Modernizing Compliance
What this covers
In this conversation, Roxanne Petraeus, founder of the compliance training company Ethena, talks with Patrick about why she built it and what she learned along the way. The evidence she leans on is wide-ranging. She borrows the military maxim train like you fight to argue that training should rehearse real situations. She cites a study of one military unit in which troops' perception of whether their leader actively cared best predicted harassment rates. She also notes that in 2019 more CEOs were removed for personal misconduct than for missing earnings. She says employees judge priorities by what gets resourced, so clunky ethics courses beside polished sales training teach the wrong lesson. Her answer is digestible training: about five minutes a month through Slack or email.
The middle of the discussion is about building in a regulated market. She describes New York's rule requiring annual harassment training at every employer, and six states whose requirements differ enough to defeat a single national course. That fragmentation is the kind of schlep she argues a startup can turn into an advantage. Her advice to founders includes keeping a rough, duct-taped version before committing to infrastructure, and interviewing domain experts until the same problems keep recurring. Her stated long-term plan is a compliance OS that delivers nudge-style reminders at the moment of action, such as anti-bribery guidance before a trip to China.
The last stretch turns to venture capital and is more contested. She points to a Harvard Business School study on the defensive questions women founders get, to the fall in funding for all-women teams from about 2.9 to 2.2 percent, and to the bias in early-stage bets on a person. She also touches on servant leadership and the limits of rank in startups.
Roxanne Petraeus argues that compliance training fails because it is built to check a box rather than change behavior, and that redesigning it as short, relevant, well-designed content, backed by visible leadership commitment, can actually reduce workplace misconduct.
- Check-the-box training signals that an organization does not take an issue seriously, and some studies show it can increase bias
- Employees read leadership priorities from what gets resourced, so ethics training must be as good as sales training
- Regulatory fragmentation and dated design make compliance a solvable product problem, and solving it creates a business advantage
Traditional compliance training is a formality that fails to change measurable behavior.
- Traditional compliance training is designed to provide legal cover or a completion certificate rather than to change behavior, so it signals that the topic is a formality and produces no measurable change.
“how would you train if you actually designed it to be effective versus just check a box or provide legal cover”
- Employees are good at reading what leadership actually values, so if an ethics course is clunky and inaccessible while sales training is polished, employees will conclude that sales matters and code of conduct does not, regardless of stated values.
“that employee gets that what's important is sales and what is not important is code of conduct”
- The check-the-box training pattern Petraeus saw in the military, with PowerPoints, hot auditoriums, and rotating presenters, also appears in private-sector finance, so the problem is not specific to the military.
“check-the-box training actually existed in the private sector too”
- There is no evidence that compliance training prevents harassment, and at least one study of sexual harassment prevention training found participants showed more unconscious gender bias after training than before.
“there's actually no evidence to show that compliance training does that. Unfortunately, there are studies that show that it's not just ineffective, but it actually produces a backlash”
- A graphic-novel office romance nudge for February received strongly positive feedback, leading the team to conclude that learners respond to the format and to produce more non-traditional formats.
“we released a nudge a couple of months ago that was done via graphic novel. It was a very fun office romance”
- Ethena collects over 150,000 pieces of learner feedback through thumbs up, thumbs down, and question-mark ratings after each nudge, and roughly 30 percent of learners add optional free-text comments, which the content team reviews weekly to revise nudges.
“we have over 150,000 pieces of learner feedback at this point”
- Someone in finance reportedly added up required training and found it came to about 10 hours per quarter, a large cost in employee time that compliance training imposes.
“someone told me that they added up all of the required training that they need to do and it was just an astronomical 10 hours or something quarterly”
- Mandatory compliance training is typically a boring, dated, click-through experience with certificates that expire in about a year, and employees treat it as a box to check rather than something that changes their behavior.
“how would you train if you actually designed it to be effective versus just check a box or provide legal cover”
- The company's core hypothesis was that digestible training outperforms all-at-once training because people have short attention spans, while the training must still be high quality because compliance topics are inherently fascinating.
“our hypothesis was digestible training is better than all at once because people have really short attention spans.”
- Compliance training resembles eating kale when you are not, meaning it appears to be doing something good for the organization but does not actually produce the intended outcome.
“Someone had joked to me that it's like you think you're eating kale when you're actually not”
- Compliance content has no reason to be a PowerPoint; it can be a podcast, comic, or short-form video, and the design should signal the organization takes the topic seriously.
“There's no reason that training has to be a PowerPoint. It could be a podcast, it could be a comic, it could be short-form video.”
- A single compliance curriculum for everyone fails, because a salesperson and an engineer face different versions of issues such as anti-money laundering, so training should be personalized to job function.
“One size fits all doesn't work. So training relevant based on someone's work stream”
Investors apply biased scrutiny to women founders, which deliberate policy can correct.
- During pre-seed fundraising, an investor asked Petraeus whether she was pregnant, unprompted and unrelated to the conversation, and when she pointed out it could be illegal, he replied that it was not a job interview, indicating awareness of the norm rather than ignorance of it.
“he said, 'Well, it's not a job interview so it's not illegal.' Which indicated that this wasn't a knowledge problem”
- In the most recent survey, venture capital going to all-women founding teams fell from a high of about 2.9 percent to about 2.2 percent, which cannot be squared with an efficient market that fairly evaluates founders.
“it is down from a whopping high of something like 2.9% down to 2.2%”
- Pre-seed and seed investing asks whether a founder can do something amazing with very little data, with no financials to evaluate, so it is a bet on the person that is especially prone to bias.
“venture is so ripe for bias because what you're asking is, do I think somebody can do something amazing based on very little data?”
- Investors can counter the defensive-question bias by making a deliberate policy to ask every founder 'how does this become a billion-dollar business' type questions, rather than only the ones who fit their image of a founder.
“make sure that if you tend to ask majority opportunity, dream with me questions, you do that for all founders who come in the door”
- A Harvard Business School study found that women founders are asked mostly defensive questions about risks and moats, while men are asked mostly opportunistic questions about growth, and defensive questioning puts founders on their back foot, making them less bold in their answers.
“women founders who were pitching get asked majority defensive questions, whereas men founders who are pitching get the majority of opportunistic type questions”
- Investor interest in funded women rises once a company shows breakout traction, which reflects pressure over portfolio diversity rather than a real change in willingness to fund women, so the desire to have funded women does not translate into funding them.
“That there's a desire to have funded women, but not to fund women”
- Investors question women founders' dedication in ways they would not question a man's passion for an outside interest, such as rock climbing, which reveals an asymmetric ambition check.
“if I had been a really passionate rock climber, nobody would look at me as a founder and say, I'm worried about your dedication to this company”
- Ethena once sent a nudge on harassment in venture capital to test investors, and someone noted that an investor who did not want to see it was unlikely to be a good partner, so the nudge functioned as a screening device.
“someone told me it was a perfect screening device because anyone who got that nudge and did not want to see that probably would also not be a great investor for us.”
Compliance should be rebuilt as short, timely, product-tested content at the point of action.
- Delivering about five minutes of compliance content per month through Slack or email, instead of an hour-long annual course, removes login and completion barriers and fits short attention spans, which increases engagement.
“digestible training over time. So think about five minutes a month delivered via Slack or email, because we want to remove all of the barriers to doing this training”
- Using a current news story, such as the Harvey Weinstein case, to illustrate quid pro quo harassment in a nudge made the content resonate, showing that tying training to events people already follow increases engagement.
“we used that in one of our nudges and said, there's no reason we can't explain quid pro quo harassment with something that's in the news”
- Ethena plans a compliance operating system that delivers reminders at the point of action, such as an insider-trading nudge at a brokerage or a political-donation reminder at a donation site, replacing reactive weekly email lists and manual tracking.
“Wouldn't it be great if when instead you went to ActBlue, there was a pop-up that reminded you about your company's policies?”
- Companies that are bold and visionary about products often freeze when confronted with harassment or hiring diversity, but the same principles used to build great companies can produce solutions to these problems.
“Apply the same principles that you do to building a great company to these problems”
- In compliance software, the buyer is usually legal or people ops, but the employee is the user, and the two needs align because a clunky employee experience generates complaints that land on the administrator, so fixing employee pain also serves the buyer.
“if our training is really hard to access and you have issues with log-in or whatever, the employee is emailing that lawyer at the company”
- The long-term vision is to deliver training tied to moments a learner is about to face, such as anti-bribery training a week before a business trip to China, so training is temporally relevant and delivered just in time.
“what if we could send training based on particular moments that we know you're about to have?”
- Compliance content should be built with product discipline, meaning measurable learner feedback and fast iteration, because the goal is comprehension rather than art, and in-house content production enables experimentation that a marketplace model would undermine.
“we should approach content like product people. That feedback loop that you mentioned is crucial. We're not poets here”
Customer-led simulated building validates demand before committing engineering effort.
- Ethena's first version was offered free to venture firm portfolio companies in exchange for their honest critique, launched about three to four weeks after the co-founders first met, to test demand before building functionality.
“the exchange of value was, we'll get you compliant in a way that we think is much better than any of your other options. And in exchange, we would just love to know how bad our approach was”
- Early product decisions such as notification frequency should be kept flexible and simulated with duct-taped systems until real user data shows the right default; the team found monthly was the default, with an admin dial to adjust it.
“we have tried not to build things until we're confident that it's right and instead simulate with things that are sort of held together with duct tape”
- New York changed its sexual harassment training rules to require every company with one or more employees to train annually, creating a sudden market need that a compliance product could serve, with a deadline of October 2019.
“It went from I believe no requirements, to actually requiring every company with one or more employees to train annually”
- Three lessons for building software quickly are having a complementary co-founder with product skill, talking to end users constantly, and simulating features before building them, which together reduce wasted engineering work.
“Three lessons are coming to mind. One is have a great co-founder.”
- Talking directly with early adopters is the most valuable sales activity; early calls were mostly product-learning sessions, and this shaped the company's sales motion around product development.
“the single most valuable thing that I can be doing is talking to customers and especially our early adopters, the innovators”
- A TechCrunch article about Ethena led to an early lead at Netflix, and the company later learned that Reed Hastings had forwarded the article to his legal team, which shows that media coverage can create executive-level attention.
“Reed Hastings had seen the TechCrunch article on us and had forwarded it to his legal team”
Caring leadership, not rank, determines whether conduct problems are taken seriously.
- In 2019, more CEOs were removed for personal indiscretions such as harassment, discrimination, bullying, and financial misconduct than for missing earnings targets, which indicates that conduct problems carry major business consequences.
“in 2019 more CEOs were removed for personal indiscretions”
- Effective military training works because it repeats the exact actions required in the real task, such as practicing parachute rigging in a mock-up, which is why 'train like you fight, fight like you train' is the standard.
“it's about making sure that the way in which you train resembles the exact thing you're going to do”
- A study of a military unit over a year found that the strongest determinant of harassment prevalence was whether troops perceived their leader as actively caring, meaning that incidents would be taken seriously as a leadership priority.
“the biggest determinant of the prevalence of harassment in military units was whether the leader of that particular unit was perceived as actively caring”
- Great leaders care for the people they lead, so leadership is a privilege; rank-based hierarchy works only in brief, dangerous, time-sensitive moments, and in startups, where talent has many options, relying on rank drives talent away.
“great leaders care”
Startups win by absorbing regulatory schlep and turning it into customer value.
- Six states regulate sexual harassment training with requirements different enough that companies cannot use the same course nationwide, which is a source of schlep; a company that solves this mapping turns the pain into a competitive advantage.
“there are six states that regulate the training and I'm kind of convinced that the e-learning lobby had a hand in these regulations”
- After a company-wide launch of harassment training, employees in other departments such as recruiting or anti-bribery ask to use the platform for their own needs, so each successful launch earns the right to sell the next product.
“When we as a company really deliver on our first launch, we actually get to see almost a bottom-up sales adoption”
- Ethena commissioned a detailed legal memo from Latham and Watkins showing how its content meets each state's requirements and the EEOC's 2016 training guidance, which functions as documented proof for buyers.
“we work with Latham and Watkins to demonstrate in excruciating detail, like 25-page memo, how we meet these different state requirements”
- Early-stage founders should keep talking to smart domain experts until they keep hearing the same problem statements, at which point the marginal value of further conversations is zero and it is time to build.
“Have conversations until the marginal value goes to zero". Meaning you just keep hearing the same problem statements over and over.”
- The company's first pilot exchanged free compliance training for portfolio companies in return for candid feedback on how bad the approach was, which let it learn quickly before investing heavily in features.
“the exchange of value was, we'll get you compliant in a way that we think is much better than any of your other options. And in exchange, we would just love to know how bad our approach was.”
- Entering a complicated regulatory space creates a moat when the startup absorbs the schlep of figuring out regulations, because customers who face a pain point value the solution once it is done.
“then we take all of that mess and it becomes an advantage for us because we're able to say like, "You know this pain point, you know it's very difficult, we've solved it."”
- Investors suggested the company become a platform connecting content creators to companies, but Petraeus rejected that because compliance requires control, so the company built content in-house to gain the muscle memory needed to expand later.
“That seems like you lose a lot of control and for compliance, that's not a great idea.”
Leaders have few tools to signal ethics, so investigations must show structural seriousness.
- Research on workplace misconduct suggests that the main lever is leadership buy-in, because employees understand which behaviors get people promoted or fired, so when leaders are part of the problem the solution is very difficult.
“it really is all about leadership buy-in. Employees are incredibly smart and they understand what types of behaviors get someone promoted and what behaviors get someone fired”
- Leaders who want to show ethics matters have few tools; an all-hands speech is the main option, and investigations of misconduct should focus on structural causes rather than scapegoating individuals.
“There aren't a lot of great tools right now to allow her to do that so she could at all hands say, 'Hey, I care about this.'”
- Few tools exist that let a CEO demonstrate that ethics and code of conduct are priorities, so leaders can only make statements at all-hands meetings, which employees discount.
“There aren't a lot of great tools right now to allow her to do that so she could at all hands say, "Hey, I care about this."”
- When misconduct occurs, a proper investigation aimed at finding what went wrong structurally signals seriousness, whereas quietly sweeping issues under the rug or hanging one person out to dry does not.
“instead of feeling like it was swept under the rug, there was a proper investigation in which the goal was really to figure out what structurally went wrong. Not just hang someone out to dry.”
Institutions should use their influence to invest in people as whole persons.
- Remote work has broken down the rigid barrier between personal and professional life, so companies should design for schedule flexibility and treat employees as whole people, though the specific work-from-home setup may not persist.
“I think that this really rigid barrier between personal and professional has just been blown up by the pandemic”
- The Rhodes Scholarship's distinctive value is a deliberately diverse, interdisciplinary cohort of about 32 American students at Oxford, and the platform it provides carries a responsibility to use influence for things that improve people's lives.
“32 students a year from the US go to Oxford and get to learn with an international cohort”
- Martin Feldstein's kindness toward Petraeus, including mentoring her through college and drawing a supply and demand curve by hand to explain government spending, shows that a busy expert's investment in a student's learning has a magnifying effect during formative years.
“once he got out of pen and paper and drew a supply and demand curve for me”