What this covers

Patrick interviews Ted Seides, an allocator who talks through his time around Yale and his work at Protégé, about how hedge funds get chosen, priced, and launched. The conversation runs from industry economics to fees to the mechanics of backing new managers. Patrick keeps returning to the zero-sum contest for excess return, where manager talent is converging while fees rise.

Fees get the most sustained attention. Ted calls them a clearing price and walks through Yale's early-1990s cost-of-capital hurdle, when a strategy earning 4% over cash could not justify a 20% incentive fee. He also argues, against the simple "fees are too high" line, that 6% can be excellent alpha in a zero-rate world. That claim is contested. He is harder on long-only managers: a fund that is about 90% market return and charges 80 basis points is paying roughly 70 basis points for 1% of active return. Patrick adds the closet-indexer arithmetic and wonders whether smart beta is another rent-capturing device. Ted also explains why fees stay put: investors choose on perceived quality, and managers build cost bases around existing revenue.

The rest covers where hedge funds still earn their place. Ted discusses the subprime shorts, including John Paulson's fund, the structural drag on dedicated short sellers, and the rebalancing problem that shrinks a short book as it pays off. He then turns to seeding as an option on young managers, where being a price maker matters. He ranks which seeds are most and least useful, treats operational failures as symptoms, and explains why he has moved away from David Swensen's ownership ideal.

Sharpest takeaway

Seides argues the hedge fund industry has become structurally harder to launch and less rewarding for allocators, because abundant capital, zero interest rates, and sticky fee structures let managers keep high fees for shrinking true alpha, so allocators must price skill, capacity, and cost of capital explicitly.

  • Required returns on hedge fund portfolios fell as pensions bolted hedge funds onto beta exposure, so fees now go unchallenged against the cost of capital
  • Fee structures are sticky because of investor inertia, embedded relationships, and managers' cost bases built around existing revenue
  • Seeding works as an option on early-stage managers, but its value depends on the seeder's early access and ability to set terms

The argument · threads4 threads · 78 claims
0.85

Hedge funds charge rising fees for converging talent, leaving investors overpaying for uncertain alpha.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • A closet index fund with 70 percent overlap with the S&P charging 30 basis points effectively charges approaching 1 percent on its active portion, and smart beta may be the industry's way of capturing more rent on invested assets.

    “the fee that's being charged on the active portion is a lot higher than it looks at the stated management fee level.”

  • Hedge fund managers resemble growth stocks: because the most talented, charismatic managers have the greatest potential upside, investors overpay for them, and as a group allocators are unlikely to outearn the fees relative to a low-cost S&P 500 index fund.

    “It sounds to me like a growth stock, in a small group versus a public company.”

  • Because of the paradox of skill, relative manager talent is becoming more uniform while fees rise, so investors pay more for a lower probability of achieving the excess return hedge funds promise, and this is a zero-sum competition for alpha.

    “what matters is not an absolute skill but the competitive landscape, how talented are these managers relative to one another? Because it's in some ways a zero sum game.”

  • Investors consistently overpay for growth, and the psychology behind that, linked to hope springing eternal, will likely always sustain the hedge fund world, since hedge funds offer the most talented managers with potentially outsized upside.

    “I wonder if there's some of this that will always sustain, the same psychology that will always sustain the hedge fund world.”

0.43

Fee and incentive structures should be redesigned to align managers with long-term investors, like Vanguard's.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Patrick proposed carving off part of fees into a side vehicle invested on the investor's behalf, vesting over time like reverse vesting, to encourage patience; Ted considered it a better version of his idea but expects it to be too small for a long time to notice.

    “what if you took the discount at each stage, carved it off, and put it in some sort of side vehicle”

  • Patrick believes Vanguard's mutual structure, in which funds own the management company, is one of the most genius arrangements because it perfectly aligns incentives for long-term investors, and asks whether hedge funds could adopt similar thinking.

    “one of the most genius things that they did obviously was this mutual structure where the funds own the company.”

0.29

Market conditions and pedigree halos can mislead judgments about investing skill.

2 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Zero interest rates and a perpetual bid for risk assets have removed the value investor's opportunity to buy at distressed prices after over-corrections, which explains the historically bad recent run for value investing, although this is hard to confirm.

    “the fed's actions, zero interest rates in general, a perpetual bid that's been created in risk assets, has removed what worked about value investing”

  • Apparent success of people who leave big institutions can reflect the halo of their former employer, as with Marissa Mayer leaving Google for Yahoo, so pedigree may overstate personal ability.

    “you often find people whose success in hindsight seems to be as much because of the institution that they were a part of before as their own personal abilities.”

0.15

Success depends on a mindset change and blind faith in stepping into the unknown.

2 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Dale Carnegie's How to Win Friends and Influence People works through ego destruction and many small good deeds that accumulate into large results, which requires a mindset change that the reader must buy into to make it work, as a habit rather than a diet.

    “it's basically one of ego destruction and lots of small good deeds adding up to something really big over time”

  • Joseph Campbell's monomyth describes a common hero storyline across mythologies, including the stage of crossing a threshold into an unknown world, which George Lucas drew on for Star Wars, and Patrick suggests stepping into the unknown with blind faith.

    “he called it the monomyth, the same exact storyline that is the undercurrent of all these major myths”