A 30,000 Foot View of Niche Media Businesses
What this covers
This Making Media conversation has Jon Ostrower explaining how his aviation publication works as a business, with Dom and Matt asking questions and adding context. It begins with the constraints of a solo publisher: doubling one person's output does not double quality or revenue, so the first eighteen months meant choosing what to cover. From there it takes up advertiser concentration, where losing one of five advertisers costs about 20 percent of revenue and advertisers can punish coverage they dislike. It also covers a paywall defended against copy-and-paste, and the loss of his 2007 to 2012 blog, now reachable only through the Internet Archive.
The range is wider than media economics. Matt argues that aviation supports a niche audience because standardized assets get commoditized and then financed, through aircraft leasing, teardowns, and tax-advantaged structures. That claim is contested. Dom says TechCrunch's subscription effort failed because it couldn't afford enough writers worth paying for. Jon forecasts that AI summarizing and rewriting tools will destroy high-volume SEO publications. He also describes countercyclical demand during COVID, executives venting candidly to the publication, and glossy PDFs selling for $70 to $100 as a new revenue pillar.
The last stretch is about management and pace. Jon says the model is openly shared and the team is the real differentiator, that a manager's job is to remove barriers, and that growing too fast contributed to his CNN layoff. He wants subscribers to inform coverage without dictating it, and he explains a new hire covering underreported airports and business aviation.
Ostrower argues a niche subscription media business survives by optimizing for readers rather than advertisers, owning its distribution, and scaling a small team slowly, since quality cannot be automated or rushed.
- Advertising incentives push a publication toward traffic rather than content value, while subscribers spread risk across many payers
- Owning the email list, app, and archive protects the business from platform algorithms and syndication economics
- Quality is constrained by human time and expertise, so growth must be paced and the team must be allowed to do the work
Commercial work must fund passion projects so creators and the business keep going.
- Successful creators balance commercial productions that fund the business with passion projects that build a cult following; if all work is commercial, creators may quit, so balance keeps the enterprise going.
“make one for them and then one for me... that keeps you in the game.”
- Coverage of big names such as Apple or Google generates heavy traffic that subsidizes the less commercial work, analogous to filmmakers who make one commercial film and then one for themselves.
“when you write about the big names an Apple or a Google, you get a ton of traffic. And those basically subsidize everything else.”
- Writers should keep their curiosity for themselves rather than write for an audience, because writing for the audience can go awry.
“never just writing for your audience. You got to keep it to yourself because if you write for your audience, things can go awry.”
- Annual reflection on focus changes is like a New Year's resolution, where most efforts fail but people still learn something, though the core of the business may stay the same and the fringe tactics may be a distraction.
“It's like a New Year's resolution in some ways, where sure, most of them fail, but you're usually getting something out of it.”
Economic viability of a niche depends on sector financial depth and commercial demand.
- Aviation can sustain a niche subscription publication because its financial sector, including aircraft leasing, teardowns, and tax-advantaged investment structures, makes the industry interesting to business readers even beyond enthusiasts.
“aviation has evolved where there's this huge financial sector built around it.”
- A niche can be fulfilling even if extremely narrow, but if the goal is economic viability, a niche can become too narrow when the sector lacks sufficient commercial demand or financial depth.
“So my instinct is that you can be too niche. And if you pick the wrong niche, it's just not economically viable.”
- Once an asset class is standardized, such as aviation with aircraft leasing and tax-advantaged investment, it is commoditized and can be lent against and securitized, which in turn creates a large financial sector around it.
“once you have something that's commoditized, you can lend more against it, you can secure it. You can create all these different financial instruments”
- Ben Thompson's Stratechery faces similar copy-and-paste and forwarding problems, and he has built a successful business despite them, showing that distribution barriers need not destroy a paid media model.
“Ben's proven you can create a successful business and you built barriers.”