What this covers
This episode of Business Breakdowns works through MTN Group's business as a conversation between its two hosts, Benjamin and Benjamin Isaac. It starts with where the money comes from. In 2022 about 38% of group revenue came from Nigeria and 25% from South Africa, so two markets dominate. The mix is shifting: voice fell from roughly 60% of service revenue in 2018 to 43%, data rose to 37%, and fintech reached 9%. Management's Ambition 2025 plan targets fintech above 20%. ARPU runs from about $1.50 to $5.50 a month, a very small share of a household budget.
The structural backdrop gets real attention. Africa leapfrogged landlines and fiber because grid power was unreliable, so wireless carries most connectivity, and the hosts argue that self-financing telcos make competing fiber hard to justify. Demographics supply the growth case: a population heading from 1.4 billion toward 2.5 billion by 2050, more than 40% of it under 15, and urbanization at about 40%. Smartphone adoption is still early.
The longest stretch is on fintech. Mobile money filled a gap left by sparse banking, and the hosts describe it as a three-sided network whose winner-take-most dynamics play out country by country. They put 2022 transaction value near USD 220 billion, guide to roughly 35% EBITDA margins, and discuss a Ghana transaction levy that depressed reported results. The more contested material concerns the strong dollar, whether an ADR or a U.S. or London listing would lower the cost of equity, why a listed Nigerian subsidiary protects against government action, and the comparison with how investors treat Argentina in Mercado Libre.
MTN is an underappreciated, profitable fintech and telecom platform whose growth is driven by African demographics and infrastructure leapfrogging, and global investors underrate it because they treat African political and macro risk as uniquely disqualifying.
- Mobile money leapfrogged the absence of banks and landlines, creating a fintech business processing about USD 220 billion of transaction value in 2022
- Africa's young, fast-urbanizing population means decades of subscriber growth, and fintech margins are far higher than expected
- Investors should apply the same risk management to Africa as to Argentina or other jurisdictions instead of treating Africa as uniquely risky
Mobile money grew to fill infrastructure gaps and is now large, growing, and already profitable.
- Mobile money was not invented by MTN; it started elsewhere in Africa with M-PESA in Kenya around 2007, and MTN has evolved the offering over time.
“Mobile money is certainly not innovated within MTN, although they've certainly done a tremendous job of evolving the offering over time.”
- M-PESA is dominant in Kenya, has a presence in Tanzania and the DRC, and has struggled to gain traction elsewhere, even in markets where its parent Vodacom has material telco presence.
“M-PESA is dominant in Kenya, has a presence in Tanzania and the DRC and has really struggled to find a lot of traction elsewhere in the continent”
- Mobile money took off because there was little banking infrastructure: few ATMs and small bank branch networks meant mobile money filled a need for safe storage of cash and cheap transfers across long distances, which banks could not serve.
“there is often no banking infrastructure... mobile money provided a tremendous opportunity that banks simply were not able to fill”
- Mobile money is a three-sided network: users must accept it and agents must sell airtime and convert cash, which takes effort to launch; merchant acceptance is the longer-run step that makes the flywheel spin.
“It's effectively a three-sided network. You need the merchants to be willing to accept it ultimately, that's kind of the longer game”
- MTN itself acknowledged that about 95% of broadband-to-the-home opportunities will be fulfilled through fixed wireless access rather than last-mile fiber, a profound difference from developed markets.
“they acknowledged that 95% of all broadband-to-the-home opportunities were going to wind up being fulfilled through fixed wireless access as opposed to some kind of last-mile fiber connection”
- Outside a thin elite and South Africa, credit cards are not part of everyday commerce for most Africans, Visa and Mastercard have only tried to insert themselves into mobile money, and mobile money ecosystems remain effectively closed loops.
“credit cards really aren't in the game. There's some efforts by Mastercard and Visa to try to insert themselves into the mobile money ecosystem over time”
- Africa skipped landlines and fiber because grid power was unreliable and few consumers had landlines, so wireless infrastructure, which often needs gensets and fuel logistics off-grid, now provides a supermajority of connectivity services.
“So the wireless ecosystem really winds up providing a supermajority of connectivity services.”
- MTN's mobile money business processed around USD 220 billion of transaction value in 2022, which is larger than Square's Cash App, making MTN one of the largest fintechs in the world even though most investors do not appreciate it.
“in 2022, MTN's mobile money business processed around USD 220 billion of transaction value, which is larger than Square's Cash App”
- Changes that Alipay created in China and UPI is enabling in India are already starting to happen in Africa through dominant mobile money platforms such as MTN's, which makes the mobile money shift consequential on its own.
“some of the same positive changes that, for example, Alipay created in China and UPI is allowing for in India are already starting to happen in an African context”
- Serigne Dioum built MTN's most successful mobile money market in Ghana and was then elevated to run the entire MTN fintech ecosystem, where he will oversee a separate fintech operating company after structural separation.
“the architect of its success in Ghana, which is definitely its most successful mobile money market run by the gentleman who supervised that success, a man by the name of Serigne Dioum”
- A large levy on mobile money transactions in Ghana and currency headwinds in 2022 depressed reported fintech revenue, and excluding Ghana the fintech business grew roughly 30% year over year in 2022 despite a difficult year for emerging markets.
“if you just exclude Ghana for a second, this was a business that was up roughly 30% year-over-year in 2022”
- Airtel Money's spinout, tied to its TPG investment, is likely in the next 12 to 24 months, and since Airtel Africa is London-listed, it may seek a London or U.S. listing.
“that spinout process is likely to happen in the next, I would say, 12 to 24 months”
- The most recent regulatory data suggests Ghana's mobile money business is back on its prior growth trajectory after the 2022 levy and currency headwinds.
“Ghana appears to be back on its prior growth trajectory”
- Mobile money and fintech businesses run by African telcos are all profitable, and MTN's fintech is guided to an all-in fully loaded EBITDA margin of about 35% with capex below 5% of revenue, which defies the expectation that scaling fintech is unprofitable.
“all-in fully loaded EBITDA margins are going to be something like 35% and with very minimal CapEx needs”
- On management's disclosed guidance, MTN fintech is doing more than USD 200 million of net profit fully loaded for tax, and its net margins could be roughly twice those of the rest of MTN, with upside as incrementality rises.
“the idea of saying that MTN fintech is today a business doing more than $200 million of net profitability fully loaded for tax is certainly in line with management's guidance”
- Mobile money ecosystems are defined first by withdrawals and transfers, with remittances, payments and e-commerce as advanced services, and airtime advance as a short-term lending product, which MTN reports separately.
“Mobile money ecosystems are really defined on the basis, first and foremost, of withdrawals and transfer services”
- A team member traveling in Senegal, an enthusiastic mobile money adopter, touched cash only three times over 10 days, including in rural areas, suggesting how rapidly cashless flows can spread.
“he touched cash three times and not just in Dakar”
- A friend paid a cobbler in Kibera through M-PESA with no physical cash changing hands, illustrating how quickly mobile money transformed even informal micro-economies.
“my friend took out his phone and paid this cobbler through his M-PESA code. And there was literally no physical transfer of money”
- Mobile money pricing has evolved from fees on both deposits and withdrawals toward free deposits and modest withdrawal fees, while peer-to-peer transfers carry fees.
“over time, the model has trended towards free deposits and modest fee for withdrawals”
Africa's youthful, mobile-first population creates a large early runway for sustained connectivity demand growth.
- Some African markets have as few as 60% of people with even a feature phone, and only about 50% of mobile subscribers are expected to have a smartphone by 2025, with only a third of those on 4G or 5G, so basic connectivity and smartphone adoption are still early.
“only 50% of mobile subscribers in Africa expected to have a smartphone by the year 2025 and with only 1/3 of that being a 4G or 5G subscription”
- Africa's population is about 1.4 billion today, or 16% of the world, and UN median expectations put it at 2.5 billion by 2050, roughly 26% of world population, making Africa a supermajority source of global population growth over the coming decades.
“median expectations for the population of Africa by 2050 are 2.5 billion, which should be about 26% of the world's totals on the UN's numbers”
- Sub-Saharan African economies vary widely: Kenya's dollar GDP rose about 9x since 2000 with GDP per capita up 5x, Mozambique's GDP per capita is still under USD 500 per year, and South Africa's GDP per capita has declined since 2011 after a post-2000 boom.
“South Africa, which is absolutely a relatively advanced economy certainly in the context of the African continent... GDP per capita has actually declined meaningfully since year 2011, so something of a lost decade”
- Mauritius, which tripled GDP per capita since 2000 before COVID, has purchasing-power-parity adjusted per capita GDP roughly 30% to 50% higher than Brazil or China, a fact Benjamin thinks is poorly understood.
“it has purchasing parity adjusted per capita GDP roughly 30% to 50% higher than Brazil or China”
- Africa is about 40% urbanized versus 55% globally, 65% in China and more than 80% in the U.S.; urban migration helps incomes and moves people away from family into areas with better network coverage, which strengthens the incentive to adopt and use smartphones.
“This tends to help incomes for those that move to cities, but it also moves them away from family and into an area with much better network coverage. The incentive to adopt a smartphone and use it more is pretty clear.”
- More than 40% of Africa is under age 15, versus 16% in Europe and 23% in Asia, which means a large pipeline of prospective new mobile subscribers.
“with more than 40% of the entire continent below the age of 15 versus 16% in Europe or 23% in Asia, that's a lot of prospective new mobile subscribers”
- For many African consumers the mobile phone is their only connectivity option and often their main entertainment option, which gives mobile a more central place in the home than in developed markets.
“It is often their one connectivity option. It is often now their primary entertainment option”
- The stock of 18-year-olds in African markets is growing mid-single digits or faster each year, creating a pipeline of digitally fluent young people eager for a first smartphone once affordable.
“the stock of 18-year-olds in these countries are growing mid-single digits or higher every single year just by dint of demographics”
- A new class of digitally fluent, mobile-first young consumers in emerging economies is a barely touched talent pool, and companies that take these populations for granted have seen their franchises dismantled while those that adapt have built businesses quickly.
“We've watched companies that take these populations for granted have their franchises totally dismantled”
- African telcos have grown subscribers strongly through COVID and survived a decade of challenging macro conditions, making them more resilient than people credit, with the pandemic accelerating adoption of communications behaviors.
“these are businesses that have been growing really strongly through COVID”
- MTN has aggressively cut prices, bringing the cost of a gigabyte of data in Nigeria well below USD 1, and that price is likely to keep falling, with Jio in India as a precedent for affordability expanding the market.
“the price of a gigabyte well below $1. And we think that that's likely to continue going down.”
- The stereotype that emerging markets offer only commodities and sleepy state-owned enterprises is dated, because many of these markets are increasingly tilted toward information technology and information services.
“it's beginning to be a dated stereotype to assume that the only thing that emerging market economies have to offer are commodities and state-owned enterprises”
Mobile money and fintech can become a scaling, profitable toll-taker on the African economy.
- MTN's fintech business had 22 million active users at the end of 2017 and 69 million at the end of 2022, showing rapid scale growth in users.
“This is a business that had 22 million active users at the end of 2017 and, at the end of 2022, was at 69 million users.”
- Mobile money works through agents who act as on- and off-ramps, functioning like living ATMs that take cash to credit an account (float) and pay cash out, with fees that have trended toward free deposits and modest withdrawal fees.
“mobile money merchants to provide the on-ramp and off-ramp into the ecosystem. Think almost living ATMs”
- Mobile money market structure varies country by country, and regulation and each telco's competitive position largely determine whether one player becomes dominant, so winner-take-most dynamics apply within markets rather than uniformly across Africa.
“So the regulatory realities as well as the telco competitive realities of a given market will often dictate some element of its competitive structure.”
- If mobile money becomes fully established, MTN fintech could act like a Visa or Mastercard toll-taker on the economy, growing for decades on population growth alone, provided it keeps adding incremental value to its ecosystem.
“in a Mastercard or Visa kind of way, if it gets fully established, could have a toll-taking-like feature on the economy”
- Investors are preconditioned to expect fintech and payments companies beyond the card networks to be unprofitable at scale, so the profitability of African mobile money may surprise them, just as investors wrongly assume bad outcomes in Africa.
“people are preconditioned on fintech to expect the lack of profitability. So the level of profitability here may be surprising”
- If Ghana's current mobile money profit per user were applied across MTN's entire African subscriber base with minimal incrementality and no subscriber growth, group earnings power would rise roughly 70% to 80%.
“if we were to just use the current mobile money profitability generated per user in Ghana and apply that across MTN's entire African subscriber base... you'd increase earnings power by roughly 70% to 80% today”
Competitive entry and currency or listing issues are manageable, not reasons to avoid African exposure.
- Because scarce capital and low subscriber ARPUs of roughly USD 2 to 5 per month make pass-through economics hard, once telcos become self-financing it is extremely difficult to justify building competing fiber infrastructure.
“it is extremely difficult to justify building out competing infrastructure. Especially when you're often talking about ARPUs for the average subscriber of between $2 and $5 a month”
- A competitor entering one of MTN's roughly 20 markets does not automatically gain regulatory permissions, commercial relationships, or capacity to threaten MTN across its other markets, though it can increase organizational capacity to compete.
“coming into one market does not mean that you have the regulatory permissions, commercial relationships, et cetera, to threaten MTN in its other markets”
- If investors are willing to fund a competing network against MTN Nigeria, that suggests strong enthusiasm for the asset and the operating environment, and it is unlikely to produce dramatic ARPU compression.
“wouldn't that also suggest that it's a market in which there's some real enthusiasm for MTN Nigeria as an asset”
- Western investors look through Argentina's political and currency risk for Mercado Libre, whose Mercado Pago unit is about 40% Argentina-exposed, so treating African jurisdictions as uniquely risky is inconsistent and African exposure should be managed in a diversified portfolio rather than avoided.
“Western investors have the ability to look through various forms of political risk... Mercado Libre... where 40% of their crown jewel fintech asset Mercado Pago is probably represented by Argentina”
- As the rand has weakened and foreign participants have left the Johannesburg Stock Exchange, MTN has struggled to get premium valuations, so relisting in the U.S. or London or issuing an ADR would make sense to lower its cost of equity.
“we think it would make a ton of sense for MTN to explore relisting in the United States or in London or at least exploring an ADR”
- MTN is the biggest and most liquid pure play on the African telecom and mobile opportunity, a rare, well-run company that leads the sector on data adoption and fintech, making it a good lens on the space.
“it's the biggest and most liquid pure play, first of all. So it's a great lens through which to analyze the space”
- A persistently strong dollar against emerging-market currencies could leave dollar-denominated returns flat in real terms, and a strong dollar was the single largest headwind to several MTN business lines, but it is hedgeable and unlikely to be permanent.
“a strong dollar was easily the single largest headwind to a number of lines of business of MTN”
MTN's importance to governments and disciplined management support its strong standing.
- Despite a volatile election, a large-scale bank note conversion, and Ukraine-driven inflation, MTN Nigeria data subscribers grew mid-teens and voice subscriptions grew high single digits in the most recent quarter.
“Despite that, data subscribers in MTN Nigeria grew mid-teens. ...voice subscriptions were up high single digits.”
- Because a large part of MTN Nigeria is listed on the Nigerian Stock Exchange, a government action against MTN would hurt its largest taxpayer, a major listed company, and local asset managers, so the alignment of interests is strong.
“for the Nigerian government to act against MTN Nigeria, they not only would have to cut off service and communication capabilities for tens of millions of Nigerians”
- MTN is usually the largest taxpayer in pretty much any of its markets, and if not the largest then among the top five or ten, which makes it important to local governments.
“MTN is usually the largest taxpayer in pretty much any of its markets. And if it's not the largest, it's among the top 5 or 10.”
- Legacy MTN was more focused on empire building, while current management's capital allocation discipline is genuinely strong relative to that history.
“relative to the legacy MTN that I think you could fairly call somewhat more focused on empire building”
MTN's management is simplifying and reshaping the company to compete in fintech.
- CEO Ralph Mupita has dramatically simplified MTN's structure, pursued a significant asset disposal policy, targeted ROE at both group and country levels, and shown willingness to exit markets that are not strategic fits even at the cost of revenue.
“you have the now not so recent but fairly recent CEO, Ralph Mupita, who has dramatically simplified the structure of MTN”
- Running an app-based fintech or mobile money ecosystem requires skills and culture that differ sharply from network engineering and gradual capital discipline, so MTN must change culture to compete with venture-backed digital services companies.
“the necessary skills to offer an app-based fintech ecosystem or mobile money ecosystem are just dramatically different than the network engineers and studied gradual capital discipline policy that a more traditional telco needs”
- MTN's move to structurally separate fintech followed Airtel Money's TPG transaction and planned spinout, which pressured MTN to clarify fintech's role, and it also anticipates possible regulation requiring fintech to be regulated like a bank.
“At the same time, they were clearly anticipating some level of future regulatory scrutiny in terms of making sure that MTN fintech could be, for example, regulated like a bank”
- Operators with incumbency advantages are willing to build thoughtfully and adopt global best practices, which can radically change their local economies, and the digital revolution is still in its early innings globally.
“operators are willing to thoughtfully build when there are incumbency advantages, innovate and incorporate global best practices. They can radically change their local economies”
Listed subsidiaries and tower companies give global investors practical access to African exposure.
- Many African telcos have listed local subsidiaries on smaller exchanges such as Nigeria or Ghana, which are often impractical for global investors to access but have excellent disclosure that helps analysis of the business.
“those often trade on smaller exchanges like in Nigeria or Ghana and are likely not practical for most of your audience to access”
- A local listing of MTN Nigeria is not the optimal way to get a premium valuation, but it is a good way to give local participants a meaningful commercial stake and align stakeholders.
“We're very confident that listing MTN Nigeria in Nigeria is not the optimal way to get a premium valuation”
- Companies willing to relist in the United States have seen substantial re-rate opportunities, though it is unclear whether this will be a sustained trend.
“there's been a lot of substantial re-rate opportunity for companies that are willing to explore relisting in the United States”
- Tower companies such as American Tower, Helios and IHS provide African connectivity exposure, with Helios and IHS being entirely or mostly focused on the continent.
“as well as pure plays like Helios and IHS, which trade in London and New York, respectively”
- Bharti Airtel's listed subsidiary Airtel Africa has roughly 130 million subscribers, trades in London, and is expected to spin off its mobile money business, creating a useful entry point to African fintech.
“Bharti Airtel has a listed subsidiary called Airtel Africa that has roughly 130 million subscribers and trades in London”
Rising data use and ARPU growth can lift African telcos even as unit data prices fall.
- African mobile ARPUs range from about USD 1.50 to 5.50 per month with an average in the mid-2s, and as data penetration (around 50% of subscribers) rises, there could be another USD 0.50 to 2 of ARPU growth over time even as data unit prices fall.
“the idea that there could be another $0.50 to $2 worth of ARPU growth gradually over time just on the basis of data penetration going substantially higher”
- Communications technology inflects dramatically once product-market fit and workable pricing exist, as the iPhone and smartphone adoption did in the West during the GFC, and the same can happen in Africa even in a weak macro environment.
“once the product market fit is there, the price is at a workable level, the inflections can be really quite dramatic and sustain themselves even during difficult macroeconomic environments”
- Voice fell from about 60% of service revenue in 2018 to about 43% in 2022, data rose from about 24% to 37%, and fintech grew from about 6% to 9%, and management's Ambition 2025 plan targets voice below 50%, data above 50%, and fintech above 20% of total revenue.
“back in 2018, for example, voice was about 60% of the total service mix and data about 24%, fintech at about 6%”
- Although data prices per unit keep falling, rising data consumption and market consolidation should allow ARPU to grow, and a new entrant would find it difficult to inflict severe damage on MTN in Nigeria because demand enthusiasm shows the market's attractiveness.
“wouldn't that also suggest that it's a market in which there's some real enthusiasm for MTN Nigeria as an asset”
MTN's history, two-market revenue concentration, and device revenue treatment shape how its results should be read.
- MTN was founded in 1993 by a South African consortium that included government-affiliated entities and Koos Bekker, expanded within South Africa and Southern Africa from the late 1990s, and received its Nigerian wireless license in 2001 before spreading across the continent.
“MTN was effectively born almost exactly 30 years ago in 1993 through a consortium of South African investors”
- In 2022, about 38% of group revenue came from Nigeria and about 25% from South Africa, with West and Central Africa at 24%, Southeast Africa at 10%, and Middle East and North Africa at 3%, so revenue is concentrated in two markets.
“in 2022, roughly 38% of group revenue was coming from Nigeria, call it, 25% from South Africa, 24% from West and Central Africa”
- MTN's service revenue excludes device revenue, which is effectively a pass-through for subsidized devices used to keep customers on network, similar to U.S. carrier subsidized phones tied to two-year contracts.
“Service revenue is the same revenue item excluding their device line, which is effectively a pass-through for subsidized devices”
Emerging markets can pioneer innovation, so their incumbents should be seen as opportunities.
- Emerging markets can leapfrog and pioneer in many areas, including mobile money, so the narrative that innovation belongs only to the U.S. is outdated, and investors should study these markets as a source of lessons.
“emerging markets have had the ability to leapfrog and pioneer in a large number of areas, including things like mobile money”
- In Senegal a Silicon Valley-backed startup successfully competed against Orange, which was a dominant telco there, showing that competitive dynamics vary sharply by market.
“in the case of Senegal, there's actually a Silicon Valley backed-start-up that wound up successfully competing against Orange”
- Operators that build on incumbency advantages and adopt global best practices can radically change their local economies, and emerging-market operators should see their home market as a source of opportunity rather than a backwater.
“operators are willing to thoughtfully build when there are incumbency advantages, innovate and incorporate global best practices. They can radically change their local economies”
- African demographics will drive consumer demand, popular culture and commodities for the rest of investors' careers, so every investor should develop a view on the continent.
“African demographics alone demand that investors start to have a view”