#113 A.G. Gaston (Black Titan and the Making of a Black American Millionaire)
What this covers
This Founders episode follows David Senra as he works through a biography of A.G. Gaston. It moves from Gaston's boyhood in Alabama and his schooling at the Tuggle Institute, under Granny Tuggle's demand for excellence, through service in France and a mine job, and then to the businesses that made him rich. Senra keeps pairing Gaston with Benjamin Franklin and Booker T. Washington, whose autobiography Gaston reread and copied. A Franklin aside, about bread and water supplying more strength than beer, becomes a short case for reasoning from first principles over reasoning by analogy.
The business sequence is the core. At about ten, Gaston charged buttons for rides on a swing. Later came box lunches, peanuts and popcorn, and loans to coworkers at 25 cents on the dollar, which let him save 66 to 75 percent of his earnings. Then he started a burial society, collected door to door at about 25 cents a week. He kept his mine job while agents handled solicitation, and he later bought the funeral home that served his policyholders. Senra reads this through Find a Need and Fill It, and notes that Gaston's approach stalled until he began asking what the community needed. The Booker T. Washington Business College followed in 1939.
The episode turns contested where Gaston's politics appear. He held that civil rights activists could not seek equality while begging from the people they opposed, and that without economic power equality is only a catchphrase. Senra also argues that people inevitably copy others, so they should choose to copy the best minds through biographical modeling.
A.G. Gaston climbed from grandson of slaves to a $130 million fortune through relentless self-discipline, frugality, and building businesses that filled concrete community needs, and the host argues these traits are reproducible by studying great biographies.
- Gaston repeatedly chose demand-driven ventures (box lunches, lending, burial insurance) over product creation after losing money on his own soda.
- Industry and frugality, modeled on Benjamin Franklin and Booker T. Washington, let him save 66-75% of earnings and compound them.
- The host argues people inevitably copy, so they should copy the most effective figures from biography.
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Benjamin Franklin argued from first principles that the strength from beer comes only from the flour in the barley, so a pennyworth of bread with water would provide more strength than a quart of beer, which the other workers ignored.
“That there was more flour in a pennyworth of bread, and therefore, if he would eat that with a pint of water, it would give him more strength than a quart of beer.”
Gaston started a burial society charging about 25 cents a week, collected door to door, to replace church fundraising for funerals and the large bills families faced after a death, targeting a need in the black community that white morticians often ignored or served poorly.
“what he realizes is like, well, why don't we just have burial insurance. Like, I think he starts charging $0.25 a week”
Franklin, working as a printer, argued that a pint of beer gave less strength than the flour equivalent of bread and water, and Senra says this kind of first-principles reasoning sets a person apart, which he sees as parallel to Gaston's frugality.
“That there was more flour in a pennyworth of bread, and therefore, if he would eat that with a pint of water, it would give him more strength than a quart of beer.”
Gaston read Booker T. Washington's autobiography repeatedly and copied his emphasis on work, merit, and economic self-improvement as the foundation for how he lived.
“His endless thumbing through his copy of Washington's autobiography, Up from Slavery, had inspired him to action and taught him crucial lessons.”
At about age 10, Gaston charged buttons for rides on the only sturdy swing in his neighborhood, turning social isolation into a business that won back his friends and became the template for his later trademark approach of finding a need and filling it.
“He would turn his swing into a business venture, charging a button for a ride. This first endeavor was a resounding success, and it came to form the backbone of what would be Gaston's trademark for business development.”
Gaston believed that civil rights activists could not fight for equality while begging from the same people they were fighting, and that power came from economic power, a view that met criticism but that he held until he died.
“We cannot fight and beg from those we fight at the same time.”
After the insurance business grew, Gaston bought the funeral home that performed the services his insured customers paid for, eliminating the middleman and capturing a larger share of net gains and control over profit-and-loss margins.
“He eliminated the middleman and freed up a greater share of the net gains for himself.”
Without economic power, equality becomes merely a catchphrase for rights that are guaranteed on paper but never fully accessible, and Gaston never believed there was any route up other than economic success.
“Without economic power, equality becomes merely a catchphrase for rights guaranteed, but never fully accessible.”
Gaston's time in France, where Black soldiers were treated as men, reinforced Booker T. Washington's teaching that merit, not color, was the fulcrum of success, leading Gaston to return home to build conditions in Alabama instead of staying abroad.
“Start at home. The experience in France had only served to make Gaston more certain of the fact that Dr. Washington had been right to believe that merit, not color, was the fulcrum point on which a successful life was balanced.”
Once Gaston had a financial foundation, he lent money to coworkers at 25 cents on the dollar, and with little competition for his services his wealth snowballed, compounding biweekly as the men spent their wages on luxuries.
“he began lending money out to his coworkers at a rate of $0.25 on the dollar.”
Most humans reason by analogy, which is copying; first-principles reasoning is rare and laborious, so people inevitably rely on heuristics borrowed from others, and the host argues they should choose to copy the greatest entrepreneurial minds through biography.
“Most of the time, we're reasoning by analogy, which is another way to say, we're copying.”
The book argues Gaston picked funeral-related insurance because it had proven potential for growth and an untapped population of prospective customers, not because it was a fortuitous accident.
“A. G. picked an area of business that had a proven potential for growth and in which he had a bead on untapped population of prospective customers.”
Gaston's advice that a young person should keep their eyes open, study the people around them, and ask how they live, what makes them tick, and what they need, is a method of situational awareness for spotting business opportunity.
“A young person should keep his eyes open. They should study the people around them. How do they live? What makes them tick? What do they need?”
Gaston's core business rule was to find a need and fill it: he avoided creating new products that required heavy production costs before any sale, and instead let customer demand reveal his next opportunity.
“He had, as he liked to say, found a need and filled it.”
When Gaston's own business approach stalled because no new markets were opening, he realized his methodology was the problem and shifted to asking what the community needed, a turn away from self-interest toward public service that shaped his later business.
“It was a turn, in his mind, away from self-interest and toward public service, and the change was one that would inform his business endeavors for the rest of his life.”
Franklin's two defining traits, industry and frugality, are mirrored in Gaston, who worked constantly on self-improvement and saved the fruits of his labor, and over decades this turned a grandson of slaves into a $130 million net worth.
“He was industry, which is essentially willing to work, willing to focus on self-improvement, willing to do the work necessary to improve my life and save the fruits of that labor.”
The burial society satisfied Gaston's two conditions for investing in any business: it met a genuine community need and offered a real opportunity to accumulate wealth, which is why he named it after Booker T. Washington.
“The burial society as a concept fulfilled the two major conditions Gaston required before he could invest in any business: It met a genuine need in the community and offered a real opportunity for him to accumulate wealth.”
Gaston initially kept his mine job while building the burial insurance business and hired agents to take over solicitation calls, capping his downside risk until the new business was a foregone conclusion.
“Initially uncertain of the burial society's soundness, he held on to his job at the mines while trying to extend membership in the society”
Gaston founded the Booker T. Washington Business College in 1939 because applicants lacked basic office skills, and the school became a self-sustaining business that trained people for jobs across the community.
“It didn't take long for Gaston to realize that the only way to ensure that his employees were properly trained was to educate them himself.”
Senra says Franklin's autobiography deserves reading, since Franklin's habits of reasoning and frugality are the kind of practice that puts a person ahead of nearly everyone in history.
“If you're able to maintain a habit of reasoning from first principles, that puts you ahead of probably 99% of all humans that have ever lived.”
Gaston built wealth slowly by securing one income source and using it to fund the next, combining box lunches, peanuts and popcorn, and loans, so that multiple small streams compounded into a financial base.
“this is how like you just got to grab onto your first opportunity, not let it go, and then you can use that to build on to the second, the third, to fourth.”
Gaston's time at the Tuggle Institute, which taught that life was about work modeled on Booker T. Washington, plus Granny Tuggle's relentless demand for excellence, instilled a self-pressure that became central to his character.
“Life, they were taught would be about work, after the model of Booker T. Washington.”
Gaston saved between 66% and 75% of his earnings monthly, a rate impossible on a mine salary alone but achievable when combined with his multiple income streams.
“A. G. was saving between 66% and 75% of his earnings on a monthly basis.”
Everyone experiences self-doubt and hopelessness; the difference between people who succeed and those who fail is that successful people keep persisting while failures quit and shrink, and Gaston's relentlessness was the key trait.
“The difference between people that succeed, and that fail are the people that -- that feeling is inevitable, right? The people that fail, quit, they become smaller.”
After losing his partner Dad Smith and his wife Creola within six months, Gaston did not dwell on grief; he buried himself in work, treating regret and dissatisfaction as luxuries he could not afford, a pattern of focusing only on what he could control.
“As if regret and dissatisfaction were luxuries he could either not afford or simply refused to brook.”
Seeing a growing black middle class in Birmingham of doctors, lawyers, and architects convinced Gaston that he could not only work in a store but own one, shifting his aspirations from employment to ownership.
“It allowed him to believe that not only could he work in a store, he might be able to own it.”
The mining company charged workers large markups on housing, food, and goods deducted from wages, leaving them with no money at week's end and unable to quit, which the host calls slavery in another name.
“they like overcharge, essentially, you can -- you show up, they'll give you a job, they'll give you housing, and they'll sell you food and everything else, but it's a huge markup and it's taken out of your paycheck.”
Gaston noticed a coworker happily eating his mother Rosie's food when he himself did not want it, and realized men would pay for these meals, launching a box lunch business that he later extended to peanuts and popcorn.
“Art smiled right back, realizing he had found is business. Men would pay for these meals, he thought.”
Surviving extreme experiences such as WWI combat builds confidence, because a person who has survived one of the worst things that can happen to them gains a deep belief that they can handle future hardship.
“when you go through these hard trying experiences and you survive, you adapt and you overcome, you're going to -- he's building confidence”
In his office Gaston kept a placard reading THINK, and he committed to becoming the best businessman he could be by studying profit-and-loss statements, keeping records, watching investments, and demanding topflight performance from employees.
“I learned to quickly digest a profit and loss statement. I realized the great importance of keeping good records, and I was scrupulous about detailed accuracy.”
Like Gaston, Andrew Carnegie started poor, earning $1.20 a week as a bobbin boy, began in railroad investments, and moved into steel, then sold his company to JPMorgan in 1901 for roughly $500 million.
“earning as little as $1.20 a week as a bobbin boy in a cotton factory.”
Gaston founded a hotel in Birmingham because black travelers had nowhere to stay, and Martin Luther King Jr. stayed there when he visited, though Gaston and King differed in views on tactics given their age gap.
“Martin Luther King, when he came to Birmingham, would stay at the hotel that A. G. founded. And A. G. founded that hotel because black travelers had no place to stay.”
Gaston lost a great deal of money manufacturing his own soda after he was already wealthy, and that loss made him avoid ventures that require heavy production costs before they can be sold.
“He winds up -- later on when he's already wealthy, winds up losing a great deal of money trying to manufacture his own soda.”
Black veterans returning from WWI found that Alabama's racist society did not honor their service, and many suffered depression, PTSD, drug and alcohol abuse, and hopelessness.
“they came back and the racist people, especially in Alabama and the Deep South, they didn't care that you fought. They still treated you like animals.”
Beyond his businesses, Gaston started a bank and taught other black people to invest in real estate and avoid spending foolishly, acting as an educator who passed on the lessons of his experience.
“That's why he started a bank, started teaching other black people to invest in real estate, to not spend their money foolishly.”
Gaston's father died working on railroad construction and his mother had to leave her son to seek work in a larger city, because the only skills available in their small town were in excess there; the shift from land-based farming to industrial labor left families displaced.
“His father would die for the promise of the industrial age, and, partly as a result of this, his mother would be forced to leave him behind as she, too, attempted to build a life away from the land.”
Senra notes that Gaston's pivot to mining work was driven by the fact that mining was one of the few decently paying jobs open to Black men in the South at the time, since few others wanted the labor.
“the only decent paying job for a black man in the South at this time was in the mines, backbreaking labor.”
Senra notes Gaston's story parallels Andrew Carnegie's, since both were born poor and began in low-paying jobs before finding wealth in heavy industry, though Carnegie's rise was much faster.
“like much like industrial giant Andrew Carnegie before him, he would find the beginnings of his wealth in the steel mill.”
Carnegie sold his Pittsburgh steel company to JPMorgan in 1901 for almost $500 million after building a business that produced four million tons of steel a year by 1890.
“In 1901, Carnegie sold his company to JPMorgan for almost $0.5 billion.”
Gaston named his insurance company the Booker T. Washington Burial Society as a public reminder of the dedication to industry Washington advocated, which he believed could raise the economic position of Black Americans.
“Hanging Washington's name on his business was a not-so-subtle reminder, to himself and everyone else who saw or heard it, of what dedication to task might accomplish.”
Washington taught Gaston that when opportunity knocks you should open the door and invite it to tea, a lesson Gaston applied by taking action on opportunities as they came.
“One of these lessons is when opportunity knocks, open the door, and invite him to tea.”
By acquiring the New Grace Hill Cemetery and the Mason City Cemetery in 1951, Gaston completed vertical integration of the death business, controlling burial insurance, preparation of bodies, and interment.
“Gaston can now control every level of the business of dying from preparation to interment.”
Gaston learned in the Army to respect authority and discipline: after a superior's blow to his face for an excuse, he chose to stand at attention and say 'Yes sir' rather than complain or desert, a lesson he regarded as having saved his life.
“He did neither. Instead he picked himself up off the ground and stood at attention before the officer, offering a simple but firm, 'Yes sir,' as his response.”
Reading biographies repeatedly is a powerful source of inspiration, and drawing on the life stories of others is hardwired into human nature, which is why so many people across history have done it.
“I also think it speaks to the power of reading biographies over and over again. And why I feel that go throughout history, why so many people draw inspiration from the life stories of others. I just think it's in our DNA.”
Gaston's emphasis on economic self-improvement over direct civil rights action drew heavy criticism, as did Booker T. Washington's similar doctrine, and the host argues that neither answer is the only right one.
“he got a lot, a lot of criticism for. But again, he shaped -- everybody shaped through their own unique experiences”
Gaston's emphasis on economic self-help over direct political action drew criticism from some as foolish, a criticism Senra notes was also directed at Booker T. Washington, though others benefited from his education and investment teaching.
“Some people criticize him for it. Some people thought it was foolish. Other people listened”
Gaston concluded that nothing would change unless he acted, and that success comes from doing something to make it happen rather than contemplating whether one will succeed.
“You didn't get successful by thinking about whether you're going to be successful or not. You got successful by doing something to make yourself successful.”
Gaston died at 103 with a fortune well over $130 million, built from a business empire spanning communications, real estate, and insurance that grew from his early small-scale enterprises.
“A. G. Gaston died more than a century later with a fortune well over $130 million and a business empire spanning communications, real estate, and insurance.”
Gaston never complained or shared his problems, adopting an extreme self-reliance he drew from Washington's autobiography and from surviving war, and kept that discipline throughout his life.
“He never complained. He didn't share his problems with other people. He said, this is my life. I'm a believer in extreme self-reliance.”
Gaston's relentlessness, running into obstacle after obstacle with a singular focus, is a trait the host admires and compares to Jeff Bezos, who once wanted to name Amazon Relentless.
“Jeff Bezos wanted to initially name Amazon Relentless. In fact, he owns relentless.com to this day”
Gaston's family remembered him for his high expectations and insistence that excellence was the only option, mirroring the way Granny Tuggle held him to a standard, and the host suggests this inspired people to aim big.
“There were no excuses in his house. He made it clear that excellence was the only option.”
Gaston's mother Rosie, a cook and maid, left him in Demopolis to seek work and later earned enough to bring him to Birmingham, and her labor became his motivation to build a life that would spare her from working.
“It began to disturb him, Gaston would write, to see how hard his mother was forced to work to keep the family afloat.”
Senra says he does not fight human nature but routes around it, and would have chosen to stay in France rather than return, which he presents as his personal operating system.
“I don't try to fight against human nature. I try to route around it.”
Gaston rarely revealed negative emotion in his autobiography, presenting events with a positive spin, which Senra interprets as a personality that treated regret as a luxury.
“He was a man who recounted events without betraying much sentiment of the negative sort.”