What this covers

A conversation among Will, Paul, and Rick that builds its case from examples. These include a records management consolidation, where acquired revenue carried 60 to 70 percent margins and roughly 25 million dollars of equity was enough. They also cover Banyan Software, which grew from 17 million dollars of equity to a recapitalization well above 1 billion, and the Rales brothers, who held 95 percent of their net worth in Danaher for 45 years. Will contrasts conventional fund structures with his early vehicle that had no fund life. He also traces the search fund world's growth from fewer than one a year to well over 100.

The range is wide. On capital allocation, Paul relays Nick Howley's point that The Outsiders treated leverage as a way to grow free cash flow per share and buybacks as a way to buy cheap stock. The speakers also discuss CEOs who scheduled white space for reading, why public boards resist unconventional decisions, and why performance should be judged over at least two full business cycles. Hellman and Friedman's return on tangible capital and TA Associates' finding about market growth come up as lessons drawn from reviewing past deals. The contested claims are Paul's view that organic growth cannot supply enough duration, Rick's argument that many 100x outcomes are chains of 5x to 10x handoffs, and Will's claim that search investing has narrowed the dispersion of outcomes. Will also cautions that Asurion's market tailwind explains little of its result.

The last stretch turns personal. The speakers apply compounding to learning, relationships, and reputation, and argue that churn undoes all of them. Will says life flexibility comes from balance sheet net worth rather than pay. Paul notes that founders wait years for meaningful equity. Rick speculates that these models may form a new asset class.

Sharpest takeaway

Thorndike argues that long-duration, equity-efficient holding companies with founder economics tied to net multiples of invested capital (not IRR) can compound better than conventional private equity and venture, because unlimited holding periods let outsized outcomes accrue.

  • Traditional PE fund lives force early exits, which cap the 20x to 100x outcomes that long holds can capture
  • IRR-based incentives create misalignment, while MOIC-based, ownership-increasing schedules keep founders and investors aligned over decades
  • Compounding applies to capital, learning, relationships, and reputation alike, and churn destroys all of them

The argument · threads3 threads · 87 claims
0.85

Holding company structures align founder incentives better than venture dilution and IRR-based models.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Almost every other part of the investing world builds its incentives around IRR, which is why the holding company model's MOIC-based structure is distinctive.

    “if you look at almost any other pocket of the investing world and you deconstruct the incentives, they almost all hinge on IRR.”

  • In the holding company model, founders' ownership percentage increases as multiple and capital outcomes appreciate, reversing the venture pattern where founder ownership is diluted over time.

    “you create avenues for founders to perpetually, as long as they are continuing to drive multiple and capital outcomes, to increase their percentage ownership”

  • Holding companies can compound capital because founders hold their stakes long enough to benefit from both multiple expansion and capital growth, which makes the alignment reflexive.

    “The team running things actually gets more and more skin in the game as the multiple and capital outcomes appreciate”

  • In traditional venture, founders start with their largest ownership and are diluted over time as the pie grows, which creates poor incentives because the incentives structurally weaken as the company scales.

    “the founder kind of starts with as much as they're ever likely going to have. And then there's just, as you go through time, the pie is getting bigger, but your ownership is getting diluted down”

0.71

Institutions' short holding periods forfeit compounding that permanent capital can capture over decades.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Many 100x outcomes are actually built by a chain of 5x to 10x outcomes handed from one investor to another, and the institutional world's structure often prevents holding long enough to capture them.

    “there's plenty of 100x's around. They're just a series of five 10x outcomes.”

  • Trinity Ventures sold most of its Starbucks shares around the IPO, and the lost opportunity included not only a larger multiple but the learnings from staying on the board through the next decade.

    “what if they had held on for the next 10 years?”

  • Buffett's annual letter line that mistakes fade away while winners forever blossom captures the power of permanent capital.

    “Mistakes fade away, winners forever blossom. That's the power of permanent capital.”

  • The new co-formed holding companies are effectively capitalized on day one at book value, buy and build recurring revenue businesses in niche markets, and deploy often just 10 to 25 million dollars of equity forever.

    “These are new co-formations that are effectively capitalized on day one at book value.”

0.29

Search funds and holding companies may be a distinct asset class, and public teaching builds useful networks.

2 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Publishing a book and teaching publicly act as a bat signal that attracts like-minded people, producing friendships and business opportunities that the author did not expect.

    “the book itself became this bat signal for other people who had the same zany beliefs”

  • Rick suggested search funds and holding companies may be a new asset class with distinct risk-return and duration profiles, with compressed left-tail risk alongside uncapped venture-like upside.

    “where the left tail risk of permanent impairment is compressed alongside a virtually uncapped, more venture-like upside.”