What this covers

Patrick interviews John Rogers of Ariel Investments about how a value shop runs day to day and how Rogers has built its people. Rogers separates process, meaning thorough and consistent research, from edge, meaning the willingness to look years past what competitors see. Manager evaluation recurs throughout. Ariel checks whether executives deliver their stated plan quarter after quarter and own mistakes without excuses, and it relies on a Circle of Competence in its sectors to tell honest teams from weak ones. After a failed investment, the team re-reads its own research in a Post-Mortem Review.

The middle of the conversation is about Capital Allocation and mispricing. Patrick cites his quantitative work: buybacks at expensive prices destroy value, and heavy capex and acquisition spending marks "empire builders" (a contested claim). Rogers argues that buybacks help only when shares trade well below Intrinsic Value. He adds that strong brands don't guarantee a durable moat, citing Blockbuster and BlackBerry. He recalls trying to buy at Maximum Pessimism during the 1987 crash, and he points to stocks written off at about $2 that later traded near $50. Two of his more contested views are that ETFs are creating more mispricing and that value investing endures because acting independently is hard. He also argues that JLL and CBRE are still priced like their crisis-era selves, and that David Dreman deserves more credit for pioneering Behavioral Finance.

The last stretch turns to talent and diversity. Rogers says finance has not become more diverse, and he argues that institutional clients such as endowments and pension boards must demand change. He describes Ariel's pipeline through the University of Chicago Lab School and its urban school partnerships, and how his Princeton volunteering led to Mellody Hobson and Danny Kahneman.

Sharpest takeaway

Rogers argues Ariel's edge comes from a consistent, repeatable research process combined with long-term ownership, which lets the firm look past temporary bad news, and that the hard-to-teach traits behind this are built early and sustained through deep institutional networks.

  • Long-term ownership and talking to management about 3-7 year plans lets Ariel see recovery that the market misses
  • Value investing's edge persists because executing it requires independent thinking, which most investors lack
  • Traits like independence and courage are largely formed early, so talent is best sourced through long-running institutional relationships

The argument · threads2 threads · 66 claims
0.85

Capital allocation quality is an underappreciated way to find great companies.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Patrick reports that companies with the largest percentage increases in capital spending and acquisition goodwill have tended to underperform, which he presents as one of the best ways to avoid companies, which he calls empire builders.

    “the companies that have the largest ramp up in CapEx have tended to underperform and acquisitions goodwill have tended to go on to underperform”

  • Capital allocation quality is an understudied and underappreciated way to find great companies, and Rogers is one of the first to emphasize it as a key part of the value equation.

    “capital allocation as a key part of the value equation, and I think that that is an understudied and underappreciated way of finding great companies”

  • Per Patrick's quantitative work, buybacks executed at expensive prices relative to the market destroy value and underperform, while buybacks at discounts versus peers tend to outperform significantly.

    “companies that buy back at expensive prices relative to the market destroy value, do very badly versus the market”

  • The shrinking average tenure of public company CEOs and the quarterly earnings focus on Wall Street make it hard for management incentives to align with horizons of three to five years or more.

    “the decline in the average tenure for CEOs of public companies”

0.29

Relationships and client allocator pressure meaningfully shape an investor's thinking and firm.

2 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Patrick reports that a client board recently asked his firm pointed questions about its diversity while reviewing the org chart, and that hearing this directly from allocators is far more impactful than general pressure.

    “They said, 'Okay, we want to get a sense for your diversity, your people'”

  • Building a quality network of people can be the best investment one makes, because a single relationship such as Mellody Hobson can have an outsized impact on a firm and on how an investor's thinking is shaped.

    “I'm always struck by the nonlinear payoffs of networking”