The Search for the Truth with the Anonymous Master
What this covers
Patrick talks with Jesse, an investor who approaches markets as a question of how anyone comes to know anything. The conversation is organized around three inference bins: intuition, analysis, and testing. Intuition is automatic System One pattern recognition. It is cheap, but it needs a stable, kind environment to become valid, and noisy markets teach false patterns. Analysis is transparent but breaks when one variable is missed, so it needs margins for error and stress tests. Testing has its own traps. Jesse explains trial size versus sample size, noting that overlapping multi-year forward returns yield only four or five independent segments, and he describes how repeated searching produces findings that look causal but aren't.
The second stretch applies this to specific questions. Trend strategies earn their keep by accepting whipsaws to avoid long drawdowns, and they offer no protection against sudden crashes like 1987. Write-downs depressed the CAPE ratio in the early 2010s, making historical comparisons misleading. Jesse also treats asset markets as banks, where better confidence-building structures justify lower returns, and he finds that the equity share of aggregate portfolios signals future returns slightly better than CAPE. Several claims are contested: his explanation of the value premium, and his view that 1940s preferred stocks yielding less than the same companies' senior debt contradict efficient markets.
Some detours leave finance. Jesse discusses how communication works on submarines, where status and close quarters make public praise and private criticism the norm. He also covers why traders score high on cognitive reflection, and why both very fast and very slow decision-making perform badly.
Livermore argues that investing is a problem of inference, and that analysis, statistical testing, and intuition each fail in predictable ways. He contends that inflation-distorted accounting has made earnings overstated and valuations misread, so free cash flow and inflation-adjusted measures like price to integrated equity give a clearer picture of expected returns.
- Intuition is cheap but unreliable in noisy environments like markets, and analysis is transparent but easy to get wrong, so both need testing.
- Statistical findings are often spurious because of overlapping observations and repeated searching, so out-of-sample and called-shot tests are needed.
- Historical-cost depreciation understates true replacement costs under inflation, so reported earnings are overstated and P/E ratios are misread; free cash flow and integrated equity correct for this.
Truth-seeking firms gain real value from outside researchers' cognitive diversity and fresh process views.
- Bringing in outside researchers who have different interests and skills and who look at a firm's process for the first time produces real value through cognitive diversity, because each looks at the same problem from a different angle.
“people talk about cognitive diversity, this program has made us realize the true value of cognitive diversity”
- Companies can be divided into those above the line, committed to searching for truth and learning, and those below the line, focused on ego and being right, and firms that consciously choose to be above the line see better results while below-the-line firms are frustrating.
“if you're an above the line organization, you're committed to that search for truth and learning.”
Price to integrated equity and handicapping cheap-company recoveries improve value-factor signals.
- Price to integrated equity is more statistically predictive of forward equity returns than CAPE, earnings, Tobin's Q, or other common valuation measures, and Jesse agreed it is much more predictive, though he noted that the underlying conclusion matches CAPE.
“PI, the ratio, is more statistically predictive of forward returns than any other measure of valuation”
- Improving value signals depends on handicapping which cheap companies will recover in sales and earnings, a Moneyball-style process that is very hard but is where most value-factor improvement lies.
“parsing value stocks by some sort of handicapping, Moneyball style of future fundamental outcomes”
Trend investing's returns depend on large equity drawdowns, which develop slowly over time.
- Trend investing's return source is large equity drawdowns, whether caused by recession or valuation blow-offs, so without such drawdowns investors should not expect trend to add value, and the drawdowns take time to develop, as the 2008 decline began in November 2007.
“the causal source of your return is some large equity drawdown.”
- The host introduces the guest and sets the conversation structure.
“This week, I have a very special guest years in the making.”