What this covers

Journalist Bethany McLean talks with host Patrick about a career spent examining companies that looked better than they were. She argues that people who convince others usually believe it themselves, so bad actors tend to be a mix of rationalization, ego-driven greed and sometimes idealism, not simple thieves. A friend's remark that history's worst crimes were committed by believers recasts Jeff Skilling's apparent sincerity as no defense. The Elon Musk debate turns on the same question: whether he is lying, or whether broken details matter little beside a big dream. She also covers the murky line between legal and illegal information advantage, as in the SAC case, and the Me Too dilemma of anonymous accusers against accused people who need specifics.

The longest stretch is housing finance. McLean's 2005 Fortune story called Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac horrible companies with no reason to exist. She now calls them a horrible solution that still beats every alternative proposed. She traces their origins to the Depression, Fannie's privatization during the Vietnam War to move it off the budget, and the uniform mortgage rates they produced. Around 75 to 80 percent of mortgages still go to them. She also treats homeownership as forced savings that funds retirement, and argues the GSEs softened the 2008 crisis, a contested claim.

The last area is energy. Fracking and horizontal drilling turned shortage fears into abundance, yet producers generate no free cash flow and depend on cheap capital. McLean notes how often skeptics have been wrong about their resilience and why oil forecasts almost always miss.

Sharpest takeaway

Bethany McLean argues that business frauds succeed by blending self-delusion, ego, and compelling narrative, that whether a visionary is later judged a fraud often depends on luck, and that skeptical investigators must pursue the small circle of overlooked detail that the market misses.

  • Visionaries and fraudsters often share the same self-belief; the distinction is frequently visible only in retrospect and often depends on whether the venture works out
  • Skeptical theses about companies are known only in small circles of people who have done the work, so publishing them is a real service
  • Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were accidental creations whose implicit guarantee and uniform mortgage pricing still carry real social value that reform must replace

The argument · threads9 threads · 65 claims
0.85

Skeptical investigation begins with what does not add up and relies on persistent, empathetic, careful listening.

15 pointscentrality 5/5
  • McLean got her first serious short-seller lead by calling Doug Millett roughly every week for six months, until he finally told her to see whether she could figure out how Enron made money.

    “I called Doug maybe every week for like six months.”

  • Thorough investment research is analogous to investigative journalism; the difference is that investors focus on numbers and act on them, while McLean focuses on characters and narrative and has no interest in putting ideas to work in markets.

    “the process of thoroughly researching an investment is really analogous to what I do. I think the focus in the end is different.”

  • Short sellers are often fascinating because their work is emotionally charged and they have a crusader personality with a sense of righteousness, which can itself be dangerous.

    “there is usually a highly emotional component to what they do. Two, there's a sense of, there's a crusader type element to that personality, a sense of righteousness which can be dangerous”

  • The Enron project began with a 2000 conversation with Jim Chanos's team and a Fortune piece titled 'Is Enron Overpriced' published in February or March 2001; Enron went bankrupt in fall 2001, and the book was published in fall 2003, roughly three years total.

    “So I guess in all told it was about three years.”

  • Interviewers must learn what is knowable about a subject before asking for their time, because failing to do that signals disrespect and creates a barrier between the two people.

    “there's nothing more off-putting than having asked for somebody's time only to show that you haven't done your work”

  • Her usual trigger for investigating is a company at the center of celebration that has something wrong beneath the surface, something that does not add up or is not being explained, and people repeatedly believe in what they do not understand.

    “usually for me, I guess it begins with a company that's at the center of something and is being celebrated for something and there's something wrong under the surface.”

  • Good interviewing requires genuine caring and curiosity, and the interviewer should stay as quiet as possible, since interjecting one's own observations cuts off the interviewee's most interesting material.

    “the person would start to say something really interesting and I'd break in with my own observation or my own question”

  • Information is abundant but selective pieces travel in very small circles, so when a skeptical thesis about a company exists it is known only to a few people who did the work, and the story available to most investors is not that story, making publishing skeptical research a worthwhile service.

    “selective pieces of information only travel in very small circles. And often when there is a skeptical thesis about a company, it is well-known in a very small circle of people who have done the work”

  • As a Fortune columnist writing the Companies to Watch stock-picking column, McLean initially trusted executives, portfolio managers and analysts without skepticism, then watched the recommended stocks fall, which led her to accidentally specialize in businesses gone wrong.

    “And I had no cynicism and no skepticism in those days. I thought somebody was saying it and they were smart so it must be true.”

  • Satya Nadella is an impressive leader and the type Microsoft needed, and reporting on him led McLean to a more nuanced and more accurate story than the initial doomed-company framing.

    “Nadella is an incredibly impressive leader and probably what Microsoft needed”

  • McLean is intellectually honest mainly when writing, because the act of putting ideas on paper reveals what she does not understand, and iterating on the text is how she reaches clarity even when she conceded in conversation.

    “what makes me intellectually honest is when I sit down to write, I realize I didn't understand it.”

  • Empathy in journalism is the willingness to care, be curious, and understand why a source sees things from their point of view, even when that view is skewed, and McLean believes this disposition is what made her, not a fixed trait, empathetic.

    “when I said earlier in the conversation that you have to care, that was my version of empathy.”

  • McLean spent over a year pursuing a Microsoft story about a Gates and Ballmer feud, gaining cooperation only after convincing the company she was willing to listen, and the reporting turned a potential 'Microsoft is doomed' story into a more nuanced one.

    “I think I worked on that story for over a year.”

  • Peter Elkind, McLean's Enron co-author, is the best investigative journalist she knows because of relentless doggedness: calling everyone who might talk and never giving up, which McLean cannot match even after watching him.

    “the best thing I learned from Peter is just doggedness. You call everybody who you think might talk to you.”

  • The words listen and silent are anagrams, which suggests that you must be silent in order to listen.

    “you can actually make silent out of listen, they're anagrams”

0.63

Fraud grows from ego-driven self-delusion that believers in celebrated companies rationalize.

11 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Morgan Housel's point that optimism requires believing in things one does not understand is a useful lens, but being unwilling to believe in what one does not understand may itself be a problem or a marker of a specific personality type.

    “to be an optimist, you have to believe in things that you don't understand because sometimes the inexplicable is just the thing that's one step ahead of all of us.”

  • Great scientists have also committed deliberate fraud, as with Isaac Newton's use of crafted fudge factors to win over opponents while lacking the math to back his idea, showing that the visionary-fraud theme extends far beyond business.

    “some of his most famous work was deliberate fraud. He knew he was right about the idea and he just didn't have the math skills to back it up.”

  • When people convince others to believe in something, they usually believe it themselves, and bad actors are typically a mix of self-delusion, rationalization, ego-driven greed, and sometimes idealism rather than simple knowing theft.

    “they are always a mixture of some level of self-delusion, rationalization, maybe greed, but usually greed in the service of ego, not greed for money, per se.”

  • Unlike Enron, where the smart hedge funds were skeptical, Valeant drew a major divide in the investment community with some of the smartest investors being strong believers, which McLean found hard to understand even now.

    “there was a big divide in the investment community and some of the smartest investors out there were big believers in Valeant.”

  • A central line between Elon Musk skeptics and believers is whether he is lying; believers treat the broken details as unimportant to a brilliant person with a big dream, a stance McLean sees as the core of the debate.

    “one of the lines between the skeptics and the believers is he's lying. He's not telling the truth.”

  • Sometimes the difference between a visionary and a fraudster is simply whether the venture works in the end, and outcomes depend on luck, timing, and whether things break your way, not only on the actions themselves, making the distinction clear only in retrospect.

    “sometimes I think it's only clear in retrospect because the luck of whether or not it all works, whether or not you get the time for it to work, whether or not things break your way”

  • A friend's observation that the worst crimes in human history were committed by people who believed in what they were doing reframes Skilling's apparent sincerity as no defense against fraud.

    “Bethany, the worst crimes in human history have been committed by people who believed.”

  • Mike Pearson spread a veneer of efficient capitalism, arguing that price hikes were fine because insurers would pay and the poor would be helped, and that a drug costing less than a liver transplant made sense, which made people lose sight of basic right and wrong.

    “Mike Pearson managed to spread this veneer of efficient capitalism over the whole thing.”

  • The line between legal and illegal information advantage is much murkier than most people think, because sophisticated investors always have access to better information, so the SAC case raised the question of whether to pursue a firm through a backdoor when it could not be prosecuted directly.

    “what's legal and what's illegal and what's a legal way to get information and what's a legal edge. And I think that line is much murkier than most people think.”

  • Bad people doing bad things is not that interesting, whereas good people doing bad things reveals self-delusion and rationalization, which is why McLean now condemns people less and studies what drives them.

    “Bad people doing bad things is not that interesting. Good people doing good things is really great.”

  • Greed in fraud cases is usually greed in the service of ego rather than money itself, and the fraudsters' motives mix self-delusion, rationalization, outright corruption and sometimes idealism.

    “usually greed in the service of ego, not greed for money, per se.”

0.57

Character and human behavior, not numbers alone, shape business outcomes and leadership.

8 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Her husband's habit of dismissing petty comments and rising above them sets a precedent that makes both people focus on the good in each other, creating a virtuous cycle instead of a vicious cycle of squabbling.

    “that sets a precedent where both people rise above and see the good and the other person”

  • Jeff Skilling mastered intellectual intimidation that made people pretend to understand, and a data dump that buried questions so people could not follow up on unanswered points.

    “Jeff Skilling was a master of two things. One was a sort of intellectual intimidation that made people pretend to get things”

  • Many small-business owners quietly do the right thing, like mortgage broker Dave Zitting, who stopped subprime lending after a year, refused to sell loans he believed borrowers could not repay, and watched peers get rich while he stayed on plain prime business.

    “he shut it down because he was just like, 'You know what, my borrower, I can't...'”

  • McLean has changed from a numbers-focused math major to recognizing that people make the numbers, so the personal and human dimension is essential to the truth of any business situation.

    “the numbers don't exist without the people. And so think that's one big way that I've changed.”

  • To be non-empathetic toward others one has to believe oneself far better than other people, which McLean suggests is a failure mode that she could imagine falling into had she worked in Enron's finance department under Andy Fastow.

    “In order not to be empathetic, you have to really believe you're a lot better than other people.”

  • Leaders who say they like being surrounded by people who challenge them are usually deceiving themselves, because the more successful someone is the less they like being challenged, so they end up surrounded by people who tell them what they want to hear.

    “a big red flag for me is actually when people say, 'I really like to be surrounded by people who challenge me.'”

  • One line between Elon Musk's skeptics and believers is whether he is telling the truth, since Musk makes predictions that do not come to pass and Ashlee Vance's book describes how he skirted rules and lied while getting away with it.

    “one of the lines between the skeptics and the believers is he's lying.”

  • Investors condemned Martin Shkreli's behavior as reprehensible yet accepted similar pricing conduct at Valeant, showing that the same behavior is judged differently depending on the packaging.

    “the behavior that in one person people saw as utterly reprehensible, somehow it was acceptable in the case of Valeant”

0.44

Fannie and Freddie are flawed but better than alternatives, so reform needs a replacement plan.

8 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Homeownership has functioned as a forced savings mechanism that funded most Americans' retirement in the absence of a European-style welfare net for older people, so eliminating housing subsidies without a replacement would leave a serious gap.

    “home ownership as a forced savings mechanism. Has actually worked pretty well until the financial crisis.”

  • The American romance with homeownership dates back to the 1800s, when presidents promoted land and home ownership as a way to unite a sprawling, disparate, immigrant nation by giving people a stake in the country.

    “this romance with home ownership really goes all the way back to the 1800s, the beginning of this country.”

  • McLean's 2005 Fortune story called Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac horrible companies with no reason to exist, but over fifteen years she has changed her mind, seeing them as a horrible solution that is still better than any alternative anyone has proposed.

    “they're a horrible solution, but they're better than everything anybody else can come up with.”

  • After the Depression, private banks would not step up to create a national mortgage market that would even out wildly varying local mortgage rates, so the government created Fannie Mae, which then operated as a government arm for decades until it was privatized during the Vietnam War to move it off the budget.

    “the private market wasn't interested and wouldn't step up to the plate. So it became the government and that's how Fannie Mae was born.”

  • Fannie and Freddie argued that Wall Street would abandon mortgages in a downturn, and that proved right: without the GSEs the 2008 crisis would have been far worse because the mortgage market would have shut down entirely.

    “if we hadn't had Fannie and Freddie, the crisis would have been a million times worse because the entire mortgage market in this country would have shut down.”

  • Fannie Mae was privatized during the Vietnam War largely to move it off the government budget, a decision driven by numerical maneuvering rather than a philosophical commitment to privatization.

    “it was privatized during the Vietnam war as a way to basically get it off the budget”

  • Fannie and Freddie are a horrible solution, but they are better than anything else proposed, paraphrasing Churchill's view of capitalism, so reform requires a full replacement plan rather than simple removal.

    “you better have a plan for the whole rest of it. You can't just take it away”

  • Close to 75 to 80 percent of US mortgages are sold to Fannie and Freddie by lenders, and McLean believes the FHA and Ginnie Mae figures are also large.

    “I think it is still close to 75, 80%.”

0.32

Enron and Valeant treated rules as things to stretch rather than follow.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Enron and Valeant both treated rules as things to be manipulated and stretched to their limits rather than followed, and both were led by executives with McKinsey backgrounds, Mike Pearson and Jeff Skilling.

    “both had the same attitude toward the rules, which is that the rules were meant to be manipulated.”

  • Enron Broadband was in substance a fraud built on manufactured profits, yet it resembled a Netflix-like future business, and Enron might have gotten away with it had its other problems not surfaced.

    “Enron broadband was Netflix. I find that incredibly interesting because if it hadn't been for all the other manifold problems”

0.30

Fracking yields real energy, but company economics depend on cheap capital and constant reinvestment.

8 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Coastal Americans fixate on Silicon Valley as the driver of the US economy, while the energy activity in Texas and similar places is far more important for the country's future and is underexamined.

    “this far more important for the future of this country than what's happening in Silicon Valley.”

  • The shift from peak-oil and gas-shortage fears to a century of natural gas supply and US oil and gas exports came almost entirely from combining horizontal drilling with fracking, which made previously trapped molecules flow.

    “it's really solely a result of this new technique of fracking, which is really the combination of two techniques, which is horizontal drilling”

  • The fracking boom depends on cheap capital because shale producers do not generate free cash flow and their wells decline quickly, requiring constant reinvestment that was funded by Federal Reserve low rates and yield-hungry pension money.

    “it's required the availability of cheap capital, both in the form of debt, thanks to the Federal Reserve's low interest rate policy, but also in the form of pension funds desperate for a return”

  • Aubrey McClendon likely died broke after being a multibillion-dollar figure who reshaped the industry, and the company he left behind burned through tens of billions of dollars, illustrating the broader fracking dependence on capital.

    “he essentially most likely died broke after being a multi-billionaire.”

  • The fracking conundrum is that the oil and gas are physically real but the economics do not work at the company level, a tension summarized by John Hempton's observation that 'it's real, but the economics don't work.'

    “The oil and gas is real. It's there.' And John would say, 'Yeah, it's real, but the economics don't work.'”

  • Access to hydrocarbon energy has been the surest way to raise a population's standard of living, as the contrast between energy-rich and energy-poor neighboring economies such as Haiti and the Dominican Republic shows, whatever one thinks about the environmental cost.

    “hydrocarbons energy have been the surest way to change the standard of living of a population throughout.”

  • Fracking was expected to collapse when prices fell in 2015 and 2016 but rebounded strongly, and its roughly decade-long track record suggests not to underestimate the producers involved.

    “This was supposed to be done when prices cratered in 2015 and 2016, and yet it came roaring back.”

  • The onset of renewables will eventually push oil and natural gas prices into a secular decline, as coal experienced, and the timing of that transition is as hard to predict as the oil price itself.

    “as soon as it does, the price of both oil and natural gas goes into a secular decline just as it did with coal.”

0.22

Reporting misconduct requires balancing fairness, anonymity, and severity against the time elapsed.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Some founders of small firms say they would not hire a woman when an equally competent man is available because it feels like a risk, and McLean finds such comments frightening evidence of why fair process matters.

    “Why would I hire a woman if there is a equally competent or almost as competent man, why would I take that risk?”

  • The Me Too reporting dilemma is that accusers often need anonymity while accused people need specific details to defend themselves, and McLean worries there is no way to be fully fair to both sides.

    “I worry there isn't a way to be fair to both.”

  • Deciding what to report on misconduct requires weighing time elapsed, number of accusers, and severity, so a single decades-old allegation of inappropriate comments may not warrant publication while severe recent allegations from many people clearly do.

    “there's a temporal aspect to it, quantitative aspect to it, and a severity aspect to it”

  • Joe Nocera's early interest in McLean's Enron work, and his help turning it into a book while taking less credit than he deserved, was the kindest act she received and shaped the path of her career.

    “Joe Nocera taking an interest in my work early on at Fortune and helping me take the Enron story from a story into something that became a book”

0.22

Markets and commodity forecasts resist reliable prediction, and information asymmetry undermines fairness claims.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Hedge funds are largely a fee structure rather than an asset class, and the viciously competitive industry means that anyone who survives in it is very good, since incompetent managers cannot sustain large fees.

    “If you can survive in that world, then you're really good at what you do.”

  • Forecasts about oil and gas are almost always wrong, and the only reliable prior is that a solidly reasoned forecast will still miss, because prices can swing from $60 to $150 and make the same economics either viable or not.

    “you can't predict the price of oil or natural gas. So what doesn't work at $60 a barrel would work at $150 a barrel, for sure”

  • Regulators' claim that markets can be made fair with a level playing field of information is itself a lie, because some participants always have better information and spend all day and night pursuing it.

    “It's never level. There are people who have access to better information than you do.”

  • Predicting whether fracking works economically is impossible because oil prices cannot be forecast, fracking technology keeps improving costs, and the industry has proven more resilient than skeptics expected.

    “the history of the fracking revolution is that it has been way more resilient than its detractors ever believed”

0.20

Fannie and Freddie's implicit guarantee produced uniform mortgage rates, worth weighing before any reform.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac created a fairly uniform mortgage rate for most American homeowners regardless of income or location, an achievement that would need to be weighed before any reform, though jumbo mortgage borrowers get lower rates through other channels.

    “Fannie and Freddie have created a pretty uniform mortgage rate, no matter what your income level and no matter where you live. And I actually think that's an achievement.”

  • Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac operated under an implicit guarantee, the belief they were backed by the government though they were not formally, which McLean considers one of the most remarkable concepts in the annals of finance.

    “The idea that Fannie and Freddie were backed by the government, except they weren't really.”

  • Roughly 75 to 80 percent of US mortgages are still sold to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, and the private securitization market has not returned a decade after the financial crisis.

    “I think it is still close to 75, 80%.”