What this covers
Niel Robertson, a software founder, talks through how money moves in media, starting with history. Amazon's early growth leaned on affiliate attribution, paying bloggers 4 to 8 percent of what their readers bought. YouTube's CPM rates then collapsed as creators flooded in, which pushed them toward sponsored content and now toward direct payment from fans. He says sponsorship rates are flattening too, for the same reason. From there he argues that platforms now see the future as the Creator-Led Media Shift.
The middle of the conversation covers the mechanics of building on creators. Two-sided influencer marketing marketplaces, he says, slide into being agencies and struggle to scale, since campaign budgets rarely pass roughly $100,000. Searchable communities such as LinkedIn grow cheaply because SEO compounds their content. He expects content to split into a free front of house and a paid back of house, and he doubts live streaming outside gaming, a claim he states against the direction Twitter is taking. He also gives a view on Facebook's decision to leave its news feed unchanged.
The last stretch turns to the blockchain. He describes digital collectibles built on the ERC-721 standard and the Built-In Information API that a transparent ledger provides. He also describes security tokens that would give early community members equity tied to continued participation, and the possibility of leasing items such as a World of Warcraft weapon. Several of these claims are contested. He closes with personal lessons: the Tour of Duty Model for employees and the Lateral Translatability Fallacy, which he learned from his restaurant investments.
Robertson argues that distribution and monetization control where value accrues in media: creators and communities are displacing traditional media, Amazon is positioned to win through Twitch and commerce, and blockchain-based digital collectibles can extend authentic ownership to digital goods.
- Influencers and creators are becoming core to media strategy, and platforms compete to offer them monetization tools
- Searchable, community-centric businesses scale with low marginal cost, while two-sided campaign marketplaces struggle to scale
- Blockchain's transparency plus standardized ownership (ERC-721) lets new digital assets inherit existing markets and participants
Creator-led content is displacing traditional media as the core of the future of media.
- A 12-year-old will within two or three years turn on a Roku TV, see Instagram TV, and consume that as their first point of entry instead of HBO or Netflix.
“someone who's 12 will probably wake up in two or three years, walk into the living room, flip on their Roku TV and see Instagram TV on there”
- The Snapchat channel Arsenic TV had more active viewers on the day it posted than MTV had that day, which Robertson saw as the moment signaling that traditional media jobs would be disrupted within five to ten years.
“they had more active viewers than MTV did that day”
- Influencers have shifted from being a targeted-ad channel to being treated as content creators, and traditional media companies and platforms like Instagram, Facebook, and YouTube now see creator-led content as the core of their strategy and direct competition to traditional media.
“they're realizing platforms like Instagram, and Facebook and YouTube and everything else are actually much more direct competitors than I think perhaps they had realized before”
- Major platforms have concluded that the future of media is creator-led: people increasingly consume content because of a person they admire rather than because of a random show found on a streaming service.
“It's the media you start consuming in relation to a person that you admire, as opposed to necessarily a TV show that you just randomly find on Netflix and start binging.”
- Fortnite, a Battle Royale game streamed on YouTube and Twitch, drew around 608,000 concurrent viewers when Ninja played with Drake, more than many professional sports events draw for a single game.
“getting something like 608,000 concurrent views, which is more than a lot of professional sports will get for a single game”
- Game makers are increasingly designing games to be as interesting for viewers as for players, creating a new category in which spectators may watch briefly without playing.
“people are trying to build games that are as interesting for viewers as they are for players”
- Esports is spreading across many business areas at once, including venue design, casino events, merchandise, ticketing, and sports betting, so it is hard to give an overview of the sector.
“the challenging thing about giving an overview of eSports is that its becoming everything at once”
- A single individual can now build something more valuable from a media perspective than large legacy corporations like Hearst, NBC, or ABC, which Robertson calls an incredible global disruption.
“one individual person can build something more valuable than they can from a media perspective”
Direct paid monetization like subscriptions is replacing ad-driven income for creators.
- Platforms are competing for creators by offering the most ways to monetize, including ad revenue sharing, brand deal sourcing, direct subscriptions, and in-game gifting, because monetization is hard for any individual creator.
“the battle that's happening between the platforms right now is really around who can create a relationship with an influencer creator by giving them the most ways to monetize themselves”
- Patreon, funded with about 100 million dollars, led the shift to direct creator monetization by letting audiences pay creators directly, and podcasters and YouTubers are among its largest user groups.
“Patreon is a company that was funded, it has about 100 million dollars that led the charge”
- Live video platforms, including adult webcam sites and Chinese apps like YY and YouNow, monetize through in-stream gifting, which is part of the broader platform race to create monetization strategies for creators.
“a lot of the Webcam girl stuff is all about in game gifting and things like that”
- Podcasting is among the most monetizable content categories because listeners give 30 minutes to an hour of attention, so they are already deeply engaged and likely to pay around $2.99 to $4.99 a month for specialized content.
“One of the most monetizable categories is actually podcasting.”
- YouTube CPM rates dropped sharply as creators flooded in, so early YouTubers with millions of views could earn only two or three thousand dollars a month, pushing creators toward sponsored content and then toward direct monetization.
“you could be essentially making videos with millions of views and making two or $3,000 a month”
- Whoever has the best distribution to audiences willing to pay wins direct monetization, and a generic Instagram following is less likely to convert to paid subscriptions than a highly engaged Facebook group or Twitch audience.
“I think whoever has the best distribution to audiences that are willing to pay, back to distribution again.”
- Content is splitting into front-of-house public material and back-of-house paid material, because the bottom of the funnel, which was previously empty, now has a generation willing to pay around $2.99 a month for exclusive content.
“that's the future of content, it's front of house back of house. You're just going to start to see people not give it all away for free anymore.”
- Content subscriptions at $1.99 to $3.99 a month are the new ringtone business: consumers have long paid small recurring amounts for things they like, and that habit is now moving into content.
“content subscriptions is just the new ringtone business”
Blockchain tokens make community ownership transparent, queryable, and tradable with equity-like value.
- A new blockchain asset inherits the existing participants, rules, and technology of an established network, which is like building a new market on top of the NASDAQ rather than building an exchange from scratch.
“you instantly inherit all of the people that are already playing. It's like saying, I don't need the NASDAQ.”
- Digital collectibles are a standard built on Ethereum (ERC-721) that tracks distributed ownership of a unique item, allowing duplicates like numbered prints while still proving which copy one owns, translating uniqueness and authenticity onto the blockchain.
“digital collectibles is essentially a standard on top of Ethereum, the ERC-721 Standard that allows for a distributed knowledge of ownership of a unique item”
- Blockchains combine anonymity with complete transparency, which seems contradictory but gives every application a built-in information API, letting anyone query the full ownership and transaction history of an item.
“the thing that's such a funny dichotomy in crypto to me is anonymity plus complete transparency”
- Much of the money and transaction volume in crypto collectibles like CryptoKitties comes from headless back-end players who algorithmically scan the blockchain and execute trades directly, like algorithmic stock traders.
“a lot of the players are not front end players, they're back end players”
- Once digital items are authentically owned and tradable, adding the ability to lease them to other users opens a large range of new ideas, such as leasing a hard-earned World of Warcraft item for three months.
“if I want to... I might lease it to you for three months”
- Activity-based tokens can work like startup options: a community member keeps tokens by continuing to participate, and pays tax only at a liquidity event, when the difference is settled.
“as long as you show up to the community once a month, you essentially retain your token that you earned and you don't have to pay tax on it until there's actually a liquidity event”
- Early blockchain entrants are wedded to philosophical anonymity and extreme decentralization, but most people want known identities, so collectibles that associate ownership with individuals are a step toward mainstream adoption.
“I think the biggest problem with blockchain is the early entrants are really wed to a lot of the philosophical underpinnings, anonymity, complete and utter decentralization.”
- Tokenization of non-equity assets such as leasable game items, tickets, and digital collectibles could disrupt traditional industries with central authorities controlling their digital equivalents.
“it becomes highly disruptive to a lot of traditional industries that have digital equivalents, but have central authorities”
- Robertson treats tokenization of real-world equity as a useful idea, with tokens tied to a real class of stock and perks or activity layered on top, though he does not endorse the specific Apple-iPhone discount example.
“to tie just like basic participation in things into ongoing ownership of something that's tied to a real class of stock”
- Security tokens could give the first several hundred thousand community members a share of a community business's equity, which is tradable and tied to ongoing participation, solving the problem that early members create value but receive nothing from stock options.
“you could take 10% of the common shares of a business that was a community and essentially issue securitized tokens to the first 500,000 people in that community”
Quality content survives through community soul and paid curation rather than mass volume.
- The most successful creators think about engagement and community behind their content, because mass soulless content marketing has devalued content, so content with soul or community is the future rather than raw volume.
“content marketing became a channel that was so utterly adopted by everybody, that just general proliferation of content, that's soulless”
- influence.co's showcases let influencers publish brand-sponsored content along with the story of how it was made, including techniques and choices not taken, and this transparency became a very successful part of the site.
“allowing influencers to put up a piece of content that they created with a brand and then tell the story of how they got that content”
- There are two ways to curate good content in the long run: employ an editor, or charge for it, and Robertson pays for Stratechery and a journal because he prefers paying people who spend time doing the work over hunting for information himself.
“There are two ways to curate good content. One is have an editor and one is charge for it.”
- Robertson believes everyone should learn a new physical skill every year, because digital consumption creates the feeling of learning without tactical, embodied mastery, and he finds motocross more rewarding than digital learning.
“we consume massive amounts of new information about new topics all the time. And so we think that we are learning and evolving, but we're doing very little learning and evolving tactically.”
Established platforms keep durable advantages through reputation, attribution, and stable product design.
- Most influencers and creators hold a neutral-to-positive view of Amazon, while other platforms have suffered from demonetization or perceptions of being for older users, making Amazon's reputation one of its greatest strengths.
“they have a neutral to positive opinion by most influencers and creators”
- Amazon's early growth relied on affiliate attribution: cookies with time windows paid bloggers 4 to 8 percent of whatever a referred reader bought, and the last affiliate click won attribution, making word-of-mouth traceable.
“whatever you buy in this time window on Amazon, you get paid 4 to 8% of”
- Amazon owns Twitch, which Robertson calls one of the greatest secrets of Amazon's portfolio, because Twitch lets streamers earn through subscriptions and in-game gifts such as Cheers.
“Amazon, that owns Twitch, which is one of the greatest secrets of Amazon's portfolio”
- Pinterest, with about 450 million dollars in revenue, roughly breakeven profitability, and 250 million users, has the content-centric features of the future of media and faces no real threat, so Robertson would buy its stock if it goes public.
“Yeah, I think if Pinterest goes public, I'd buy some of that stock.”
- Snapchat has roughly six months to make a few moves before it becomes a steady-state platform that never grows larger or smaller, and Snap Kit, which enables authentication, is a basic infrastructure step that could attract developers.
“I think there's probably six months for them to make a few moves, before they start to just Twitter themselves into a steady state platform”
- Facebook's genius is that it has barely changed its core news feed for six years while building adjacent products, because users resist relearning basic interfaces, which is the problem Snapchat and Twitter face.
“Facebook's genius is they basically haven't changed anything for six years.”
Influencer marketing is a searchable, content-driven channel that can scale like SEO.
- Brands cannot easily spend more than about 5,000 to 100,000 dollars on an influencer campaign, which limits scale for early companies; SEO had the same problem when monthly budgets were capped near 5,000 dollars, but the SEO industry now runs about 80 billion dollars a year.
“It was really hard to spend more than $5,000 a month in SEO. Now the industry is $80 billion a year”
- Blogging-based affiliate marketing was the birth of influencers, because it established the pattern of finding people with aggregated audiences and pushing their followers toward products, and visual platforms later simplified that into product photos.
“That really is the birth of influencers at the end of the day”
- Business models built on searchable content communities, like LinkedIn, Stack Overflow, Dribbble, Behance, IMDb, and Model Mayhem, scale with very low cost to grow because search traffic (SEO) compounds the content the community creates.
“a very large, scalable business that costs very little to grow because of the SEO value”
- Influencers are an incredibly searchable space because millennials look up favorite influencers and related products on Google, and because influencers produce content, making the space a content-centric SEO opportunity.
“It's all these millennials looking up all their favorite influencers and typing that into Google”
- Ritholtz Wealth Management's strategy of identifying and hiring the biggest financial influencers on Twitter is a good strategy, because it separates publicly available content from privately available content, similar to private GLG.
“I love that strategy. It's like private GLG.”
Global US platforms displace local incumbents, while genuinely new creative channels remain scarce.
- Amazon is the sleeper winner of the creator economy because it combines Twitch, 100 million Prime members with access to Prime channels, an influencer storefront program, native commerce, and a neutral-to-positive reputation among creators.
“I think the absolute sleeper in this game is Amazon. I think they are actually going to be the player that wins.”
- B2B companies are reverting to hiring large numbers of young salespeople to cold call, and to scraping LinkedIn through low-cost offshore workers, because no new creative channels have emerged.
“People are actually going back to things like hiring 150 23-year old's and sticking in an office and having them call people”
- Apart from gaming, live streaming has never produced significant returns, and Instagram and Facebook are backing away from live toward long-form on-demand content, so Twitter's bet on live is risky.
“I personally think that live has never produced significant returns”
- Services that once came from governments, such as utilities, housing, and taxes, are now supplied by large US tech companies on a global basis, so Netflix, Uber, Airbnb, and Verizon's travel SIM displace local providers and are the biggest disruptors of incumbent companies.
“all the stuff has been abstracted completely away. And all of those companies are now actually big US companies operating on a global level.”
- Local companies that compete with globally scaled US services, such as regional telephone companies, are the ones that should be scared, while healthcare remains the exception because it still must be sourced locally.
“I think that if you're going to look at the companies that are essentially competing with that... I would be scared.”
Influencer marketing is saturating and hard to scale.
- Influencer marketing means finding anyone who has aggregated an audience, from podcasters to Instagram models to Twitch gamers, and leveraging that audience to promote products, usually for payment.
“Generally speaking, it's finding anybody that has an audience, whether it's this podcast or a model on Instagram, or anything in between”
- Two-sided influencer marketplaces that run campaigns and take a percentage of spend fall into the subjectivity trap: when clients dispute subjective outcomes, the business regresses into an agency and is hard to scale.
“when people call you and debate subjective outcomes, you end up having a lot of stuff, and you end up regressing to being agency”
- The path to million-dollar brand sponsorships runs through platforms aggregating paying subscribers, so a channel with 100,000 people paying a few dollars a month can sell a million-dollar sponsorship, as with native advertising sponsoring a whole community.
“there is 100,000 people paying on this channel. This is a million dollar sponsorship opportunity.”
- Sponsored-content rates rose for a while as creators shifted to brand deals, but they are now flattening because the same supply glut that crushed ad rates has flooded the sponsorship market.
“Because there was a lot of supply now in that space, because everybody flooded in and said, they were an influencer, those numbers are flattening up as well.”
Leaders should treat tenure as a tour of duty and expect hierarchy to emerge as companies grow.
- A generation raised in non-hierarchical networked organizations will eventually have to adopt hierarchy as companies grow, because networked structures can survive only at small scale, creating a leadership challenge of guiding that transition.
“smaller companies can survive networked organizations. But I think at some point in time, when they grow bigger, they have to become hierarchical to run themselves.”
- The kindest thing Tom Higley did was let Robertson participate fully in the first business, Service Metrics, rather than cordoning him off, which shifted Robertson from being a technology storyteller to a business storyteller and made access the key factor.
“he changed my opinion about what I wanted to be from someone that just told technology stories to someone that built business stories”
- Success in one industry does not translate laterally to another, as Robertson learned when investing in restaurants and bars after selling his first software company, and early success tends to cause people to keep doubling down on unrelated ventures.
“they just think success is laterally translatable. And I really don't think that's true.”
- Leaders should treat employee tenure as a defined tour of duty with a personal goal and an explicit end point, aiming for alumni relationships instead of trying to retain staff indefinitely, which Robertson says reduced the sense of personal failure when people leave.
“taking a look at a leader not as trying to retain all their staff as long as possible, but to help them go through a journey for a couple of years”
B2B software growth is constrained by exhausted distribution channels and data regulation.
- B2B software distribution has run out of genuinely new channels: SEO and content marketing have been flattened quickly, so companies now rely on squeezing existing channels, which makes unit economics hard to build.
“in the B2B space we're tapped out of anything new and interesting”
- Scraping data and feeding it into marketing drips breaks many GDPR rules, so scraping-based B2B companies will face harder scaling for roughly the next five years.
“I think it's going to get harder before it gets easier, probably in the next five years for those kinds of companies to scale”
- Interesting remaining B2B distribution channels include co-registration with partners, where free-trial signups recommend other trials, and AppSumo, which lets companies pre-sell software bundles to gain marketplace scale.
“There's distribution channels like AppSumo, that let you pre sell bundles of stuff to try to get scale in your marketplace.”