Petco: Capturing the Pet Economy
What this covers
This episode of Business Breakdowns has Greg Kamstra walking the hosts through Petco as a store-based specialty retailer. It begins with the economics. Store-level margins are roughly 20-25%, but rent and labor are largely fixed, so operating leverage makes comparable store sales the metric that matters most, and that depends on how often customers come back. From there it turns to the market. Spend per pet is said to have risen from about $650 in 2009 to about $1,000, with a forecast of $2,000 by 2030. Kamstra ties the longer growth to more people living alone and the pandemic's push toward dog ownership.
The middle of the conversation is about trust. Because an animal cannot say what it needs, owners depend on advice, and Kamstra argues Petco wants to be the most trusted source, while Chewy and Amazon serve people who already know what they want. Vet clinics in stores, grooming and services, and the roughly 27% of sales from owned brands all feed that loop. Kamstra also notes that some independent brands refused to sell online. The discussion of Petco's e-commerce share, about 12%, includes the suggestion that Petco may not want it to rise much, given margins and white-label delivery through DoorDash.
The last stretch covers deals and outcomes. PetSmart bought Chewy for $3 billion in 2017, and BC Partners turned its stake in Chewy into a very large private equity gain. Kamstra describes pet retail as levered beta for funds and names market selection as the main lesson. He closes with scenarios for Petco's market cap doubling or halving, citing Sports Authority as a warning about big-box fixed costs.
Greg Kamstra argues Petco's durable edge is owning customer trust and physical distribution in a secularly growing pet market, but its weak digital execution and missed acquisitions, including Chewy, mean it has underused its position.
- Pet spend per household is growing faster than household count, creating a secular tailwind that supports store economics.
- Stores function as trust-based advice channels and fulfillment hubs, which e-commerce players like Chewy cannot easily replicate.
- Petco missed major digital and M&A opportunities, so its e-commerce share (about 12%) lags the market.
Private equity owners of pet retailers bet on growth or operational improvement.
- Petco and PetSmart spent much of the last twenty years under private equity ownership, with Petco owned by a Canadian pension board and PetSmart by BC Partners, and Petco was bought and sold multiple times.
“PetSmart and Petco spent much of the last 20 years being owned by private equity.”
- A major share of the roughly 11 million incremental pet adoptions in 2020 likely went to households without a pet before, so millions of households became first-time owners, since most people did not add a second pet.
“millions of households became dog owners or cat or whatever, for the first time, probably a safe assumption. Most people didn't go out and get a second dog.”
- PetSmart has outperformed Petco for much of its history, which helped it finance the Chewy purchase largely with debt, while both companies were owned by private equity.
“PetSmart is a good business, PetSmart for much of its history has outperformed Petco.”
- Private equity investors either believe they can improve a business operationally or treat the deal as levered beta on a growth rate, and in pet both theses work because growth alone or operational improvement would each produce returns.
“there's two types. There's some people that really have this thesis of I improve these businesses... There are other candidates and it's just for a lot of funds... it's just levered beta.”
Petco's owned store network and adjacencies create value beyond core retail margins.
- Grocery retail is famous for very low margins, but it does not matter because stores move so much volume, and for specialty retail the primary driver of store margin is revenue per store against largely fixed rent and labor.
“The US grocery industry is famous for very low margin, but it doesn't matter because the stores can move so much volume. For these guys, they've got about 13,000 square foot stores.”
- Petco has a pet insurance business and other adjacencies that can be layered on its owned distribution network, which Kamstra sees as a source of additive strategic value.
“I mean, they have a pet insurance business we haven't talked about much yet. They have all these other little legs.”
- Vet clinics inside Petco create a strategic loop in which the veterinarian can recommend food or products that only the chain sells, deepening the relationship and driving product purchases beyond the vet visit.
“the veterinarian is going to be able to tell you what kind of food to buy and maybe you'll buy from them. Maybe the veterinarian is going to recommend a piece of some food that only they have.”