Fintech and Trend Following
What this covers
Patrick interviews Howard Lindzon, an early-stage investor, about how fintech got built and where it goes next. Howard's own path runs through the conversation. He started a hedge fund in the 1990s after early gains convinced him he was a genius, and he now counts that as a costly mistake. He later taught himself venture investing through Fred Wilson's blog, made a first investment in GolfNow, and gave up extra ownership to buy Wilson's mentorship.
The industry account centers on Silo Lock-In. Howard says E*Trade and Schwab bought competitors to wall customers in, until social networks let those customers talk outside the walls. He calls the Bloomberg terminal the original financial social network, with Twitter as its successor. Against that, he points to Robinhood, pitched as a broker-dealer in a box, and to Rally Road, which spent nine months on a license so users could simply buy a piece of a car. Contested forecasts include his claim that everything will be fractionalized and that Vanguard withholds the capability. He also holds that a robo-advisor allocation suits about 90 percent of people, yet fintech that fights human nature fails. He contrasts China's few giant platforms with the US's scattered constellation of apps.
On method, Howard describes trend following: waiting for respected VCs to adopt an asset, as with Bitcoin near $1,000, then checking price action. He also argues that domain experience outweighs market size in early-stage teams. Patrick adds his own lens, that weird things get mispriced. Howard also explains why he invests in media with his own money rather than limited partners' capital.
Lindzon argues that trend following, staying close to influential people and products and breaking off only with real resources, is a durable investing edge, and that fintech's real opportunity lies in products built around how people actually behave rather than how they should behave.
- Successful participants in a 'pack' (investors, startups, social networks) gain by staying near trend-setters rather than leading them
- Incumbent fintech firms built silos to lock in customers, while software, social networks and simple UIs break those silos open
- Fractionalization and simple interfaces meet demand for small, self-directed investing that robo-advisors and incumbents have neglected
Fintech value flows to intermediaries that collect tolls and hide complexity.
- Howard says investors should own Visa or MasterCard in the US because every fintech app ends up paying them a toll on transactions.
“You've got to own Visa or MasterCard because everybody's paying a toll.”
- Howard argues that the best fintech products hide the complexity of regulation, insurance and storage behind a simple interface so the user only sees the simple act of buying a piece of something.
“when you looked at the product, you couldn't see the complexity, you just could buy a piece of a car”
- Howard argues that E*Trade, Schwab and similar brokers acquired companies to lock customers into closed ecosystems, so customers could not interact with customers of rival platforms, and that this silo strategy stalled fintech innovation.
“everybody was just buying companies to lock in their customer. That was the business model, and it worked.”
Engagement and dependence on information tools create lasting platform value.
- Howard argues the Bloomberg terminal was the original financial social network, because traders paid about 2,000 dollars a month to access information and chat with other rich people, showing that people are addicted to information displayed in a different way.
“Bloomberg is the ultimate social network. Talk to rich people for $2,000 a month.”
- Howard says Stocktwits has grown into a healthy independent company with strong community, so he would now hate to sell it, despite having expected a buyer such as Twitter, Yahoo or E*Trade.
“now I would hate the idea of selling it because it's growing on its own and healthy.”
- Howard argues that Google may be overvalued but Google Maps is priceless, because his son lost basic navigation skills and became embarrassed when his phone was taken away.
“Google Maps is priceless. Because it's priceless.”
Costly personal mistakes and generous equity giving taught Howard lasting investing lessons.
- Howard argues that he bought the mentorship he valued from Fred Wilson by giving away more ownership of his company than was strictly deserved, and that cap table structure should be planned to look ten years ahead.
“I probably gave him way too much ownership of my company, but that bought me the right mentorship”
- Howard says he started a hedge fund after early gains in the 1990s bull market led him to believe he was a genius, a lesson he now sees as a mistake that cost him years of paying his dues.
“thinking that a bull market was that you were a genius”