What this covers
This Business Breakdowns episode has Zehrid walking Matt through L'Oréal as an analyst would: the company's history, its divisions, its competitive position, and then a risk and sustainability checklist. The history starts with Eugène Schueller in 1930s France, who hired top poster designers, produced a radio jingle, and launched the magazine Votre Beauté in 1933, which reached over a million women. Zehrid reads this as the origin of a DNA that pairs technology with marketing.
The middle of the episode is the economics. Zehrid distinguishes barriers to entry, which are low in beauty, from barriers to scale, which are high. He backs this with spending figures: advertising near 32% of sales, against 5-15% in many consumer businesses, and R&D of about 3% of sales, over EUR 1.1 billion, which he believes is the largest in the sector. He also cites 517 patents registered in 2021. Divisional growth is covered too, with L'Oréal Luxe more than doubling from EUR 6.2 billion to EUR 14.7 billion on organic growth plus acquired brands. Other topics are pricing tiers within and across brands, acquiring rising brands such as NYX before they become threats, and long-running licences with Yves Saint Laurent, Giorgio Armani and Ralph Lauren. Matt adds that fragrance licensing was what finally made Lauren's business profitable.
The contested material concerns the future. Zehrid sees emerging-market middle classes, aging populations and a health-and-wellness focus all supporting premiumization, though the aging argument is debatable. He rates disruption and innovation risk as low, while conceding that cheap digital channels could let small brands become a real threat. He closes on valuation, arguing that investors using short-horizon tools tend to price quality compounders near fair value.
L'Oréal's dominance rests on a repeatable system of multi-brand price segmentation, acquisitions that neutralize rising competitors, and R&D and advertising spending that a rival cannot easily match, so its high returns on invested capital should be valued as long-duration compounding rather than near fair value.
- Barriers to scale, not barriers to entry, protect L'Oréal, because going from a local hit to a global brand requires marketing, distribution and R&D reach
- Advertising (about 32% of sales) and R&D (about 3% of sales) are funded by scale and sustain share leadership
- Margins expand slowly by choice while ROIC rises toward 40%, which markets tend to undervalue
High barriers to scale, not low barriers to entry, sustain L'Oréal's competitive advantage.
- In beauty, barriers to entry are relatively low, because a brand can emerge in a local market, but barriers to scale are very high, because taking a brand to multinational recognition requires marketing, channel reach and R&D that L'Oréal has built.
“barriers to entry in the industry, might not be that elevated, but barrier to scale is very high”
- Former CEO Jean-Paul Agon repeatedly framed the R&D-driven barrier to scale as a critical competitive advantage for L'Oréal.
“the previous CEO, Jean-Paul Agon was always mentioning, very much an important competitive advantage for them”
- L'Oréal's scale lets it fund advertising, global channel reach and R&D together, and those three capabilities combine to sustain its competitive advantage.
“that expertise is a combination of being good at marketing, notably advertising, but also being good at reaching all the different consumers and the different channel points”
- L'Oréal registered 517 patents in 2021 across active cosmetics, sun products and general cosmetics, which Zehrid cites as evidence of the R&D scale that supports the barrier to scale.
“in 2021, they had 517 patents registered across their different products”
Heavy, steady advertising is core to L'Oréal's technology-and-marketing company DNA.
- L'Oréal spends roughly 32% of sales on advertising and promotions (32.1% this year, rising to about 32.4% over four years), a far higher share than the typical 5-15% of revenue seen in many other consumer businesses.
“In the region of 32% is what we estimate for this year.”
- L'Oréal's advertising has moved from television commercials and celebrity figureheads toward online channels and influencers, which allow targeting of specific age groups, demographics and consumer types for better return on advertising.
“increasingly, they are now spending more on influencers. Influencers who are able to then target the delivery of that marketing message”
- Advertising and promotion spending is estimated at about 32% of sales this year (32.1%), and is forecast to rise only to about 32.4% over the next four years, which the speaker treats as a steady-state level.
“In the region of 32% is what we estimate for this year... 32.1% this year, going to 32.4% within the next 4 years.”
- Eugène Schueller, a young chemist, launched his first hair dyes in 1907 and founded the company in 1909 as Société Française de Teintures Inoffensives pour Cheveux, focused on high-technology, quality products for women.
“that was 1907 when he launched his first hair dyes”
- Eugène Schueller in 1930s France hired the best poster designers, produced a radio jingle, and in 1933 launched the magazine Votre Beauté, which reached over 1 million women, treating advertising as core to the company's DNA alongside technology.
“in 1933, even released a magazine called Votre Beauté in French, which built a readership, which actually at the time reached over 1 million women.”
- Zehrid argues that L'Oréal's company DNA combines superior technology with savvy marketing, so that consumers believe the products are good for them and therefore more desirable.
“it just highlights the company's DNA was a combination of having superior technology to deliver high-quality products. But also a very savvy marketing”
A large global R&D network drives innovation and locally adapted products.
- L'Oréal employs over 4,000 researchers across 20 research centers in six key regions (US, Brazil, South Africa, India, China, Japan, plus Europe), and registered 517 patents in 2021, with local centers tailoring products to local demand.
“they have over 4,000 researchers across the world. They have 20 research centers”
- L'Oréal spends about 3% of sales on R&D, over EUR 1.1 billion this year, rising toward EUR 1.5 billion over four years, which the analyst believes is the largest R&D budget of any competitor.
“we're talking about 3 percentage points of sales going towards R&D. So when you look at the monetary amount, it's over EUR 1.1 billion this year”
- L'Oréal designs products differently for different ethnicities based on science, and that need is part of why it operates so many R&D centers across geographies.
“the science also tell them that they need to design products in a different manner for the different ethnicities”
- A risk is that local brands in emerging markets could grow faster than established multinationals, which L'Oréal manages by running R&D centers that adapt products to local needs.
“there are local brands that come in and that start growing at a pace that surpasses some of these existing well-established brands”
- L'Oréal has produced consistent progress in anti-aging cosmetics, sun creams, hair coloring and shampoo, using different active ingredients, though some breakthroughs have been overly amplified in marketing.
“There have been many breakthroughs and at times, they have possibly been overly amplified.”
Disruption and new-entrant risks are low, though digital entrants remain a threat.
- The analyst rates disruption risk as low and new-entrant risk as somewhat low, because barriers to scale are high and cosmetics are a feel-good purchase, and assesses innovation risk as low because L'Oréal's R&D keeps it able to respond to disruption.
“we look at this industry as having a very low disruption risk”
- Zehrid's risk assessment looks at industry risks, including competition, new entrants and disruption, and at company risks, especially innovation risk, judging L'Oréal well placed to respond to disruption through its innovation.
“we feel that L'Oréal is very well placed to remain innovative and therefore, to be able to tackle any of the disruption risks.”
- Industry disruption risk is low because consumers want to spend on cosmetics, fragrances and makeup steadily, partly for the feel-good effect of looking and feeling better, and wellness trends reinforce this.
“we actually look at this industry as having a very low disruption risk”
- The main operational risk is that digital channels let small innovative brands reach consumers cheaply, lowering barriers to entry so much that they could become a threat, although the analyst believes L'Oréal can respond.
“online digital channels reduce the barriers to entry so much that it becomes a threat”
Acquisitions and licensing add growth beyond organic share gains.
- L'Oréal acquires consumer-appealing brands once they begin to look like a threat, before they become serious competitors, which both protects market share and adds growth; NYX is an example of a brand the company moved to acquire.
“whenever they can see the brand is starting to look appealing to consumers and might start being at risk of becoming an issue or a serious competitor to them, they will move in and acquire it.”
- Analysts expect the market to grow about 5% per year, with L'Oréal growing 6-7% organically by gaining share and high-single-digit top-line growth in some years when acquisitions are included.
“L'Oréal consistently gaining share means that they can achieve 6% to 7% organic growth”
- Many luxury brands in L'Oréal's portfolio, such as Yves Saint Laurent, Giorgio Armani and Ralph Lauren, are operated under long-lasting license agreements, and the brand owners have been satisfied because L'Oréal supplies scale, expertise and profit pool.
“These licenses have actually been, for some of them, very long-lasting. Brands have typically been very happy with the way L'Oréal has managed to drive scale, expertise and then drive the profit pool”
- The analyst does not model future acquisitions because L'Oréal's deals happen irregularly; instead, acquisitions are added to the numbers once announced, as with the 2016 CeraVe and Four Star Salon Services deals, which together cost net EUR 1.2 billion in a year the company also sold The Body Shop.
“they spent net EUR 1.2 billion, having also been the year that they sold out of the Body Shop.”
- Professional Products grew from about EUR 3 billion in 2014 to EUR 4.4 billion at a few percent a year, Consumer Products grew from EUR 10.8 billion to EUR 14 billion at roughly 3-4% a year, and L'Oréal Luxe more than doubled from EUR 6.2 billion to EUR 14.7 billion through organic growth plus acquired brands.
“L'Oréal Luxe back in 2014 was generating EUR 6.2 billion of sales and has more than doubled, EUR 14.7 billion.”
Scale-driven margins and returns on capital support long-term compounding.
- L'Oréal's group EBITDA margin is about 24.5% and EBIT margin is near 20%; the analyst forecasts about 30 basis points of annual margin expansion, which the company chooses to limit so it can reinvest in growth.
“you're looking at EBITDA margin that is currently around 24.5%. We forecast that to be growing at about 30 basis points per annum.”
- L'Oréal's return on invested capital was about 23.3% in 2018 and is forecast to reach almost 32% this year, into the high 30s, and above 40% by 2026, driven by scale economies and steady margin gains rather than fast top-line growth.
“We forecast that return on invested capital to be reaching almost 32% this year and then to continue to grow into the high 30s and then to reach a level of over 40% by 2026.”
- L'Oréal's operating margin rose from about 18% in 2017 to a forecast 19.7% this year, with an assumed 30-50 basis points of expansion per year.
“you're looking at EBITDA margin that is currently around 24.5%. We forecast that to be growing at about 30 basis points per annum.”
- L'Oréal pays out roughly 43% of earnings as dividends, and the analyst assumes that ratio stays around 43-44% over time.
“they've got a dividend payout of low 40s. So we're forecasting about 43% payout this year.”
- Investors often value high-quality compounders like L'Oréal near fair value because they use short-horizon tools, but such businesses can compound at attractive returns on invested capital even with modest growth, so long-term valuation tools are required.
“the markets tend to miss the compounding characteristics of these type of businesses”
Tiered pricing across brands keeps consumers as they grow wealthier.
- L'Oréal segments price points both within each brand and across separate brands (mass, premium, luxury), so it can keep premium brands premium while still capturing consumers at lower price points.
“they then use different brands for different price points, which permits to keep some of the brands higher premium and others more mass market and others more affordable.”
- In emerging markets, aspirational consumers start with L'Oréal's entry-level brands and move up its price tiers as they grow wealthier, so pricing architecture lets the company keep the consumer across her life cycle.
“they will be able to take them on that journey as they become more well off and as aspirational consumption is able to be turning to reality.”
- Aging populations, such as China's, are a challenge but also an opportunity, since older consumers have stronger spending power that supports premiumization.
“whether you look at China as an aging population that can also become a challenge, but it's also an opportunity because as you have more of your demographics that's getting into a higher age group, their spending power is actually stronger”
- Three structural themes drive L'Oréal's future: a growing emerging-market middle class, aging populations that increase demand for active cosmetics, and a rising focus on health and wellness, all of which support premiumization.
“across these three themes of emerging market consumers, middle class emerging market consumers, aging population and increased focus on health and wellness.”
Beauty's low returns and multichannel reach favor direct, repeat consumer sales.
- Beauty products have low e-commerce returns because the products are homogeneous and consumers already know what they want, and their small size with high value per unit keeps shipping costs low relative to bulky categories like apparel.
“therefore returns are very small incidents in consumer's purchases in the cosmetics space”
- Over 50% of L'Oréal's China revenue is now generated online through e-commerce, showing how quickly that market has shifted, while e-commerce is roughly 30% of group sales.
“when you look at a market like China, over 50% of revenues generated in China are now online through e-commerce.”
- Cosmetics and fragrances are predictable, repeatable purchases where consumers stick to brands that work for their skin or look, so strong brands can convert online presence into repeat direct-to-consumer purchases that are more profitable because L'Oréal accesses the consumer directly.
“And often, consumers get tied to a certain brand because they know the products work for them.”
- L'Oréal reaches consumers through travel retail (an important channel for some brands), department stores, specialty perfumeries, and e-commerce, while Professional Products works almost as partnerships with hair salons, training their staff and supplying products through them.
“they're almost operating as partnerships with some of these hair salons, helping them train some of their staff”
Sustainability is credibly integrated into strategy, management ownership and pay.
- The analyst's sustainability assessment checks whether companies understand materiality, whether senior management owns the sustainability agenda, whether it is linked to remuneration and incentives, and whether it appears in reporting; L'Oréal scores highly on these tests.
“whether that is properly integrated into the strategy of the company in the medium to long term, but also into the remuneration and therefore, the incentives”
- Through its L'Oréal for the Future program launched in 2020, the company targets carbon neutrality at its sites by 2025, five years ahead of 2030, using 100% renewable energy and a 50% cut in greenhouse gases, plus a ban on deforestation-linked raw materials by 2030.
“The company is committed to carbon neutrality at its sites by 2025. So 5 years sooner than the 2030 targets”
- Zehrid's ESG assessment checks whether sustainability is material to the strategy, whether senior management owns it, and whether it is linked to remuneration, because pay incentives are what make managers deliver on sustainability targets.
“and whether that is properly integrated into the strategy of the company in the medium to long term, but also into the remuneration and therefore, the incentives”
- L'Oréal's social engagement programs aim to reach 3 million people by 2030, and had already reached over 900,000 people by 2021.
“aiming to reach 3 million people by 2030. And already by 2021, they had reached over 900,000 people.”
L'Oréal holds #1 or near-#1 positions across its divisions and markets.
- L'Oréal operates four divisions (Professional Products, Consumer Products, L'Oréal Luxe, Active Cosmetics) generating about EUR 38 billion in sales and ranking #1 in each with mid-teens global market share.
“Altogether, they're achieving about EUR 38 billion of sales across those four divisions. And they're typically #1 across all of those with market share in the mid-teens.”
- Estée Lauder is L'Oréal's main competitor, trading the #1 or #2 position depending on brand and market; Unilever is generally #2 overall, with P&G, Shiseido, Beiersdorf, Coty and J&J as other key rivals, while L'Oréal ranks #1 or a very close #2 in nearly every market.
“Estée Lauder is definitely their main competitor and typically also trading horses in terms of #1, #2 position”
- About 53% of revenue comes from developed markets and 47% from emerging markets, with the US and Western Europe each about 20% and China about 20%, a balance the analyst sees as a strength.
“developed markets being 53% of revenues and emerging markets being 47%”