What this covers

This is a three-way conversation in which Simon makes most of the case while Matt and Dom test it against how platforms and creators actually behave. It opens on marketing: audiences are fragmented, ad blockers and ad-free tiers limit reach, and a paid YouTube pre-roll disappears when spend stops while an owned channel compounds. From there it turns to publishing economics. Simon calls the picture of pre-internet newspapers running six-month investigations romanticized, and he calls the promise of programmatic advertising a lie that fed scam sites and drained quality publishers.

The middle stretch is about what works instead. Simon points to POLITICO Pro, the Bloomberg Terminal, and Axios's abandoned $10,000 plan as proof that niche products essential to well-funded clients can command high prices. He forecasts that purely subscription-driven companies have a weak future, urges delaying a paywall until the audience is built, and argues that closing comment sections was a mistake. He also describes hybrid companies that give star journalists equity or revenue shares. Matt counters that upfront equity cannot be extended indefinitely, which limits how far a company like Puck can scale.

The sharpest disagreement concerns platforms. Matt holds that money and incentives drive behavior more than viewership, so Spotify should favor monetizable podcasts and look more like YouTube than TikTok. He was surprised that Simon expects YouTube Shorts to win. Dom notes that platforms push formats, as YouTube pushed shorter videos, and warns against over-optimizing for them. The episode closes on tactics: email as a decentralized channel, Substack's Recommendations, weekly one-question polls, and consistency as a moat.

Sharpest takeaway

Simon Owens argues media is moving from top-down, ad-funded institutions toward creator-led hybrids, where equity-linked talent, owned audience relationships, and differentiated niche products matter more than scale and early paywalls.

  • Talent equity and revenue shares replace salaried employment to retain star journalists and scale creator businesses
  • Subscription-only models proved hard to sustain alone, so advertising and sponsorships are returning alongside subscriptions
  • Publishers that delay paywalls, build owned audiences, and offer super-fan products outperform those chasing scale or open programmatic traffic

The argument · threads10 threads · 81 claims
0.85

Free owned-audience building should precede hybrid paid models, because paywalls block discovery in fragmented markets.

14 pointscentrality 5/5
  • After two years of failed experiments, Simon's working subscription product is themed live Zoom office hours with paying subscribers and recruited experts, recorded and distributed to those who could not attend.

    “launching these things called Office Hours. These were basically themed live Zoom calls with my paying subscribers”

  • Traditional marketing channels show diminishing returns because audiences are fragmented: there is no longer a monoculture of 50 million people watching the same show or reading the same magazine, and ad blockers and ad-free tiers make reaching consumers harder.

    “The traditional marketing channels that brands had to rely on are showing increasingly diminishing returns. Audiences are becoming way more fragmented.”

  • The top priority is to delay launching a subscription product as long as possible and grow the audience first, because paywalled content cannot be shared or discovered and so undermines audience growth.

    “The moment that you launch a subscription product, you're tying your hand behind your back”

  • A paid YouTube pre-roll stops reaching audiences the moment spend ends, while the same budget spent building an owned YouTube channel compounds through evergreen content that pays off for years.

    “The second that your ad spend runs out, those ads stop showing to the audience. There's no evergreen long-tail benefit from that.”

  • Around 2017 to 2020, the rise of Substack and the 1,000 true fans idea led many launches to be subscription-only, but publishers then realized subscription economics are hard to sustain on their own, prompting a shift back toward advertising.

    “a rude awakening where a lot of publishers and creators just realized how difficult subscription economics are, at least just by themselves”

  • Before a full subscription, creators can generate some revenue with a low-effort, low-priced Patreon-style offer, such as $5 a month or $50 a year to support free journalism.

    “maybe start with more of a Patreon-ish model, like a low-priced product, saying for $5 a month, $50 a year”

  • Instead of adding more free content or locking extra content behind a paywall, creators should build products for super fans that differ from the free product, since news consumers already get too much content.

    “What can you create for subscribers only that are your super fans that services them specifically”

  • Media is an incredibly difficult business with tough economics, and because there is no barrier to entry, there is no reliable playbook; success comes from repeatedly trying and slowly building an audience and figuring out monetization.

    “I would hesitate to call anything a playbook because it really is about just throwing yourself at the wall repeatedly”

  • Axios offered only free products for its first several years to build its email list and brand, and only four or five years after launch introduced subscription products, which Simon considers a smart choice.

    “they actually had only free products for the first several years where they built up their e-mail list and audience and brand recognition”

  • The subscription-only era was a bubble in which Netflix-style growth made subscriptions look like they would change everything; purely subscription-driven media companies have a weak future unless they serve a very niche product and accept limited scale.

    “the future for purely subscription-driven media companies is not that strong, unless you like have a very niche product”

  • The future of creator businesses will be a spectrum: from the New York Times on one end, to solo creators on the other, with many hybrid models in between, since creators often build a personal brand first and then try to scale into something they can sell.

    “you're going to see kind of like a spectrum of The New York Times on one end, the solo creator on the other hand”

  • Axios has staying power because it created a new model for owning and segmenting audiences and is now growing a paid product, and Puck is a premium brand worth watching for how it merges with the creator economy.

    “Axios still has staying power. It's just created a great new model in terms of owning audiences and segmenting audiences”

  • Axios shifted away from its paid-product plan because the founders were surprised by audience demand for free content and advertiser demand, and chose to amplify that growth rather than halt it to launch a paid product.

    “They just were surprised by how much demand there was from the audience for the free content”

  • The Athletic was born in the era when subscriptions were expected to change everything, and its sale to The New York Times was framed around subscriber count with low monetization per subscriber, reflecting the failure of the pure-subscription thesis.

    “I think The Athletic was born in that era that I was talking about when we thought that subscriptions were going to change everything”

0.52

Email, community spaces, and polls let publishers own audience relationships and measure real value.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Embedding one poll per week in a Substack newsletter, asking a different question each time, gathers demographic data far more effectively than long surveys, because a single click has much higher participation than a 15-minute survey.

    “if you embed like one poll per week, asking a different question, over a period of weeks, you can collect a lot of data”

  • Text messaging and community spaces such as Discord, Facebook Groups, and Slack are emerging as decentralized channels for media companies to interact with audiences and let audience members interact with each other.

    “There are tools that are coming around like Subtext that allow publishers and creators to send text messages”

  • Email will always have value because it is one of the last great decentralized distribution mechanisms, though returns will diminish as every publisher crowds inboxes, and social platforms and Google Search will remain important alongside it.

    “I think it will always have value because e-mail is one of the last great decentralized distribution mechanism”

  • For Simon's newsletter business, email subscribers rather than page views are the headline metric shown to advertisers, because subscribers represent the real value of the audience.

    “E-mail sign-ups are my North Star, whereas at another media organization, page views are their North Star”

  • Every publisher should have a community strategy that brings audiences back from social platforms into decentralized spaces such as Slack, Discord, or whitelisted third-party tools, so the audience relationship is owned.

    “So I think every publisher today should have some kind of community strategy in place”

0.43

Advertising and sponsorship are returning as legitimate funding for quality journalism alongside subscriptions.

7 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The near future of media is more diversified across subscriptions, advertising, sponsorships, merchandise, and affiliate revenue than five years ago.

    “the near future of media is more diversified, diversifying across subscriptions, advertising, sponsorships, merchandise, affiliate advertising”

  • Advertising is not inherently bad: much programmatic advertising is poor, but premium native advertising can be scaled tastefully and bring in substantial revenue, which is why media companies are shifting back toward ads and sponsorships.

    “there is a way to scale up premium native advertising that's really tasteful and can bring in a lot of revenue”

  • Long-form investigative reporting is not going away: magazines like The New Yorker and The New York Times remain strong, and creators such as Coffeezilla and Johnny Harris show that good long-form reporting can be monetized.

    “the scale, the monetization is there for good long-form deep reporting, and I don't think that's going away”

  • Axios hired a separate journalist to run a niche Deals newsletter about the media industry, which is sold for about $500 a year, while keeping all its free content unchanged.

    “the subscription product was a Deals newsletter. So it drilled down further into the media space”

  • The idea that pre-Internet newspapers had large teams doing six-month investigations is romanticized: most newspaper staff juggled many tasks, and only occasionally worked on a story for a few weeks.

    “that was not what we were doing. We were having to juggle a million different tasks”

  • Many subscription-only companies that once said advertising was evil are now quietly admitting advertising is a good way to pay for quality journalism, with Netflix launching an ad tier and The Information building a sponsorships function.

    “Netflix has introduced an ad tier, The athletic. The Information hasn't officially introduced advertising, but they have a sponsorships head”

  • YouTube Shorts will likely win the short-form video competition, or at least force Instagram and TikTok to compete harder on creator revenue, because it feeds long-form channels and now shares ad revenue with Shorts creators starting in February.

    “I'm very bullish on YouTube Shorts right now winning the short-form video wars”

0.40

Rebundling creators with equity and revenue shares keeps star talent and scales media companies.

6 pointscentrality 3/5
  • A new kind of media company blends the creator model with rebundling: it recruits star journalists and gives them equity or a revenue cut, so they have incentives to stay and gain the benefits of scale, much like early startup employees with equity.

    “they're giving them a piece of the action and making them actual participants in the business by giving them equity or some kind of cut of revenue”

  • HubSpot, a CRM and marketing software company, invested heavily in its own blog and podcast content, acquired the business newsletter The Hustle, and then launched a podcast network that gives creators monthly retainers and makes HubSpot their sole distribution and advertising partner.

    “they acquired this thriving business-focused newsletter, The Hustle”

  • Over the last five to seven years, the creator economy unbundled media as star journalists and creators with their own brands left traditional companies and monetized directly through sponsorships, subscriptions, memberships, merchandise, and events, using free platform distribution.

    “we've seen a kind of unbundling of the media, like the creation of the so-called creator economy”

  • Workweek recruits star and emerging newsletter writers by providing a monthly stipend, health benefits, and infrastructure, plus a percentage of subscribers the writer brings in, and runs a venture fund where writers act as limited partners in companies Workweek invests in.

    “they also have been experimenting with a venture capital fund, where they allow their newsletter writers to kind of identify other companies to invest in”

  • Puck, a premium long-form newsletter company founded by Vanity Fair alumni, recruits high-level reporters from outlets like The Hollywood Reporter, CNN, and The Verge, giving them equity and revenue-sharing benefits alongside a premium subscription product.

    “the journalists that they recruited, they get equity in the company and then they also get to see some of the benefits from revenue sharing”

  • Defector Media, a writers' collective formed by former Deadspin staff after a mass resignation, is monetized mainly through subscriptions, reports over $3 million in revenue, and distributes it equitably across journalists.

    “they're generating over $3 million of revenue, and they're just distributing that equitably across all the journalists”

0.38

Niche, essential data products sold at high prices to well-funded clients remain the viable paid model.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Niche products essential to well-funded clients whose business depends on specialized information can charge very high prices, as the Bloomberg Terminal at over $20,000 a year has shown for decades without disruption.

    “One of the killer media businesses today still is the Bloomberg Terminal, costs over $20,000 a year”

  • Axios's founders, who came from POLITICO, initially planned a roughly $10,000 subscription product modeled on POLITICO Pro and the Bloomberg Terminal, aimed at lobbyists and corporations needing granular information, before deciding to keep content free.

    “that $10,000 product was what they were talking about selling”

  • The Information, founded by Jessica Lessin, succeeds by publishing only two or three high-impact stories a day and refusing commodity news, and this kind of differentiation is key to building a successful media company on a low-barrier internet.

    “they only focus on stories where they can move the needle”

  • The Bloomberg Terminal, costing over $20,000 a year, has resisted disruption for decades despite repeated attempts by would-be killers to launch competing products.

    “One of the killer media businesses today still is the Bloomberg Terminal, costs over $20,000 a year. It's been around for decades and still hasn't been disrupted.”

  • POLITICO Pro sold a super-niche, expensive product to lobbyists, hedge funds, and agriculture firms while its main site stayed free, and Axios's original $10,000 plan aimed to replicate that model beyond politics, following the Bloomberg Terminal's long-lived model of selling essential data to well-funded clients.

    “that $10,000 product was what they were talking about selling”

0.24

Substack's network effects, brand, and archive-building make creator audiences defensible.

5 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Matt Yglesias runs a solo Substack that generates about $1 million a year and has said he loves the freedom and does not want to scale into a media company, outsourcing tech to Substack.

    “now he has a Substack that generates like $1 million a year”

  • Substack's Recommendations tool, a blogroll-style feature where writers recommend each other, has produced large audience growth: some Substackers report 50 percent of audience growth comes from within the ecosystem, and defectors are returning because of this network effect.

    “50% of their audience growth is happening within the Substack ecosystem versus what they're bringing in on their own”

  • Substack benefits from brand recognition because everything it hosts sits on the Substack domain unless a creator buys a separate domain and redirects it, so creators gain visibility from the platform's name.

    “everything that it hosts is on the Substack domain unless you buy a separate domain”

  • Consistency is the biggest source of defensibility for creators: since anyone can start a channel or newsletter, and many podcasts stop early (Simon cites that 99 percent have fewer than 10 episodes), building an archive and repetition week after week creates a moat.

    “It is only through consistency that you build a moat”

  • Substack has a small but productive tech team that ships features constantly, because it recognizes that a basic newsletter monetization platform is not hard to build, so differentiation through new features and analytics is necessary.

    “This is a company that recognizes that it's not that hard to build a basic newsletter monetization platform. So they're constantly trying to build differentiation into their product”

0.22

Creators can sell products beyond themselves, since low barriers keep platform power limited.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Substack's future revenue growth lies in building products creators can sell, such as paid consulting calls, e-books, and online courses, and in a sponsorship marketplace, taking a cut of each transaction.

    “the future of Substack for the revenue growth is building more products that its creators can sell”

  • It is hard for a solo creator to exit or sell a business because the entire brand is based on one personality, which is why creators who want a sellable company try to build a brand beyond themselves.

    “it's hard to exit when you're a solo creator because the entire brand is based on that one personality”

  • A 10 percent Substack take rate is a good sweet spot in terms of fairness, and raising it would make competing platforms more enticing to creators.

    “the 10% is a good sweet spot in terms of fairness. I think the more they move it up”

  • Substack does not have a monopoly because barriers to entry are low: creators can cobble together Mailchimp, Stripe, and WordPress, and competitors such as beehiiv and Ghost exist.

    “I don't think they have a monopoly. I think the barrier to entry is rather low”

0.22

Brand media should stay arm's length from products and focus on channels where it excels.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Brands can become media companies at a range of cost levels: a high-end approach hires an editor-in-chief and in-house journalists, while the low end uses freelancers, ghostwriters, or agencies to produce regular content.

    “The high end is an editor in chief who can either hire part-time or full-time journalists and build an entire media organization in-house”

  • The most successful brand media remains arm's length from the product, using synergies to funnel audiences toward purchase while focusing on content that is not an advertisement, though sales-side leaders often fail to understand long-term content ROI, which may take 6 to 12 months or more.

    “the most successful companies are going to be the ones that try to remain arm's length from the product”

  • Events are an important revenue diversifier for media companies that already own an audience, but they carry high upfront overhead and scale poorly because only people who can afford to pay and travel can attend.

    “the overhead can be higher. And also, it doesn't scale as well because you can only market to people who have the income”

  • Most media companies will need multimedia content, but because media is so fragmented they cannot afford to do everything, so they must choose channels where they already excel rather than spreading resources thinly.

    “media has become so fragmented that I do think most media companies can't afford to do everything”

0.22

Programmatic ads and Google News traffic produce low-quality audiences that cannot sustain revenue.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Traffic spikes from Google News after aggregating stories are low quality: readers bounce within seconds, do not sign up for newsletters, do not return, and advertisers do not value them, so chasing scale has diminishing returns.

    “You're seeing a rush of visitors from Google News, but they're going to bounce right off your page right away”

  • Bloomberg Media has taken itself completely off all programmatic ad exchanges, illustrating publishers moving away from open programmatic advertising.

    “Like Bloomberg Media, for instance, they've taken themselves off all the programmatic ad exchanges completely”

  • The promise that programmatic advertising would unlock high CPMs for granular audiences was a complete lie: programmatic fueled misinformation sites and scammers, drained revenue from quality publishers, and is now under antitrust scrutiny against Google.

    “that has been exposed to be basically a complete lie”

  • Media companies that closed their comment sections and outsourced engagement to social platforms made a huge mistake, because commenting readers visit many times a month and are far more likely to convert to paid subscribers, and the trolling problem came from not staffing moderation.

    “readers or audience that comment on your articles or participate in some kind of community function are many times more likely to visit your site multiple times a month”

0.09

Media companies should be selective about TikTok, and brand media faces hard executive expectations.

4 pointscentrality 1/5
  • For roughly the last 100 years, media companies were top-down organizations that handled marketing, payroll, distribution, and monetization, while journalists were at-will salaried employees.

    “they are very traditional top-down organizations in which the parent company, the media company was handling the marketing, the payroll, the distribution to the monetization”

  • TikTok has its own language and culture so YouTube videos cannot simply be resliced for it, and there are few revenue opportunities there, so media companies should question whether investing scarce resources in a TikTok channel is worthwhile.

    “there are actually very few revenue opportunities for TikTok right now”

  • Major TikTok stars typically launch YouTube channels once famous, because TikTok audiences are ephemeral given its reliance on the algorithm, and YouTube lets them monetize that audience far better.

    “TikTok audience is, one, very ephemeral because TikTok is so reliant on its algorithm. But then two, that they can actually monetize that audience much better on YouTube.”

  • Brand media is hard because the executives who sign checks often do not understand content or journalism, and they expect returns in a month when the payoff takes six to twelve months or more.

    “the people who are signing the checks, maybe they don't understand content or they don't understand journalism”