Lessons from a Young Investor Turned Operator
What this covers
Jan Mohr walks through his path from young investor to operator at CHAPTERS, a European group that buys small software businesses. The early part is career advice: study how your idols behaved at your own age rather than at the end of their careers, and pick organizations that help you find your investing style over ones that look good on a CV. He cites Norman Rentrop's family office, which sends successful analysts out with seed capital instead of promoting them, and which has produced seven or eight spin-off funds.
The middle of the conversation is about structure. Jan argues that returns depend on the Right Side of the Balance Sheet as much as on what is bought, and that a fund with monthly or quarterly liquidity creates a duration mismatch against long-term theses. He applies the Institutional Imperative to boards that reinvest sale proceeds in the same industry, and points to Danaher under Mitchell Rales as a company that reset itself every three to five years. On decentralization he borrows a Montessori-style model of strict guardrails with freedom inside them. He is openly sceptical of holding-company CEOs who claim to oversee around forty companies informally. He also admits that a portfolio assembled with growing conviction will look untidy.
The market case is specific. Vertical software that wins in one European country rarely travels, so outcomes look like steady compounders rather than winner-take-all leaders. Niches such as orchestra ERP are too small for SAP or Sage. German founders from the late 1990s are reaching retirement, and Jan forecasts that Europe's window, five to ten years behind the US, may close within three to five years.
Jan Mohr argues that a decentralized holding company built by acquiring small, founder-owned vertical market software businesses compounds best when it pairs permanent capital and explicit shareholder alignment with strict management systems and a disciplined focus on fewer, better platforms.
- Holding-company permanent capital avoids the duration mismatch that public-fund LPs with monthly or quarterly liquidity create
- Acquisition-driven companies need a management system or they drift into mediocrity or blow up
- Small founder-owned vertical software firms offer high margins and low competition because private equity prefers larger assets
Being a reliable partner wins owner-operated software deals before competitors arrive.
- Acquisition deal flow in the seven target markets is built by compiling a database of private software companies and running a B2B sales funnel to reach owners, and the decisive factor is whether the vendor feels comfortable selling to the buyer.
“if you know what you're doing, you can build a database of these companies, and then it's all about creating a B2B sales funnel”
- Being a reliable partner is a European value and a key differentiator for CHAPTERS in acquiring owner-operated businesses, because most vendors do not need the money and choose buyers based on credibility.
“Most of these people don't need the money, and it's all about, are you a serious, reliable, and credible partner.”
- Waiting five to ten years to acquire these succession-stage software companies is unwise because the founders' timing creates current urgency for buying businesses before professional ownership or competition arrives.
“I don't think it's wise to wait for another 5 to 10 years. I think time is now.”
- CHAPTERS scaled from zero to 33 operating companies in three years, and the team wants to keep that speed and aggressiveness while becoming more selective.
“we went from 0 to 33 operating companies in three years”
- Horizontal software serves general needs across many users, such as video conferencing, while vertical applications solve specific needs for narrow industries like orchestra management, supermarket accounting, or building access control.
“So that's an application you could use for all sorts of content. It's horizontal.”
Decentralized platforms need explicit culture and federation rather than headquarters-driven HR.
- Culture is what happens when the leader is absent, and in a decentralized group the core values of reliability and decentralization must be made explicit and overcommunicated rather than left implicit.
“the next five years will be all about being more explicit about values as opposed to having implicit understanding”
- Young leadership teams that started operating companies early have long time horizons and no need for quick exits, which is a structural advantage for building durable companies.
“So none of the people involved have or will, in the immediate future, see some sort of, oh, we need to make a quick exit.”
- Small specialized software companies must recruit and pay top talent to run businesses, and the Ookam team's success in building larger roles for recruits shows that growth potential can attract talent.
“that's hard, right, recruiting into small companies and finding the right people that see that as a growth potential.”
- A company built from scratch can establish a setup where rationality wins, something public-company CEOs with legacy structures struggle to achieve, and that culture should be maintained.
“creating a setup where rationality wins, we can do that because we build things from scratch”
- CHAPTERS headquarters should not act as HR for its platforms; instead, platforms recruit better when they feel part of a federation, and talent bottlenecks appear when old management methods stop letting people grow.
“I wouldn't define the CHAPTERS HQ role as the HR for the organization”
Holding companies face investor and board constraints on reinvestment, dilution, and liquidity.
- Choosing the right level of equity capitalization is hard because it requires balancing an attractive acquisition pipeline against dilution of existing shareholders when issuing new shares.
“you got to trade off obviously super attractive deal funnel within dilution”
- Running a fund that underwrites long-term compounding theses while offering monthly or quarterly liquidity and quarter-by-quarter performance measurement creates a duration mismatch between investor expectations and investment horizon.
“you were matching that with monthly liquidity”
- Warren Buffett's most distinctive achievement is not only his investing but the construction of Berkshire Hathaway's structure, which is why value investors aspire to build their own holding companies.
“where Buffett is the absolute complete outlier is just in terms of the building of Berkshire Hathaway”
- Boards tend to reinvest sale proceeds in the same industry, and moving capital into a different industry is like moving a mountain because of institutional focus on the existing business.
“Most boardrooms would say, listen, we need to reallocate the capital from the sale in that industry into the same industry”
- The average public market investor dislikes portfolios that do not look clean and prefers pure-play exposure, but holding companies that group businesses for underlying reasons deserve more appreciation.
“the average public market investor hates that because there's this thing about simplicity, cleanliness. Pure play is a thing.”
Early investors should develop their own style rather than optimize for credentials.
- Mohr started JMX Capital in 2015 with only EUR 5,000 of personal wealth plus seed money from Norman Rentrop, having no finance background and no substantial family capital.
“I had EUR 5,000 for my personal wealth and then the seed money from Norman”
- CHAPTERS did not initially have an investor relations presentation, and Mohr argues a strong track record attracts investors without it, while many advisers push average public-company tactics that aim for mediocrity.
“I don't want to build the average public company, I want to build an excellent public company.”
- Early-career investors should seek organizations that foster their own investing style and discover what they are not, rather than optimizing for CV branding, because discovering who you are as an investor matters more than prestigious lines on a résumé.
“If you can swap two years of learning and at the end, you actually know who you not are, I think that's drastically more important”
- Mohr is a high-intensity person who is weaker at passive stock selection but stronger at driving change in companies, so he gravitates toward active involvement in investing and company building.
“I'm not great at some aspects of passive stock selection, but I'm better at driving change.”
- Will Thorndike teaches strict rationality about capital allocation, delivered in a non-emotional, friendly, constructive way, and he is an excellent interviewer who draws out other investors.
“I think Will's style is to combine 100% rationality in a really friendly and constructive method of delivery”