#187 Albert Einstein
What this covers
This episode follows the life of Albert Einstein and stops often to compare him with other founders and builders. It starts with the Bern patent office, where Einstein was expected to work eight hours a day, six days a week, but learned to finish his reviews in two or three hours and used the rest for physics. The host stresses how little pointed toward the miracle year of 1905: five little-noticed papers, no doctorate, no teaching job. Newton's plague-year isolation in 1666 is the usual comparison. The career side is told through Weber and Pernet, the professors who blocked him, and through a humble letter from Einstein's father to the physicist Ostwald that went unanswered. Nine years later Ostwald nominated Einstein for the Nobel Prize.
The middle of the episode ranges across learning and method. Einstein hated the rote drills of his German gymnasium, and his lectures ran on scribbled cards rather than prepared notes. His patent office boss told examiners to doubt every premise, a habit the host sets beside Jeff Bezos's practice of assuming every claim is wrong. Other comparisons include Elon Musk on intuition, Yvon Chouinard on testing and stepping back, Claude Shannon and Henry Singleton on working alone, and Jocko Willink and Sam Walton on difficult people and ego.
The later sections turn to politics. Einstein doubted assimilation would protect German Jews, and the 1922 assassination of Walther Rathenau bore that out. The host argues, contentiously, that the exodus of scientists after the Nazi academic-exclusion law helped the Allies reach the bomb first. Other threads are the FBI's suspicion of Einstein, which kept him out of the Manhattan Project, his world-government proposal against Oppenheimer's objections, and Bertrand Russell's defense of civil disobedience.
The host argues that Einstein's independence, imprudence, and solitude drove his scientific breakthroughs, but the same traits cost him years of career progress, so the lesson is to keep the strengths while learning to build relationships.
- Traits that produce breakthroughs in one domain, such as questioning authority, become liabilities in another, such as getting hired and building relationships.
- Einstein's delayed academic career (9 years after graduation) came from his reputation with professors, not from a lack of ability.
- Individual solitude and independent judgment, not group consensus, produce new ideas.
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Einstein's rebellious attitude and disrespect toward his professors, especially Weber and Pernet, led them to block his academic career, so he did not get a junior professorship until 9 years after graduation and 4 years after his 1905 papers.
“It would be an astonishing 9 years after his graduation and 4 years after the miracle year”
Einstein's 1905 miracle year is the most common parallel to Newton's 1666, when Newton isolated at home during the plague and developed calculus, light spectrum analysis and gravity laws, and Einstein had published only five little-noted papers before it.
“Up until then, Einstein had published five little noted papers”
Before 1905 Einstein had published five little-noticed papers that earned him neither a doctorate nor a teaching job, and the host finds it remarkable that nothing in his record predicted the miracle year that followed.
“Had he given up theoretical physics at this point, the scientific community would not have noticed”
Einstein was never officially asked to join the Manhattan Project, but Vannevar Bush sought his help on isotope separation, while the FBI under J. Edgar Hoover had long investigated Einstein as a suspected spy and communist, blocking fuller involvement.
“Hoover, that crazy nut job, was convinced that Einstein was a spy and a communist”
Einstein's job as a patent examiner in Bern required him to work 8 hours a day, six days a week, but he learned to finish patent reviews in two or three hours, leaving the rest of the day for his own physics.
“I was able to do a full day's work in only 2 or 3 hours. The remaining part of my day, I would work on my own ideas”
Einstein never believed assimilation would protect German Jews, and the 1922 assassination of Walther Rathenau showed that assimilated Jews could still be targeted by nationalists who saw them as a threat.
“Assimilation did not bring safety”
The German law barring Jews from academic posts forced out 14 Nobel laureates and 26 theoretical physics professors, and the host argues this emigration helped the Allies rather than the Nazis develop the atomic bomb first.
“Among those forced to flee were 14 Nobel laureates and 26 professors of theoretical physics”
Einstein's imaginative, independent thinking, which broke from conventional wisdom and was allergic to herd mentality, is what let him rethink the fundamentals of physics; his 'imprudence' was the trait that served him well as a young scientist.
“His imprudent instincts, which served him so well as a young scientist, made him allergic to anything that smacked of a herd mentality.”
Einstein advocated a world government that would require nations to surrender some sovereignty to prevent war, while Oppenheimer argued that federal union is hard even within one country with deep value differences, so global integration was unrealistic.
“The history of this nation up to the civil war shows how difficult the establishment of a federal authority can be”
In his farewell speech before leaving Europe, Einstein argued that without intellectual and individual freedom there would have been no Shakespeare, Goethe, Newton, Faraday, Pasteur, or Lister, and that a quiet life of monotony stimulates creative minds.
“Without such freedom, there would have been no Shakespeare, no Goethe, no Newton”
Einstein said that a new idea comes suddenly and intuitively, but that intuition is the outcome of earlier intellectual experience, a view the host compares to Elon Musk's claim that ideas arrive as a download of prior calculations.
“A new idea comes suddenly and in a rather intuitive way, but the intuition is nothing but the outcome of earlier intellectual experience”
Einstein found the rote drills and unquestioning obedience of his German gymnasium repugnant and later argued that education based on free action and personal responsibility is far superior to one relying on outward authority.
“how much superior an education based on free action and personal responsibility is to one relying on outward authority”
Einstein, like Claude Shannon and Henry Singleton, did his best work alone and withdrew from the outside world, which the host argues shows that outsized results do not come from mimicking the herd.
“they did all their best work alone”
Einstein claimed imagination is more important than knowledge, and his success came from questioning conventional wisdom and marveling at mysteries others found mundane rather than from raw mental processing power.
“imagination is more important than knowledge”
The host argues that Einstein's personal detachment and scientific creativity were linked, because it is easier to be a nonconformist and rebel when you can detach yourself from others, which let him pursue theories in a single-minded way.
“It is easier to be a nonconformist and rebel when you can detach yourself easily from others”
Jeff Bezos reads every sentence as wrong until he can prove otherwise, challenging the content rather than the motive of the writer, which is a tactic for producing unique insights from the same material others read.
“He assumes each sentence he reads is wrong until he can prove otherwise.”
Einstein's patent office boss Haller advised examiners to think everything an inventor says is wrong and to question every premise, and Jeff Bezos uses the same tactic of assuming each sentence is wrong until proven otherwise.
“When you pick up a patent application, think that everything the inventor says is wrong”
Einstein's friend said that because Einstein explored in all directions, most paths he took would be blind alleys, and the host compares this to Yvon Chouinard's advice to step forward, test, and step back, since learning by doing is faster.
“one must expect the majority of the paths on which he embarks to be blind alleys”
Bertrand Russell argued in a letter to the New York Times that obeying bad laws is not the same as acting ethically, and that the logic of the paper's criticism would condemn George Washington, while Einstein thanked him and said older people with little to lose should speak out.
“older people who have scarcely anything to lose ought to be willing to speak out on behalf of those who are young”
Jocko Willink argues that whether you like people is irrelevant to success, and that it is your responsibility to build a working relationship with difficult people because that relationship is what makes you effective.
“it's irrelevant if you don't like them or not”
Einstein's father wrote a humble letter to the physicist Ostwald asking him to read Einstein's paper and help him find an assistant position, but Ostwald never replied, although nine years later Ostwald nominated Einstein for the Nobel Prize.
“Ostwald still did not answer. However, he would become 9 years later, the first person to nominate Einstein for the Nobel Prize”
Einstein explained his mental accomplishments mainly through his curiosity, saying he had no special talents and was only passionately curious, and he aimed for simplicity and beauty in his theories.
“I have no special talents. I am only passionately curious”
Because his university lectures did not fit his interests, Einstein skipped classes and studied the masters of theoretical physics on his own, creating a personal curriculum that mattered more to his development than formal schooling.
“I played hooky a lot and study the masters of theoretical physics with a holy zeal at home”
Sam Walton argued that exercising your ego in public is not the way to build an effective organization, and the host adds that successful leaders keep ego as a source of confidence and drive but hide it rather than display it.
“exercising your ego in public is definitely not the way to build an effective organization”
Einstein's lectures used scribbled cards instead of prepared notes, so students watched him develop ideas live, and his friend judged him a poor teacher for lazy students who wanted to memorize but a first-class teacher for anyone who wanted to think.
“He is not a good teacher for mentally lazy gentleman who merely want to fill a notebook”
When a conventional physics result conflicted with an elegant theory, Einstein questioned the conventional wisdom rather than his theory, and his stubbornness was often rewarded, which James Dyson also credited as a virtue, celebrating the virtues of a mule.
“he was stubborn that he celebrated the virtues of a mule”
Einstein's difficulty getting hired was a people problem rather than a talent problem, and the host argues that selling yourself and your ideas is the most important job when success depends on collaboration.
“since the fact that we do need other humans to collaborate with other humans to be successful in the world that really sales is the most important job”
Older people who have little left to lose ought to speak out on behalf of younger people who face greater restraints, which is why Einstein spoke publicly against McCarthyism.
“Besides, I believe that older people who have scarcely anything to lose ought to be willing to speak out on behalf of those who are young and are subject to much greater restraints.”
Einstein's second marriage to Elsa, who managed his meals, travel and visitors and protected his periods of intense work, reflected his desire to outsource everything except thinking, which the host sees as revealing what was important to him.
“the need for keeping all disturbing elements away from him”
Einstein's independence and rebellion against received wisdom served him well as a scientist, but the same disposition made him disrespectful to people who could hire or recommend him, so traits that are strengths in one domain can be weaknesses in another and must be tempered.
“traits that are strengths in one domain and weaknesses in another”
Einstein wrote in a condolence letter that for believing physicists the distinction between past, present, and future is only a stubborn illusion, reflecting his view of death and time.
“the distinction between past, present, and future is only a stubborn illusion”
Einstein's proposed contract to his first wife Mileva demanded she keep his meals, laundry, and room, renounce personal relations, and avoid intimacy, showing the cold, business-like approach he applied to personal life.
“The personal aspects must be reduced to a tiny remnant”
Warren Buffett took a Dale Carnegie public speaking course and later volunteered to teach investing at a local night college, reasoning that he needed to communicate his ideas and work effectively with others.
“He winds up taking Dale Carnegie's course on public speaking.”
Einstein's physics professor Weber told prospective employers not to hire him, so Einstein was the only graduate in his section left without a job offer.
“Weber tells them, no, don't hire this guy”
When Einstein left Germany in December 1932 he told Elsa to take a good look at it because she would never see it again, and he later planned to return to Oxford but never saw Europe again in the remaining 22 years of his life.
“Einstein would never see Europe again”
Einstein later called his letter urging President Roosevelt to begin atomic weapons research his biggest regret, though he hedged that Germany with the bomb would have been much more dangerous.
“this is the letter that he writes to FDR, which Einstein later says was his biggest regret”
Einstein's friend and biographer wrote that his tenacity in sticking to a problem for years and returning to it again and again was the characteristic feature of his genius.
“His tenacity in sticking to a problem for years and returning to the problem, again and again, this is the characteristic feature of Einstein's genius”
Einstein was a militant pacifist who believed war stems from a biological imperative and that voluntary refusal was the only ethical response, but after Hitler took power he accepted that pacifism could not solve some threats and changed his position.
“I'm not only a pacifist, I'm a militant pacifist”
Weber, Einstein's main physics professor, gave poor references when employers checked, and Weber had developed such an allergy to Einstein that he preferred hiring engineering students over him as assistant.
“Weber tells them, no, don't hire this guy”
The book Freedom's Forge documents how quickly American industry was reorganized to produce weapons of war, and Patrick Collison recommended it to the host, who believes Collison studies how large organizations move rapidly.
“that entire book is about how quickly America's industry was reorganized to produce weapons of war”
Einstein and friends in Bern formed the Olympia Academy, meeting all night to discuss great thinkers' works, sometimes climbing mountains to watch sunrises, which the host presents as a model of self-designed learning.
“They dubbed themselves the Olympia Academy”
Einstein is associated with the atomic bomb largely through the E=mc2 formula even though he did not play a direct specific role in building it.
“he did not really play much of a role, at least specifically”
Einstein's divorce from his first wife separated him from his sons, which caused him deep emotional anguish; he later said that a man who avoided personal moments was devastated by losing daily contact with his children.
“The prospect of parting with his children was devastating to Einstein.”
Within days of Einstein's March 10, 1933 statement that he would not live in Germany under conditions lacking civil liberty, Nazis raided his Berlin apartment several times and confiscated his summer boat, showing how fast the situation changed.
“Look how fast things changed”
By age 12 Einstein taught himself geometry and algebra over a summer, proving theorems on his own and working alone for days until he found solutions, which the host presents as early evidence of his ability to focus on a goal.
“His parents bought him two textbooks in advance so that he could master them over summer vacation”
Humans do not like being criticized directly, so one should use an indirect approach when disagreeing with someone like Weber, and one does not need to voice disagreement to build a relationship.
“Humans don't like when you criticize them directly. You have to use an indirect approach”
Multiple successful executives, including Charles Kettering, Edwin Land, Warren Buffett, David Ogilvy, and Larry Ellison, have argued there is no such thing as group creativity and that new ideas come from individuals.
“They don't believe and some of them don't even mince by any means to say there is no such thing as group creativity”
In his final year Einstein reflected that life is a fleeting visit in a strange house, that growing old means losing intimate identification with the here and now, and that for physicists the distinction between past, present and future is only a stubborn illusion.
“the distinction between past, present, and future is only a stubborn illusion”
At an honorary dinner in a straw hat and informal suit, Einstein joked that Calvin would have burned the attendees at the stake for their sinful extravagance, and the man next to him never spoke to him again.
“He would have erected an enormous stake and had us all burnt for its sinful extravagance”
Dan Carlin argues that Hitler got power through charisma and rhetoric and is given more military credit than deserved, since Carlin believes few of the best German generals from either war would have been admitted to a room with him.
“people give him a lot more credit, in Dan's opinion, than he was”
Einstein's concentration was so deep that conversation in a noisy room stimulated rather than disturbed him, and he could withdraw into a problem regardless of surroundings.
“Even in a large noisy group, he could withdraw to the sofa, take a pen and paper in hand and lose himself so completely in the problem”
The Pestalozzi school had students reach their own conclusions through hands-on observation, intuition, conceptual thinking and visual imagery, avoiding rote drills and memorization, and Einstein agreed with this philosophy.
“Students should be allowed to reach their own conclusions”
Einstein refused a surgery to repair his ruptured aortic aneurysm, saying it was tasteless to prolong life artificially, that he had done his share, and that it was time to go.
“Einstein refused, it is tasteless to prolong life artificially. I have done my share. It's time to go”
Einstein said he was a lone traveler who never belonged wholeheartedly to his country, home, friends or family, and that he never lost a sense of distance and a need for solitude, despite his social responsibility.
“I am truly a lone traveler and have never belonged to my country”
Einstein repeated his earlier suggestion that scientists could be employed as lighthouse keepers so they could devote themselves undisturbed to thinking.
“scientists might be employed as lighthouse keepers so they could devote themselves undisturbed to thinking”
In America, Einstein became an enfant terrible because he could not keep silent or swallow everything that happened, and he took pride in the freedom to say whatever he felt.
“I've become kind of enfant terrible in my new homeland due to my inability to keep silent”
Einstein's oldest son Hans Albert wrote letters begging for Easter visits and a father again, showing the host's point that children do not care how successful their parents are and only want their time.
“I just think if you're coming for Easter, you're going to be here, and we'll have a Papa again”
Einstein felt guilt for the rest of his life about his father Hermann's death because his father never saw his son become more than a patent examiner, and the host ties this to Pat Riley's similar regret about his father missing his success.
“Einstein felt for the rest of his life a sense of guilt about that moment”
Charlie Munger warned that intense ideology turns your brain to cabbage, and the host applies this to Hitler's antisemitic laws, which drove away Nobel laureates and theoretical physicists from Germany.
“You need to avoid intense ideology because it turns your brain to cabbage”
Einstein stayed in Berlin for 17 years despite warnings and assassination threats, which the host notes was a striking change from the restless rebel who hopped from job to job and resisted restraint.
“He had once been a restless rebel who'd hop from job to job, insight to insight”
Einstein argued that teachers should be free to teach what they want and students free to choose their classes, and he opposed student revolutionaries who tried to impose new university rules.
“Teachers should be free to teach how and what they want and then that students should be free to select into the classes they want”
Einstein showed stubborn patience with scientific problems but impatience with personal entanglements, and when a theory conflicted with physics orthodoxy he questioned the orthodoxy instead of the theory.
“The stubborn patience that Einstein displayed when dealing with scientific problems was equaled by his impatience when dealing with personal entanglements”
WhatsApp co-founder Brian Acton was rejected by Facebook in 2009 during a job search and five years later sold WhatsApp to Facebook for $19 billion.
“they don't hire him in 2009. 5 years later, he winds up selling WhatsApp to Facebook for $19 billion”
Students at a university Einstein was trying to leave signed a petition to pay him more because he was such a good teacher, showing that the students being taught by him valued him even as others did not.
“they actually started a signed petition to pay Einstein more to prevent him from leaving”
Einstein threw away an invitation to an honorary doctorate written in Latin calligraphy because it seemed odd and impersonal, illustrating his disdain for formal convention.
“he threw it in the wastepaper basket. It was an invitation to receive an honorary doctorate”
When Nazis raided his summer cottage and confiscated his boat, Einstein joked that his summer house was honored by many guests, but none had any reason to break in, showing his wry detachment.
“My summer house was often honored by the presence of many guests”
When asked what the third world war would look like, Einstein said he did not know how it would be fought but could say that the fourth would be fought with rocks.
“I don't know how the third world war will be fought, he answered, But I can tell you what they will use in the fourth. Rocks”
Steve Jobs said after returning to Apple he wanted an A-player team like the one he admired in Pixar, and he modeled his role on J. Robert Oppenheimer's approach to recruiting the atom bomb team.
“My role model was J. Robert Oppenheimer”
Asked near the end of his life what schools should emphasize, Einstein said history teaching should discuss personalities who benefited mankind through independence of character and judgment, a view the host takes as a self-description.
“there should be extensive discussion of personalities who benefited mankind through independence of character and judgment”
Steve Jobs would learn from every experience and bring what he learned back to Apple, a habit the host cites as a reason to study how strong operators build on past lessons.
“he would learn from every experience and then bring everything he learned from every experience back to Apple”
Einstein's most important lifelong values were the dignity of the individual and protection of political and intellectual freedom, and he tested them when he tried to persuade student revolutionaries to free jailed deans.
“Basic to his thinking was that recognition of the dignity of the individual and the protection of political and intellectual freedom.”
Einstein said he would never give up living alone, which he described as an indescribable blessing, and he kept his own apartment even when he planned to marry Elsa.
“For I shall never give up the state of living alone, which has manifested itself as an indescribable blessing”
Einstein learned to temper his abrasive traits in later life, becoming tactful enough to pursue his goals against obstacles, though he never stopped having disagreeable opinions.
“later on in life, he learns. Obviously, he's smart and he stops doing this”
Tim Urban wrote that those rare people who dramatically change the world in a short time know something the rest of us do not, so studying their biographies offers valuable lessons.
“Those people know something the rest of us don't, and we can learn something valuable from them”
Although biographies usually reveal a subject's essence after roughly 20 hours of reading, the host felt Einstein kept a wall between himself and the reader, so he understood Einstein's thinking but not the person behind it.
“I don't feel that with Einstein”
When offered a desk at Princeton, Einstein asked for a large wastebasket so he could throw away his mistakes, which the host presents as a sign of his comfort with trial and error.
“a large wastebasket, so I can throw away all my mistakes”
After lunch with Winston Churchill in 1933, Einstein judged that British leaders were preparing to rearm Germany's threat and would act soon, an assessment Isaacson calls the product of someone who had just eaten lunch with Churchill.
“It became clear to me that these people have made preparations and are determined to act resolutely and soon.”