no records.”
Money for early automobile companies was hard to raise because New York capitalists were uneasy about the automobile proposition and doubted that the industry could make money in the early 1900s, and Henry Ford, Ransom Olds, and Durant all ran into this.
“Money is hard to get, owing to somewhat unaccountable feeling of uneasiness and a general distrust of the automobile proposition.”
A person who wants to help others must first remain financially solvent, because one cannot help the poor if one is among them, so generosity that causes ruin ends the ability to help.
“But you can't help them if you go broke, and that's exactly what's going to happen to you.”
Durant died believing he had been set up by his friends in the 1920 collapse, though the host notes this cannot be proven.
“Durant dies thinking that he got set up by his friends. Let me just tell you that. And I'll go -- we can't really prove it.”
Durant could never focus on one thing, constantly starting new ventures such as insurance, utilities, carriages, stock market speculation, and cars, which the host finds frustrating because he kept abandoning businesses that were already working.
“he can never focus on one thing.”
The host says Billy Durant is the opposite of Hetty Green and Mark Spitznagel, who built businesses to benefit from unusual events, whereas Durant could only succeed in good times.
“Billy Durant could only succeed in good times. And he never learned because it has happened a bunch of times.”
Chevrolet grew to selling about 70,000 cars a year by 1914, within a few years of founding, showing the success of the low-price strategy.
“By 1914, it's selling 70,000 cars a year.”
Durant could arrive in a town, find the best salesman, and hire them away from their current work, and this talent for selling a cart, a salesman a career, or a company made him a dynamic force in the vehicle industry for more than 40 years.
“Billy Durant could arrive in town, find the best salesman and hire them away from whatever they were doing.”
Early Buick spent more money than it earned, did research instead of producing for the market, and was backed by men who could not afford that luxury, so its founder David Buick ended up selling most of the company to investors.
“In the process, they spent more money than they ever made. That's a big problem.”
Durant conducted acquisition talks at odd hours, including a 3 a.m. tour of Olds plants after arriving in Lansing past midnight and a 1:30 a.m. appointment, reflecting an extreme pace that the host sees as part of his character.
“Durant arrived in Lansing after midnight one night. He roused the Olds executives from bed, and at 3 a.m. galloped through the Olds plants for a 15-minute tour.”
Durant dropped out of high school just after turning 17, then sold lumber, groceries, patent medicines, cigars, and real estate before becoming a partner in an insurance agency, building the sales skill that defined his career.
“Billy Durant had sold lumber, groceries, patent medicines, cigars and real estate.”
Ed Stettinius, part of Morgan's syndicate, sold GM shares at an insider price and urged Durant to sell GM short, which Durant viewed as a betrayal of trust that worsened his personal disaster.
“Stettinius told him, meaning Durant, that he thought the stock would go lower and they should sell short 200,000 shares.”
Durant's grandfather, Governor Crapo, criticized Durant's father, William Clark Durant, for stock speculation and reckless ventures, and the host suggests Durant inherited a speculative temperament, though Durant's motives were more altruistic than his father's.
“his grandfather picks up on something about Billy's father that maybe Billy inherited from his father”
In the 1908 meeting, Durant tried to buy Ford, Ransom Olds's REO company, and Oldsmobile, but Ford said he had no idea of REO's value or earning capacity, and the host argues no one can be an expert in another person's company.
“Henry Ford said that he didn't have the slightest idea of the value or the earning capacity of REO.”
The author describes Henry Ford as someone who liked publicity and would not follow unless he could lead, so Durant suggested the group first see Ford to get the procession moving.
“I suggested he first see Henry Ford who was in the limelight, liked publicity and unless he could lead, the procession would not play.”
Different founders in separate companies, such as Durant, Dodge, and Ford, made the same decision to control key inputs, and the host argues this repetition across unrelated people signals that the decision is important.
“You see the same people in separate times and separate companies making the same decisions. That's a good indication that it's probably important.”
Walter Chrysler wrote that Durant had the most winning personality he had ever known and could coax a bird out of a tree, and the host treats Durant's charm as his most important asset.
“He could coax a bird right down out of a tree.”
The host considers Durant the most likable of the automotive founders he has studied, and says a person should learn from his ideas but not want to be like him financially.
“Billy Durant is by far the most likable person.”
Louis Kaufman said in 1927 that if Durant had not become involved in the stock market he would have been worth $500 million and still in charge of GM, which the host presents as the clearest counterfactual of Durant's speculation.
“Louis Kaufman said in 1927 that if Durant had not become involved in the market, he would have been worth $500 million and still in charge of GM.”