What this covers

This is a clip-driven roundup. Dom and Matt of Making Media revisit advice from guests across the show and add their own commentary. The voices include Sara Fischer on funding, Simon on subscriptions, David Senra and Doug DeMuro on longevity, Lenny on a business that grows out of its newsletter, and Neil on running a team.

The most contested material concerns money. Fischer argues that media is slow and labor-intensive, so large raises at lofty valuations push companies to grow in ways the industry cannot sustain. She puts a sensible ceiling near 3x on the revenue multiple for media, with investors paying far more once a software component is attached. Matt goes further and forecasts that software multiples will be corrected within about three years, since many self-described software businesses have worse churn and stickiness than ad or event businesses. Dom cites Spotify's costly effort to recruit celebrity podcast hosts as evidence that audience trust can't be bought. Matt adds that the best media businesses are often slow-growing ones nobody hears about.

The remainder is practical. Dom and Doug favor starting low and scaling up, and DeMuro's setup includes a $40 tripod. Senra's unpaid years and unbroken weekly schedule since August 2018 illustrate duration as a moat. Simon recommends delaying paywalls and building distinct products for super fans, as Axios did, and Dom admits Colossus has struggled to design a paid product for the same reason. Dom also explains why he took the Making Media newsletter back under one voice, and argues that a newsletter is a direct relationship the company controls. The episode closes on remote-team habits and the value of early, direct conversations.

Sharpest takeaway

Dom and Matt argue that durable media businesses are built by serving the listener, keeping production simple and cheap, and staying in the game for a long time, and that chasing funding-market valuations or scale undermines this.

  • Listeners, not advertisers or guests, are the root of the business, and neglecting them makes everything else fail
  • Media is labor-intensive and slow-growing, so it should not be raised or valued like a software business
  • Low-cost, simple production is a durable advantage because you can upgrade later but cannot easily downgrade
  • Duration and consistency are among the few real moats in media

The argument · threads4 threads · 42 claims
0.85

Media businesses should grow slowly by self-funding from market gaps and cheaper production.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The media businesses that grow slowly are often the best, and they are frequently the ones people never hear about, because chasing views and the funding economy is a different and often dilutive game.

    “I think the media businesses that grow slower are actually the best out there.”

  • Rather than being dictated by the funding market, a media business should ask where the market is not going and what segment people are leaving behind, then use that gap through self-investment, sponsorship, or partnerships to build something sustainable.

    “If you realize that's where the market is going, okay, where isn't the market going?”

  • The minimum spend to reach acceptable quality is much lower for audio than for video, so creators who cannot meet a video quality bar should compensate by focusing on substance, as Doug DeMuro does.

    “Audio versus video is massive difference. The quality in audio is noticeable, but the threshold or the minimum spend to reach that quality is much different”

  • MasterClass spending a million dollars on sets to monetize consumers is a model that will likely have to change, but changing production quality will be painful for the business.

    “you could spend $1 million on sets in MasterClass, and I'm curious to see what happens to that business model.”

0.71

Subscription and software businesses are overvalued and copycat-prone because their models lack durability.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Advertising is cyclical but often cash-flow positive, events can be highly profitable, and neither will earn a large software-style multiple, whereas software is treated as an overly broad asset class even though many self-described software businesses have worse revenue sensitivity and stickiness.

    “over the next three years, you're going to learn that there's not a lot of businesses that classify themselves as software that probably have worse actual revenue sensitivity.”

  • Public-market enthusiasm for subscription businesses increases supply of similar-looking courses and subscription products, and because funding flows to the narrative, many of these copycats fail even though the model suits only the upper tier of such businesses.

    “You just see a ton of courses. You just see a ton of subscription products.”

  • Many course products look like easy upfront revenue, but they are not differentiated and customers churn quickly, so building a subscription business around them is a poor strategy.

    “there are a lot of low-dangling fruits that don't actually feel differentiated. Customers would probably buy them upfront, but then they would churn fast.”

  • Software is being treated as an overly broad asset class, and many businesses that call themselves software have worse revenue sensitivity than media, being easy to churn with little stickiness, so the high multiples attached to them are likely to be corrected within about three years.

    “software is getting treated as insanely broad asset class. And over the next three years, you're going to learn that there's not a lot of businesses that classify themselves as software that probably have worse actual revenue sensitivity.”

0.50

Audience relationships and first-party data are the most valuable direct channels for media businesses.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Listeners are often a media company's future guests or sponsors, since they understand the business and its value proposition best, so a business model can be built from listeners converting into customers in non-obvious ways.

    “the listener is oftentimes our future guest or our future sponsor.”

  • Colossus's newsletter audience is perhaps one-tenth or one-twentieth the size of its podcast listener base, so it reaches fewer of the total audience, but it offers a direct channel that podcasts lack because of opaque data.

    “maybe it's one-tenth, maybe one-twentieth the size of our podcast listener base.”

  • Talk of first-party data is overemphasized, yet it has become the most important thing in the industry, as many businesses are built around collecting it and internet changes make it increasingly relevant.

    “I oftentimes think there's a little bit too much talk about first-party data, but it was very clear that it was the most important thing”

0.15

Teams and operators should build loyalty and accountability beyond purely transactional relationships.

2 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Remote work removes the casual check-ins of an office, so teams must deliberately ask about personal lives, because a purely transactional remote environment creates little loyalty and people feel bad about spending meeting time on anything but the agenda.

    “There's zero loyalty created when you have just a pure transactional environment that is on steroids in a remote work environment.”

  • Matt notes that two of three guests he recommended to Patrick O'Shaughnessy for Invest Like the Best, Brad Jacobs and Jeff Green, later appeared, and the third, Charlie Munger, appeared on Acquired, which illustrates how writing predictions down lets people check where they were right.

    “Two out of three.”