Keys to Successful Growth Investing
What this covers
Jay Hoag of TCV talks with Jay about how a growth investor actually operates. The starting point is a definition: Growth Investing sits between early-stage venture, where loss rates of 30 to 50 percent are built into the model, and large private equity. The main case study is Netflix. In 2001, after its stock fell 60 percent twice, no equity provider would invest, so TCV led a restructuring financing. Subscription later fixed the unit economics, and after the 2002 IPO the stock traded sideways for about six years while investors questioned why TCV stayed.
The range is wide. Hoag draws on autonomous vehicles and AR/VR to explain Applicability vs Availability of Technology, and on Apple and Microsoft for the Desert of Disillusionment. He also covers Money Chases Momentum, which he illustrates with young soccer players chasing the ball. The most contested claims are that consumer internet is a contrarian opportunity despite over 5 billion smartphone users, and that the shift to staying private is unlikely to be permanent. He also argues for paying up for the best technology companies rather than anchoring to median SaaS prices.
The last stretch turns to how the firm and the industry work. TCV's Data Intelligence Group uses AI to score roughly 11 million companies, and weekly pipeline meetings track candidates two or more years out. Hoag argues that talent differences are an order of magnitude, calls investing a batting-average business, and says industry egos rise with returns but don't fall afterward, with 2020-2021 capital largely broken. He closes with advice for young firm founders.
Hoag argues that durable growth investing rests on backing proven businesses after technology risk is gone, holding the best companies for decades, and staying concentrated and disciplined, while momentum-chasing capital overlooks consumer internet and misreads the gap between technological availability and commercial applicability.
- Growth investing targets companies after product risk is eliminated, so loss rates are low relative to early-stage venture
- Capital follows perceived momentum, leaving consumer internet under-funded relative to SaaS and AI
- The best public companies compound for decades, so holding them is an economically rational choice
Great companies deserve long-term holding through doubts, sell-offs, and public revaluations rather than market timing.
- Netflix went public in 2002 but traded sideways for about six years, and during that stretch investors repeatedly asked why TCV was staying with the company.
“they went public in 2002, although traded down for a while and traded sideways for six years.”
- TCV works today on companies that may be investment candidates two or more years out, because young companies are not yet in the growth stage, so engagement must begin long before a financing and be built on relationships.
“we're working today on what might be a 2026 investment. Because a young company is not yet in the growth stage.”
- For the highest-quality technology companies, investors should be willing to pay more on valuation and not anchor to what the median SaaS company has sold for over the last decade, because the best companies will be long-term winners.
“One may at different points in time have to be aggressive on valuation and pay more, but it will be a long-term win.”
- Companies that have been through failures in their history often end up as great companies, and the company selection criterion of growth is that it is applied only after the business has proven its model.
“Your risk of principal loss is quite low.”
- Investors must hold through doubts because many great companies face existential challenges, and after experience an investor learns that most of a fund's 20 to 25 companies will not be the next Netflix, so the sorting process to find decade-long compounders is essential.
“hopefully they're all next Netflix or Spotify. But after some period of time you realize, well, they aren't.”
- Apple was left for dead in 2000 and by today is one of the two companies, along with Microsoft, worth $3 trillion.
“Apple was left for dead in 2000. Apple and Microsoft, the two companies worth $3 trillion today.”
- Holding a great company through public revaluations means enduring second-guessing, and no one can predict market sell-offs, so the right stance is to keep backing long-term winners rather than trying to time the market.
“Well, if you could predict when the market's going to sell off, that'd be a productive discussion to have. But I don't think one can predict that.”
Technology expertise, not diversification into other growth categories, is the right focus for growth investing.
- TCV has deliberately stayed relatively small and focused on technology rather than diversifying into other growth categories, because technology is the greatest industry and requires substantial expertise to execute.
“But really just stay focused on technology because we think it's the greatest industry and it also requires tremendous amount of expertise”
- Early-stage venture effectively invests in science projects because the technology is undeveloped and must be built, proven to work and cost-effective, and then monetized.
“early-stage venture will invest in, to some extent, science projects - meaning undeveloped technology”
- AR and VR are a great opportunity set in general, but they are still looking for commercialization.
“AR/VR generally great opportunity set but still really looking for commercialization.”
- Many growth investors have moved from pure technology into other categories such as retail and healthcare, including hospitals, or scaled into buyout-style private equity, which Hoag views as acceptable but different from TCV's focus.
“many have gone from being purely focused on the tech vertical to other categories of growth, be it retail, healthcare”
Investors deserve modest credit and must expect resilience through their own mistakes and criticism.
- Many people speak with great authority about macro issues such as regulation and tariffs while knowing very little about them, and Hoag includes himself in that group.
“A lot of people are talking with great authority about that which I think they know very little. That includes myself.”
- During returns booms investment egos rise with returns, and they often fail to come down after busts, so the industry needs more modesty because success has many fathers while failure is an orphan.
“venture returns went like this and venture egos went right with them, and then the bubble burst and returns went to this, and egos for a lot of people in the investment business didn't come down. Success has many fathers; failure is an orphan.”
- A firm should try not to repeat its mistakes, but every investor makes mistakes, and TCV has had many bad investments, especially in the Internet bubble period.
“we had plenty of bad investments... particularly in the Internet bubble days”
- Investors deserve little credit for successful companies because the blood, sweat, and tears belong to the founders, and investors are only active participants in the industry.
“to me, all of the credit and blood, sweat and tears, so to speak, goes to the founders”
- Investors need resilience to survive multiple crises and must be prepared for adversity and for people thinking they don't know what they are doing.
“it requires a lot of resilience. Because in my investing career, I've been through so many crises.”
Investment quality comes from many bets, committee rigor, and human judgment in sourcing.
- Early-stage venture funds need many investments, or bets, to capture the one or two outliers that pay off big, so missing a significant portion of the borderline deals in a vintage can be very problematic.
“investments in a given fund in part because they want to have as many chips on the betting table as possible to get that one or two that really will pay off big.”
- The three investment committee members share a commitment to rigor but differ in how aggressive or conservative they are, and this variation creates a good mix in decisions.
“I would say the similarity is rigor. The differences, the degrees of aggressive or conservative, vary by practitioner. So it's actually a good mix.”
- Automated sourcing does not replace human judgment; it allows partners to allocate their time better and prioritize companies, while inbound leads from trusted network figures such as Reed Hastings still get checked.
“If Reed Hastings sends a note saying you should check XYZ company out, we're going to check it out.”
Technology's market expansion has made early growth investing unusually rewarding.
- Today six companies are worth more than $1 trillion, including Microsoft, Apple, Nvidia at $2.8 trillion, Amazon and Google at about $2 trillion each, and Meta at $1.5 trillion, while in 1991 there were 31 public tech companies above $1 billion.
“there were 31 companies north of a billion dollars and another 13 companies between $500 million and a billion”
- The scale of the market has grown dramatically: the entire venture industry raised about $4 billion in 1994, a figure that is now a small fund for some firms, and the NASDAQ rose from 751 at the end of 1994 to over 17,000, about a 23x increase.
“The entire venture industry in 1994 raised $4 billion. Today that's a small fund for some... the NASDAQ was at 751. Today it's north of 17,000.”
- Growth was not viewed as a separate investment category in 1995, when firms like KKR were still tiny and most investors saw technology as a tiny prize with little interest.
“growth didn't really exist. It wasn't viewed as a separate category.”
- A decade or more of falling interest rates was a huge tailwind for private equity returns, and Hoag will not forecast whether rates will become a headwind.
“in a world where rates went down for 10 years, 15 years, that was a huge tailwind.”
- Early growth investing was more rewarding because there was little competition when growth was not yet a distinct category, and TCV started in 1994-1995 when technology itself was viewed as a tiny prize.
“back in '95 when we started, as you might imagine, it wasn't just there was not much interest in growth, there actually wasn't that much interest in technology.”
Biographical and anecdotal remarks about the speaker's own history and background.
- Hoag and Rick Kimball quit their jobs in 1994 to start TCV, and Hoag closed the first fund at age 36 after having young children and moving to Palo Alto.
“As I reflect back on when Rick Kimball and myself started TCV, we quit our jobs in '94.”
- Hoag as a high school point guard guarded Bill Hanzlik in sectional finals, holding him to 10 points below his season average of 25 points per game.
“I defended Bill Hanzlik and I held him to 10 points over his season average. So he scored 35 on me.”
- Netflix market capitalization reached roughly 480 billion dollars at the time of the conversation.
“Netflix market cap Friday was $480 billion”