What this covers
This episode is a conversation between Brett and Matt about Winmark, the franchisor behind several store-based resale concepts. Brett supplies nearly all the substance, describing the company from the inside. The talk moves from how the franchise system runs day to day, to the market it sits in, to how the company thinks about capital, growth, and its own shareholders.
On operations, Brett draws a sharp line between Winmark and consignment or marketplace players. Winmark takes ownership of what it buys and pays cash on the spot, and he argues that companies touting take rate or GMV are signaling that they carry no inventory. A point-of-sale pricing matrix built on style, brand, condition, and target retail price lets a new franchisee learn to buy in under 30 minutes. Brett says the most common franchisee mistakes are halting purchases when inventory builds and spending less than the contractual 5% of sales on marketing, and that these take up about 95% of Winmark's helping time. Most good ideas, he adds, come up from the field.
The wider range covers consumer behavior and sustainability. Brett cites more than half of consumers shopping secondhand apparel in 2023, expects most middle-market customers to both buy and sell used goods, and says brands now want a share of the second and third trades. His claim that stores are more sustainable than online resale is flagged as contested, and he names the landfill as the real competitor. The most pointed passages concern discipline: past territory deals were, in his words, a disaster; he accepts criticism for slow growth; and he estimates he spent 30% to 40% of his time on the leasing businesses before the 2020 exit. He also explains why heavy ownership concentration makes conference calls unnecessary.
Winmark's franchised resale model, where franchisees fund inventory and Winmark earns only a sales-based royalty, creates tight alignment and a focused core business that the company's former leasing and consulting side businesses could not match.
- Franchisees make all purchasing decisions with their own capital, and Winmark's only meaningful compensation is a weekly percentage of sales, so both sides succeed or fail together
- Winmark exited its equipment leasing and franchise consulting businesses in 2020 to concentrate on resale, and management says the refocus improved idea quality and investment capacity
- Strict single-unit discipline and a 99%+ renewal rate are presented as evidence that slow, quality-controlled growth beats territory build-outs
Owning inventory in a store-based model beats consignment, online, and marketplace alternatives on certainty.
- Lower-priced apparel and goods have fewer places to go once a consumer is finished with them, so they often end up in landfills, which is why Winmark focuses on value-priced items.
“these lower-priced items, they have less places to go when you're done with them. And unfortunately, they end up in landfills.”
- Peer-to-peer marketplaces are better suited to higher-priced items because sellers will not spend the time to list a $2 or $3 item themselves.
“Typically better for higher-priced items because you're not going to take the time and energy to do that for a $2 or $3 item.”
- Donation-based resale operators such as Goodwill and Savers pay nothing for inventory, and they are environmentally beneficial because they handle very large volumes.
“they're not paying for their inventory, they're getting it as a donation, but it's also very good for the environment because they handle huge volumes.”
- Winmark believes it is the only company buying and selling used goods at scale on a daily basis, in contrast to consignment and marketplace models that only act as agents without taking ownership of inventory.
“Our stores buy and sell used items on a daily basis, and we believe we're the only company doing this at scale.”
- Companies that tout take rate or GMV are signaling that they do not own inventory, which means they carry less certainty for consumers than a company that buys goods outright.
“you'll see companies touting terms such as take rate or GMV or other metrics. And when you hear companies saying that, it just means that they don't take ownership of the inventory, and there's less certainty for the consumer.”
- The store-based resale model is more sustainable than online alternatives because it involves no packaging or shipping and no warehouse robots, and goods are shipped into the community once and stay there.
“There's no packaging. There's no shipping. There's no robots moving around the warehouse. And more importantly, the goods get shipped into the community once and they stay there.”
- Each Winmark store paid out over $400,000 in cash to community members on average, roughly $1,100 per day, and this cash-on-the-spot payout is the mechanism that brings customers in to sell and then buy.
“on average, each store paid out over $400,000 in cash to customers in the community. That's over $1,100 a day they're paying out.”
- Winmark takes ownership of the items it buys and pays cash on the spot, whereas consignment and marketplace players act as agents who do not own inventory, which creates less certainty for the consumer.
“Our stores buy and sell used items on a daily basis, and we believe we're the only company doing this at scale.”
- The worst thing a store can do is turn away a quality item, because the customer then loses confidence in that store and location, so stores are trained to buy as much as they can.
“The worst thing we can do for a customer is turn away an item that's a quality item because then they lose confidence in that store, in that location”
- Winmark's used goods are sold at 50% to 80% off the retail price of comparable new products, and customers bought about $1.6 billion in sales last year.
“they get sold from like 50% to 80% off a regular retail for the comparable new product and customers buy a lot of it, $1.6 billion almost in sales last year alone.”
- When Brett joined Winmark over 21 years ago the word resale was not in common use, and the company thought of itself as a franchisor of concepts that buy and sell gently used goods.
“I don't even think the word resale was a term that was being used.”
- Brett was inspired by a Business Breakdowns episode on Patek Philippe and says its idea that you never actually own a watch but look after it for the next generation would be a powerful message for Winmark franchises.
“Consider that you never actually own a Winmark franchise, you merely look after it for the next generation.”
Gradual, screened, quality-first franchise growth protects the brand better than fast expansion.
- Winmark's past territory agreements, which granted developers rights to build many stores in a market, were a complete and unmitigated disaster, because undeveloped or below-average stores damage the brand and other franchisees.
“We've dabbled with that over the years. It's been a complete and unmitigated disaster for us every time we've tried it, so we're just -- slow and steady wins the race”
- The franchisee role combines bottle washer and CEO, covering financial management, marketing, operations, staffing, customer service, and community relations, so it is not suitable for everyone.
“You're the bottle washer. You're the CEO. You're everything. And you're responsible for financial management.”
- Winmark holds a discovery day every other week, which Brett attends, to vet candidates by telling them the job is complex and that following the operating model is the path to success.
“We have a discovery day every other week. I'm at almost every single one of them.”
- Winmark prefers franchisees to operate one unit first, with about 940 franchisees running roughly 1,319 stores (about 1.4 per owner, mode of one), and it will not approve a second store without a documented operational plan.
“We have about 940 franchisees at this point in time... it's about 1.4 is the number, but our mode is one.”
- Winmark accepts criticism for growing slower than investors want because it prioritizes franchise partner quality, and Brett says he will not yield on qualification even though he personally wants faster growth.
“I'll take the heat for the growth rate that maybe people want. They want a little higher, but I want quality”
- Winmark identifies stores under a dollar sales threshold early and uses its M&A operation to transfer them to new owners before their renewal, so that underperforming owners can exit gracefully.
“We try to really identify early if we have a real focus on stores that are under a certain dollar threshold and try to work with them to sell.”
- Winmark has tried granting territory deals, where a franchisee develops many stores in one market, and each attempt was a complete failure because underperforming or delayed stores harm the brand and other franchisees, so the company now prefers slow, steady single-store growth.
“We've dabbled with that over the years. It's been a complete and unmitigated disaster for us every time we've tried it, so we're just -- slow and steady wins the race is our view.”
- Winmark works with multi-unit owners but keeps a strict sequence, where a second store is not supported until the first store is operating correctly and the owner has a plan for operational staffing, because a weak owner's stores will both decline without a strong manager, relative, or partner.
“we're not going to work with you on the second store until the first store is working right.”
- Winmark screens franchise candidates through qualitative operational and financial qualification, including discovery days held every other week, where the actual demanding nature of the job is explained before any agreement is signed.
“We have a discovery day every other week. I'm at almost every single one of them.”
- Over the past ten years Winmark's annual renewal rate peaked at 100% and bottomed at 97.4%, meaning system-wide problems have not occurred and problem stores are identified early.
“last year, we renewed 176 of 177 agreements that were available, 99.4%. If you look over the past five years, it's 99.2%.”
- Winmark's franchise agreements run ten years, after which both the franchisee and the company can choose whether to extend, and the contract licenses the brand name in exchange for following the operating handbook.
“They sign 10-year agreements. We signed 10-year agreements with the franchisees.”
Exiting the leasing businesses to focus on the resale core was the most important decision.
- Three years after exiting the non-core businesses, Brett believes the decision was the most important in a decade or two, since it improved idea quality, investment capacity, and alignment among franchisees, employees, and shareholders.
“since we've done this, the quality of the ideas, the desire and the ability to invest more in the business is a direct result of focusing all of our efforts on the resale industry.”
- The leasing business never grew fast enough to use the franchising cash flow, consistently missed customer acquisition goals, and although it was highly profitable and capital-light, it diverted management attention from the core resale business.
“we never were able to grow the leasing business fast enough to utilize the cash flow from franchising. We just never met our goals for customer acquisition.”
- In 2020, during COVID, Winmark sold the small-ticket lease portfolio, shut down its franchise consulting business, and rebranded around a resale-for-everyone mission, replacing the earlier 'Create, support, finance business' tagline.
“So in 2020, we sold the small ticket lease portfolio. We shut down the franchise consulting business.”
- Brett estimates he personally spent 30% to 40% of his time on the leasing and related businesses, and the realization that the core resale business deserved that attention is what led to the 2020 exit.
“I estimate that I probably spent 30% to 40% of my time on these businesses.”
- Winmark started a small-ticket and middle-market equipment leasing operation on April 1, 2004 to deploy franchising cash flow into a high-return finance product, but 2008-2009 hurt small-ticket results and the company later shrank that unit.
“Our leasing operations, we started a small ticket and a middle-market equipment leasing operation in 2004... It was April 1, 2004.”
- Winmark's middle-market leasing unit financed and purchased $300 million of technology equipment for customers, a sizable amount when Winmark's market cap was about $140 million and the business represented over 70% of its balance sheet.
“we financed over $300 million. We purchased $300 million of equipment on behalf of our customers... our market cap was $140 million.”
Franchising is the right model because Winmark's fees align with franchisee success.
- Winmark is paid a weekly percentage of franchisee sales called the continuing fee, which is its main compensation and not a profit center, so Winmark only does better when franchisees do better.
“there's a weekly percent of sales that we get paid, and that's called the continuing fee. And there's a few other little things here and there. They're not profit centers for us”
- Franchising is the right model because a corporate-level team could not commit capital on behalf of the company in the way local owners do, since each store's capital, hiring, and inventory clearing depend on local accountability.
“I don't think this would work at a corporate level, to have a bunch of corporate employees trying to commit capital on behalf of the mother ship.”
- Successful franchisees treat their stores as permanent legacy assets they look after for the next generation, which changes how they operate and makes store closures painful for communities.
“our successful franchisees, they embrace the notion that our stores are legacy assets in the community because you act differently as an owner, if you think what you're doing is permanent.”
- Entrepreneurial franchisees should run the Winmark model per the handbook for a few years before changing it, and any deviation that works should be reported to headquarters rather than implemented unilaterally.
“what we really try to get people to do is just run the model for a few years, just do it per the handbook.”
Franchisee operating discipline and high renewal rates reflect healthy stores and reward responsible disposal.
- The biggest competitor to Winmark is the landfill, because many people either do not know about resale options or do not take time to use them, so the industry must make responsible disposal more convenient.
“I still think the biggest competitor to us is the landfill because still too many people just don't take the time to pursue one of these options”
- The most common franchisee mistakes are stopping purchases when inventory builds and underspending on marketing, which is below the 5% of sales required by contract, and these account for about 95% of the time Winmark spends helping franchisees.
“the contract states -- we talked about the contract that they have to spend 5% of sales on marketing, that our average numbers are a little bit lower than that.”
- When stores stop buying due to excess inventory, the cause is operational and mindset-based, such as back-counter organization, staffing, and how the store communicates 'we're not buying today,' rather than the economy.
“It's definitely caused stress on individual stores, it's never been prevalent across the whole concept... It's not due to the economy. We believe it's more operational in nature, it's more mindset in nature.”
- Winmark renewed 176 of 177 available agreements last year (99.4%), 622 of 627 over five years (99.2%), and over the past 10 years its renewal rate ranged from 97.4% to 100%.
“last year, we renewed 176 of 177 agreements that were available, 99.4%. If you look over the past five years, it's 99.2%.”
- A single franchise store closing has negligible financial impact on Winmark's roughly 1,300 stores, but it harms local families and young customers who lose access to affordable clothing and gear.
“Like one store closing from a financial standpoint, it's not going to impact us. But you have young families that now don't have access to our clothes”
- Renewal rate is the single most important metric for Winmark because it reflects franchisee health and relations; franchise agreements last 10 years and both parties choose whether to extend.
“The single most important metric of the company is renewal rate. It speaks to franchisee health. It speaks to franchisee relations.”
Secondhand resale is a large, mainstream market dominated by hybrid buyers and sellers.
- The U.S. secondhand apparel market is over $40 billion, with resale accounting for $23 billion of that total, according to the most recent estimates Brett reviewed.
“U.S. secondhand apparel market of over $40 billion with resale accounting for $23 billion of this.”
- Over 50% of consumers shopped secondhand apparel in 2023, indicating that resale participation has broadened from early adopters and value-conscious buyers to a widespread mainstream behavior.
“over 50% of consumers shop secondhand apparel in 2023, so it's very wide in terms of participation.”
- Apparel and sporting goods brands earn revenue only on first sale, so they are now seeking ways to participate in the second, third, and fourth trades of their durable goods.
“Right now, they're only getting remuneration one time when it gets sold. So all the brands are trying to figure out, how do I participate in the second, third and fourth time the good's traded hands?”
- Most customers in the middle two-thirds of the market will be hybrid buyers who both buy and sell used goods, with well over 50% of customers on both sides of the transaction, while only extremes buy exclusively new or used.
“you're well over 50%. Well over 50% or both, and that's the sweet spot for us... But the middle 2/3 of the bell curve today, I think, for quite some time are going to be hybrid users.”
- Winmark can acquire a customer as a newborn and retain them for more than 50 years across its brands, a customer lifetime span rare among consumer businesses other than staples like toothpaste.
“we can acquire you as a newborn customer and keep you for more than 50 years.”
Discipline in following a proven operating model, not superior intelligence, drives Winmark's advantage.
- Clarity of purpose allows an organization to achieve sustained excellence, because a pure mission inspires people, gives everyone a clear role, and lets the company amplify its message to a broader audience.
“I believe that having clarity of purpose as an organization allows for this... when you have a pure mission, Matt, it really inspires people.”
- The franchise agreement requires owners to spend 5% of sales on marketing, but average spending runs below that level, and Brett treats the 5% as the minimum, because community awareness drives the business.
“they have to spend 5% of sales on marketing, that our average numbers are a little bit lower than that.”
- Winmark's advantage is discipline rather than superior intelligence, since the company is not smarter than others but consistently follows a proven model, which Brett considers a valuable trait in the resale industry.
“We're not terribly smarter than anybody else. We're very disciplined.”
- The best franchise candidate is one who follows the operating model rather than tweaking it, because Winmark has about 30 years of accumulated mistakes built into the system, and the strongest traits are community responsibility, sustainability buy-in, and willingness to run the model for years before experimenting.
“We and our franchisees have made every mistake out there. So if you follow that operating model, we think you're going to have success.”
- Decentralized franchisee management combined with centralized education is the right structure for this business, because a corporate-level team committing capital on behalf of a parent company would not work.
“I don't think this would work at a corporate level, to have a bunch of corporate employees trying to commit capital on behalf of the mother ship.”
Franchisees make buying decisions, and their field ideas flow up and get packaged system-wide.
- Winmark's point-of-sale system contains a pricing matrix based on style, brand, condition, and target retail price, so a new franchisee can learn to buy in under 30 minutes without a team of data scientists.
“that pricing matrix in terms of what to pay is inherent in that point-of-sale system. If we wanted to, we could teach you how to buy under 30 minutes.”
- Franchisees make 100% of point-of-attack purchasing decisions because they use their own capital, though Winmark trains them to buy as much as possible, since turning away quality items erodes customer confidence.
“All the purchasing decisions at the point of attack are the franchisees, so it's 100% theirs.”
- Most of Winmark's best operational and marketing ideas originate with franchisees, and the corporate team's role is to identify what works in the field and package it for the whole system of hundreds of stores.
“all the best ideas that have happened at the company and operational ideas and local store marketing... they've all happened from franchisees.”
- Winmark completed over 3,000 franchisee support visits last year, which Brett links to a 99% renewal rate and the company's highest level of system-wide sales.
“We completed over 3,000 support visits last year. And that's why we had a 99% renewal rate last year, and we had our highest level of system-wide sales.”
Excess cash follows a fixed priority order, with special dividends replacing buybacks when valuation is unattractive.
- Winmark's first capital allocation principle is to run a good, profitable company, because without it there is no capital to allocate, and the company generates excess capital every year after heavy marketing and technology investment.
“Our first tenet of capital allocation is run a good company because if you don't run a good company, there's no capital to allocate.”
- Winmark allocates excess cash in order: first high-return reinvestment consistent with the resale core, which has been scarce; then debt paydown, which is currently unattractive because the company's long-maturity debt carries very low rates; then share repurchases when valuation is attractive; then a quarterly dividend and special dividends.
“the primary use of funds has been debt paydown, share repurchase and special dividends. Right now, we have longer maturity debt at very low rates, so debt paydown isn't a great option.”
- Winmark repurchases stock only when its price is at a valuation management deems proper, not by formula or to offset dilution, having bought back 4.3 million shares (about $350 million) over 20 years, leaving under 3.5 million shares today.
“We've repurchased 4.3 million shares in the last 20 years or about $350 million. We have under 3.5 million shares today.”
- Winmark's CFO does not weigh taxes when choosing between buying back stock and returning cash to owners; if stock is not undervalued, the cash should go back to shareholders regardless of tax effects.
“Taxes doesn't factor into that decision. It's just we're going to give you your money back. It's yours.”
- 2023 was the first year in 20 years that Winmark did not repurchase shares, a decision driven by valuation rather than a formula, and the company paid a special dividend that year instead.
“Frankly, 2023 was the first time in 20 years that we didn't repurchase shares”
- Twenty shareholders own 74% of Winmark, so the company can personally call most of its major holders, reaching 18 of the top 20, which makes a conference-call-based investor relations program unnecessary.
“20 shareholders own 74% of the company. So it doesn't take us a lot to really understand.”
- When buybacks are not attractive, Winmark pays special dividends, which shareholders value highly, and it paid special dividends in each of the last four years totaling a little under $23 per share.
“And we've paid out special dividends in each of the last four years, totaling a little under $23 a share.”
- Between 2002 and 2021 Winmark pursued several corporate development ideas, including minority private investments, two leasing businesses, and a franchise consulting venture, and management concluded that the resale core was getting too little attention.
“And I just didn't think it was getting enough attention.”
Winmark's multi-brand footprint reaches many communities and keeps customers moving across brands.
- Winmark operates a network of 1,319 locally owned buying centers across North America through five brands (Plato's Closet, Once Upon A Child, Play It Again Sports, Style Encore, Music Go Round) with a mission to provide resale for everyone.
“we're responsible for a network of 1,319 locally owned buying centers in communities all across North America. And we have a very simple and pure mission, to provide resale for everyone.”
- Winmark claims it has kept 1.7 billion items out of landfills since 2010 and returned over $1 billion in cash to communities in the past 24 months, positioning it as a leader in the circular economy.
“We've kept 1.7 billion items out of landfills since 2010 and have returned over $1 billion in cash to the communities we serve in the past 24 months alone.”
- Digital and social media is now the most cost-effective advertising channel for Winmark's stores, replacing cable TV and radio, which were effective when Brett started.
“Right now, it's digital and social. It's just so cost-effective to tell your message that way... digital and social is really the most effective, cost-effective way”
- Winmark has not built a national strategy to move customers between its brands as they age; instead, migration happens naturally where a community has all three store types.
“It's more about being in the community that has all three. So we're not there yet on the master plan to do that, but it's just naturally occurring.”
Talking directly to shareholders serves them better than analyst conference calls and analyst days.
- Brett argues shareholders would rather see management spend time on core operations than on analyst conference calls or analyst days, so Winmark's approach of talking directly to shareholders is more effective.
“I've never met a shareholder that doesn't want me spending my time on the core operations.”
- Brett says he copied a low-touch investor relations approach from someone he admires and will not change it because Winmark has not suffered from low valuation; he would revisit the approach if valuation were depressed.
“it's not like we suffered from a low valuation. I do think we can have a different argument if that were the case.”
- Writing handwritten thank-you notes is an underused professional practice that deepens relationships, because it tells the recipient their help was meaningful and that they were worth the time it took to write.
“Write handwritten thank you notes. It may sound a little cliche.”