What this covers

This is a conversation between host Patrick and Todd McKinnon, co-founder and CEO of Okta, about how the company found its category. McKinnon tells the origin story concretely. Okta began as a cloud application monitoring tool called SaaSure, but IT buyers were lukewarm on monitoring and kept asking for help logging into cloud apps, so the company pivoted to Identity Management within a couple of months. He explains the technical shift from each application checking its own passwords to centralized authentication, and why moving apps out of data centers undermined the old reliance on Active Directory.

The middle of the conversation covers go-to-market and operating lessons. McKinnon attributes the 2011 sales slump to targeting tiny companies, since identity's value rises with user count. He describes how a pharmaceutical customer's request to log in doctors pointed to Customer Identity, now about 24 percent of revenue. He also covers the gross margin threshold for a subscription business (above 75 percent), balancing growth against sales payback, and funding low-probability bets outside the normal budget cycle. On leadership, he recalls losing credibility by pretending to have all the answers, and he weighs past experience against first principles.

The most contested stretch concerns policy. McKinnon argues that every outlet and ecosystem running its own identity system burdens consumers and small firms, favoring large platforms. Patrick adds that GDPR, though aimed at big social networks, hurt small providers. McKinnon also notes how many companies still lack basic protections like multifactor authentication.

Sharpest takeaway

McKinnon argues that creating a new market category requires enduring early uncertainty and pain, and that the company which defines the category, not just the product, becomes the default choice.

  • Early pivots are best made early, when the market is not yet defined and the product can still be reshaped around customer pain.
  • Identity management moved from embedded features in other platforms to a standalone centralized platform because cloud application sprawl made it too large to ignore.
  • Companies that want to keep innovating need a budget and framework for risky bets outside the normal budget cycle, with clear rules to double down or shut down.

The argument · threads9 threads · 57 claims
0.75

Creating a new category requires making integration to every application easy.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • To become the default choice in a vertical, a company has to create and define the category itself, proving that a market others thought did not exist could be built by making integration and rollout easy and building features around a core platform.

    “you have to define the category so to speak. You have to create the category.”

  • In the traditional model each application checks passwords and user records locally, whereas with Okta authentication is centralized in one system holding a meta map of applications and a single credential, with integration handing off authentication to the disparate systems and keeping user directories in sync according to company policy.

    “It's really moving from a distributed system to a centralized system that is integrated to all the distributed systems.”

  • Identity management was historically a sleepy feature embedded inside platforms like Oracle or Microsoft, but the explosion of computers, applications, users and mobile devices in the cloud era made it important enough to become its own standalone platform.

    “It was the perfect time to pull that system out of all the other platforms and have it be its own platform.”

  • Early on, the biggest pushback was that no company had ever succeeded in this market, and Okta overcame it by building a system that made it easy to build an integration to every application in a customer's environment.

    “We built a system that was easy to build an integration to every application in your environment.”

0.71

Startup success depends on timing and luck, so founders must persist despite doubt.

6 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Periods of major technological transition create the most fertile environment for starting new companies, even though success is never guaranteed.

    “there's no more fertile environment to start new companies than when there's a ton of transition.”

  • Founders of new ventures must accept that success depends partly on timing and luck, and must keep pushing forward while privately doubting the outcome, which McKinnon summarized as believing even when you don't believe.

    “they have to be able to just believe even when they don't believe.”

  • The market caught up to Okta because more applications and devices made the identity problem painful enough, and the product improved enough, so the company was off to the races by 2012.

    “More applications made the problem really painful enough and the product got good enough. By 2012, we were kind of off to the races.”

  • A new product must be built before everyone recognizes the need, but not so early that it falls on a market that does not yet need it, so founders must thread the needle on timing.

    “You have to thread the needle between building something before everyone else knows it's obviously needed, but you have to build it not so early that it kind of falls on a world that doesn't need it.”

  • Okta's early customers were adopting cloud systems but were not yet confident enough to put their security on the cloud, so selling cloud identity and security was ahead of broader cloud acceptance, which slowed early sales.

    “they were adopting cloud systems but they weren't totally sure about putting their security on the cloud.”

  • When applications moved from company data centers to the cloud, the existing approach of hooking apps to Windows login or Active Directory stopped working well, creating a pain point that customers would pay to solve.

    “It doesn't work as well. Can you solve that basic problem for me?”

0.57

Identity should become simpler and standardized, reducing complexity for consumers and smaller firms.

6 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Because every media outlet, company, social network and device ecosystem maintains its own identity system, consumers face complexity and smaller technology firms bear privacy and security costs that hinder their ability to innovate, advantaging large platforms.

    “Especially for the smaller companies, the smaller technology companies, them dealing with the privacy and the security implications of this customer data, really hinders their ability to innovate”

  • The shift in how people consume media, from linear TV and radio to streaming, podcasts and newsletters, is creating large value and significant effects on politics, culture and society because ideas now spread so widely.

    “the whole transition going on in media is going to be incredibly impactful and profound.”

  • Passwords will not disappear, because there will always need to be a fallback or emergency access method, but identity should become simpler and more portable over the next several years as ease of use and security concerns are a drag on technology.

    “You're always going to have passwords. There will always be a fall-back in a way to do something”

  • Identity and authentication requirements extend far beyond people logging into apps, reaching machine-to-machine authentication and ambient devices, so Okta's infrastructure ambitions would involve APIs and SDKs covering every interaction between machines and people.

    “It extends to things like how machines interact with each other and how machines on the network identify themselves.”

  • Many companies still lack basic security such as multifactor authentication, so despite a Silicon Valley perception that the world is further along technologically, there is tremendous opportunity in helping businesses get online and become more secure.

    “there's just so much out there that doesn't have basic security like that.”

  • Okta believes it must reach large scale in users, companies and integrations so it can set a standard for identity, since universal connection is unrealistic but a widely adopted standard could resolve complexity and privacy issues.

    “it's not unrealistic to think that we can help set a standard that then will be adopted by everyone”

0.57

Platforms expand into adjacent businesses, where customer use cases reveal new product lines.

6 pointscentrality 3/5
  • About three or four years after launch, customers began using Okta to log in their own customers, which led to customer identity becoming the second major business line, now about 24 percent of revenue.

    “Now, about 24% of our revenue is our customers providing login for their customers”

  • Customers repurposing a product for an unintended use case can reveal a new product line, and Okta treated the pharmaceutical company Allergan's doctor-login request as a signal that led to its customer identity business.

    “Now, about 24% of our revenue is our customers providing login for their customers”

  • Microsoft is the most successful example of moving from infrastructure to applications, having started with programming languages and operating systems and later building Office and Exchange, which became the core of the company.

    “Probably the most successful company ever in history doing this is Microsoft”

  • Platforms are foundational infrastructure for many applications, exemplified by operating systems like Windows and iOS, and companies increasingly want to broaden their functionality, move up into solutions, or move down into infrastructure.

    “they want to move from the infrastructure up into the application layers or the solution layers.”

  • Even iconic companies like IBM have had to rely on acquisitions to stay innovative, showing how daunting it is for established firms to sustain internal innovation.

    “Companies kind of vesting parts of their business and doing acquisitions to stay innovative. And this is IBM, big blue.”

  • The central question for Okta is how to sustain long-term growth, which involves choosing markets to expand into and deciding which markets can be dominated, since being a platform creates so many options that it is both a blessing and a curse.

    “One of the great things about building a company that's becoming a platform... there are a lot of options. But it's kind of a blessing and a curse”

0.47

New ventures demand personal commitment to unfamiliar, risky work over safe, familiar paths.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • McKinnon made a formal presentation to his wife, a 13-slide deck titled My Proposal to Quit My Job and Start a New Company, in which the forward-looking slides were balanced by contingency slides that showed how he could get a job if the venture failed.

    “the next 12 slides, they were all basically CYA for when it didn't work out.”

  • Leaving a large company, McKinnon found that if he did not act, nothing happened at a startup, unlike at a big company where work continued regardless of individual effort, which forced him to build the company brick by brick every day.

    “If I don't do everything today, there's nothing happening, and we're not making any progress.”

  • McKinnon's father refused to let him take the family truck to ski, but then offered to drive him and wait all day, an example of the foundation and small acts of kindness his parents provided.

    “he said, I'll drive you. I'll get up early. I'll drive you up there”

  • Founders should expect to work on one venture for a long time and should deliberately resist the instinct toward familiar, safe work, since only doing something new and scary lets a person define a category and become the marquee name.

    “you need something that's new and unknown and scary and you just got to get used to that feeling because that's the only way you can really innovate.”

0.47

Young companies should target the largest enterprises, avoid overpromising, and charge fairly.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Companies should avoid blaming customers for failures, but some customers cannot execute, follow up or partner well, and the company should recognize that early and stop pouring resources into them.

    “too many times we just should've just recognized that and not poured as many resources into those certain customers”

  • Identity management value scales with the number of users, unlike Salesforce automation where early go-to-market focused on small companies, so a young company should sell to the largest enterprises it can win because they have the most users and the biggest pain.

    “identity management is different than Salesforce automation. Identity management, the more users you have, the bigger the problem is.”

  • Young companies selling to large enterprises should not fake capabilities they lack, because enterprise buyers recognize gaps and value a new company's flexibility and willingness to listen, and they should also charge enough to reflect the value they deliver.

    “Resist the tendency to fake that you're something you're not and be open and honest with the company.”

  • Young companies often feel too lucky to be invited into big-company deals and fail to charge enough, even though they deliver substantial value that should be paid for.

    “they're so happy to just be invited to the dance with the big company. They're not clear enough about the value and that they don't charge enough.”

0.39

Okta's history moved from an early pivot to identity through successive chapters of growth.

5 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Okta began as a cloud application monitoring tool called SaaSure, but after prospective IT buyers were lukewarm on monitoring and repeatedly asked for help logging into cloud apps, the company pivoted to identity management within a couple of months, and early mock-ups already resembled the current product.

    “But then, it was a pivot but it was early, which is the best time to pivot.”

  • In 2011 Okta committed to a $250,000 bookings target for a quarter tied to a signed Series B term sheet but delivered about $100,000, and only the investor's willingness to stay and the team's argument for more time kept the round alive.

    “the target for the quarter was, we wanted to get $250,000 of new bookings for that quarter... the actual number we delivered was like $100,000”

  • The name Okta is a real word referring to a pilots' scale of cloud cover, where eight okta is full cloud cover, and the company chose it as a cute tie-in that over time came to mean only the company's category.

    “It means it's a scale for cloud cover. Eight okta is full cloud cover”

  • Okta treated its 2017 IPO as a high school graduation: a milestone worth celebrating, but not a reason to stop, so the company moved on to building an iconic long-term platform.

    “we actually talked about the IPO like a high school graduation.”

  • Okta's history divides into chapters: founding to the 2011 summer and early wins, the 2014 Microsoft competing product announcement that validated the category, and the post-IPO era after 2017 focused on building a broad platform.

    “The second chapter would be another time I remember really clearly is 2014 when we, on one day, Microsoft announced a competing product.”

0.39

Innovation needs funded long-shot bets, and growth must be balanced by margins and sales payback.

5 pointscentrality 2/5
  • For a subscription software company like Okta, cost of goods sold is the cost to run the service including cloud infrastructure and monitoring staff, and gross margins above 75 percent are the foundation because R&D, G&A and sales costs are funded by recurring revenue.

    “our gross margins have always been 75% plus - you can't be selling dollars for 80 cents.”

  • Companies must deliberately fund low-probability, high-impact ideas because normal budget cycles favor high-likelihood projects and penalize initiatives that start small, so projects needing years to scale need budget set aside outside the traditional process.

    “you have to have a way, a process internally to come up with ideas of things that maybe have a low likelihood of working but that if they did work, would have a big impact”

  • As Okta grew, it moved from a focused customer-driven culture to explicitly trying many new initiatives, using a framework to double down on those that work, admit mistakes on those that do not, and let the rest die.

    “have a framework for how we can double down on the new initiatives that work and just admit a mistake and move on”

  • Focus is rewarded, but in new initiatives only a small fraction of focused efforts succeed, since roughly 8,000 venture-backed companies were started in the year Okta was founded and only a small subset survive.

    “I think the focus is rewarded. The problem is that if you zoom out, there's a thousand people that focus on something.”

  • Growth is rewarded when a company has high gross margins and a large total addressable market, but growth should be balanced so that sales and marketing dollars pay back within a reasonable time in recurring revenue.

    “we don't want to be spending a dollar of sales and marketing and have it not make a dollar of recurring revenue”

0.29

Leaders should share opinions openly, reason from first principles, and hire for specific ambitions.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • When interviewing candidates, McKinnon looks for people who articulate specific things they want to accomplish and why Okta fits their ambition, rather than vague praise of the company's growth.

    “one of my favorite questions is like, What do you want to accomplish and what is your ambition”

  • Early in his career McKinnon acted as if he had all the answers, which lost credibility; sharing opinions while acknowledging what he does not know empowered and motivated the team.

    “people can see through that, the lack of expertise and the lack of experience. And so you lose credibility with them.”

  • A leader must balance using past experience as a roadmap against thinking from first principles about what is uniquely different in the current situation, and articulating those trade-offs is a powerful decision-making capability.

    “there's a really interesting balance between using your past experience as a roadmap for what you're trying to accomplish”