What this covers

This is a year-end recap in which Matt and Dom take stock of the podcast industry and of Making Media's first year. The industry half is built on numbers: December downloads for the top 20 publishers were down 24% year over year, new RSS feeds hit a five-year low of just over 200,000, and CPM rates fell about 10%, from roughly $25 to $22, according to Libsyn. They argue over how much of this is real. Apple's iOS 17 change to auto-download is blamed for part of the drop, though Matt concedes how much is debatable. Dom ties the ad slowdown to the end of cheap money and says Making Media felt it directly in selling certain shows.

The middle of the conversation turns on how to read a downturn. Matt brings in capital cycle investing, where opportunity tends to appear as supply shrinks, and prefers calm markets because booms attract silly ideas. Dom adds that podcasts are easy to launch, hard to maintain, and harder to scale, and Matt notes the power law still holds. Dom treats Spotify's press announcements about cutting shows as a barometer of industry direction.

The rest is about Making Media itself. They grade year one a 4 out of 5, withholding the 5 for limited scale, and weigh relationships over audience size. Dom singles out the flat ~95% retention curve on the No Laying Up episode and the Spike Eskin episode's frameworks for multi-host shows. They also float a favorite-media interview format and discuss how persistent outreach emails land unusual guests.

Sharpest takeaway

Matt and Dom argue that 2023's podcast-industry declines are partly measurement artifacts and partly cyclical, so the downturn is an investing opportunity, and that Making Media should be judged by relationships and niche access rather than downloads.

  • Download counts are inflated by passive auto-downloads, so one download does not equal another
  • Industry declines in downloads and ad rates are tied to iOS 17 changes and interest rates, which are cyclical
  • Capital-cycle investing says the best opportunities appear when industry supply shrinks
  • Making Media's success is measured by guest relationships, connections, and audience quality

The argument · threads6 threads · 50 claims
0.85

Headline podcast metrics mislead, since downloads are inflated and the industry is probably fine beneath them.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The retention chart for the No Laying Up episode is a flat line at about 95% across roughly 90 minutes, unlike any other podcast retention chart Dom has seen, indicating an exceptionally loyal audience.

    “it basically is a flat line at 95%. No chart I've seen of any other podcasts looks remotely similar.”

  • Download counts on platforms like Apple are inflated because users who subscribed years ago and never unsubscribed keep auto-downloading episodes they never listen to, so one download does not equal another.

    “one download does not equal another download. Those two things can be very different.”

  • Spotify's podcast press announcements, including cutting launched shows and focusing on profitable ones and creators who have been around longer, are a good barometer for overall industry direction.

    “Spotify for me has always been a really good barometer for the overall industry.”

  • Podcasts are easy to launch, very hard to maintain, and even harder to scale, a dynamic that will always be true and is reflected in the declining numbers.

    “the classic thing of podcasts are really easy to launch, very hard to maintain, even harder to scale, I think, will always be true”

  • Headline podcast metrics look bad, but under the surface the industry is probably fine, so the graphs should not be read at face value.

    “probably not all that it seems. Like if you look at the graph... I think under the surface, things are just fine.”

0.52

Guest relationships and a favorite-media interview format are valuable enough to pursue despite cold-pitch awkwardness.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Building relationships with guests beyond the recording is very valuable, because guests give their time and wisdom selflessly, and relationships formed through events like Capital Camp deepen the value of the show.

    “when those relationships go beyond the recording. Which I always think is a very selfless thing to do.”

  • A promising new format would invite guests to talk about their favorite piece of media rather than their business, letting conversations uncover what they do and how they think about life.

    “we're going to talk to you about your favorite piece of media ever. And it can be anything, but it has to be a piece of media.”

  • Interviewing guests about their favorite piece of media rather than their business is a format Dom wants to try, but the cold pitch sounds embarrassing and accomplished people may decline as uninteresting.

    “we're going to talk to you about your favorite piece of media ever. And it can be anything, but it has to be a piece of media.”

  • There are millions of people doing incredible work that the listener has never heard of, and while one cannot learn about most of them, diving into a new operator's work and finding them impressive is a satisfying experience.

    “there on the planet right now exist millions of people doing incredible work that you've never heard of before.”

0.46

The advertising slowdown is cyclical, driven by interest rates ending the era of cheap money.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The ad-rate and industry slowdown is largely related to interest rates, with the end of the era of free money creating a downturn that is cyclical and likely to reverse eventually.

    “I like to explain it with interest rates. The era of free money is over. Podcasting is going through a downturn.”

  • The downturn in podcast advertising is probably linked to interest rates, since the era of cheap money is over, and the ad slowdown was felt directly in Making Media's own business, harder to sell certain shows than the prior year.

    “I like to explain it with interest rates. The era of free money is over. Podcasting is going through a downturn.”

  • Dom believes most things are cyclical, so the podcast advertising slowdown will likely come back, though he admits his reflections are simple.

    “And I'm sure at some point, they'll come back. I'd like to believe that most things are cyclical.”

0.44

Interview preparation difficulty depends on how much context Dom has, and guests' reactions reveal their attitudes.

5 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Matt Levine declined to dissect one of his own pieces because he does not remember his past writing, having produced it on a daily basis, which signals resistance to the proposed format.

    “I don't think that would be particularly interesting partly because I don't remember anything that I've written because I'm doing it on a daily basis”

  • Matt was most nervous before the Matt Levine conversation because he thought it had strong content and wanted to avoid mishandling it, while Dom found the Joanna Robinson Marvel conversation hardest to prepare for given his limited context.

    “I think Matt Levine was probably the one that I had the most nerves going into”

  • Dom jokingly claims credit for getting Matt to pronounce niche as 'niches', which Matt rejects because he has always been a niche guy.

    “probably my proudest achievement this year is getting you to say niches, not niches”

  • Dom found the Joanna Robinson conversation on the Marvel Cinematic Universe hardest to prepare for because he had little context and worried every question sounded stupid.

    “I felt like every time I asked a question, I was thinking, this must be such a stupid question to ask.”

  • Dom found the No Laying Up conversation the easiest to prep for because he knew so much about their story from years of listening, which made it easier to build questions, though it also made him reflect on conversations where he knows less.

    “that was probably the easiest one I had to prep for just because I knew so much about their story”

0.38

The Spike Eskin, Kevin Espiritu, and Making Media episodes offer the most useful lessons for media operators.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • The Spike Eskin episode, drawing on sports radio, contains frameworks highly applicable to podcast creation, especially for shows with more than one host.

    “if anyone ever asked what do I need to know about podcasting from a creation standpoint and particularly if you have more than one host, then that episode is phenomenal.”

  • The Kevin Espiritu episode is the one to recommend to other media operators, since he is an excellent operator whose business-building story is highly instructive.

    “I think that's the episode I'd recommend to most other media operators.”

  • Making Media released over 50 episodes in its first year, close to one per week, achieved by a few double-episode weeks and insight-class episodes alongside guest interviews.

    “We're over 50 episodes. So we've done -- we're actually on par for more than an episode a week”

  • Dom believes the Spike Eskin episode is the one to hear for anyone wanting to know about podcast creation, especially shows with more than one host, and speculates it may have helped Eskin land on Ben Thompson's Stratechery.

    “if anyone ever asked what do I need to know about podcasting from a creation standpoint and particularly if you have more than one host, then that episode is phenomenal.”

0.12

Team pride scores and listener out-of-five ratings are tools for gauging the show's reception.

2 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Dom wants a graph of the weekly proudness scores with easy access to comments to test whether the team's pride follows any seasonal trend, though he suspects there is none.

    “I want a graph, and I want some easy way of looking at the comments. I don't think there's a trend to our comments, I think.”

  • Dom asks listeners to send in their own out-of-5 opinions of Making Media to make the grading unbiased.

    “To make it unbiased, I'd like anyone to send in their opinions out of 5.”