What this covers

This episode has James walking through Wise with James Revell, who adds commentary on trust and organizational design; Zack is also listed as a speaker. It opens with the origin story. Kristo Kaarmann and Taavet Hinrikus found that banks hid an exchange-rate markup behind an upfront fee, and they first solved it by netting opposite currency flows between themselves over Skype. The discussion then explains why correspondent banking is slow and opaque: chains of intermediaries, weekday batch processing, weekend gaps, and interbank liabilities. It sizes the market at roughly GBP 100 trillion a year, about two-thirds of it held by banks.

The middle of the conversation is comparison and numbers. Western Union, founded in 1851 as a telegraph company, runs about 600,000 agent locations at a take rate near 5%. At a 4% take rate it would still earn $40 per $1,000 transferred and nothing at EBITDA. Other points include Wise's Net Promoter Score of 71, with two-thirds of customers referred, and transfers that arrive instantly about half the time. Average fees have fallen from about 9% to 6-7%, against a UN goal of roughly 3% by 2030. Rising rates have also turned customer balances into a profit line, which poses an odd question of what to do with the windfall.

The last stretch is contested. It covers Visa and Mastercard, interlinked real-time payments systems such as Singapore's, and stablecoins or central bank digital currencies as possible threats. It also covers regulatory exposure across roughly 63 licenses, including an Abu Dhabi fine. Revell adds a disputed argument for High Alignment Loose Coupling, in which leaders say what to do, not how.

Sharpest takeaway

Wise wins by counter-positioning against correspondent banking: it owns bank accounts in many countries so money rarely crosses borders, and it passes the resulting scale economies to customers as lower prices, which fuels a growth flywheel that a bank-based incumbent cannot easily copy.

  • Wise routes transfers through its own domestic accounts, so it incurs only domestic costs while charging a cross-border fee
  • Wise charges roughly 65 basis points against a World Bank average near 6.5%, and reinvests scale savings into lower prices and growth
  • Competitive threats (card networks, neobanks, social platforms, CBDCs, interlinked payment systems) are real, and regulation is a rising risk

The argument · threads10 threads · 65 claims
0.82

Wise's domestic-payout model lets it undercut bank cross-border fees profitably.

8 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Wise's founders, Kristo Kaarmann and Taavet Hinrikus, discovered that banks quoted an upfront fee but also marked up the foreign exchange rate, so recipients got far less than expected, and they solved this by netting opposite currency flows between themselves via a Skype chat.

    “what the banks do, they'll quote you a fee upfront, and then they'll try to mark up on the foreign exchange”

  • Wise's model keeps money inside its own network of owned bank accounts in each country, so a cross-border transfer is executed as a domestic payout from a local Wise account, meaning Wise incurs only domestic costs while customers are charged as if money crossed a border.

    “all Wise is doing is collecting your money in the U.K. and disbursing money from its own account in Japan to your recipients bank”

  • Average cross-border transfer fees have fallen from about 9% in 2008 to 2009 to roughly 6% to 7% today, a decline James attributes to Wise's competitive pressure and regulatory attention, even as the market grows about 5% a year.

    “2008, 2009, it was about 9% in fees. It's now like, say, close to 6%, 7%”

  • Wise's average customer price is about 65 basis points, roughly ten times cheaper than the World Bank's average cross-border transfer cost of about 6.5%.

    “Wise average customer price at the moment is about 65 basis points. So 10x cheaper.”

  • Western Union, founded in 1851 as a telegraph company, operates in about 200 countries through roughly 600,000 agent locations and charges about a 5% take rate, versus Wise's 65 basis points, with a gross margin near 40% against Wise's 60%.

    “it's charging about a 5% take rate, compare that to Wise, is at 65 basis points”

  • On a $1,000 transfer Western Union earns $50 and turns about $10 into earnings, while Wise earns $6.50 and turns about $1.30 into earnings, so Wise's lean cost base lets it stay profitable at a far lower price.

    “for every $1,000 transfer, Western Union is earning $50 in fares versus Wise is earning $6.50”

  • Wise's counter-position against banks is strong because its low-cost infrastructure lets it charge 65 basis points and still earn about a 20% margin, while banks charging 6% to 7% would cannibalize their own profits by matching Wise's price, so banks may not respond.

    “Banks are charging 6%, 7% on this and earning a lot of profitability out of it. So banks can choose to respond to this”

  • Wise runs its personal and business products on a single platform with one code base, about 99% of which has grown organically, so the company maintains one infrastructure across all products rather than separate systems.

    “Its entire infrastructure is one platform. It's one code base. 99% of it has been growing organically”

0.71

Interest income and the free-transfer mission make Wise's profit less durable and dilemma-laden.

9 pointscentrality 4/5
  • About 80% of Wise's revenue comes from cross-border fees, while roughly 20% comes from newer lines such as debit card interchange and investment products, and revenue is about 90% of total income with net interest income making up the rest.

    “80% of that revenue line is cross-border revenue”

  • Wise holds about GBP 10 billion of customer balances that earned nothing while rates were near zero, but rising rates turned them into a new revenue line, with about GBP 50 million of net interest income in the last quarter and a projection of around GBP 120 million for the financial year.

    “they're sitting on about GBP 10 billion of customer deposits. As interest rates goes up, the yield on those balances are going up.”

  • Wise is on track for roughly GBP 1 billion in total income this year with a 60% gross margin, about GBP 600 million of gross profit, and about GBP 200 million of EBITDA, a roughly 20% EBITDA margin, while transfer volume approaches GBP 100 billion and grows over 40% a year.

    “They've got 60% gross profit margin, so GBP 600 million in gross profit, and that's flying through to about GBP 200 million in EBITDA.”

  • Because Wise is not a bank and cannot simply pay interest, it intends to return the interest income to customers through lower prices, cashback, or by letting customers invest in government bonds through a vehicle that moves the earnings off balance sheet.

    “the way they're kind of crafty trying to give it back to the customers without becoming a bank is allow customers to invest in government bonds basically”

  • Interest income from customer balances should not be valued at the same earnings multiple as the core cross-border business, because management intends to reinvest or pass that income back to customers, making it less durable and less clearly profit.

    “I don't think in kind of a some of the parts analysis, you'd be able to apply the same earnings multiple on that revenue stream as you would to say their core business.”

  • Wise's stated Mission Zero is to make cross-border transfers free, which would eliminate its own primary revenue line, so the business either pivots to a free core funded by ancillary products or stays a price-focused zealot.

    “if they're successful in achieving their mission, the business doesn't exist anymore”

  • Wise is a polarizing stock that investors see either as a commodity business whose price will be eroded to zero or as a shared-economy scale business whose growth runway is very large.

    “is this a commodity business that only really competes on price and that will continue to be eroded down to 0? Or is it a shared economy scale business”

  • Wise allocates roughly a third of gross profit each to operating costs, growth and marketing, and EBITDA, so the roughly 20% EBITDA margin is a managed outcome; in 2021 it spiked to 26% when growth spend was reduced, and pulling growth spend entirely could roughly double EBITDA to a 40% margin.

    “they take 1/3 of their gross profit and spend on keeping the lights on. They take 1/3 of it into growth and put it into growth and marketing and 1/3 falls through to EBITDA”

  • Four quarters before the interview, Wise's float income was a net interest loss, but rising rates have flipped customer balances into a profit line, creating operating leverage that the company cannot yet return through pricing, forcing an unusual dilemma about what to do with the windfall.

    “four quarters ago, it was basically a net interest loss, they were losing money on this.”

0.68

Transparency, speed, and referrals drive customer trust and cheaper, word-of-mouth acquisition.

8 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Wise has a Net Promoter Score of 71, and about two-thirds of its customers are referred by other customers, which makes its organic acquisition engine unusually powerful for a company of its size.

    “They've got a 71 Net Promoter Score, which is phenomenal, particularly for a business with 6 million customers.”

  • Studies show only about 4% of customers know the true cost of transferring money overseas, so Wise's transparency about fees and timing is a differentiator that banks, which hide markups, do not offer.

    “studies have shown only about 4% of customers know the true cost of transferring money overseas”

  • About 50% of Wise's cross-border transfer volume arrives instantly and about 90% completes within 24 hours, a speed advantage that matters because bank transfers can take up to five days and create uncertainty.

    “About 50% of all of that cross-border transfer volume arrives instantly and about 90% is done within 24 hours”

  • Wise's transfer tool compares its prices with other providers and displays cheaper alternatives when they exist, a counterintuitive move that reinforces its trust and transparency positioning.

    “if there's another provider that's offering a cheaper rate, they'll show that, which is a bit counterintuitive when you're trying to compete.”

  • Companies such as Costco and Floor & Decor succeed through a relentless focus on one thing, passing operational improvements and unit cost efficiencies back to customers, and Wise's single mission of free, transparent cross-border transfers belongs to the same pattern.

    “There's been great breakdowns on Floor & Decor or Costco, where it's a relentless focus on one thing”

  • Wise's paid marketing has a payback target of under nine months, and currently trends closer to three months, after the company shifted from growth hacking stunts to a disciplined paid approach that complements its referral network.

    “they look for kind of a less than nine-month payback on paid marketing spend. I think it's currently trending closer to three months.”

  • Customers often tell others about Wise in everyday settings, such as an expat transferring money home, because the user experience is so much better than banks, so word-of-mouth becomes the core acquisition channel.

    “I had to go to my bank, I had to fill out a bunch of forms. I had no idea how much it was going to cost”

  • Wise acquires customers efficiently despite lacking the distribution of social platforms because referrals drive about two-thirds of customer growth, a result of a superior user experience against a broken incumbent process, which personal anecdotes such as an Englishman in Australia referring friends illustrate.

    “I had to go to my bank, I had to fill out a bunch of forms. I had no idea how much it was going to cost”

0.55

A price-cutting flywheel passes efficiency gains to customers and drives long-horizon growth.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Given the size of the total addressable market and the strength of the flywheel, investors should not underestimate how long Wise can keep growing, possibly for a decade, and the company may eventually shift toward profitability at some point.

    “just don't underestimate how long this business can grow for.”

  • Wise's flywheel works because better user experience drives volume, volume lowers unit costs, the savings are reinvested in marketing and product, and then passed to customers as lower prices, which deepens the experience and restarts the cycle, so growth comes from giving more back.

    “They share that scale economy back to the customer in the form of a lower price, which drives a better user experience and then the flywheel starts again.”

  • Wise differs from most companies by aiming to drive the lowest possible price rather than pricing to the equilibrium that maximizes short-term profit, which would be as high as possible without pushing customers to competitors.

    “they're always is trying to drive the lowest price possible as opposed to what a lot of companies do, which is focus on profit maximization in the shorter term”

  • Wise's Mission Zero holds that cross-border transfers should be as easy as sending an email and ultimately free, so the company publishes quarterly price updates, shows a comparison tool that exposes cheaper competitors, and treats price cuts as its central goal.

    “if they're successful in achieving their mission, the business doesn't exist anymore”

0.54

Owning national payment access removes intermediaries and lowers unit costs, adding regulatory exposure.

8 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Wise enters each new country with the simplest financial license, then climbs toward full integration with national payment systems, becoming the first nonbanks in the UK and Australia to join real-time payment infrastructure, which lets it cut prices over time and gives it about 63 licenses worldwide.

    “in the U.K. and in Australia, they're actually the first nonbanks to be participants in the national real-time payments infrastructure”

  • Operating roughly 63 licenses, each with its own nuances, increases Wise's regulatory exposure, particularly around anti-money laundering, counterterrorism financing and know-your-customer obligations, and a fine by Abu Dhabi authorities shows how controls failures can occur.

    “Last year, I think it was. They were fined by the Abu Dhabi financial authorities for not having appropriate controls in place.”

  • As Wise becomes vertically integrated in each market, removing partner banks and intermediaries, it eliminates partner fees and friction and lowers unit costs, a process that took almost ten years in the UK to complete within the national real-time payments system.

    “In the U.K., I think it's taken them almost 10 years to become completely fully integrated with the national real-time payments game.”

  • Wise reviews at least 20,000 customer applications a day, with 85% returned or reviewed within an hour, and uses machine learning to forecast liquidity needs in each market so it avoids relying on partners or buying currency on international money markets.

    “the onboarding or reviewing at least 20,000 customer applications per day. And 85% of those are returned or reviewed within one hour.”

  • Wise Platform lets competitors such as Monzo and Xero white-label Wise's cross-border infrastructure, so rivals can offer transfers to their own customers while the Wise infrastructure earns from them, lowering friction of adoption for Wise.

    “Wise Platform where any of these players, if they don't want to build it themselves or partner with bank accounts can partner with Wise.”

  • Wise's model depends on owning a global network of bank accounts and running its own communication and liquidity management across them, so it avoids the cross-border messaging, format, language, and time-zone frictions that arise when a company must rely on outside banks.

    “what Wise does, it keeps that communication and keeps ownership of all those bank accounts within its own network.”

  • Wise is a cross-border money transfer business focused on retail and small business peer-to-peer and SMB transfers between jurisdictions, not cash remittances or card e-commerce; it is a licensed financial institution but not a bank.

    “Wise, funny enough, isn't a bank. So it is a licensed financial institution, but it's not a bank.”

  • A small Australian credit union would be unlikely to have a direct relationship with a bank in the UK, so it must route transfers through a chain of intermediary banks.

    “you're a credit union in Australia, it would very unlikely to have a relationship with the bank in the U.K.”

0.44

Correspondent banking chains add compliance, delay, and cost to every cross-border transfer.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The compliance burden along correspondent banking chains (anti-money laundering, counterterrorism financing, sanctions, data protection, prudential liquidity rules, consumer disputes) has grown substantially since the global financial crisis, adding complexity to every cross-border transfer.

    “the regulatory and compliance burden along that chain is huge”

  • Domestic batch payment processing that runs only certain hours on weekdays, combined with differing time zones, means money stops moving over weekends, and non-simultaneous settlement creates interbank liabilities that banks charge fees to cover.

    “if transfers between banks aren't done simultaneously, which often they are, that creates liabilities between banks, which is problems and banks charge fees for that”

  • Correspondent banking requires a chain of intermediary banks that each validate data, run compliance checks, reformat messages and settle funds, so each hand-off adds cost, delay, opacity and inconvenience for the customer.

    “Every step of the way you need to validate the data, you needed to complete the regulatory checks”

  • Cross-border value transfer has long moved through ledger entries rather than physical money, from ship-borne gold and spices to 11th-12th century bills of exchange and later telex messages, so the modern system is essentially a web of bank-to-bank account relationships.

    “money stopped moving across borders a long time ago. It was a lot of credits and debits of accounts with each banks held with each other”

  • As countries such as Singapore interlink their real-time payment systems with India and Thailand and upgrade data formats, cross-border transfers may become as easy as domestic ones, removing the translation-layer friction that Wise profits from.

    “Singapore has done this or is doing this with India and Thailand.”

0.44

Incumbents, social platforms, and stablecoins or CBDCs threaten Wise's cross-border position.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Neobanks such as Revolut can offer cross-border transfers and foreign exchange for free by cross-subsidizing them with subscription fees and other ancillary revenue, making transfers a loss leader that Wise cannot easily match on price.

    “one of the biggest risks I see for Wise is where a business decides to use cross-border transfers and foreign exchange is a bit of a loss leader”

  • Visa and Mastercard, with products like Visa Direct and Mastercard Send, pose a serious threat to Wise because they already have global bank relationships, brand awareness and networks that could enable near real-time cross-border transfers linked to cards.

    “Visa and Mastercard have made serious investments in cross-border transfers through acquisition and organic growth.”

  • If the world moves toward sending money as easily as an instant message, social media platforms such as Meta and Twitter, which already have global reach and user accounts, represent a significant competitive threat to Wise.

    “if you see the world moving towards a place where moving money around is it's easy as sending an instant message, then the social media players represent a significant threat”

  • Private stablecoins or central bank digital currencies could make fiat transfers between bank accounts obsolete, a paradigm shift that James calls a big threat to Wise, noting around 90% of central banks are researching or experimenting with CBDCs.

    “around 90% of all central banks globally are researching or experimenting with central bank digital currencies”

  • Western Union was founded in 1851 as a telegraph company and later added money transfers on top of its communications business.

    “Founded in 1851 essentially as a telegraph company.”

0.24

A public listing adds trust and liquidity for a business that depends on customer trust.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • For a financial services business whose value depends on trust, a publicly visible stock ticker adds credibility when the company pitches to RFPs or customers, as James observed from his own experience at a company that listed in 2019.

    “if they can see your ticker on a stock exchange, there is added brand trust there.”

  • Wise chose a direct listing on the London Stock Exchange in 2021 without raising capital, to increase liquidity for existing shareholders and to raise awareness and customer ownership, and a public ticker adds brand trust for a business reliant on trust.

    “if you don't need capital, there are other reasons you might want to... increase the liquidity for existing shareholders”

  • Slack and Spotify are high-profile examples of companies that used direct listings rather than traditional IPOs.

    “I think Slack did it, Spotify also did it.”

0.20

Market size and regulatory attention signal a large but heavily scrutinized opportunity for Wise.

2 pointscentrality 2/5
  • The global cross-border payments market moves roughly GBP 100 trillion a year, of which about GBP 2 trillion is personal and about GBP 9 trillion is small business transfers, and banks hold about two-thirds of the market while money transfer operators hold roughly 10% to 20%.

    “about 2/3 still sits with banks, about 10% to 20% with money transfer operators”

  • The United Nations has set a goal that cross-border transfer fees should be close to 3% by 2030, and regulators such as the G20 and the FSB are focused on the issue, partly because migrants sending money home bear the heaviest costs.

    “UN have set of goal that by 2030, cross-border transfer fees should be close to 3%”

0.07

Autonomous cross-functional teams keep alignment high without slowing as the company grows.

2 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Wise organizes its work into more than 100 small, autonomous, cross-functional teams that set their own missions and objectives and compete for prioritization, producing high alignment with loose coupling, which is the structure needed to avoid the slowdown of growing companies.

    “the thesis around having very highly aligned but very loosely coupled people within your organization to overcome this inertia”

  • Organizations with low alignment and high autonomy create empowered silos that duplicate work or pull in opposite directions, while high alignment with low autonomy becomes command-and-control, and both patterns struggle to scale.

    “very highly aligned but very loosely coupled people within your organization to overcome this inertia”