First Citizens Bank: The Bank Buyers
What this covers
This conversation between Bill Nygren and Alex Fitch uses First Citizens to explain how banks make money and where they get into trouble. It starts with arithmetic. An unlevered bank earning 150 basis points under T-bills makes only about a 6% ROE, while lending out deposits lifts that to roughly 17%, which is why banking attracts capital and why it carries the Three Risks of Banking. Because leverage is so high, Nygren says management quality matters more here than in most industries. Fitch adds that lending is largely commoditized, so cheap funding is what lets a bank pass on riskier borrowers and still earn a fair spread.
The middle of the discussion turns to events. Nygren reads Silicon Valley Bank's failure as a liquidity and duration problem rather than a credit one, worsened by depositors concentrated in one industry who reacted to a single influential tweet. They describe the FDIC's restricted auction, which left about 20 eligible bidders, and the roughly 27 acquisitions First Citizens has made over 15 years, mostly FDIC-assisted takeovers. Fitch credits family ownership for the speed of decision-making that hired CEOs may lack, and explains the earlier CIT deal as pairing cheap deposits with high-yielding loans.
The more contested ground is valuation and structure. Nygren holds that a bank's P/E should roughly equal its ROE and that it is hard to justify more than about twice book value. Fitch reaches a similar ceiling from a 7% to 10% deposit premium. They also disagree with common assumptions on consolidation, arguing that fewer banks, from about 14,000 to about 3,000, have made the system safer. Fitch further argues that new liquidity and debt rules will narrow regional banks' regulatory advantage over the largest banks. On rates, they weigh a mixed trade-off between securities losses and deposit repricing.
Nygren and Fitch argue First Citizens is a rare bank whose durable edge comes from low-cost, relationship-based deposits and a repeatable, owner-driven record of acquiring failed banks, and that its SVB deal and capital position still leave the stock near 1x tangible book value, which they see as undervalued.
- Deposit franchise quality, not lending, is the primary source of bank differentiation, and First Citizens' sticky low-cost deposits sustain above-peer returns.
- Family ownership and a 15-plus-deal FDIC-auction playbook let First Citizens buy failed banks capital-efficiently while rivals hesitate.
- The SVB transaction was structured with liquidity, funding, and capital protections, so the stock trades near 1x tangible book despite a potential 2x value.
Sticky low-cost deposits are the primary differentiator that sustains returns and franchise value.
- First Citizens' plain-vanilla model gathers deposits through customer service and lends conservatively to wealthy individuals and small businesses, producing consistently low deposit costs and low loan losses that kept it profitable through 2008.
“It's focused on gathering deposits through great customer service, earning a spread through conservative lending to its customer base in those markets, primarily wealthy individuals, and small businesses.”
- First Citizens' brand, real estate footprint, personal customer service, and century-long relationships create a sticky depositor base that accepts very low yields even in a high-rate environment, unlike a technology-first bank.
“And it's given them a very sticky depositor base that has been willing to provide funds at a very low price even in this higher rate market.”
- Large banks that invest heavily in technology, apps, and branch footprint can also hold deposits that stay even when paying next to nothing in a high-rate world.
“if you're like the large banks where you can invest quite a bit into your technology and your app and provide a great experience, you can have a deposit base that will stay with you”
- The deposit franchise is the primary differentiator in banking, because lending is largely commoditized and advantages in lending tend to appear only in downturns, while sticky low-cost deposits sustain returns through rate cycles.
“in our view, the deposit franchise is really the primary differentiator of a bank. Lending, there can be specialized areas, there can be relationships, but a lot of it is commoditized”
- Applying a 7% to 10% deposit premium typical of high-quality deposit franchises gives a valuation of roughly 2x tangible book value, consistent with the earnings-multiple approach.
“If you think about deposit premiums on high-quality deposit franchises and a 7% to 10% deposit premium, you end up with something like 2x tangible book value.”
- During the 2010s zero-rate period high-quality deposit franchises earned less because low-quality peers paid similar near-zero rates, and higher rates later allowed franchise value to show up as margin expansion, but unrealized losses from rising rates now complicate that benefit.
“the high-quality deposit franchise and the low-quality deposit franchise, they can both pay roughly the same amount when rates are zero and the high-quality deposit franchises as a result, under-earn.”
- First Citizens' charge-offs through the financial crisis were lower than the average US bank in the good years before the crisis, and it still earned a high single-digit ROE through 2008.
“First Citizens charge-offs through the financial crisis were lower than those of the average bank in the U.S. in the good years before the financial crisis. They still earned a high single-digit return on equity through 2008”
- At zero interest rates, high-quality and low-quality deposit franchises pay about the same, so the value of strong franchises is hidden until rates rise.
“the high-quality deposit franchise and the low-quality deposit franchise, they can both pay roughly the same amount when rates are zero and the high-quality deposit franchises as a result, under-earn.”
Serial FDIC-assisted acquisitions have been a consistent, accretive engine of value creation.
- Under Frank Holding, the bank accelerated acquisitions after the financial crisis, completing about half a dozen FDIC-assisted takeovers from 2009 to 2011 and continuing consistently after, building a core competency in bidding, integration, and retention.
“from 2009 to '11, they completed something like a half-dozen FDIC-assisted takeovers with meaningful gains associated with taking over those businesses.”
- Over the last 15 years First Citizens completed about 27 acquisitions, mostly FDIC-assisted takeovers of failing banks, and these have been enormously accretive and largely worked out well.
“Over the last 15 years, First Citizens done some 27 acquisitions, the vast majority of which were actually FDIC-assisted takeovers of failing banks. And it's been an enormously accretive set of transactions”
- First Citizens has mapped every step of FDIC auctions, including bidding strategy, next-day integration, employee retention packages, and depositor communication, which gives it a skill set most large banks have never considered building.
“They know the processes. They know how they're going to bid. They know on the next day, how they're going to begin the integrations, how they're going to structure employee retention packages, how they're going to communicate depositors.”
- The CIT deal was part of a long pattern of value creation, including around 17 FDIC-assisted takeovers and about $1 billion in historic bargain purchase gains from buying below book value in FDIC auctions.
“this CIT deal, in which there is so much value being created, was not the only example of value creation at First Citizens, but rather was part of a long history of deals like that, including around 17 FDIC-assisted takeovers and around $1 billion in historic bargain purchase gains”
- First Citizens can buy failed banks from the FDIC in a capital-light way because it receives loans at a discount without issuing equity, and future failure-driven deals are potential upside, though not required for the stock to be cheap.
“When they took over Silicon Valley Bank from the FDIC, they didn't have to put up a dollar. They were essentially given the loans at a discount.”
- Since the 2008 financial crisis, First Citizens has continually bought failed banks through FDIC auctions at attractive prices, and the process is a consistent feature rather than an occasional event.
“And in the subsequent 12 years, continued down that path. Doesn't feel like there are FDIC auctions and bank failures every year given how newsworthy the recent ones have been, but there are.”
The SVB deal adds substantial tangible book value, though deposit retention remains the key unknown.
- Even if the remaining SVB deposits run off and must be paid down, First Citizens still captures roughly $700 or more of tangible book value per share accretion, which is real value, so the investment does not depend on retaining deposits.
“the worst-case scenario is that you get the $700 or so of tangible book value, coming back dollar good as you liquidate it over time.”
- Of roughly $130 billion of SVB deposits that left the books, about $41 billion remain, and whether First Citizens can retain or grow that remaining base is the biggest unknown for its future earnings power.
“there's about $130 billion of deposits that were on Silicon Valley's books three months ago that are now gone. And there's some chance that the $41 billion of deposits that remain will continue running off”
- Part of SVB's deposits may have depended on its securities business, but other components like its winery lending, industry publication, and survey data are independent value drivers that could help First Citizens retain deposits.
“For instance, they have their winery business where they lend to winemakers. And they publish an industry periodical magazine. They have all kinds of survey data.”
Family ownership enables decisive action, but concentrates key-man risk in Frank Holding.
- The Holding family has run First Citizens for more than 80 years, with R.P. Holding as CEO from 1935, his son Lewis from the 1950s until 2008, and Frank Holding as CEO since 2008.
“R.P. Holding took over as CEO in 1935. And again, what's been a more than 80-year run of consistent management by the holding family.”
- Frank Holding and his four sisters own about 24% of shares outstanding and control around 40% of the vote, with Frank starting at the bank at 22 and never selling shares in at least 25 years.
“Frank and his four sisters own something like 24% of the shares outstanding. They control around 40% of the vote.”
- Hired CEOs facing an unfamiliar, career-risking decision like buying SVB may be reluctant to act, whereas owner-operators like the Holding family can act decisively because they are not worried about short-term job loss.
“There's a certain decisiveness that comes with being the ultimate owner and acting like an ultimate owner.”
- The largest risk for First Citizens is key-man risk tied to Frank Holding, since replacing his value creation will be difficult, though he has said he would not let an unqualified family member or anyone else run the company.
“there is, to some extent, key man risk that comes with that, especially having the bank being family controlled.”
- Frank Holding has said that the family has too much money invested to let an unqualified person run the company, so the succession decision will not be made for family reasons alone.
“it's not necessarily going to be a family member to take the helm after him, and he said, we all have way too much money invested in this thing to let an idiot run it.”
- Frank Holding has not sold shares in at least 25 years of reported data and takes a modest salary, so his wealth is tied to the bank's performance and his family's reputation.
“Frank has never sold the share at least in the last 25 years of reported data. He takes a modest salary.”
Low-cost funding lets the bank lend to safer borrowers and focus on relationship loans.
- Because First Citizens has low-cost funding, it no longer needs to take excess credit risk to earn a spread, so it is shifting the CIT portfolio toward more creditworthy borrowers and pulling back risk at the margin.
“So they have been tailoring the CIT portfolio, pulling back risk on the margin.”
- SVB's capital call lending business, which funds capital commitments before limited partners pay in, has had about one loss in its 30-year history, making it very low risk and consistent with First Citizens' style.
“That's had something like one loss in the 30-year history that SVB has been running it.”
- The loan book is now relatively diversified across dentist and doctor lending, middle-market loans, railcar and equipment finance, and SVB's capital call and early-stage lending, and it skews toward relationship or specialized loans rather than price-driven commodity loans.
“And so it's relatively spread out at this point.”
- Loans where the bank is the primary banker or has specialized expertise are much less likely to be priced down to the bare minimum, while price-driven loans are effectively a commodity jump ball.
“And then there are loans where you have a relationship, or you have some type of specialization where more than price is factoring into the equation.”
- A bank with high funding costs must take on credit risk to earn a fair spread, whereas a bank with low-cost deposits can afford to lend to safer borrowers and still earn adequate returns.
“That you needed to take some level of risk in order to get a fair spread.”
Excess capital, liquidity, and downside-limiting deal structures keep mark-to-market and credit risk minor.
- After the SVB deal First Citizens sits about 300 basis points above regulatory capital minimums, and even if it had to sell all securities and realize mark-to-market losses it would still be about 100 basis points above the regulatory minimum, which is extremely unusual for a US bank.
“First Citizens is still 100 basis points above their regulatory minimum in that scenario, which is extremely unusual for a U.S. bank today.”
- The SVB transaction includes an FDIC loss-sharing agreement, a $35 billion prepayable term loan, and $35 billion of cash, so total liquidity plus an FDIC revolver exceeds 100% of deposits, making First Citizens one of the most liquid banks relative to deposits.
“They got a $35 billion term loan that can be repaid without penalty early and $35 billion of cash. So their total liquidity on the balance sheet between that and a new revolver from the FDIC is more than 100% of their deposits today.”
- Under the mark-to-market scenario most US banks would see losses reaching well into double digits, often 50% to 70% of their equity, which is the risk that dominated bank investor discussion in recent months.
“The vast majority have declined well into double-digit percentages, often 50% to 70% of their equity.”
- Frank Holding's focus on risk and making sure the bank has its arms around it showed up in both the CIT and SVB transactions, where the structure was designed to limit downside.
“When we talk to Frank, his focus is clearly on risk and managing the risk and making sure they have their arms around it. That was true with Silicon Valley Bank and CIT.”
- The risks most investors worry about for banks today, such as mark-to-market securities losses and credit risk, are not very meaningful for First Citizens, so its risk profile differs from most banks investors own.
“I think that the risks that most people talk about today for banks like the mark-to-market on securities, really aren't that meaningful here.”
The CIT combination was accretive, with cost-cutting upside and stock issued at a deep discount.
- On paper the CIT combination added roughly 50% to First Citizens' earnings power, raising earnings per share from around $50 before the deal to about $75 after.
“The combination on paper did something like adding 50% to the earnings power of First Citizens, taking the earnings per share up from around $50 a share before the deal to $75 post-deal.”
- In bank deals, cost overlap and synergy opportunities typically amount to 20% to 25% of the target's cost base, and CIT had bloated operations that offered a large opportunity to remove costs.
“you usually have cost overlap and synergy opportunities that amount to 20%, 25% of the target cost base.”
- The CIT acquisition made strategic sense because First Citizens had low-cost deposits but low-yielding loans, while CIT had high-yielding loans but expensive wholesale and online funding, so combining them lets the low-cost funding pay off CIT's expensive liabilities.
“You could take the very low-cost funding at First Citizens, pair it with the really high-yielding loans at CIT and liquidate your low-yielding assets to pay off those expensive liabilities at CIT.”
- First Citizens acquired CIT in an all-stock deal when CIT traded at around 40% of book value, giving First Citizens about 61% of the combined bank while contributing only about 40% of the assets.
“At the time, CIT was at something like 40% of book value. And so First Citizens was going to end up with about 61% ownership in the combined bank for contributing only 40% or so of the assets.”
Rate-path effects on earnings are cushioned by asset sensitivity and a mixed fixed and floating funding base.
- First Citizens built a mix of floating and fixed funding sources through the FDIC agreement, so it can fund the business whether rates rise or fall, neutralizing interest rate risk across a wide range of outcomes.
“some floating rate, some fixed rate, and all of them very large. And the combination means that if interest rates go up a lot, there's a way to fund the business even in the event that SVB runs off profitably.”
- If rates returned to zero, First Citizens' earnings would be pressured, but it should still be meaningfully above pre-acquisition levels and in the double-digit return-on-equity range.
“If rates went back to zero, it'll pressure the earnings profile, but it should still be meaningfully above what it was prior to these acquisitions and in the double digits in terms of return on equity.”
- After the SVB deal First Citizens remains asset sensitive because of its cash and fixed-rate FDIC funding, so higher rates would still lift net interest income on the margin, while the industry as a whole faces uncertain benefits from high rates due to unrealized losses.
“they're still asset sensitive. Higher interest rates would still lead to incremental net interest income.”
- A slower rate increase would have produced fewer mark-to-market losses because more securities would have matured, but it would also have given deposit costs more time to adjust, so the effect is mixed.
“If the latest rate increases had happened more slowly, you wouldn't have the mark-to-market issues to the same extent that you have today because more of it would have matured.”
The under-followed bank has compounded value yet trades cheaply relative to tangible book.
- First Citizens is probably the best-performing bank stock over the last two decades, with its share price compounding alongside tangible book value per share at roughly a mid-teens rate for almost 20 years.
“It's also probably been the best-performing bank stock in the market over the last two decades. You've seen the stock price compound right alongside tangible book value per share at about a mid-teens clip for almost 20 years.”
- Until recently First Citizens never held a public conference call, never hosted an investor meeting, and was never the subject of a sell-side research report, despite its size.
“this was a company that had never held a public conference call and had never hosted an investor meeting or been the subject of a sell-side report.”
- Tangible book value per share rose from about $570 to roughly $1,250 with the SVB transaction, and the stock trades barely above 1x tangible book, which Fitch argued should be worth closer to 2x for a high-return, fast-growing bank.
“I think the tangible book value jumped from $570 to something like $1,250 with this Silicon Valley Bank transaction. The stock is just barely above 1x tangible book value.”
- First Citizens was not discussed at hedge fund dinners or on social media, so the lesson is that doing your own work and turning over rocks can uncover value that popular investment communities miss.
“this is a company that was not on anyone's radar, wasn't brought up in these idea dinners, didn't have long threads on Twitter.”
The regulatory environment favors regionals and may enable mergers, while rapid growth adds integration risk.
- Over the last decade the very largest banks were disadvantaged by regulation compared with regionals, which were allowed to run with less capital, liquidity, and debt, and new liquidity and debt rules will level the field and weigh on regional returns.
“the very largest banks have been disadvantaged. You've allowed all of the smaller regionals, still top 25 banks, up global systematically important banks... to run with meaningfully less capital, far less liquidity”
- Large bank mergers could be possible despite the administration, since First Citizens is far below the 10% deposit market share cap and as the 16th largest bank has room for mergers of equals, and the recent crisis may change how regulators view consolidation.
“It might be tough under this administration, but there's potential for large bank M&A.”
- Because First Citizens has grown very rapidly, it must integrate risk, liquidity, and reporting systems and meet stress test burdens, and any system shortfalls could draw a regulatory response from the Fed.
“More broadly, the bank has increased its size very rapidly. That comes with the need to integrate risk systems, liquidity management systems”
First Citizens is a large, long-run family bank with a dominant Carolina deposit footprint.
- First Citizens is a 125-year-old, roughly $200 billion asset bank run by the same family for three generations, with 550 branches, ranked as the 16th largest US bank, and it is probably the most important bank almost no one has heard of.
“So First Citizens probably is the most important bank that almost no one has heard of. It's a 125-year-old bank. It's been run by the same family for three generations. They have more than $200 billion in assets, 550 branches, the 16th largest bank in the U.S.”
- The Carolina markets still hold about a third or slightly more of First Citizens' deposits, and the bank is the number four player by market share there, with only California larger in its footprint.
“The Carolina markets are still a third of deposits or a little bit more than that today, and First Citizens is the number four bank by market share there.”