What this covers
The episode is a business breakdown of the Times, with Alex Lieberman walking Jesse through its history and its 2021 financials. The history starts with Adolph Ochs, who rescued the near-bankrupt paper in 1896 by cutting its price from 3 cents to 1 cent, lifting circulation from about 25,000 to 75,000. It then covers print's golden age, when publishers charged readers and also sold advertisers access to mass distribution, the model Rupert Murdoch called gold rivers. Circulation peaked in 1994 at 1.18 million copies a day. By 2000, newspapers produced 3.1 billion of the Times' 3.3 billion in revenue. The collapse that followed was in advertising, not readership.
The financial middle section is dense with numbers. Revenue of 2.1 billion in 2021 is still 30 to 40 percent below the 2000 peak. Net profit was 268 million, a 13 percent margin. Digital is about 48 percent of revenue and print about 37 percent, and the company has reached 10 million subscribers, years ahead of its 2025 goal. The discussion also covers the trade-off of putting content behind a paywall, the gap between digital ARPU of $15 to $17 a month and print's historical $60, and thin switching costs. The Athletic's churn problem and its bundling into the Times are discussed too.
The contentious turns come late. Alex calls perceived political bias the largest controllable risk, citing Bari Weiss's resignation, and Jesse argues that subscriber incentives push outlets toward partisanship. Alex answers that the Times can offer point of view through insight rather than politics. Other threads include the Times' poor acquisition record, with the Boston Globe and about.com both sold at losses, and the Sulzberger family's five-generation run, with A.G. Sulzberger as the management signal to watch.
Alex Lieberman argues the New York Times survived the internet by treating itself as a news-making institution that rebuilt its business model around digital subscriptions, and its next growth limits are perceived political bias and news-cycle dependence rather than competition.
- The 2014 Innovation Report reorganized the Times around digital-first, subscription-first operations, with product, engineering, and audience development treated as equal to the newsroom
- Subscription revenue now dominates while print advertising collapsed, and digital ARPU remains a fraction of print's historical level
- The Times' main risks are perceived political lean and dependence on a favorable news cycle, which it can partly control
Subscriber incentives drive partisan media positioning across the political spectrum, fueling divisiveness.
- Subscriber-driven incentives push media organizations toward partisan positioning, whether left-leaning like the Times or right-leaning like Breitbart, which fuels divisiveness.
“the incentive structure just seems, to your point, or any media organization, the New York Times, the incentive structure is one that attracts you. You need subscribers.”