What this covers
Joanna Robinson walks Matt and Dom through the history of Marvel Studios, starting before the films existed. Marvel was then largely a toy business licensing its characters, and Ike Perlmutter saw movies mainly as advertising for merchandise. Its best-known heroes were optioned out characters: X-Men at Fox, Spider-Man at Sony, Hulk at Universal. The studio therefore had to launch with B-list names. The financing story is central: David Maisel raised roughly $400 million through the Merrill Lynch deal, which set a clock for repayment. He also found a contract loophole that let Marvel keep using the Hulk.
The middle of the conversation is about people and process. Kevin Feige is credited with a diplomat's skill at staying on good terms with feuding executives and with an outsider's approach that made the films accessible to newcomers. Jon Favreau probably drove the early push on VFX. The connected universe is described as a background option that became strategy only after early hits, a point Robinson treats as contested. Feige's advice to other studios, Walk Before You Run, comes with the claim that most studios skip it. The Disney acquisition appears as a bid for full ownership and marketing muscle, with Bob Iger promising Pixar-style independence.
The last stretch covers the slide. Robinson cites Gravity of Scale, the Disney+ content mandate, COVID, departing stars, and Chadwick Boseman's death. She also points to television built on a film model, and she rejects the claim that Marvel had no post-Endgame plan. Wider changes in moviegoing and Hollywood's dependence on familiar IP complicate any blame on Marvel alone. She calls Secret Invasion genuinely terrible but thinks declaring Marvel finished is premature.
Joanna Robinson argues Marvel's success came from a rare alignment of creative leadership, contract engineering, and a deliberate walk-before-you-run sequencing strategy, and that its recent decline reflects dilution and outside shocks as much as creative failure.
- Kevin Feige's relationship-building and blockbuster storytelling sense were the central differentiator, ahead of the characters themselves
- David Maisel's Merrill Lynch financing and Hulk loophole structured the company so Marvel could build a shared universe
- The decline came from Disney+ over-expansion, COVID, and losing key actors, not from a single creative failure
Sequenced franchise building, not rushed shared universes or familiar IP alone, drove Marvel's success.
- Maisel's sequel-and-familiarity idea became the MCU design, in which films are not all direct sequels but function as one long sequelized story, and Avengers: Endgame paid off that strategy.
“through Avengers: Endgame was essentially one long sequelized story, and that paid off.”
- Universal's Dark Universe failed because it tried to launch a shared franchise with a group photo of stars before making the individual films succeed, which is the opposite of the sequencing Feige advised.
“My favorite example of this will always be the Dark Universe soft launch that Universal did”
- Warner Bros. pushed Zack Snyder toward a Justice League team-up before the individual Superman and Batman films were established, and a slower, steadier build might have worked better for the DC films.
“if they had done that much slower, steadier pace towards their team-up movie, that would have worked out better.”
- Feige's advice to other studios is to walk before you run: make a good Iron Man, Captain America, and Thor film before attempting an Avengers film, and most studios fail by skipping this step.
“You have to make a good Iron Man movie and a good Captain America movie and a good Thor movie before you can make an Avengers movie.”
- Familiar IP does not guarantee success; the Captain America and Iron Man films succeeded because the films had heart and emotional investment, and Warner Bros. and DC's Snyderverse shows that well-known characters still fail without quality.
“you have to actually execute it with heart and get us to emotionally invest in those characters. You can't just give us action figures to smash against each other.”
- In Hollywood a sequel almost always makes as much as, or more than, the original because audiences who saw the first film at home are familiar with it, so familiar IP lowers the perceived risk for studios relative to new original properties.
“a sequel will almost always make as much as, if not more than the original movie in the franchise. That's just a rule of Hollywood.”
- Early Marvel leaders kept the cross-pollinated universe as a possibility rather than a certainty, with Nick Fury at the end of Iron Man and Tony Stark in Hulk meant as fan Easter eggs, not a declared plan.
“Nick Fury showing up at the end of Iron Man wasn't this big declaration of intent. It was meant as a little treat for hardcore comic book fans.”
- Avi Arad's claim to have pitched the connected MCU idea is not corroborated by anyone else at Marvel, and Joanna considers him a fabulist, so credit for the idea likely belongs to David Maisel and Kevin Feige.
“Avi claims that he pitched this in this year, and then you can't find a single person at Marvel to corroborate that story.”
Feige's diplomacy and storytelling were indispensable, though corporate mandates rushed the pacing.
- Kevin Feige is the single most important ingredient in Marvel's success, ranked ahead of the actors, the characters, and the VFX technology, because he is the eye of the needle through which the entire MCU passes.
“There's a reason I rank Kevin Feige #1 because I think without his creative genius and without him existing as this eye of the needle that all of the MCU passes through, you don't get what you get.”
- Feige's diplomatic skill let him stay on good terms with rival executives Avi Arad and David Maisel, who despised each other, so he never had to take a side and rose quickly through the ranks.
“If you talk to Avi Arad or David Maisel, who hated each other and were at loggerheads the whole time that they were coexisting at Marvel, but they both love Kevin.”
- Feige's gift for blockbuster storytelling came from childhood moviegoing, when he took notes on Amblin and late-70s and 80s blockbusters rather than collecting comics, and he effectively built his own film school after failing to get into film school repeatedly.
“instead of collecting comics as a kid, he was just constantly going to the movie theater, literally taking his notebook and taking notes on the Amblin movies”
- Feige's outside-looking-in approach to comic book storytelling made the MCU films more accessible to people coming to superhero stories for the first time, which some colleagues who grew up on comics believed the franchise would not have achieved under an insider.
“they're not sure the MCU would have been as successful if it were run by someone who was too far inside that world”
- Edward Norton's push for final cut and a moody, psychologically intense Hulk made his version incompatible with the shared universe, leading Feige to publicly distance Marvel from him.
“He's trying to have final cut. He wants a real moody, psychologically intense Hulk”
- Feige was by temperament a slow, methodical storyteller, but after Disney's content mandate and Bob Chapek's investor event, his careful pacing was overridden, forcing announcements of projects not yet ready and creating rushed output.
“he was not in charge of the pace that slow, methodical, quality control that they had before was ripped out of his hands”
- Marvel's internal Kevincon event, where Feige gained control and introduced Chadwick Boseman as T'Challa, was a key moment in which Feige championed Black Panther despite executives doubting it could turn a profit.
“Marvel people don't think we can turn a profit on a Black Panther movie”
- Kevin Feige's rise came from diplomatic relationship-building that avoids burning bridges, from being an outsider to comics who studied 1980s and 1990s blockbusters like Back to the Future and Star Wars, and from creative storytelling sense, not just relationships.
“instead of collecting comics as a kid, he was just constantly going to the movie theater, literally taking his notebook and taking notes on the Amblin movies”
- The connected MCU was not planned from the start; it was a background possibility that Feige and Maisel kept open, and it became a deliberate strategy only after Iron Man and its successors performed well enough to justify it.
“I think they had it as a possibility. I think when Feige says at Comic-Con... that's on their minds, but not a certainty until those individual installments start doing as well as they do.”
- Joss Whedon and Jeph Loeb launched Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. for television, prompting Feige to respond that S.H.I.E.L.D. is now HYDRA in the films, a retort that shows the internal rivalry over the franchise's story.
“S.H.I.E.L.D. is HYDRA now in our movies. So good luck with your little show.”
- Marvel had to launch its cinematic universe with B-list characters because its A-list properties were optioned to other studios: X-Men to Fox, Spider-Man to Sony, and Hulk to Universal.
“the reason Marvel has to launch the MCU with the B list is because their A-list, X-Men, Fantastic Four, Spider-Man have all been optioned out to other studios.”
Marvel's slump reflects market forces and external shocks more than Marvel's own overexpansion.
- Marvel's decline is partly a natural gravity effect: the bigger a franchise grows, the harder it is to keep nailing it, and the Disney+ mandate to expand from three or four films a year into many films and TV shows diluted the brand.
“we can't undersell how important the Disney+ era, the Bob Iger mandate for content, the insistence that Marvel ramp up from making 3 to 4 movies a year”
- After Bob Iger returned to Disney, he announced that the company would do less and drill down on what works, a plan aimed at slowing output and rehabilitating the brand.
“Guess what guys, we're going to do less. We're going to drill down on what's working”
- Marvel's box office decline reflects broader forces, including COVID, streaming and home theater, binge culture, and the rise of spectacle-driven international demand, so blaming Marvel alone is unfair even though Marvel's success prompted imitation.
“I don't think it's fair to lay it all at Marvel”
- Every studio copied Marvel's model because it was so profitable, and the resulting imitation, which the Sony hack exposed, tipped the industry out of balance and produced a glut of superhero films that audiences are now skeptical of.
“everyone trying to be Marvel is why we're really here.”
- Marvel's television struggles before Feige's control stemmed partly from a turf battle between Feige and Jeph Loeb over which properties went to film versus TV, which led to shows like Inhumans being handed to Loeb and weakened the brand.
“there was a battle between Jeph and Kevin over who gets to tell which stories or which properties.”
- Marvel is stumbling, with the Secret Invasion series considered genuinely terrible, but declaring the company over is premature because it still holds the Fantastic Four and X-Men, and its Guardians of the Galaxy hit a success.
“I think it's a little too soon to hand crepe on Marvel. So they've got a lot of places they can go.”
- Marvel had years to plant successor heroes, with Benedict Cumberbatch's Doctor Strange, Paul Rudd's Scott Lang, Brie Larson's Captain Marvel, and Chadwick Boseman's T'Challa intended to lead the next phase, so claims that Marvel had no post-Endgame plan are wildly untrue.
“People who are critical of Marvel say they didn't plan for post-Endgame. And that's just wildly untrue”
- Marvel's franchise cracked under the weight of its own history as viewers came to see the films as homework, and critics' glee at knocking Marvel off its pedestal amplified the backlash beyond what the quality decline alone would justify.
“there is some glee that happens in knocking someone off a high pedestal.”
- Marvel's post-Endgame problems came mainly from events outside its control, including Downey, Evans, and Johansson leaving, COVID disrupting production, Chadwick Boseman's death, and the Disney+ shift, rather than from a failure to plan.
“a number of events outside of their control came and knocked their pretty little plan off the tracks.”
- Joanna hopes that the current backlash against superhero films, driven by failures like Black Adam and The Flash, will lead to fewer superhero releases and leave room for other stories while keeping the good films.
“my hope is what that means is we will see -- yes, a ramping down of superhero content”
- Current criticism of Marvel contains genuine critique of weaker quality but also a gleeful pleasure in toppling a dominant brand, a dynamic Joanna sees as stronger now than in any prior year, even beyond legendary critics like Scorsese and Coppola.
“there is some glee that happens in knocking someone off a high pedestal.”
Early Marvel films had creative freedom and substantial-looking VFX rather than pixels.
- VFX technology was deeply important to Marvel's success because after 1990s and early 2000s superhero films, such as the Green Lantern CGI suit, the first Iron Man needed a suit that looked heavy and substantial rather than like pixels.
“It was very important with Iron Man specifically, the first Iron Man movie, that they had the ability to make that suit look like it was heavy and substantial”
- The four launch characters, Iron Man, Captain America, Thor, and Hulk, had little popularity at the time, which was an advantage because it lowered the burden of expectations and let audiences attach to the actors' versions rather than preexisting comic images.
“that lack of familiarity with those characters was an advantage to Marvel”
- Jon Favreau, not Feige, likely drove the early VFX push, and he brought a team from his VFX-heavy film Zathura to Marvel, including Louis D'Esposito, who later became Marvel Studios' number two.
“Louis D'Esposito, who's #2 at Marvel Studios, worked on Zathura, and Favreau brought him over.”
- Iron Man was made like an independent or student film because Marvel East Coast and the executive board ignored it since they bore no financial risk, so the filmmakers, including Favreau and Downey Jr., had creative freedom that produced a maverick approach.
“zero risk to us if it doesn't come through.”
Maisel's deal-making and contract engineering secured Marvel's full ownership of its characters.
- Maisel exploited a contract loophole with Universal: by making Hulk not the title character, Marvel could use Mark Ruffalo's Hulk in other films without partnering with Universal, giving Disney ownership of the Hulk's use in the MCU.
“if Hulk isn't the names character in the title of the movie, they don't have to play with Universal.”
- David Maisel negotiated the Disney deal worth about $4 billion within a few years of building Marvel Studios from nothing, and then left the company, having previously built a relationship with Bob Iger.
“I built this up from literally nothing to a $4 billion Disney deal within span a couple of years.”
- Marvel's Disney acquisition was driven less by cash needs than by the desire for full ownership, because Disney provided marketing and in-house distribution muscle that Marvel had previously lacked while Marvel still operated as its own brand, like Pixar.
“Less a cash injection and more, again, we want full ownership of what we're doing.”
- Contract engineering, such as the Hulk title loophole, shows that Marvel's ownership structure was built through deliberate and detailed negotiation rather than luck, making the legal structure as important as creative choices.
“just very deeply nerdy that David Maisel figured out that I love.”
- Joanna would rank David Maisel above VFX in importance to Marvel's success, placing the financing architect above the technology factor.
“I would put him above VFX, probably.”
- David Maisel was a creatively minded deal-maker with real passion for Iron Man and story, and his financial structuring was intertwined with genuine creative investment in the characters.
“He cares about the characters in and above this financial opportunity that he saw.”
Spectacle, familiar IP, and declining moviegoing keep studios making franchise films.
- For international audiences, where language is a barrier, spectacle-heavy films with big CGI action are easier to follow, which makes them lucrative and encourages studios to keep producing them.
“certainly for international audiences, where there's a language barrier, the international box office success that you can have comes from delivering these movies that are easier for people to follow”
- Attempts to recreate the MCU, such as Universal's Dark Universe, have failed, because the MCU depended on many unlikely factors and on building each character film before the team-up, so the formula is hard to reproduce.
“the number of times we've seen people try and fail to already recreate.”
- Moviegoing declined for reasons beyond Marvel, including home theater quality, streaming like Netflix, binge culture, and the loss of movie stars, so theaters now mainly sell spectacle that audiences feel they must see big.
“moviegoing for a large percentage of the population becomes about spectacle.”
- Hollywood's IP proliferation stems from studio fear that launching a new, original property will not draw audiences, so familiar titles like Barbie are used to pull people in.
“the proliferation of IP in Hollywood, which is everywhere... comes from that fear space from the studios that launching something new, something original is not going to pull people in.”
- Barbie is an example of familiar IP executed with a distinctive vision, making it feel unexpected despite the property's recognition; Dom adds that its marketing was also a key separate lever.
“Barbie is this incredible execution of IP where we are extremely familiar with Barbie”
Merrill Lynch debt and Maisel's valuation claims pushed early Marvel films to repay quickly.
- The Merrill Lynch deal set a clock of a limited number of films to repay the loan, so the early Marvel movies were 'at-bats' that had to generate enough returns, and Iron Man paid the loan off quickly.
“The clock is ticking, you have this many movies to pay back the Merrill Lynch deal.”
- David Maisel financed Marvel Studios with a roughly $400 million Merrill Lynch loan by leveraging Marvel's character rights, while telling Marvel's board the characters were bargain-basement assets and telling Merrill Lynch they were worth hundreds of millions.
“he has to tell Marvel these characters are worth nothing and tell Merrill Lynch these characters are worth hundreds of millions of dollars.”
Marvel's television and Spotlight moves correct earlier film-model hubris and homework viewing.
- Marvel's Disney+ television struggled because Marvel Studios assumed it could reinvent television using its film model, relying on head writers rather than experienced television showrunners, a hubris it is now correcting by hiring showrunners and piloting shows.
“they thought, well, we'll learn what we need to learn from our head writers and then we'll kind of make TV like we make our movies.”
- Marvel's Spotlight sub-brand, launched with the Echo series, signals a shift away from requiring viewers to watch everything, which conflicts with the franchise's earlier model that made the brand's success depend on homework viewing.
“If they put the Marvel Spotlight brand on something, that means you don't have to do any homework.”
Marvel's toy-business origins and Disney's ownership shaped the direction of its brand.
- Before films, Marvel was essentially a toy business that licensed out its characters, and its toy-centric leadership, notably Ike Perlmutter, viewed movies as advertising for merchandise.
“kind of sees these movies as advertising for merch, we make these movies and we sell action figures and bedsheets and underwear”
- Disney acquired Marvel and Lucasfilm to diversify its portfolio beyond princess properties, bringing in superhero and Jedi franchises to appeal to boys while princess properties covered girls.
“Disney is looking to diversify its portfolio because they've got corner of the market on Princess.”
- During the Disney negotiations Bob Iger promised Marvel would be treated like Pixar, allowed to keep its own brand identity, and Steve Jobs personally called Ike Perlmutter to reassure him about Marvel's independence.
“we're going to treat you like Pixar, which Pixar is allowed to be its own thing under our umbrella”