Mastering Mental Models
What this covers
This is a conversation in which Patrick questions Shane Parrish about building a personal Repository of Mental Models. Parrish's starting point is that people learn ideas inside one discipline and fail to carry them elsewhere, so he collects examples from unrelated places, such as an NFL coach's decisions or Atticus Finch's behavior, to use as heuristics later. From there the talk moves to automation. Dashboards turn reality into numbers or colors, a case of Map Versus Territory, and the useful question when a metric goes red is whether something has changed. Culture, which he treats as shared stories competitors can't copy, gets the same attention, including fixed and growth mindsets at company level.
The middle of the conversation is the most contested. Parrish argues that matching the norm leaves a firm in the middle of a Gaussian Distribution, and he cites Warren Buffett leaving the textile industry's reinvestment habit. He adds that most deviators fail, so only correct deviation counts. Patrick offers a Multifactor Model of the self, in which someone at the 15th percentile on three independent traits lands near the 1st percentile combined. They also take up whether data will confer lasting advantage as Machine Learning spreads, and when outsourcing hands advantage to someone else.
The last stretch is about how Parrish learns. He prefers old books to bestsellers, many of which vanish within a decade or lean on studies that fail to replicate. He read 152 books in 2014 and concluded that finishing them was not the same as learning. He also covers practicing recovery on snow, the regrets of the elderly, the loss of uninterrupted focus, and the 2013 decision to put his name on his blog.
Parrish argues that lasting advantage comes from adaptability, culture, and a personal repository of cross-disciplinary mental models, while automation and fast, new-focused information consumption erode the understanding needed to adapt.
- Automated dashboards compress reality into maps, so people miss when the underlying territory has changed
- Culture is a series of shared stories that competitors cannot easily copy, unlike products or service
- Reading for learning favors old, slow-changing books over most new bestsellers, which tend to disappear within a decade
Growth mindset requires deliberately working at personal limits against the brain's fixed-thinking habits.
- Learning from pushing physical limits, such as running a hill harder than usual each morning, transfers to mental and non-physical tasks because it builds a habit of working at a frontier.
“that daily reminder, that bit of physical learning, of messing around at a frontier, mental and physical, then bleeds into the rest of my day.”
- Most people have an external locus of control, where others' opinions drive them, and the most practical way to keep a growth mindset is to surround oneself with people who are notably better in key dimensions, making oneself the least common denominator.
“Basically making yourself the least common denominator among those that you're with.”
- Because the brain naturally builds heuristics and habits that make the fixed mindset the easiest path, maintaining a growth mindset requires deliberate strain and discomfort, and red flags of fixed thinking can be used to detect when one has slipped.
“the fixed mindset is the easiest path, right? That the brain is really good at creating heuristics and subroutines, habits, that become easy to repeat.”
Automation should be applied selectively, so that frontier work does not go blind.
- Patrick's prior view that automation is almost entirely beneficial is challenged by the claim that automation can create blindness and reduce the growth potential in an area once a process runs without scrutiny.
“What you're saying is that it might create sort of a blindness or a lack of potential for growth in an area because once something's automated, you just let it work.”
- Patrick argues that the most useful lesson from programming is recognizing which repeated, complicated blocks of work can and should be automated versus which work stays creative and organic at the frontier, using the idea of chunking to describe how that repeatability is learned.
“the understanding of what can be automated and not. You use this term chunking.”
Small teams and personal multifactor profiles are underrated sources of competitive leverage.
- A person ranked at the 15th percentile on three independent traits could land near the 1st percentile on a combined three-factor model, so mapping one's personal multifactor profile is an underrated source of competitive advantage.
“if you're in the 15th percentile or something on 3 things, it's likely that if you did a 3 factor model on those 3 things, you're in the 1st percentile”
- Venkatesh Rao's crucible is a group of about 12 smart but different people who compete and cooperate to produce creative work, contrasted with the lone-wolf model of building an empire alone.
“a guy that you had on your podcast named Venkatesh Rao, has this idea of the crucible. Which is sort of like a 12 person, ideally a 12-person sized group”
- Patrick has found that outsourcing has become dramatically easier over his career, so the future of work may favor smaller groups over large corporations because technology gives small teams leverage.
“I just wonder if the future looks like smaller groups versus bigger corporations, just because of the leverage provided by technology.”