What this covers

In this conversation, Patrick interviews Sam Hinkie, the former Philadelphia 76ers general manager, about making decisions when outcomes are uncertain and feedback loops run for years. It starts in basketball, with two familiar examples: defense is poorly captured by rebounds, blocks, and steals, and a three-point attempt is worth about 50 percent more than a two. Hinkie argues that such insights sound obvious, and the edge lies in how far a team will resource them and trade on them. Patrick frames mispricing in any market as a Perception-Reality Gap. The two also dispute how much of the Sixers' rise, from 24th to 4th in ESPN's franchise rankings and from roughly $418 million to $1.2 billion in Forbes valuation, was market beta and how much was alpha.

The middle stretch covers the contested positions. Hinkie holds that draft picks for teenagers and early-twenty-somethings are undervalued, and he compares long control of young talent to drafting Google's engineers for nine years. He says contrarian thinking pays most under hard constraints like salary caps, and he sees the most room in noisy, low-sample sports such as soccer and hockey, provided you have data others lack. He also discusses machine learning: what it adds, why its complexity limits interpretability, and why people should keep their hands on the controls, as in Autopilot and Manual Override.

The last part moves outside sports. Hinkie covers negotiation as empathetic preparation with a defined walk-away point, hiring through paid projects, and A Players Hire A Players. He tests the endowment effect by asking whether you would swap what you own for an equivalent, and applies Fat Tail Thinking and a decades-long regret test to marriage. A twin-study claim about choosing a spouse for the traits you want in your children is the most contested of these.

Sharpest takeaway

Hinkie argues that durable advantage comes from long time horizons, deep investment in people, and contrarian decisions made under uncertainty, because markets, teams, and even personal relationships reward those who price future outcomes better than the consensus.

  • Inefficiency is largest where uncertainty is high and data is thin, so the edge goes to those who can generate better inputs and act against consensus.
  • Long-horizon decisions (hiring, marriage, draft picks, innovation) compound over decades, while short-term pressure and incentives push people toward shortcuts.
  • Data and ML should inform decisions but not replace human judgment, since models have blind spots and people have biases.

The argument · threads2 threads · 74 claims
0.71

Perception-reality gaps create exploitable mispricing, as Hinkie's Sixers rise and franchise gains show.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Under Hinkie the Sixers rose from 24th in ESPN franchise rankings to 4th, and Forbes valued the franchise at about 418 million dollars at takeover versus about 1.2 billion dollars recently, with some appreciation being market beta and some being alpha.

    “When he took over the franchise, it was 24th in ESPN franchise rankings. Today, it is fourth.”

  • Mispricing in any market, whether NBA talent or stocks, comes from the gap between perception and reality, which can be exploited either by measuring reality better or by finding goofy perceptions.

    “there's be better at measuring the reality or be better at finding goofy perception”

0.57

Investing has clear observable targets, though its early excess-return sources erode over time.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Investing draws on parallel findings that simple observable characteristics like value and momentum were early sources of excess returns, and the resulting arms race has eroded them over time.

    “the people that were doing this original research found value and momentum. These simple observable characteristics, and it's been sort of an arms race since then”

  • In investing, truth is defined by observable variables positively related to future returns or cash flow growth, so the target of correlation is clear, whereas sports truth is harder to define.

    “it's returns and maybe future earnings growth or cashflow growth or something like this”