What this covers

This episode strings together several practitioners' views on how to think about crypto assets, with Ari Paul, Olaf Carlson-Wee, Naval Ravikant, Josh Seims, Jordan Cooper, and Jeremiah Lowin among the voices. It starts with mechanics: the sequence from a SAFT to a crowd sale to exchange listing, and a token as a right to use a protocol, illustrated with an email analogy. Ari sketches the universe. Over 1,000 coins exist, about 100 trade with real liquidity, and roughly 25 look like real projects.

The sharpest disagreements are over value. Patrick relays the Fat Protocol Thesis, in which protocols capture more value than the apps built on them. Naval doubts that tokens will ever capture enough to compensate investors, citing regulation, scams, and high money velocity. Jordan runs a bottom-up utility valuation of Ethereum, finds under $1 billion of current usage, and argues that Bitcoin is protected from this analysis because it has no utility to measure. Jeremiah says trillion-dollar outcomes are improbable and that investing can be justified only by beliefs about other investors.

The rest covers strategy and technical limits. Josh describes a use-case bucket portfolio and the value of reading source code over white papers. Ari treats small-cap tokens as call options. Jordan prefers a few likely survivors to indexing. Olaf discusses throughput limits and the layer-2 and sharding proposals meant to address them. Josh covers the difficulty of getting real-world data onto a chain, and Ari explains XRP's bid to replace SWIFT. Naval proposes three criteria for well-designed protocols.

Sharpest takeaway

Cryptocurrency investing is not one asset class with one playbook: tokens behave differently from equity, currency, and commodities, so returns depend on which stage and strategy an investor uses, and most projects will fail.

  • Tokens grant rights to use a protocol rather than ownership of a company, so equity-style valuation fails
  • Early-stage, infrastructure, and trading strategies each require different edges, and most projects are expected to go to zero
  • Value may accrue to token holders (fat protocol thesis), but entry prices and entry-stage risk are very high

The argument · threads2 threads · 72 claims
0.85

Crypto investment is justified by investor beliefs or technical analysis, not intrinsic technology value.

2 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Investing in cryptocurrency is justified only by behavioral beliefs about other investors or by technical analysis, not by belief in the intrinsic value of the technology, because valuable technologies do not automatically make stable investments, as venture capital shows.

    “anyone who's investing in these things for any reason other than behavioral beliefs about the other people who are investing in them”

  • Multi-trillion-dollar valuations rely on coins taking market share from traditional currency as a store of value, but that outcome is improbable and the investor must also bet that the coin wins and accrues trillion-dollar value, so a $100 billion valuation is not justified by a 10% discount.

    “So you're making two bets. You're betting that people will use it as a store of value”

0.29

A blockchain needs its coin to have only modest value, enough to incentivize participation.

1 pointcentrality 2/5
  • A blockchain requires its native coin to have value only large enough to incentivize participation, perhaps just above the electricity cost of running the mining machine, so the coin does not need massive value to keep the network functioning.

    “It's only required to have value large enough to incent activity.”