#138 Alexander Graham Bell
What this covers
This episode of Founders follows David Senra reading through a biography of Alexander Graham Bell, from teacher of the deaf to inventor of the telephone. The story starts with the telegraph, which nearly thirty years after its first commercial use could still send only one message at a time. Bell showed that a piano string answers a sung note at the same frequency. That led him to theorize that one wire could carry several messages at different frequencies, the idea behind the harmonic telegraph. A model of the human ear then gave him the principle of an undulating current carrying sound. Senra notes that teaching the deaf stayed Bell's real passion, and that he never worked on the telephone again in his last forty years.
The middle of the episode is about business and law. Gardiner Hubbard filed the patent application without consulting Bell, within hours of Elisha Gray's caveat. Hubbard also chose to lease telephones rather than sell them, which Senra compares to Howard Hughes Sr. leasing drill bits. The company nearly died fighting Western Union, with employees unpaid and borrowing from one another, until a settlement pushed Western Union out of the business. Bell's 1876 forecast of wires running into homes like water or gas is set against a mostly rural, isolated population that thought it fantasy.
Senra keeps stepping aside to draw lessons. He covers Bell's guarded solitude (no knocking at his study door, no telephone in it), Edwin Land on long concentration, and Steve Jobs on mortality. He also covers Marc Andreessen on inventors swinging between euphoria and terror, and Joseph Henry urging Bell to learn the electricity he lacked.
Senra argues that Bell's telephone success came from relentless, self-directed persistence and cross-field imagination, and that people instinctively pass knowledge down the generations by studying the lives of predecessors, so reading biographies is a high-leverage way to learn how to keep going.
- Bell combined ideas from unrelated fields (acoustics and telegraphy) to reach the telephone, and his breakthrough came from an imaginative leap rather than formal training.
- Bell repeatedly drew encouragement from predecessors such as Samuel Morse, and Senra traces a chain of this inheritance through Edwin Land, Steve Jobs, James Dyson, and others.
- Bell's success depended on partners who supplied the skills he lacked, including Gardiner Hubbard's patent expertise, Thomas Watson's craftsmanship, and Mabel's steadiness.
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Bell's lifelong passion was helping and teaching the deaf, and that commitment outlasted the telephone itself, since after the company succeeded he never worked on the telephone again over the remaining roughly 40 years of his life.
“Alexander Graham Bell, his passion in life was teaching the deaf, not inventing the telephone, although, for a few short years, he was completely consumed by that.”
Gardiner Hubbard filed a patent application for the speaking telegraph without consulting Bell in February 1876, and the filing was made within hours of Elisha Gray's caveat, so Hubbard's unilateral action was decisive for the patent.
“In February 1876, without consulting Alex, he went ahead and filed on Alex's behalf for a patent on the speaking telegraph.”
Bell's demonstration that a piano string responds to a sung note at the same frequency led him to theorize that one telegraph wire could carry several messages at once if each were sent at a different frequency.
“The phenomenon should mean that a single telegraph wire could carry several messages at once if they were all vibrating at a different frequency.”
Bell projected that telegraph wires would one day run into houses like water or gas and let friends converse without leaving home, a vision most people in 1876 dismissed as fantasy when most of the population lived in isolated rural communities.
“The day is coming when telegraph wires will be laid on houses just like water or gas and friends converse with each other without leaving home.”
The telephone company's survival depended on winning its patent litigation against Western Union, which was printing money and cutting rates, and the eventual out-of-court settlement forced Western Union out of the business, leaving Bell shareholders holding a monopoly on a popular invention.
“The final out-of-court deal was an expensive blow to the mighty company, meaning Kodak in Land's case, Western Union in Bell's case. Western Union had to get out of the business just like Kodak did.”
The Bell company nearly died in its fight against Western Union, which ignored its patents, forcing employees to go unpaid and borrow from each other until a patent lawsuit victory secured the company's future.
“Bell company employees had not been paid for weeks and were lending each other money”
After building a model of the human ear and understanding how sound is produced and received, Bell realized that an undulating electric current could carry sound along a wire the way air carries sound waves, which was the principle behind the telephone.
“the idea struck him that it might be possible to create an undulating electric current that could carry sound along a telegraph wire in the same way that the air carried soundwaves”
Gardiner Hubbard advised Bell to write down every fact connected with his invention and to document prior performances because time would be essential in the patent process, and a former patent attorney's advice was decisive given how competitive patent filings were.
“Whenever you recall any fact connected with your invention, jot it down on paper as time will be essential to us.”
Gardiner Hubbard chose to lease telephones rather than sell them so the partners could maintain control, service, and maintenance revenue, a strategy Senra compares to Howard Hughes Sr. leasing drill bits, which he argues made the Hughes Tool Company one of the most profitable companies in history.
“Cleverly opted to lease telephones rather than sell them so that he and his partners could maintain control.”
Bell never liked anyone to knock before entering his study because a tap at the door could make him lose a train of thought for days, and he never had a telephone installed in his own study for the same reason.
“If he was following a train of thought and there was a tap at his door, his attention being diverted to the noise, he very often lost the thread for days”
Bell's leap to the principle of the telephone came from imaginative reasoning in a private setting, not from institutional resources, and his advantage was an understanding of the human ear that others lacked, which made him the quintessential untrained inventor of the 19th century.
“No one else knew enough about the human ear.”
There is an instinctual human pattern of looking to the past, studying the accumulated knowledge and life stories of predecessors, and pushing that knowledge down the generations, and this pattern becomes more apparent the more biographies one reads.
“there is something instinctual in our nature. This idea that we all look to the past and try to learn from their accumulated knowledge and push that knowledge down the generations.”
Bell's success depended on partners and a spouse who supplied the skills he lacked: Hubbard had business and patent expertise and access to capital, Thomas Watson had manual dexterity to build prototypes, and Mabel provided emotional steadiness and kept him grounded.
“Alex had the ideas that Hubbard needed, Hubbard had the access to capital to finance them.”
Bell's path to the telephone followed repeated cycles of breakthrough followed by struggle, so overnight success is a myth and inventions must be pushed and forced through persistence.
“He has an innovation or breakthrough, then he goes through a period of struggle. Then he has another positive event that happens and goes through a period of struggle.”
Steve Jobs's point that remembering one will die strips away external expectations and fear and leaves what is truly important, and Senra says a weekly reminder of mortality, learned from biographies, helps him focus on what matters.
“Remembering that I'll be dead soon is the most important tool I've ever encountered to help me make the big choices in life.”
Bell regarded the increase of knowledge as one of the highest achievements, saying it makes us more like God, and his purpose was learning and then teaching others, which led him to read an entire Encyclopedia Britannica set.
“I hold it as one of the highest of all things, the increasing of knowledge making us more like God.”
Joseph Henry encouraged Bell to acquire the electrical knowledge he lacked rather than give up, and the host argues this kind of instruction, to persevere and learn what you lack, is what fuels long-term inventors.
“'Get it', he barked at the 28-year-old.”
Intense concentration for hours at a time can draw out resources in a person's mind that they did not know they had, a principle Edwin Land taught in his company and which Senra sees as shared with Bell's work habits.
“intense concentration for hour after hour can bring out in people resources they didn't know they had”
Bell's breakthrough happened in a remote, silent location away from Boston and competitors, which Senra presents as evidence that uninterrupted solitude is needed for deep original thought.
“Far from the bustle of Boston and the pressure of competition from other eager inventors, he mold over everything he discovered about sound.”
Nearly thirty years after its first commercial use, the telegraph could still send only one message at a time, and the race to increase its capacity drew Bell into the field.
“Nearly 30 years after its first commercial application, the telegraph system was still limited to sending one message at a time.”
Bell met Mabel Hubbard, a fifteen-year-old private student, whose father became his business partner, and the meeting was a lucky twist that supplied the business and social skills Bell lacked.
“In a rare twist -- lucky twist of fate, he meets the person that has all the skills that he does not.”
Bell's greatest talent was not classical training but a powerful imagination that connected ideas across unrelated fields, such as applying Helmholtz's theories on the nature of sound to the electric telegraph, and that combinatorial leap is how the telephone was conceived.
“what his breakthrough was he is connecting ideas in unrelated fields and combining them to a new insight. And that's exactly how we came up with the telephone.”
Inventors experience an emotional roller coaster with only two extremes, euphoria and terror, and Marc Andreessen said lack of sleep intensifies both, which matches Bell's gloomy letters about the cares of inventing.
“You only experienced 2 emotions, euphoria and terror, and I find a lack of sleep enhances them both.”
Joseph Henry was first to convert magnetism into electricity, but Michael Faraday received the credit because he published first, which motivated Henry's insistence that Bell acquire the knowledge to capture the payoff.
“Although Henry had been the first person to convert magnetism into electricity, it was British scientist Michael Faraday, who had earned the credit for it because he was the first to publish his results.”
Many ideas credited to Steve Jobs were actually learned from Edwin Land, and many of Land's ideas were learned from Alexander Graham Bell, forming a tree of borrowed knowledge.
“a lot of the ideas that we accredit to Steve Jobs really are ideas he learned from Edwin Land”
Successful people repeatedly encourage others to read biographies because studying how predecessors persevered through difficulty gives people the inspiration to keep going when they want to give up, and the value of that inspiration can be incalculable.
“why are almost all of the smartest and most productive people in the world, why do they always encourage you to read biographies.”
After the telephone company succeeded, Bell never worked on the telephone again and turned to hydrofoils, sheep breeding, and human-powered flight, and he never had another commercially viable invention, because the telephone wealth freed him to follow curiosity.
“The telephone generated enough wealth that it freed him from having to do that, and he just followed his intellectual curiosity.”
Bell's wife Mabel recounted that he worked up to 22 hours without sleep, and he had a strict rule against being interrupted because a tap on his door could cause him to lose a train of thought for days.
“If he was following a train of thought and there was a tap at his door, his attention being diverted to the noise, he very often lost the thread for days and would not be able to pick it up again.”
A caveat was a written notice of work in progress that did not itself confer a patent but could lead to one, and it warned other inventors that Gray was pursuing speech transmission by electricity.
“So caveat was essentially like a written warning, but this is what I'm working on. It's not the same as a patent, but it could lead to a patent.”
Bell's first hire, Thomas Watson, was a skilled mechanic who translated Bell's sketches into working devices, filling the manual dexterity gap that Bell had, and Watson later called Bell the strongest influence in his life.
“'No finer influence than Mr. Bell ever came into my life', he wrote.”
Bell showed fierce independence early by adding Graham to his name because he was the third Alexander Bell in a row and wanted to be distinct, a trait that persisted throughout his life.
“Exasperated by being the third Alexander Bell in a row, he decided to add Graham to his own name.”
Bell followed his father into speech teaching, as his father Melville Bell was a professor of elocution, which today would be called speech pathology, and Bell taught both speech-impaired and deaf students.
“his father was a professor of elocution, which is the skill of clear and expressive speech. So today, you would call him a speech pathologist.”
Edwin Land applied lessons he took from Bell's life, including the marketing of the telephone and the value of long, uninterrupted concentration, to his own work on instant photography.
“There were ideas that Edwin Land learned from the marketing of the telephone that he applied to instant photography.”
Bell routinely took on more projects than he could handle, sat up all night working obsessively, and suffered recurring headaches, depression, and sleeplessness, a work pattern that persisted almost until he died.
“he would sit up all night reading or working obsessively on sound experiments. He stumbled towards his bed only when he saw the pale light of dawn seeping through the curtains.”
Intel co-founder Bob Noyce's maxim that knowledge shared is power multiplied captures the same logic as Bell's view that increasing knowledge is among the highest pursuits.
“Knowledge is power. Knowledge shared is power multiplied.”
Bell drew inspiration from Samuel Morse's life, telling himself Morse overcame electrical difficulties despite being a painter, which helped Bell persist through his own technical deficits.
“he tried to reassure himself with the knowledge that Morse conquered his electrical difficulties, although he was only a painter”
Charles Thompson's most significant contribution to the household was lifting from Mabel the full weight of dealing with Bell's eccentricities and obsessive rituals, which made Bell maddening to live with.
“Charles' most significant contribution to the household was that he lifted from Mabel's shoulders the full weight of dealing with her husband's eccentricities”
Bell was a poor student in formal schooling yet would go to great lengths to learn about things he was interested in, such as birdwatching, photography, and music, showing a pattern of willingly doing almost nothing on subjects that did not interest him.
“he's willing to go to great lengths to learn about things that he's interested in. And he's willing to do almost nothing on things that he's not interested.”
During roughly seven lean years, Bell earned his primary income by charging $200 per lecture to sponsoring organizations and gave public lectures, where he described not only how the telephone worked but its purpose, because the telephone took a long time to make money.
“He had decided to charge $200 to any organization that wanted to sponsor one of his lecture.”
Bell's obsession with telegraphy, driven by competition from Elisha Gray and Thomas Edison, left him exhausted and sick and began to overshadow his commitment to deaf education.
“The competition unnerved Alex, and once again, his health began to suffer. His obsession with telegraphy now overshadowed his commitment to deaf education.”
Bell told his parents that the neck-and-neck race with Elisha Gray pushed him to work harder, and he believed his sound expertise gave him an advantage over Gray's practical electrical skill.
“The very opposition seems to nerve me to work, and I feel with the faculties I have now, I may succeed.”
Thomas Edison devised a receiver that did not infringe Bell's patent and worked better, and Edison telephones were sold in England while Bell grew more depressed about the slipping prospect of cashing in.
“Thomas Edison had devised a new kind of receiver that did not infringe on Alex's patent and worked better than Bell's model.”
Bell wrote to Mabel that the feverish, anxious life of invention was injuring him, leaving him irritable and disgusted with life, which Senra cites to show how close even a great inventor came to quitting.
“Already, it has begun injuring me, and I feel myself growing irritable, feverish, and disgusted with life.”
Bell's majestic bearing and clear, methodical testimony made him a formidable witness, and his testimony spanned about 100 pages of a 600-page record, a comparison Senra draws to Land's testimony in the Kodak case.
“Alex's majestic bearing, steady gaze, and straightforward manner made him a formidable witness.”
Bell completed the telephone demonstration but failed to file the required report to the Philadelphia Bureau of Awards, so the medals were withheld, because his intellect was so focused on experiments that he neglected follow-through and paperwork.
“He has not yet send in the report to the Philadelphia Bureau of Awards required before the Philadelphia exhibition medals could be sent to him.”
Bell's wife Mabel pressed him on why he did not file patents for many of his inventions or explore their commercial viability, and his reply that increasing knowledge makes us more like God shows that his main ambition was learning and teaching rather than profit.
“I hold it as one of the highest of all things. The increase of knowledge making us more like God.”
Bell's temperament lacked balance, alternating between fierce focus on one goal and an inability to concentrate on anything else, yet this erratic, intuitive, rule-refusing mind was what made him a genius.
“it was his unconventional mind that made him a genius. He refused to be hemmed in by rules. He allowed his intuition to flourish.”
For Senra, studying biographies is a weekly reminder of mortality, and this reminder is a valuable part of reading them.
“It's a constant -- for me, it's a weekly reminder of the fate that we all share and that is death.”
Gardiner Hubbard's prior career as a patent attorney gave him the procedural knowledge that Bell lacked, making him central to the telephone company's success, which the host considers larger than Bell's own contribution in business terms.
“Gardiner Hubbard, that's going to be his future partner, and maybe the person outside of Alex that's most responsible for the company's success.”
London in the period when Bell taught there was one of the dirtiest cities in the world, with widespread infectious disease, and the tuberculosis deaths that followed in his family prompted their emigration to Canada.
“Alex is living and teaching in London. It's one of the dirtiest cities in the world at the time. And there's a ton of infectious diseases that spread.”
After spending hours studying a person's life, a reader feels they know him, so the death at the end is emotionally powerful, and comparing photographs of Bell at the same age Senra now is led him to recognize the shared human desires for love, family, success, and enjoyment of brief time.
“We all want to be loved. We all want to have family and friends and have close personal relationships.”
Bell hated paperwork and procrastinated on required follow-up reports, such as the Philadelphia exhibition submission needed to receive medals, a pattern Senra compares to Claude Shannon and says cost marketing value like social proof.
“Alex loved experimentation. He loved invention. He hated paperwork.”
Tuberculosis, called the Great White Plague in Bell's era, is still the deadliest infectious disease, killing 1.5 million people in 2018.
“tuberculosis is still the deadliest infectious disease. It killed 1.5 million people in 2018.”
A single lesson absorbed from a biography, such as James Dyson's takeaway from Brunel, can be worth billions of dollars even though the book costs about $20 to $30, so not reading biographies is an unforced error.
“that effect on James Dyson's life was literally worth billions of dollars in a book that you can pick up for $20. Why would you not do that?”
Bell's father Melville was an authoritarian parent, and Bell later chose to parent in the opposite direction, favoring play as nature's method of educating a child and treating a parent's duty as aiding nature's development.
“He believed that play is nature's method of educating a child and that a parent's duty is to aid nature in the development of her plan.”
Joseph Henry's brusque advice to Bell to 'Get it' and keep working, despite Bell lacking electrical knowledge, mirrors the encouragement Ed Catmull describes during the Sputnik race: you lack the skills now, so go get them without giving up.
“Oh, you don't have those skills now, you don't have the knowledge now, then go get it, but you're not going to give up.”
Bell's lectures drew thunderous applause because he spoke without notes about the purpose of the invention, not just its mechanics, and predicted that people in different cities would soon call each other.
“He described to his audience not only his -- how his invention worked, but its purpose, the why”
Bell and Edwin Land shared striking parallels: both moved their labs to the same building, both used the same patent attorneys, both won landmark patent cases largely through their own testimony, both worked long stretches without interruption, both saw themselves as teachers and scientists over entrepreneurs, and both had inventions described as toys.
“Both of their new inventions were described by others as toys.”
James Dyson drew inspiration from Isambard Kingdom Brunel's self-belief and the idea that a great project is the vision of a single man pursued with dogged determination, and Senra argues Bell's telephone effort embodied the same obsessive single-mindedness.
“I have told myself when people tried to make me modify my ideas that the Great Western Railroad could not have worked as anything but the vision of a single man pursued with dogged determination.”
Bell's note to himself that a man's own judgment should be the final appeal reflects a habit of reasoning from first principles rather than by analogy or deference, and then living with the results of his own conclusions.
“A man's own judgment should be the final appeal in all that relates to himself. Many men do this or that because someone else thought it right.”
Senra argues that Howard Hughes Sr. was a more accomplished and greater entrepreneur than his famous son.
“His dad, I would argue, is a more accomplished and greater entrepreneur than Howard Hughes ever was.”