What this covers
Patrick talks with Trish and James, the husband-and-wife founders of Chenmark, about how a young firm in Portland, Maine, buys and holds small private companies. The conversation moves from the economics of the niche to the firm's structure and then to the practical lessons of its first acquisitions. They contrast their approach with the Search Fund Model, which they say has drifted from $1 to $2 million deals toward $2 to $3 million targets at prices they would never pay, becoming mini private equity aimed at growth and a five-year exit. They also describe how capital flowing into a sector pushes participants toward shorter horizons.
The range is wide for a single conversation. James explains the Bait Shop Thesis: a business that is the only game in town earns well but offers little reinvestment, so the owner collects a yield unless the cash is redeployed. A Western Canada frozen dough company illustrates a Geographic Moat, sitting beside its flour supplier and backing onto its distributor. On structure, they favor compensation almost entirely through Carry, made workable by Portland's low cost of living, an idea credited to Brent Beshore. They will refuse outside capital that demands heavy leverage. They also plan to build a base of solid businesses for roughly ten years before taking cyclical risk.
The more reflective turns concern risk. Patrick applies Nassim Taleb's Skin in the Game to the partners, and Trish describes leaving hedge fund employment as trading dependence for control. Their early plans for systems overhauls ran into companies with no org chart and little email, and they speak candidly about how emotional gruff owner-operators can be.
Chenmark's founders argue that buying small, contracted, non-differentiated businesses at low multiples (around 4x) earns excess returns, and that their edge lies in patient relationship-building with sellers and in centralizing operational expertise across a portfolio, not in financial sophistication.
- Low small-business multiples (about 4x) create a back-of-envelope return near 25% if the business stays stable, and the premium comes from doing hands-on work that larger buyers avoid
- Durability of the franchise, tested by contracted or basic-need revenue, is the key filter rather than near-term growth
- Centralized shared-services expertise (HR, finance, technology) lets small companies professionalize without breaking the budget
Partners' livelihoods tied to outcomes make skin in the game essential for their judgment.
- Taleb's principle that no opinion should be heeded without skin in the game applies to the partners, whose livelihoods depend on their outcomes, and the family structure of the team helps them absorb the stress of the risk.
“The core idea being you should not listen to anyone unless they have an enormous amount of skin in whatever game you're talking about.”
- Nassim Taleb argues that no one should be listened to without an enormous amount of skin in the game, and that no opinions are allowed without skin in the game, a principle Patrick uses to frame the partners' livelihoods.
“The core idea being you should not listen to anyone unless they have an enormous amount of skin in whatever game you're talking about.”
Worry and hardship signal health, so bold bets beat conventional diversification and caution.
- Founders often find that difficulties which seem bad in the moment take on a special, almost magical quality, similar to the experience of a new parent who finds sleepless nights both terrible and cherished.
“all the things that seem bad take on this kind of special air to them in a way that's kind of magical.”
- The Zurich Axioms preach betting big when an opportunity is found, with the quote that worry is a sign of health and that if you are not worried you are not risking enough, a philosophy that runs contrary to conventional diversification and caution.
“Worry, is not a sickness, but a sign of health. If you're not worried, you're not risking enough.”
Geographic position gives small businesses local pricing power, which founders see as a moat.
- Small businesses like a Maine landscaping company and a Western Canada dough manufacturer are attractive because their geographic position creates local pricing power, which the founders see as a durable component of moats.
“This is something that keeps coming up in the small business arena of moat or geography as a component of a moat.”