What this covers

Patrick interviews Jason Karp about how to find an edge in markets where price-setting has changed, and then about where Karp sees opportunity. The first half is public-market mechanics. Karp lays out Three Types of Edge: informational, analytical and structural. He says Regulation Fair Disclosure erased the first, and that the third is where most of the opportunity lies. He argues deep value has been arbitraged away by the spread of Graham and Dodd, and that a quick screen for the cheapest stocks mostly returns businesses with real problems. His own tool is reverse DCF, which starts from the current price and asks what must happen to justify it. He also covers the compounding arithmetic of growing cash flows and the advantages of low-net fund structures and patient LPs.

The second half moves into consumer businesses, private markets and cannabis. Karp discusses how cyclicality limits how far cash flows can be extrapolated, why food staples hold up in recessions, and why large food buyers can pay high multiples for new brands. He warns that CPG startups chasing roughly $25 million in revenue may have no viable model if capital markets close. Private equity and venture capital also draw capital partly because their assets are not marked daily. The cannabis section is the most contested. Karp traces the drug's stigma to Prohibition-era fights and the Nixon-era Schedule I classification, and contrasts it with crypto by pointing to dispensaries that earn tens of millions in EBITDA from one store. Patrick adds a forecast drawing on Carlota Perez about the durability of today's dominant tech names. The episode closes on hiring, where Karp ranks emotional intelligence above IQ.

Sharpest takeaway

Karp argues that passive and quant flows have pushed public prices far from business fundamentals, so long-duration investors who hold through dislocations and back growing cash flows can win, and that health and wellness and cannabis offer such opportunities.

  • Fundamental discretionary managers fell from 40-50% of daily stock trading volume to under 10%, so prices are set mostly by non-fundamental flows
  • Reverse DCF and cash-flow growth matter more than cheap multiples, and duration is the structural edge
  • Consumer habits in food and cannabis create durable cash flows that public and private investors can underwrite

The argument · threads12 threads · 85 claims
0.85

Passive, quant, and analyst crowding has pushed prices far from value and limited public-market edge.

10 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Ten or so years ago 40% to 50% of daily stock trading volume came from fundamental discretionary managers, but today that share is less than 10%, so over 90% of trading comes from passive, quant, CTA and risk-premia strategies that do not evaluate what businesses are worth.

    “Today that number is less than 10%, which has been well-documented by several banks.”

  • Passive investing can create multi-year dislocations between prices and fundamentals in public stocks, while quant-driven dislocations tend to be shorter, and in Jason's experience convergence between cash flows and stock price usually takes three to five years at worst.

    “the public markets you can get substantial multi-year, not multi-month or multi-day, you can get sometimes multi-year dislocations from passive”

  • Over the last 18 months growth stocks have become over 90% correlated with momentum, the highest such correlation Jason has seen, and trend-following passive and quant money is crowding into what is already working.

    “growth has become over 90% correlated to momentum in the last 18 months”

  • Value contrarian investors have been obliterated over the last three years and are leaving the market, removing price-setters while capital flows to momentum players, which exacerbates trends.

    “you have a lot of capital from the people who are trying to be the price setters leaving”

  • The disconnect between fundamental value and price is the largest Jason has seen in his 21-year career, with overextended quality, safe and low-vol names and undervalued harder-to-categorize value names on the other side.

    “I think the disconnect between the fundamental value and where the price is, is the largest I've ever seen in my career.”

  • A 30-second screen for the cheapest S&P stocks at six to nine times earnings yields mostly businesses with severe problems, so deep value investors face adverse selection where only a few of the cheap stocks are mispriced.

    “you're inherently in an adverse selection pool to try to find the frog that you can kiss that turns into a prince”

  • The ratio of sell-side analysts to public stocks was at an all-time high at the end of 2017, indicating heavy coverage relative to the number of listed companies.

    “that ratio is at an all time high as of the end of 17”

  • Private equity still offers sources of alpha because quants and passive investors do not compete there, and certain private niches outside tech remain compelling, although heavy capital inflows now require more caution.

    “particularly in areas outside of tech”

  • The number of public stocks has fallen by more than half in the last 20 years, mostly through M&A rather than bankruptcy, with fewer companies coming public and many staying private much longer.

    “the number of stocks that exist in the market is down by more than half in the last 20 years”

  • Quant strategies ingest thousands of data sets far beyond human capacity, so in the short term and on short horizons a discretionary investor cannot possibly win against them.

    “anything in the short term and most quant that's ingesting a ton of data is on the shorter term of the time horizon, you can't possibly win”

0.62

Long horizons and structural advantages, not effort alone, produce investment edge.

7 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Market-neutral or low-net funds have a structural advantage because they are not exposed to beta, so when the market falls they keep their capital and do not make non-economic decisions that others are forced into.

    “they're starting to make decisions that are non economic”

  • Jason does not believe private equity is a better asset class than public stocks; its advantage is extra features, such as no marks and low apparent volatility, that make it easier for investors to hold.

    “I don't think it's necessarily a better asset class per se than public stocks, but it has a few extra features that make it much better for investors”

  • Instead of hunting stocks at six to eight times earnings, investors should look for growing businesses trading at around 12 to 16 times earnings, because growth can offset mistakes.

    “look for things that trade at maybe 12 to 16 times earnings, but actually have a lot of growth behind them”

  • With a five-year-plus horizon public investing has a very linear relationship between effort and outcome, but most active managers operate on quarterly or annual horizons, where investors who do not tolerate interim losses force them out of business.

    “If your time horizon is five years plus, there's a very linear relationship between effort and outcome.”

  • Much of the capital flowing into private equity and VC is driven by the fact that private assets do not mark to market daily, so a company like Uber can fall 15-20% in secondary trading without investors panicking, whereas a public stock falling 30% triggers capitulation.

    “you don't have the ability to panic”

  • A structural advantage comes from having an LP base willing to endure three years of underperformance, or a fund structure that lets managers play offense when others must play defense.

    “Having an LP base that is willing to stomach through three years of all”

  • If a company's cash flows grow about 20% a year, money doubles roughly every three and a quarter years, so a reasonably bought growing asset wins over a five-to-six-year window even if the multiple halves or falls 75%.

    “The multiple gets cut by 75%, you still win, assuming you bought it reasonably.”

0.56

Informational edge has vanished, leaving analytical edge and competition as the remaining sources.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • When Jason started there were only a few hundred hedge funds, and there are now over 10,000, plus tens of thousands of individuals running quant strategies from their apartments on platforms like Quantopian, which has raised competition sharply.

    “There are over 10,000 now”

  • There are three types of edge: informational edge, which is largely gone due to Reg FD and competition; analytical edge, which still exists because the same information can be processed better; and structural edge, which is where the most opportunity lies.

    “And then you have what I would call structural edge. And structure is where I think there's the most opportunity.”

  • Before Regulation Fair Disclosure in 2002, big commission payers could call sell-side analysts for early upgrade information and call management for quarterly results, an advantage that Reg FD eliminated.

    “prior to 2002, 2002 was the beginning of what they call reg FD or regulation fair disclosure”

  • Deep value investing has been arbitraged away because Graham and Dodd principles became widely known, with thousands of books and websites on value investing, so assuming the strategy works as it did in the 1940s-60s is insane.

    “There were 8,000 books referencing value investing, 8,000.”

  • In 1998 having a Bloomberg terminal was a unique advantage, with only about 20% to 30% of colleagues having one, and analysts had to visit the New York Public Library to get old 10-Ks and 10-Qs.

    “I probably knew 20%, 30% of my colleagues had Bloomberg's back then.”

0.46

Food is an enduring mega trend where consumer obsession and mission culture drive returns.

6 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Hu Products sells about 98% chocolate, is in over 1,600 stores and expects about 2,500 by year end, selling direct online, through Whole Foods and through distributors.

    “We're in over 1,600 stores today. We should be at about 2,500 by the end of the year.”

  • Employees must genuinely believe in the mission and be educated about ingredients, because investing in culture and education creates brand ambassadors who propagate the mission to a broader audience.

    “if you invest in the culture and you invest in your people so that they become educated, then they become successful ambassadors”

  • Large public food stocks are at 52-week lows because they cannot innovate fast enough to meet consumer demand for real, non-chemically laden food.

    “all the big food public stocks are at 52 week lows right now”

  • Investors should keep a consumer hat on and deconstruct why they are drawn to a product, because a personal obsession with a product often predicts how the broad audience will behave and is an early trend signal.

    “if I feel that innate draw to become obsessed with something, that it tends to actually happen for the broad audience”

  • Large food buyers pay high multiples for new brands because their distribution trucks can carry the acquired products at little marginal cost, along with synergies in production and sourcing, so the math is never as bad as it looks.

    “what these big buyers have is distribution”

  • Food is one of the biggest industries and an enduring mega trend that should be approached from an investment perspective in both public and private markets.

    “Food is one of the biggest industries that's been around since the dawn of man.”

0.46

Cannabis is a major cash-generating industry worth understanding, especially through private companies.

6 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The cannabis industry is about a $50 billion market today, of which only six to eight billion is legal.

    “this is a $50 billion industry today. Only six to eight billion of it is legal.”

  • Cannabis will be one of the biggest industries in the United States in the next five to ten years, and not having knowledge of it is more important for investors than understanding crypto.

    “cannabis is going to be one of the biggest industries in this country in the next five to 10 years”

  • Unlike crypto, which is greater fool theory with no cash flows, some cannabis businesses generate real cash flow, and some dispensaries earn tens of millions in EBITDA from a single store.

    “some of these dispensaries... there's a few dispensaries in the country that are doing tens of millions of EBITDA out of one store.”

  • Public cannabis companies valued at billions have ludicrous valuations and Jason would not invest in them, preferring private cannabis companies.

    “I wouldn't invest in those. But there's a ton of private companies.”

  • Cannabis will produce both stocks that go to zero and stocks that tenfold, so investors who do not understand the sub-sectors and players will miss years of alpha, as in the late 1990s tech cycle.

    “there's going to be some cannabis stocks that go to zero, and there's going to be some cannabis stocks to tenfold”

  • Canada going fully recreational in July 2018 marks a critical tipping point in cannabis legalization, and Canada has six or seven public cannabis companies of scale, many with billion-dollar valuations.

    “Canada as an entire country is going fully recreationally legal in July of 2018.”

0.40

Returns come from holding through non-linear price paths and reverse-engineering prices.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Capital markets always produce winners and losers, such as Amazon versus Walmart or Apple versus BlackBerry, so an investor who holds longs whose cash flows double or triple and shorts whose cash flows deteriorate will win if they hold through a non-linear path.

    “if you can hold it for long enough... you will win, but you have to hold it and you have to be there for the whole duration”

  • Fashion-driven companies such as Crocs can go from hot to not within a year, so their earnings cannot be extrapolated.

    “Fashion is notoriously something you can't extrapolate because the trends can go from on to off in a year.”

  • Jason uses reverse discounted cash flow, starting from today's price and asking what must happen for the stock to be worth it, rather than projecting cash flows forward and discounting them.

    “we actually take the price today... you try to figure out what's priced into today's stock”

  • Facebook went public in 2006 or 2007 and has been mainstream only about 10 to 12 years, so it would be foolish to assume it cannot be disintermediated just because it is large.

    “it would be foolish to presume that it cannot be disintermediated just because it's so big”

0.40

Businesses with entrenched daily customer habits are forecastable and cheaply priced.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Most type 2 diabetes can be easily reversed with diet and lifestyle, yet people prefer taking insulin or pills to addressing the root cause.

    “most type two diabetes can actually be easily reversed with diet and lifestyle”

  • Businesses with subscriptions, daily use and daily habits, such as the FANG platforms, are easier to forecast than fashion-driven or cyclical companies because their customers become deeply entrenched.

    “businesses that are much more prone to subscriptions, that are much more prone to daily use and daily habit, tend to be easier to bank on”

  • Facebook and Google are surprisingly cheap for how deeply ingrained they are in daily habits, given their cash flow profile, balance sheet and growth, and trade at multiples similar to cyclical companies with inferior margins and balance sheets.

    “I think several of those businesses, not Netflix and not Amazon, but Facebook and Google are surprisingly cheap”

  • Younger, digitally aware consumers, including millennials and mothers, care much less about legacy brands and instead want transparency and a company mission, which shifted in the last five to ten years from trusting big institutional brands.

    “something flipped in the last five to 10 years, where people just don't care anymore”

0.26

Clean eating is a durable shift, with taste driving repeat purchases.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Cannabis cannot cause a fatal overdose the way alcohol can, and is metabolized through the lungs rather than the liver, so it does not cause the same organ toxicity.

    “There's no overdose limit. You can literally consume as much as you want.”

  • Hu chocolate is 70% dark with no refined sugar and is high in calories, but consumers group it with protein bars as a permissible snack rather than candy, which drives uptake.

    “people seem to be grouping our chocolate in the same category as a snack, as a protein bar”

  • The shift toward cleaner food will not reverse because once consumers learn about preservatives and chemicals like glyphosate they do not return to conventional products, unlike a fad.

    “once you learn about this stuff, you don't go back. It's not like a fad”

  • Many healthier food concepts and companies do not adhere to the principle that food has to taste good, which is strange because taste is the precondition for repeat purchase.

    “a lot of healthier food concepts and companies don't actually adhere to the it has to taste good principle”

0.26

Consumer packaged goods startups are fragile if capital markets close.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Some CPG startups now chase revenue to about 25 million dollars as a minimum, aiming to sell to a dumb buyer, which is dangerous because they may lack economic models if the capital markets close.

    “people believe is around 25 million in revenue as a minimum before you should approach Big Food”

  • Most retailers buy through distributors, who act as middlemen and considerably reduce a brand's margins, so selling direct to stores is preferable but very hard today.

    “most retailers use a distributor, which functions as a middleman, which takes your margins down considerably”

  • Kellogg's paid about $600 million for RXBAR, roughly six times its estimated revenue of about $100 million, reflecting a pattern where large food companies pay four to eight times sales for CPG startups.

    “Kellogg's paid six times revenue for it.”

  • Private investors should ask whether a business works if capital markets shut off for six months, because the CPG space shows a euphoria-like aspect that under-weights this question.

    “does this business work if the capital markets shut off for six months?”

0.26

Hu Kitchen's strict guardrails and self-funding protect its founder's health-driven mission.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Jason's autoimmune illness, which left him diagnosed with several incurable diseases in his early twenties, led him to believe through research that better eating, sleep and exercise could cure his symptoms, and this personal experience inspired Hu Kitchen.

    “I could actually cure my symptoms and ultimately cure my diseases through better eating, better sleeping and better physical activity”

  • Hu Kitchen operates under strict guardrails, such as no dairy, gluten, refined sugar or preservatives, and the company has never deviated even when doing so cut against profit.

    “And we've had many situations which were against our profit motive.”

  • Hu's product test is that food must taste delicious to Jason's children before they know it is healthy, so the product must succeed on taste first and health second.

    “if we give them something, they have to think it's actually delicious before they know that it's healthy”

  • Hu Kitchen was fully internally funded with no outside investors because Jason did not want people with a profit motive pressuring the company to substitute cheaper ingredients for organic ones.

    “I didn't want people with too much of a profit motive gumming up the works”

0.26

Cannabis's stigma is misplaced, and its medical benefits changed personal and investment views.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Cannabis was known in the 1930s to be safer than alcohol, and its stigma came from a historical campaign, including a Prohibition-era mafia fight over alcohol and Nixon-era scheduling as Schedule I, which Jason says has led to 50 years of misperception.

    “The history of cannabis it was known in the 30s that it was safer than alcohol.”

  • After trying Valium, Ambien and other prescription drugs for lifelong insomnia, Jason found that certain forms of cannabis worked surprisingly well for him, which shifted his personal and investment views.

    “certain forms of cannabis are particularly good for insomnia”

  • CBD oil, a non-psychoactive cannabis extract, is the only known way to treat a rare form of childhood epilepsy, and GW Pharmaceuticals is pioneering a drug built on it.

    “It's the only way to cure this particular form of seizures.”

  • Jason's view of cannabis changed after a triathlete friend's physical performance improved when he switched from alcohol to cannabis, prompting Jason to research the drug rather than dismiss it.

    “Why don't you do your research on cannabis before you be so judgmental?”

0.12

Adversity experience and emotional intelligence matter more than credentials when hiring.

4 pointscentrality 1/5
  • When hiring, intelligence and passion are necessary but common, while emotional intelligence, including self-control, conflict resolution, empathy and rapidly changing opinions given conflicting facts, is harder to find and more important than IQ.

    “I think emotional intelligence is more important than IQ, far more important.”

  • Jason prefers hiring competitive athletes, military veterans and women who have had children, because their experience with failure, teamwork and managing children gives them conflict-resolution skills.

    “I find mothers to be spectacular.”

  • Instead of screening resumes, it is better to ask what a candidate has actually been through and done, since that shows whether they can handle adversity.

    “instead of looking for criteria on a resume, it's much better to just look at what has this person actually been through”

  • A squash coach kept Jason on the team despite being the worst player, and his belief in him changed Jason's path, teaching perseverance and organization and making him an academic All-American.

    “Jason, I see a lot of talent in you.”