What this covers

Patrick interviews Jane McGonigal, a game designer and researcher who began studying players' psychology and sociology in 2001, when most scholars treated games as formal objects. The conversation starts with definitions. A game's core is an unnecessary obstacle that a player voluntarily takes on, and "fun" is better understood as the right challenge for the right person at the right time. From there it covers Flow, the way games make players bad at something before they get good, and what Zynga's data-driven A/B testing taught the industry.

The middle stretch ranges widely. Jane draws on James Carse's finite and infinite games to explain why companies now build endless loops, citing Fortnite's ten-second respawns and Candy Crush's decade-long run. She cites a meta-analysis of more than 500 papers finding that kids benefit most when they can name the real skills games give them, and she calls "stop wasting time" the worst thing a parent can say. She then turns to SuperBetter, her recovery game built after a concussion, which she says has independent validation for depression and anxiety. Both claims are contested.

The last turns are political and commercial. Jane describes China's overlapping social scoring systems, which she finds terrifying even though posters celebrating good behavior changed how drivers treat pedestrians. She also covers Amazon's on-screen warehouse games, the argument that people may trade privacy for opportunity, and the claim that anonymous, aggressive competition dehumanizes opponents.

Sharpest takeaway

McGonigal argues that games work because they engineer voluntary, arbitrary challenges that build real skill, identity, and hope, and that point-based gamification misses this, so the same mechanics can be applied to recovery, learning, and life design.

  • Games create growth by making players bad at something first and then building real skill through flow, which becomes identity.
  • Gamification built on points and leaderboards misses what players actually value, which is authentic challenge and a sense of mastery.
  • Her SuperBetter work applies game mechanics to depression, anxiety, and brain injury recovery, and she reports clinical validation for it.

The argument · threads12 threads · 60 claims
0.85

Gameful design and game-like challenges can support recovery from injury, depression, suicidal feelings, and brain-stuck states.

11 pointscentrality 5/5
  • As a micro-intervention for traumatic brain injury recovery, brushing teeth with the non-dominant hand can activate the emotional benefits of game-like challenge, because performing a task in a harder way produces neurological engagement and growth.

    “brush your teeth with your left hand instead of your right hand”

  • Independent meta-analyses published in the past year rated SuperBetter as the best-validated app for depression and anxiety with the most positive measurable impact, supported by randomized controlled trials conducted with doctors and hospitals.

    “SuperBetter scored number one for having the most positive impact, measurable, best clinical research.”

  • In SuperBetter, bad guys are obstacles such as pain, anxiety, or insomnia that should be identified, invited along, and integrated into a life plan rather than avoided, because avoidance stops people from pursuing what matters to them.

    “one of the fundamental principles of SuperBetter is that you can't run away from your problems.”

  • Assigning herself small game missions, such as watching the window for something weird or having friends give her tasks, forced her energy-conserving brain to power back up enough to perceive possible good outcomes, reducing her suicidal feelings and creating a route back to hope.

    “it forced the parts of my brain that were trying to conserve energy, to just power them back up enough that I didn't want to kill myself.”

  • In SuperBetter, power-ups are any reliable action that makes a person feel better right now, such as sending a thank-you text, which provides savoring, social connection, and a reminder of personal control even on bad days.

    “power-ups in the SuperBetter framework, are just anything that can make you feel better right now.”

  • For depression, large diffuse games like Pokemon Go can trigger anticipation that something good could happen anywhere, while for anxiety, small focused single-player games like mini-golf or Tetris better occupy attention and interrupt rumination.

    “if you're anxious, you might want a really small game, a really tiny game, a single-player game.”

  • After a concussion, the brain intentionally turns off reward and anticipation circuits to conserve energy for healing, which produces severe depression and, in one in three people, suicidal ideation, because the brain stops motivating pursuit of any goal.

    “your brain intentionally turns off the reward and anticipation centers so that you don't go out and get hit in the head again”

  • Creating a heroic alter ego, such as Jane the Concussion Slayer modeled on Buffy, expresses desired strengths and invites friends to join as allies, giving them a playful reason to check in during long recovery, though about half of users choose this and others skip it.

    “just starting to call myself Jane the Concussion Slayer was a way of communicating to friends and family”

  • After three years of research with university psychology centers, McGonigal found that the more severe the problem and the more strategies people tried, the more they benefited, so gameful intervention suits brain-stuck conditions like severe depression better than minor goals like losing five pounds.

    “the worst the problem, the more severe the trauma. The more strategies they tried, the more they benefited.”

  • When her premature twins spent two months in the NICU, McGonigal and her husband used SuperBetter power-ups, such as small ways to feel they had some control, to counter the disempowerment of being able to hold them only briefly.

    “In these situations where you lose control, power-ups very important.”

  • Bringing an actual video game into daily habits can produce the same mood-restoring benefits as a designed gamified solution, so people do not necessarily need purpose-built apps.

    “bringing a real video game into their daily habits will also do the same thing.”

0.55

Voluntarily accepted, unnecessary obstacles create flow and the experience of growing through failure.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Games are uniquely designed to place players in the perfect state between boredom and overwhelm, where challenge is calibrated to skill, attention is fully focused, and players feel optimistic that they can succeed.

    “games are just uniquely designed to put us in that perfect state between feeling bored and feeling overwhelmed”

  • The core ingredient of a game is an unnecessary obstacle, arbitrarily chosen to make a goal harder, that a player voluntarily agrees to tackle with full effort, as golf shows by making putting a ball into a hole deliberately inefficient.

    “the core ingredient for a game is an unnecessary obstacle that you agree to try to tackle with your whole heart”

  • Games are designed so players are bad at them at first, and as they improve through their own effort in flow, they accumulate evidence that they can grow, which becomes a sticky self-identity such as being a creative problem solver that players carry into real life.

    “games are designed for you to be bad at them the first time you try”

  • Arbitrary obstacles provoke curiosity about whether one can succeed and force creative experimentation with techniques, whether physical in golf or mental and social in other games, which together create the growth experience of being terrible and improving.

    “it provokes curiosity. Can I do this? What will it feel like? I want to try.”

  • The common instinct to make something more fun by making it easier is wrong; to turn an activity into a game, one should add an unnecessary obstacle, such as requiring feet never to touch the floor when leaving the house, which activates engagement immediately.

    “no, you have to make it harder. If we wanted to turn leaving the house into a game”

0.52

Games reward effort better than everyday life by engineering winnable challenge and renewable hope.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Game designers intentionally help players win faster than routine life, creating cycles of challenge, rising to the occasion, and meeting it, which makes games far more rewarding per unit of effort than everyday tasks like jogging with a long feedback loop.

    “game designers are super aware that they need to help you win faster than boring everyday routine life.”

  • Games and play that expand or question their boundaries, like soccer players moving the field into bleachers, teach cognitive flexibility, helping people see that the constraints they accept in life are chosen and can be moved, which produces wonder and adaptability.

    “when we realize that we are not limited to the constraints that we have agreed to at this moment.”

  • McGonigal personally rarely kills in Fortnite but excels at hiding, building, and storm evasion, showing that different players find different positive experiences in the same game.

    “I am the best hider, builder, storm evader. I have no kills in Fortnite”

  • Fortnite's respawn in about 10 seconds closes the feeling of losing, creating an infinite loop of hope that one can try again, achieve more, and do better.

    “it takes 10 seconds to be right back in the game.”

0.44

Players who connect game skills to real life gain transferable learning and self-belief.

6 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Telling a child to stop playing and do something real, or to stop wasting time, is the worst parental response, because it prevents the skills kids build in games from ever transferring to school or personal goals.

    “the worst thing you can do as a parent is say to a kid, Stop playing and do something real”

  • Shared play and watching others, including livestreams, compresses centuries of skill discovery into years, so that large player populations collectively become expert at arbitrary challenges, as chess strategy evolved from clumsy first games to refined play.

    “instead of having to wait hundreds of years for the secrets of chess to kind of rise up and bubble up to the masses, we can just go watch Fortnite streamers”

  • Parents can help kids turn game skills into real-world skills by asking what makes a game challenging and what it takes to succeed, then reflecting those strategies back when the child struggles with a non-game problem.

    “If you can reflect back, Oh, it's like in Pokemon Go, we have to be willing to try different ways”

  • Kids teaching themselves through games, using wikis, forums, and YouTube walkthroughs, build self-confidence and the belief that they can learn anything, making games an ultimate learning simulator that points toward just-in-time, project-based, peer-taught education.

    “it's the ultimate learning simulator. And you realize that if you can teach yourself, then you can learn anything.”

  • Across a meta-analysis of more than 500 papers from the past decade, the top predictor of whether kids reap gaming benefits such as better grades, less drug use, and more social support, versus harm, is whether they can articulate the real skills they build in games as part of who they are, rather than seeing games as escapist and separate from reality.

    “The predictor is, are the kids able to talk about the real skills and strengths that they're building in the games as part of who they are.”

  • A news story of an eight-year-old who learned to drive from YouTube, after learning Minecraft building from YouTube, illustrates in her view the future of education built on self-directed learning transfer.

    “Eight-year-old boy drives himself to McDonald's after learning how to drive on YouTube.”

0.41

Designers should target specific positive emotions and early success rather than generic fun or gamification.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Rather than aiming for vague fun, designers should target specific positive emotions such as curiosity, control, and hope that something good could happen, because these map onto distinct psychological needs.

    “We need people to feel more curious. We need people to feel more control. We need people to feel more hope”

  • Classic gamification such as points, leaderboards, and badges misses the heart of gameful experience, because players value authentic challenge, teamwork under pressure, strategy, and mastery rather than mechanical reward, so designers need experienced game designers rather than gamification software.

    “a lot of these gamification solutions, they really miss the heart of a gameful experience”

  • Borrowing from Zynga's data-driven A/B testing, SuperBetter was designed so that players experience success within the first five seconds, such as standing and raising hands overhead, because players who fail early quit before returning on day two.

    “we would say that they need to have success in the first five seconds of playing, or we will lose them.”

  • Fun is too loaded a word because different people find different activities fun; it is better understood as designing the right challenge for the right person at the right time, freely chosen according to their interests, skills, and motivations.

    “fun is just a way of saying you have designed the right challenge for the right person at the right time.”

  • Instead of relying only on speed or distance, designers should create multiple pathways to success in activities like running, so that every session can feel like a win even when personal bests are not reached, which is especially important in injury recovery.

    “how do you multiple pathways for success on a run?”

0.27

Social scoring is a reward-based system that will likely spread, so researchers should study it.

5 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Chinese social scoring has changed a widespread behavior, drivers stopping for pedestrians at crosswalks, by publicizing high-score citizens on posters and billboards for positive actions rather than shaming bad ones, which reflects reward-based rather than punishment-based behavior shaping.

    “They have actually effectively changed this widespread cultural practice in certain communities where the score is being calculated on that behavior”

  • Forecasters should hold strong, provocative opinions while remaining ready to be wrong and to update when evidence shows the future could go another way, a stance Jane attributes to the Institute for the Future.

    “Have really strong opinions, but lightly held.”

  • Social scoring will likely spread beyond China, so rather than assuming it will be rejected, researchers should study the psychology of such systems to find versions that avoid paranoia and repression.

    “I think it's going to spread. So I feel like we can't ignore it”

  • China's social scoring is not one system but many overlapping scores created by government mandates and organizations, such as city citizen scores, bank scores, and school scores, which score public and private behavior and gate access to trains, healthcare lines, schools, and stores.

    “the Chinese government has given a kind of mandate to different groups and organizations to create scoring systems.”

  • China's social scoring carves reality into access to healthcare lines, schools, stores, and express trains based on measured behavior, combining CCTV and facial recognition, which McGonigal calls absolutely terrifying even as it offers some citizens a sense of safety.

    “So basically, it's carving up reality into places that you have access to, or opportunities you have access to or don't”

0.27

Games have shifted from competing against opponents toward collaborative, infinite, lifelong player relationships.

5 pointscentrality 2/5
  • About 2.6 billion people now regularly play games on connected devices, and internet connectivity was the tipping point that let gamers play with hundreds of thousands or millions of others at once.

    “So we're at 2.6 billion people now, who regularly play games on connected devices.”

  • Traditional games were almost always competitive with an opponent, whereas computer games invented the massively collaborative game in which all players win or lose together, which shifted what was possible in game design.

    “computer games essentially invented the idea of a massively collaborative game, where we can all work together to go on a raid”

  • James Carse distinguished finite games, played to win and end, from infinite games, played to keep the game going and bring in more players, and he saw religion as the true infinite game, though game companies increasingly adopt infinite design.

    “With an infinite game, you play to keep the game going as long as possible”

  • Esports performance drops off a cliff in the late twenties due to reflex and dexterity demands, so esports companies are developing masters-level competition and mobile esports to keep older and less-equipped players engaged.

    “once you hit your late 20s, you go off this cliff.”

  • Game companies have shifted from finite experiences to infinite loops, such as Fortnite respawns in about 10 seconds and Candy Crush Saga remaining a top grossing app a decade after launch, with the aim of building player relationships spanning years or decades.

    “you die, it takes 10 seconds to be right back in the game”

0.25

Gameful experiences should start from challenges the target audience cares about, tested with data.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • The NYPL game locked the first 500 players in the library overnight to write books, playable for a year, and the first book written now sits in the rare books collection next to a Gutenberg Bible, with the library pledging to protect it as long as New York City stands.

    “The first book that was written is in the rare books collection next to a Gutenberg Bible.”

  • The New York Public Library wanted points and badges to draw young people into physical libraries, but Jane argued that library-defined rewards would fail, so she designed an overnight lock-in game in which players write a book, grounded in the finding that 92 percent of under-30s say they want to write a book someday.

    “in the United States, 92% of people under 30 say they want to write a book someday.”

  • When designing gameful experiences, start from a challenge the target audience actually cares about rather than the institution's agenda; for example, 92 percent of under-30s say they want to write a book, so the NYPL design turned authorship into the game.

    “in the United States, 92% of people under 30 say they want to write a book someday.”

  • Zynga pioneered data-driven A/B testing, giving half of players one version and measuring which keeps them engaged, tracking quit rates and day-two return predictors, rather than relying on unchecked designer assumptions.

    “You would give half of the players one version. Pink cow, blue cow.”

0.25

Skeptics and parents should engage with gaming culture through play and human connection, not fear.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Playing Fortnite and Pokemon Go is enough to become conversant in gaming culture, which Jane recommends to skeptics as a quick way to understand the medium.

    “if you've at least tried those two games, you will be conversant.”

  • If you play a highly violent game online, play against people you know or in person at tournaments, because a real, known human elicits a different physiological and emotional response that prevents treating opponents as subhuman.

    “if you're going to play a really violent themed game online, try to play against people you know.”

  • Parents' anxiety about kids' gaming arises because they cannot understand or participate in the culture, and McGonigal fears VR will become the new social media by hiding children's faces behind headsets.

    “I live in fear of the day that VR is the new social media, and I can't see my kids' face”

  • A stranger in Paris who sat beside McGonigal while she was sobbing, without asking for explanations, made her feel safe and welcome, which she now tries to emulate by checking on people in distress.

    “she just sat down next to me. And she didn't try to talk to me, she didn't make me explain anything”

0.22

Gaming's social and workplace effects, not just game form, deserve scholarly attention.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • When Jane began research in 2001, most scholars studied games as formal objects, and she argued the field needed to study players' psychology and sociology instead, including how players relate and what real-life challenges they take on.

    “It's the players that we need to study.”

  • Amazon projected games onto screens at warehouse stations, where approving a package triggers an on-screen explosion, because automated picking left workers with meaningless verification tasks; this reflects a signal that low-wage workers, citing a national economic research study, value gaming benefits over extra hours of minimum-wage work.

    “So they've created a game to project on big screens, so now the worker stands by a big screen, and when they approve a package, it blows something up on screen.”

  • Competing against anonymous strangers in aggressively themed games, without any social fabric, leads players to dehumanize opponents, become angrier and less empathetic after games win or lose, and that hostility can spill into real-life interactions, though it does not make people violent.

    “we do see a lot of players will dehumanize those opponents, and they wind up being angrier after a game, whether they win or lose.”

0.11

Privacy trade-offs reflect unequal opportunity and incarceration costs, so social scoring may beat prison.

4 pointscentrality 1/5
  • People in many countries may trade privacy for pathways to success because they experience less economic mobility and educational access, while Jane argues each generation says it does not care about privacy, so the real pain points are unequal opportunity and incarceration costs.

    “every generation's like, Take it. Take it. I really don't care.”

  • Given the high cost, family disruption, and recidivism of mass incarceration in the United States, a future with social scoring that restricts access to stores and trains might be fairer than prison, though Jane is uncertain and frames it as an open question.

    “maybe the social scoring is a better form of justice than prison.”

  • People in countries with less economic mobility and educational access may willingly trade privacy for pathways to success that feel like a fair game, so social scoring may spread even though it is worrisome.

    “in other countries, people may be very willing to trade the privacy for pathways to success”

  • McGonigal suggests people may not really care about losing privacy; the deeper pain points are unequal access to opportunity and the social cost of incarceration, so social scoring might offer a less damaging alternative to prison in America.

    “maybe the social scoring is a better form of justice than prison.”

0.05

Automation should free people for care and play rather than gamify meaningless work.

2 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Automation's trajectory is uncertain: it could either let people work less and play more for meaningful pursuits, or force workplaces to become much more gameful to keep workers engaged instead of checked out.

    “whether we're all going to be playing games more and working less or automation is going to require workplaces to become much more gameful”

  • Using games to convince workers their meaningless jobs are games is dystopian; the better goal of automation is to free people for caretaking, art, and play.

    “whether we're all going to be playing games more and working less or automation is going to require workplaces to become much more gameful”