What this covers

Zack of Business Breakdowns talks with Mikhail Lomtadze about how Kaspi became a super app in Kazakhstan, putting payments, a marketplace, fintech and government services under one login. Mikhail recalls that global peers favored single-purpose apps and called the idea crazy. He argues that super apps elsewhere stayed unprofitable because growth hid weak products until customer acquisition stalled. Much of the conversation is operating mechanics: products launch with one core feature and add roughly one per quarter, teams are measured on quality rather than profit, and about half a million consumers are surveyed monthly.

The range is wide. In commerce, Mikhail describes a grocery business built for roughly $30 weekly baskets rather than quick delivery, with about 10,000 SKUs, three-hour delivery and a reported 6-7% net margin within a year. He also covers a travel arm started during COVID, and a marketplace that, unlike Amazon, does not compete with merchants. In finance, he discusses a closed-loop payments network that undercuts Visa and Mastercard, buy-now-pay-later decisions made in a second with cost of risk below 2%, and Kazakhstan's move from mostly cash to about 90% cashless.

The more contestable claims come last: that a lost customer costs ten times more to win back, that inexperience in new verticals was an advantage, and that government services in the app deepen Kaspi's entrenchment without exclusivity. He also reports that liquidity rose almost 20 times after the move from London to Nasdaq, and he ties the Hepsiburada deal to Turkey.

Sharpest takeaway

Mikhail Lomtadze argues Kaspi's dominance comes from a quality-first culture, enforced by Net Promoter Score and product-level accountability, that a small home market forced on it, and that this culture can transfer to larger markets like Turkey through acquisition.

  • In a 20-million-person market, losing even 1 million unhappy consumers would be fatal, so quality became a survival requirement rather than a marketing claim
  • Products with negative NPS are killed or overhauled, as with the credit card that was about a third of the business
  • Marketplace and fintech reinforce each other through wallet size and merchant working capital, and the Hepsiburada acquisition extends this model to Turkey

The argument · threads10 threads · 59 claims
0.85

Product quality, not growth, is Kaspi's core discipline, driving retention, network effects, and engagement.

13 pointscentrality 5/5
  • If a Kaspi product's NPS turns negative, meaning it is not improving consumer lives, the company either drastically changes the product or kills it, and this has happened only once.

    “If the Net Promoter Score is negative, which by the way happened only once in our history, when the Net Promoter Score is negative, that means we're not improving consumers' lives. And therefore we either have to drastically change or we kill the product.”

  • Over a decade ago Kaspi shut down a credit card with negative NPS that contributed about a third of the business and a couple hundred million dollars of net income, calling it bad money because it did not improve consumers' lives.

    “We had a credit card. And the credit card had a negative Net Promoter Score. ... that was about third of our business, couple hundred million dollar contribution to our net income. And we sort of decided to kill that product because we believed what we called this was a bad money.”

  • Kaspi uses Net Promoter Score to measure whether its products improve consumers' lives, and unlike companies that use NPS as marketing, it is operationally binding, with product teams guided by it daily.

    “In case of Kaspi, we're guided by this principle. ... we measure every aspect of our business, and we wanted to measure how successfully we implement our mission.”

  • Kaspi surveys roughly half a million consumers monthly, follows up with recorded calls to those requesting improvements, and passes the consumers' own words to product teams, who turn them into limited feature releases.

    “And we would be researching or asking the question roughly to half a million consumers every month. ... we would record this call. We will call the consumer back”

  • Kaspi's product teams do not carry financial metrics such as profit or revenue; their primary KPI is product quality, which Mikhail says is what distinguishes the company.

    “our product guys don't have financial metrics. They don't have financial KPIs and most of the people in the company don't have financial KPIs like profit or revenue. The most important KPI is the quality of the product.”

  • In a 20-million-person market, losing even one million unhappy consumers would be fatal to Kaspi's next product launches, whereas in a 300-million-person market a company can mask quality problems with growth until acquisition stalls.

    “if 1 million consumers are not happy with our service, that's it, we're dead. People are not going to use our next product.”

  • Super apps elsewhere failed to be profitable because they lacked a foundational product consumers love, so growth masked poor quality until consumer acquisition stalled, at which point losses became visible.

    “So I think what has been in other markets where the super apps or the multiple services in the application have not been successful, have not been profitable, is because there is no foundational product which consumers love.”

  • Mikhail asserts that losing a consumer costs ten times more to win back than to retain, so quality failures make marketing spend wasteful over time.

    “Because if you lose a consumer, it's 10 times more expensive to bring him back.”

  • Super app network effects are bidirectional: one service promotes another, but poor quality in one product also drives users away from all services, so a single weak product can damage the whole platform.

    “if you think about super app, the network effects are very important. One service promotes another, but actually they're also working the opposite way. So if your product quality is bad, you will continue losing consumers.”

  • Mikhail believes super apps that combine many services in one app with a focus on customer service will increasingly be recognized as valuable to both shareholders and consumers.

    “I'm sure in the future there'll be more and more realization that actually single applications with multiple services, if executed correctly with a focus on customer service, will deliver a lot of value”

  • Kaspi's financial products have a Net Promoter Score around 50 to 60, which Mikhail takes as evidence that fully digital financial services are improving consumers' lives.

    “It's around 50, 60 on our financial products.”

  • When Kaspi launched financial services, more than 30 banks already offered savings accounts, consumer loans, prepaid cards, and wire transfers, yet Kaspi still entered by focusing on product quality rather than financial metrics.

    “When we started to build up our financial services, for example, I mean there were 30 plus banks.”

  • Kaspi's app has over 14 million monthly active users in a country of about 20 million people, with 67% of those users visiting the app daily, which Mikhail claims makes it probably the second most engaged app in the world after WeChat.

    “Monthly active users of our app is probably about a bit over 14 million. So 20 million people country, 14 million monthly users, and out of our monthly users, 67% of those are visiting our app daily, which makes Kaspi.kz probably the second most engaged app in the world after WeChat.”

0.71

A technology-first identity lets Kaspi enter new verticals that customers adopt through the app.

13 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Kaspi's team was not composed of bankers, and the founders expected tech companies to kill banks, so the company built its platform from a technology rather than banking orientation.

    “And I'm not the banker myself, all our guys on the team are not the bankers actually.”

  • Kaspi entered travel with no prior experience during COVID, when other players were retreating, and built it into airline tickets, train tickets and vacation packages within roughly two years.

    “we launched during COVID, so everybody was pulling out of the travel, and we said this is a great time for us to invest and build up the capabilities in travel.”

  • Mikhail argues that Kaspi's lack of experience in each new business was a competitive advantage because it allowed the team to build products differently and without the weight of prior assumptions.

    “By the way, every business we entered, we had no experience and so that was our competitive advantage because we were looking to doing things completely differently”

  • Kaspi began in 2007-2008 as a traditional financial services business after Baring Vostok stepped in when a Kazakh bank's wholesale funding dried up during the 2007 crisis, and the team chose to rebuild the bank as a technology company.

    “And then in 2007 the crisis came and the banking sector had its own really significant challenges across the region. Pretty much the third of the banking sector actually went bust because it depended very much on the wholesale funding from capital markets.”

  • Kaspi's mission is to improve people's lives through world-class mobile services with no named industry, so the company deliberately avoided defining itself as a bank and entered any vertical where it could make a difference.

    “So in our mission, even if you notice, we don't have any industry, we don't have any specific service mentioned because we are going into every vertical where we feel like we can make a difference.”

  • Every Kaspi business faced incumbent competitors at launch, including 30-plus banks in financial services, Visa and Mastercard for payments, and AliExpress and regional players in e-commerce, yet the company still entered each vertical.

    “When we started to build up our financial services, for example, I mean there were 30 plus banks.”

  • Kaspi built its grocery business for weekly purchases with an average ticket of about $30 rather than for quick commerce, because larger ticket sizes produce better e-commerce unit economics.

    “we've built the business for weekly purchases the average ticket size is about $30 which is basically a weekly purchase. It's not a quick commerce and as you know the larger is the size of the ticket, the better economics of any e-commerce business.”

  • Kaspi's new products achieve high adoption rates because satisfied consumers already using its app recommend them to others, so consumers effectively do the company's marketing.

    “Our consumers are doing job for us, so they're doing the marketing for us. They're telling each other about the products.”

  • Kaspi became the largest travel agency in its market about two years after entering travel, and the grocery business followed a similar adoption path within about a year.

    “It took us two years to become the largest travel agency on the market. Now the same is happening with the grocery.”

  • Kaspi sized the grocery market at roughly 16-17 billion (in the transcript's currency framing) and described it as largely fragmented, and grocery now accounts for about 5% of marketplace GMV.

    “So we're talking about 16, 17 billion size of the market which is largely fragmented.”

  • Kaspi's model is unusual because it has become profitable while still investing heavily in growth, which Mikhail attributes to the management team's execution rather than to access to abundant capital.

    “We never had the luxury to have abundance of money around. We always had access to limited financial resources. So therefore everything we've done, we have always done with the final goal of exciting consumers, but also generating and building the profitable business.”

  • Kaspi started in financial services in 2007 and 2008, then added payments, e-commerce, travel, grocery, B2B payments, and government services, putting all of them in one app. The company later described this as a super app.

    “So we've started from financial services back in 2007, 2008, and for a couple of years, we have been building up really probably the best financial services in Kazakhstan. Then we went into payments, then we went into e-commerce.”

  • Kaspi enters roughly two or three new businesses each year, which Mikhail attributes to a continuous wave of innovation driven by consumer feedback.

    “Every year we enter two or three new businesses basically.”

0.53

Closed-loop payments and merchant and consumer credit fuel marketplace GMV growth.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Kaspi's B2B payments were initially designed so convenience store staff could settle supplier invoices, such as from Coca-Cola, through the same closed-loop system used for consumer payments.

    “B2B Payments was a service which we developed with convenience stores in mind. So basically Coca-Cola or others would bring their goods to the convenience store.”

  • Kaspi's payments network is a closed loop in which both consumers and merchants hold accounts on Kaspi's systems, which lets it price at the cheapest rates on the market and disintermediate networks like Visa and Mastercard.

    “The biggest difference from many other payment services is actually that we are the closed loop. We control the entire value experience from the merchants to the consumer”

  • Providing working capital to merchants lets them buy more inventory and grow sales on Kaspi, and because they stock less with their own capital and sell more through the platform, Kaspi's GMV grows.

    “So for example, you can provide the working capital to your merchants and working capital means your merchants can buy more items and they are selling more items with you.”

  • Offering buy-now-pay-later financing increases consumers' effective wallet size, which lets them buy more on the marketplace, so the fintech product fuels marketplace GMV growth when indebtedness is responsibly managed.

    “Because you are by providing BNPL products, you are increasing the wallet size of your consumers and therefore consumers can buy more.”

  • Mikhail argues that BNPL-driven wallet expansion must be paired with responsible management of consumer indebtedness, and that low cost of risk is the proof that growth is responsible rather than predatory.

    “You have to make sure you're responsible in terms of managing the indebtedness of your consumers. And that has to be reflected in a cost of risk being low.”

0.39

The marketplace empowers retailers with technology and payments rather than competing with them as Amazon does.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Kaspi's e-commerce marketplace launched in 2014 with electronics, based on the idea of combining many stores' offers, prices and reviews in one place after Mikhail wasted days shopping across stores for a computer and printer.

    “We sort of decided why not put together a single location where you not only buy the items and select them, but you can actually compare the prices from different merchants.”

  • Unlike Amazon, Kaspi's marketplace does not compete with retailers; it gives offline and online retailers technology, logistics, advertising, working capital and payments, and prices fairly so it succeeds only when merchants do.

    “we are not competing with the retailers, we are actually helping them. Most of our retail partners are not just pure online stores actually. They are offline retailers”

  • Kaspi has more than 7,000 merchants and over 14 million users, and Mikhail frames this user and merchant base as the foundation and asset of its growth rather than a limit.

    “Over 14 million users and over 7,000 merchants that we have. This is actually our asset. It's not a limitation of our growth.”

  • Kaspi agreed to buy 65% of Turkish marketplace Hepsiburada from its founders, a move Mikhail says takes Kaspi's addressable market to about 100 million people given Turkey's 85 million population and similarities to Kazakhstan.

    “About a month ago we have announced that we've signed an agreement to buy 65% from the founders of one of the largest marketplaces in Turkey.”

  • Mikhail chose Hepsiburada because it is founder-led, focused on product quality, EBITDA positive while still growing, and single-brand, which he says makes it culturally compatible with Kaspi.

    “The company has a lot of similarities with Kaspi. It's founder-led, focused on the quality of the products, actually EBITDA positive, which is very unusual.”

0.37

Consumers want one login and one brand spanning many services, not single-purpose apps.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • When Kaspi pursued a super app, most global companies believed in single-purpose apps, and people said the company was crazy to combine savings accounts and kitchen accessories under one brand, but Kaspi argued consumers want one login and one brand.

    “At the time when we were developing the super app idea, most of the companies around the world actually were strong believers in the single-purpose mobile applications.”

  • Citizens can now issue driving licenses, file marriage applications, obtain birth certificates, register businesses, transfer car ownership and pay taxes entirely through the Kaspi mobile app, and Mikhail claims this is unique to Kazakhstan.

    “they can issue driving licenses, they can file marriage applications, they can get birth certificates for kids, they have all the digital documents, passport, driving license in the mobile application, they can register business”

  • Because most users access government services through Kaspi's app, government digitization deepens Kaspi's entrenchment, although Kaspi claims no exclusivity and says the services could run through other apps.

    “We don't have any exclusivity around those services. ... It's just the way that our design user experience works so conveniently that most of the people use government services through our mobile application.”

  • Kaspi works on two fronts with investors: telling its own business story and promoting Kazakhstan's investment climate and development, since the company was built in Kazakhstan.

    “because we are the company which was developed in Kazakhstan, we are promoting the country and the investment climate”

0.34

Commission-free instant payments and fast digital decisions drive the national shift to cashless.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Kazakhstan's transaction mix flipped from roughly 85-90% cash around 2016 to roughly 90% cashless today, a transformation Mikhail credits to digital reforms and to Kaspi actively driving the change.

    “If you take perspective from 2016, plus minus a year, sort of the penetration of the cashless transactions was maybe around 10, 15%. So basically 85, 90% was cash, and now it's totally opposite.”

  • Kaspi makes 99.9% of its buy-now-pay-later decisions in a second, with a cost of risk below 2%, which Mikhail says is world-class and results from being fully digital and data-driven.

    “For example on our buy now pay later products we are making 99.9% of decisions in a second on our cost of risk is less than 2%.”

  • Kaspi's P2P transfers are commission-free and settle instantly, which Mikhail credits as a driver of mobile payment adoption and of the national shift from cash to cashless.

    “consumers can wire money to friends and family commission free and money hits accounts instantly. So this has been a driver of the mobile payments in the country”

0.34

Kaspi will outgrow a Kazakhstan market that is large in resources and population.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Kazakhstan has about 20 million people, GDP of roughly $260 billion (about $14,000 per capita), large oil, gas, uranium and copper deposits, and territory equal to several European countries combined.

    “so GDP about 260 plus billion about 14,000 GDP per capita. On the one hand, it's one of the resource-rich countries in the world.”

  • The government digitization effort was enabled by President Tokayev's public digital agenda and by government agencies eager to distribute services to citizens, which Kaspi then implemented through its app about three years ago.

    “President Tokayev communicating the digital agenda and strong belief that technology improves people's lives. And at the same time, the government agencies and the departments that were basically very keen to distribute as many of the government services as possible”

  • Mikhail forecasts that Kazakhstan's retail and services industries will each grow about 14% annually over the next five years, and that Kaspi will outgrow them by vertical-by-vertical expansion.

    “The both are forecasted to grow about 14% annually during the next five years. And with our technology and with our brand, I believe we'll be growing faster than the industries growing themselves.”

0.23

Lean single-feature launches and frequent quarterly releases sustain innovation and profitability across product teams.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Kaspi runs roughly 50 product teams, each launching at least one feature per quarter, which Mikhail says produces a high rate of innovation that is becoming a competitive advantage.

    “So if you think about the product teams, we would have about 50 plus, minus the 50 product teams across the company.”

  • Kaspi launches each product with only its single most important feature and then adds one feature per quarter over roughly a year, which keeps teams lean, reduces consumer education costs, and supports profitability.

    “Extreme simplification means we'll really work really hard to understand which out of those four features is the most important feature. And then we will launch the product with this feature”

  • Kaspi's grocery business, built around about 10,000 SKUs and delivered within three hours, reached a net income margin of roughly 6-7% within 12 months while still investing in dark stores and growing about 100% year over year.

    “when we entered this business we actually made it profitable within the first 12 months. So within the first 12 months our net income margin on that business was about 6, 7%”

  • Kaspi is organized as a product company in which every product has a dedicated directly responsible individual and team that bears full responsibility for exciting the consumer.

    “In our case, we are organized around the products. We're a product company pretty much. And every product has a directly disposable individual, directly disposable team.”

0.23

Kaspi's valuation lags because investors have not used its products, despite Nasdaq liquidity gains.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Mikhail argues the US is the right listing venue because comparable business models such as MercadoLibre and Coupang are listed there, and that Kaspi's blend of PayPal, Amazon, Affirm, Klarna and Square in one app requires investor education.

    “US is a very exciting market because the companies which are similar to us and our business model, most of them are really listed in the US.”

  • Kaspi's stock liquidity increased almost 20 times after moving its listing from the London Stock Exchange to Nasdaq, and Mikhail says this is now factual evidence rather than a theory since Kaspi was the only company listed on both.

    “So the liquidity of our stock increased almost 20 times on NASDAQ compared to the London Stock Exchange. And we were actually the only company which were on both London Stock Exchange and NASDAQ.”

  • Mikhail argues Kaspi's valuation lags because most investors have never used its products, unlike investors in Apple or Amazon services, so the company must explain its business model to educate the investor base.

    “Most of our investors have not really been using our products and that's the disadvantage which we have.”

  • Kaspi listed on the London Stock Exchange in 2020, then listed on Nasdaq in January 2024 and delisted from London. Zack's introduction describes Kaspi as now listed on Nasdaq with a market cap around $20 billion.

    “We were listed on London Stock Exchange in 2020, and then we decided to list on NASDAQ in 2024 January, and then we delisted from London Stock Exchange.”

0.07

Mikhail's private equity and Harvard background led him to build Kaspi rather than exit.

3 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Harvard Business School has written two cases about Kaspi covering its product development and corporate culture.

    “Harvard Business School wrote two cases about us which I think really talk about our product development and corporate culture.”

  • Mikhail chose venture capital and private equity after Harvard Business School because it is the closest industry to actually running a business while building alongside portfolio company management teams.

    “As a result, I've decided to go for venture capital, private equity, which it's the closest industry can get to actually running your business.”

  • Mikhail and his co-founder Slav Kim moved from private equity into operating Kaspi after investing in a Kazakh bank that Baring Vostok held, choosing to build the business themselves rather than exit.

    “And then we made an investment in Kazakhstan, which was one of just the traditional banks, pretty much top 10-15 at that time.”